- Manufacturing
2.83 / 2.813 - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
2.83 / 2.813 - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Manufacturing Manufacturing Manufacturing Manufacturing 2.83 / 2.813 1) 1) 1) 1) Thiriez,
- 1)
1) 1) 1) Thiriez, “An Environmental Analysis of Injection , “An Environmental Analysis of Injection , “An Environmental Analysis of Injection , “An Environmental Analysis of Injection Molding” Molding” Molding” Molding”, IEEE 2006 Abstract. (click here for PDF). 2) 2) 2) 2) Gutowski et al, “A Thermodynamic Characterization “A Thermodynamic Characterization “A Thermodynamic Characterization “A Thermodynamic Characterization
- f Manufacturing Processes”,
- f Manufacturing Processes”,
- f Manufacturing Processes”,
- f Manufacturing Processes”, IEEE Proceedings ISIE,
Orlando, May 2007 3) 3) 3) 3) Williams, E. et al, “ “ “ “The 1.7 Kilogram Microchip The 1.7 Kilogram Microchip The 1.7 Kilogram Microchip The 1.7 Kilogram Microchip” ” ” ”,
- Enviro. Sci. Technol. 36, 2002, p 5504-5510.
(also see the comment and reply to this article) 4) 4) 4) 4) Williams, E. “Energy Intensity of Computer “Energy Intensity of Computer “Energy Intensity of Computer “Energy Intensity of Computer Manufacturing: Hybrid Assessment Combining Process Manufacturing: Hybrid Assessment Combining Process Manufacturing: Hybrid Assessment Combining Process Manufacturing: Hybrid Assessment Combining Process and Economic Input and Economic Input and Economic Input and Economic Input-
- Output Methods
Output Methods Output Methods Output Methods” Environmental Science and Technology, 2004, 38, 6166-6174
Energy Used Energy Used Energy Used Energy Used
!"# $%& ' " (" &)
*+,
"
- #./0
- 12*3'
- 1111
- 3'/-'4/-3 4/-3 /* '5
- 1 1 1 1
- 3'/-'4/-3 4/-3 4/* '3
$"6-7/33
(43%) 100% 86.1 8 (5%) 16% 13.4 Commercial Commercial Commercial Commercial 20% 17.4 Residential Residential Residential Residential (8%) 26% 22.6 Transportation Transportation Transportation Transportation 30% 38% 32.7 Industry Industry Industry Industry
Mfg(d&i)
Total Percent EJ
8"
Energy and Production in the Mfg Energy and Production in the Mfg Energy and Production in the Mfg Energy and Production in the Mfg Sector; 1980 Sector; 1980 Sector; 1980 Sector; 1980 -
- 1994
1994 1994 1994
Energy Used Energy Used Energy Used Energy Used
!"# $%& ' " (" &)
)."9:
- !
- ;< ;( ; ;
)
; ;:- / ;"- / %
6
"
- ; ; ; ;< ;= ;< ;<
- >>
- "&.
; ;! ;& ; ;
"
- /
"
- >>
- %
"
- /
"
- >>
- %
- !
""" ?
&#
# :
- !
- "
:?
- :?
"
- :#
"
Typical parameters Typical parameters Typical parameters Typical parameters
3
- +
- (sand)
(sand) (sand) (sand)
- +
+ + +4
Machining Machining Machining Machining
- +
- 3
Injection Injection Injection Injection molding molding molding molding
- +
- +4
Sand Sand Sand Sand casting casting casting casting (metal) (metal) (metal) (metal)
- recycle
- prompt
- waste
- primary
Approximations for Mfg Processes Approximations for Mfg Processes Approximations for Mfg Processes Approximations for Mfg Processes
- "
- #
- . @/
0"#
- :%
- "
- :
- .
- ::
- #
- "
- ::
" : " "
- !
- "#
"# $
%
&# '
- (
)
'
- !
- "#$
- %&
- !
'
- (
- )
- *
- +
, !
- $
"
"?
- 7-A"AB/-CCD/
- C4,D/
&9-43D/ E &
- /
- +D/
@#
- C4,D/
8&- D/
- 33D/
&
- /
- D/
&-+'D/ 6-+D/ F"-+D/ &-+D/ .- D/ 7-A"AB/-CCD/
- C4,D/
&9-43D/ E &
- /
- +D/
@#
- C4,D/
8&- D/
- 33D/
&
- /
- D/
&-+'D/ 6-+D/ F"-+D/ &-+D/ .- D/
& (
98"F:" ++
&
$G:%++'F:" ++F% 334"H!#%33C
!" &-/
- /
.-/ # &-/
- /
.-/
- (#"=#:%
- /
- (.+++:%
- $%%%"
&-/
- /
.-/ 8"+++:% !!
- .
++ A '5 A 4+ A A .+++:% '+,'+++ 343 C'+ '+++ ++,,+ !&! $'() *&+ ,% *&+ )(+ *&+ $% *&+ %< 4D 4 4 '+D D +D C4,D
- (
- (
- C+33C %<
5'' %< C 5 %< %< C5 %< + 4'5 %< + , %< '3,, 4C5 ' 5+D ' C+D +D ,+ 4,4 3+ +D 3++ 3++ 3+D 3+D +++ +++ %< 4, %< %< , CC %< C, %< %< D 4D
- !.)%%%/
,4D 0!.$112/
).
$ &
- *
- .##
- *
- )
) )
- %
- %
&%
- ''
- ;
; " ; ? ; 2
(
%( E&):-/
" :
- %
+++++'C3
- +++++'C3
' :
- %
+++++5
- +++++5
4 & :
- %
+++++++'45
- +++++++'45
C &"# :
- %
+++++
- +++++
5 &,7% :
- %
++'+
- ++'+
, &#:,7% :
- %
++++45
- ++++45
3 &# :
- %
3
- 3
+ & :
- %
++++++ 3
- ++++++ 3
G 47 :
- ++4
- ++4
G :
- ++++4
- ++++4
) :
- %
++++ 5
- ++++ 5
' E :
- %
3+,
- 3+,
4 :
- %
+++++++54
- +++++++54
C :
- %
+++
- +++
5 "# :
- %
43
- 43
, =% :
- %
+++++++34
- +++++++34
3 I'C7% :
- %
+++ +3
- +++ +3
+ :
- %
3'
- 3'
:
- %
5C4'
- 5C4'
:
- %
'
- '
:
- %
''
- ''
' . :
- %
35+3
- 35+3
4 :
- %
+++++
- +++++
C 8 :
- %
4+3+3
- 4+3+3
5 6'4G7% :
- %
+++++++C
- +++++++C
, J :
- %
+++++++5
- +++++++5
3 J :
- %
++++++++4
- ++++++++4
+ "": : : 7 +++''
- +++''
4+D"
- ;
"6:
K CC5%&IA< K 54%IA< K 4%=IA< K !AG< K 22
$6")($I++LF LG
6@?.
- ;
(0 ( "
- %<45D
"?"6/ 6@?.-+++ "+5/ ; &I K C6@H ; IK ',6@H ; =I K '6@H
G&
3!
- 4
5& "6
- C4
+ +
- C
5
- '
- C
4C3 + 3 5 '' 4 33
- +
+
- 5'
+3 +5
- 3
7! 5 , + 5 3
- ,3
'4' 7 5 554 + C 4 +, +' + 4 ', ,3 +' 4'C ' ,C
- +
4 +C + + C3 + + + CC
- 3
+ 5 + '53 +4 +
- !
+ 4 +5 5 'C 44,
- 4
" 33 + + + + + + C4'
- '
+ + C4 5' + 3 53
- 4
- +
' , 3 +5 C "! C3 44 + 4 +
- '+4
"8! 4' '' + + +4
- 5
5C !! ' 5 + ' ' 4 C 3 ! 5 3C ++ 4+5
- C5
- 3
G" I."G-#/ 33 M @&N++ 6M)(++'N
6@?.
6 :
&
9:
- *+
"( *+
- &
$ "#' ,
- *#
- *
" & "
- .$
- /
(7 ) )
O#
$?
Sand casting; energy profile Sand casting; energy profile Sand casting; energy profile Sand casting; energy profile
- National statistics
(including elect losses)
13 – 17 MJ/kg*
- or 6 to 12
MJ/kg* (at the factory)
- Melting largest
component *of saleable cast metal
$?
=H@
; @BP ; "
!*&Q8>Q! *R+34-/ 7A%-/
; "+STS+'U ; !"#$
UT11 "( 7
&)-&/
++ " C 8"
*&
- 9$)*&
::0;
- 9
+5 & C5
- +
- 0$I333
0)(++
&
; ) A' 6
K # 6F K : : .
; 0440
- ; #+4
06O +406F
0$I333
).
$ . &
- #
- %
(
- )
''
- ; B
; ." ; : ; @"
(8)-/
( 9
;
- #
.
- .
; 8"#:" " .
U*D%( +D.I
0(('+)9 0AA:::.AAA'AA#A#+
+
- +++4 ++5
- +4
6 ) +
- ++4 +C
+CU 5 C3 6 & ;! )
- :-
- 77
. &!!/
0(9 I!(9)9 :::AAI!(
+,4 (. +4'' (9. +C' (9." 7 ;!
- < 30- 7
!4!! .6&!!/
8)$K ++
VWJ9"-5++++/
),)<$1$ C5 5' + 5' J)=&-96I $68/ $<$=)<221 $<$'=<=2= ><+%% ::0; ><'2' , 4 CC'4 4 CC'+ !=IE $'(, +4 ' 4 + ' 4 &6W >,2<>%1 5C, ,5
- ',
5' (=G(= +1<,1) 344 C5 '+ 5 E($ )% + + + + $))I&W(=(8 >'<>>2 5'5+ 5, 3 C3 &I :" !.6/ : " .6/ :? .6/
- 5
.6/ :0 .6/
)
- /+0+--1(---2-230
)
, ++C G:%L8B
W: EGI XXX
&%
- XXX
I0
0AA::: A.A #A#:
0AA::::A:AAAY
&($E " $."
)
:L
- =0
9(&8IWG(8 *( " $." =I =G (":
- 8
- /
)8 (.
&
B
- /
")"
(":
- :L
- )8
$" *9("
<
$"
- /
%
)
- .
%)"
- :L
- :L
"
E")E&)
- 3-
;;- ;-
- @
- :
- 5C4C
5553 5 44 5'3 4,' ,C'C 4'4 55' (#" 4+
- 3++
4+ 534+ ,++
- C'C+
- 4 +
5+,+ ,+ + 43'+ FA=% M333N
- 5++
- 4 ++
,++ +5++ 3C++ < M333N
- C5,+
- 4'+
,5+ 5,+ !#% MI)8335N C4 , C+5 C+5 '
- :#
,+++
- C,++
C'++ 45++ ,'++
- ,++
<"0 !:"%%%"*XXX @7%"
"
&($E " $."
)
:L
- =0
9(&8IWG(8 *( " $." =I =G (":
- 8
- /
)8 (.
&
B
- /
")"
(":
- :L
- )8
$" *9("
<
$"
- /
%
)
- .
%)"
- :L
- :L
&
; (.:"# #:":? ; #:
- ;
8"- K C7A%/
."6"(.0 ;9#:-G!GH/ ; - .%"/ ;I #B- :/
$
; 6""" " ; )#
5$=% 5)%% 5+%% 5'%% 5,%% 52%% 5$%%% 5$,%% 5)'%% 5+)%% 5=%%%
*+,4 + + +' +C +,
- '
C , + 4++ +++ 4++ +++ 4++ +++ 4++ :. &/ :8
- "
.*& /
%
- *
+)
- *
- #
AB:8C
&($E " $."
)
:L
- =0
9(&8IWG(8 *( " $." =I =G (":
- 8
- /
)8 (.
&
B
- /
")"
(":
- :L
- )8
$" *9("
<
$"
- /
%
)
- .
%)"
- :L
- :L
)"O //) /!'/
0AA%"AA# A#"+
Machine Types:
; !" K I": H K )0:L:%
- " /
; ( K .: . K " K = ; !"# 0:L"
(."#
+ + '+ C+ ,+ ++ + +
- '
4 C 5 , 3 +
- '
:.!/
- "#!. 5/
44+!"# =8''+(
B ) & ):
- &
8
- 8":#."#.
AB:8C
9!"!"# & %
+
- '
4 C 5 , + 4+ ++ 4+ ++ :. &/ .*& / !4 !4+ !C+ !54 !++ E:")8@& !")8!$ @#!")
".++57A%XXX $
AB:8C
&-4D/M4,+<N !"-4CD/MC3+<N !-4+D/M4 +<N &9-+4D/M4+<N &9 8-44D/M4,+<N )-5 D/M55+<N 9-43D/MC+<N &
- /
- D/
@#
- 4+D/
&
- /
- CCD/
&-4D/M4,+<N !"-4CD/MC3+<N !-4+D/M4 +<N &9-+4D/M4+<N &9 8-44D/M4,+<N )-5 D/M55+<N 9-43D/MC+<N )-5 D/M55+<N 9-43D/MC+<N &
- /
- D/
@#
- 4+D/
&
- /
- CCD/
&
- /
- D/
@#
- 4+D/
&
- /
- CCD/
AB!" )%%)C
) :
- 9/
ZE
(..":"- :/&
,
+)
+
- '
4 C 5 , 3 + 4 + 4 + :. &/
- (,4
!",4 .*& / AB:8C
!$ EE$ E$
- @&
- & )
& 8 . ,3, 535 5 , + 43 ,5 , 5'C 345 5,, : 553 535 C'C C'+ 4' 5+, C35 C, 5, 43'
- 4
535 3+ 4 534 ,+ +5 35C 5' 3C+ . :
- .
:
- .
:
- .
:
- +33
++3
- :-!
G#"(
- /
B "$." +3
!
+' ) 8 +3 + +' "$." 45 4 ,+ + + , 4++ C
- +5+
+C
- ++C
- +
6 +
- 44
$" =GW&I=68)I=W8(G7A%
E&)B
. :
- .
:
- .
:
- .
:
- .
:
- .%:["):"
.#:"".9"&8 ""-+C47A%&+47A%8/ $" ) 8
- ,+
C
- + +
- /
+33
- ++'
+5+ C3'C 5 ' 5 4 CC, ', ,5,5 ,5+ 5+55 !"# ( 3 C+ 6 ::0;"& 4D( !!
- 5C4
5,C, !" 545
- +,
4 4 3 33 C353 44C ',3 !" !"# ( )&I 35+ C4' ''5 5
- ,+C
,'4 43
D!
::0;"&
- -!
,35 ,+' 4?+D
- 8?B+ 7A%
' 45 ,,' 53C CCC )
- %#:/
- G/
++4 ++ +
AB:8C
")"
8G# +D
3!
- 4
5& "6 5D 3CD ++D 4+5D D C5D D !6
9."7":0 53'&I +5CI + =I C'&!' +++ !
Scale Scale Scale Scale
C8 !!D ! '+>+, +C>+, CC,>+, (( 4*& 3 '>+5 46 ( 4*&
!$ E$ EE$
- @&
8))"6C3 +5 G7"-+C+, G7"/ 8=
- ):+D".XXX
Improving injection molding Improving injection molding Improving injection molding Improving injection molding
$ &
- #
&
- #
- %
(
- )
''
- ; "
; ." ; " :
General electric energy model for General electric energy model for General electric energy model for General electric energy model for mfg processes mfg processes mfg processes mfg processes , % * *
- #
:-%</
- A/
- A/
"-7A /
% , * ,
- "
"?L
8B
(: @6@3!
+
- '
4 C 5 , + 4+ ++ 4+ ++ : & .*& /
!4 !4+ !C+ !54 !++ E:" ) 8 @& !" ) 8 !$
thermal oxidative treatment thermal oxidative treatment thermal oxidative treatment thermal oxidative treatment
"
>+ >+ >+' >+4 >+C >+5 >+, >+3 >+ > > +5 +4 + + >+ >+
M
AN
)
- 9
&@$
- G
(#.< <$ $$ E$$ I 6 E:
"?M7A
N
>+ >+ >+' >+4 >+C >+5 >+, >+3 >+ > > +5 +4 + + >+ >+
M
AN
)
- 9
&@$
- G
(#.< <$ $$ E$$ I 6 E:
"?M7A
N
- #.%
).%45## )*45#) 1111 %# 6..45## )45#) 1111 .*# &#&45# 6%45#) 1111 )&.% *#45# )#645#) 1111 *.*% .#45# )#45#) 1111 %&)* *&45# 6645#) 1111 .) .%%45## #45#) 1111 ). #645# .&45#) 1111 &* *&45# .&45#) 1111 6*"# ##45# *45#* 1111 6*"# *.#45## %##45#* 1111 #%& &##45## )-#) 1111 #%& #45## -#* 1111 "# -## *6#45#) 1111 "# ))# #45#* 1111 .&% *#41# ".45#&
- 7&%8
- 6&6
#&41#) *%"45#%
- 7&%8
%## %&*41#& **45#" 1111 7%8 &## )*41#) *%)45#% 9 7.8 *." 6%)41#* %%45#. 9 7"8 &## %&41#) &45#.
- 768
%.& #&41#& %*&45#" 9 6&# )&41#* %#45#. 9 &#* %.#41#* .&45#% 1111 7.#8 .&# "&41# )#"45#& 9 78 ### %%41# %645#* 1111 78 %## #*41# &"45#% 1111 %## "#41# #%45#& 1111 "% *41# .&45#&
- "%
&&41#) )%%45#%
- *&
)41#) %)645#% 1111 7*8 %%# .41#) **45#%
- 7&8
- %)
.#41#. &*45# 9 7%.8
- "###
"41#) %*45#. 9 7&8 ## ""41#. &.45#
- *"##
*)%41#. #45
- :
9: : : !;;0 0(<0(0 !;9.&$
- =90'0
0##$0
- 7%8
768 ;914> ?-(?-
)0(0 )-
7*8 7)8 ! "
- #$
% 7.8
- &"
- '
'( )* ' ) + )* ),-
cutting tools and machining times cutting tools and machining times cutting tools and machining times cutting tools and machining times
Individual Process Energy Flow Individual Process Energy Flow Individual Process Energy Flow Individual Process Energy Flow
Mechanisms of Mechanisms of Mechanisms of Mechanisms of Exergy Exergy Exergy Exergy Loss Loss Loss Loss
- :%-
/
- "-
/
- '
A:%"
)I
R$%%E 8
.
- F$%%G
F$%%G &@$
( #.
P$%%E P$%%G (#.<
- PD
PD $&L)
- (:
:"
PD P$%%G $
I #.
PD P+D G
- PD
PD
- Comment
Comment Comment Comment Auxillary Auxillary Auxillary Auxillary Material Loss Material Loss Material Loss Material Loss Working Material Loss Working Material Loss Working Material Loss Working Material Loss Process Process Process Process
Order of Magnitude Estimates for Order of Magnitude Estimates for Order of Magnitude Estimates for Order of Magnitude Estimates for Exergy Exergy Exergy Exergy Lost/ Lost/ Lost/ Lost/Exergy Exergy Exergy Exergy of Processed Material
- f Processed Material
- f Processed Material
- f Processed Material
)
- &@$
G < <$ & $& I 9 $$ >+ >+ >+' >+4 >+C >+5 >+, >+3 >+ > + + + >++ >+ >+ >+ H;&H-! #B*&
+C
Electronics Fabrication Processes Electronics Fabrication Processes Electronics Fabrication Processes Electronics Fabrication Processes
;
K < 85F K <I A36!06
- !?!\
K F<]%&' ()*+ ,-- K '%.](/ )0+"-- (1'2+1&1
Materials and Environmental Materials and Environmental Materials and Environmental Materials and Environmental Concerns Concerns Concerns Concerns -
- Integrated Circuits
Integrated Circuits Integrated Circuits Integrated Circuits
- !" # $ " "%
&""'
- ()
$*+ +
&"
Materials and Environmental Materials and Environmental Materials and Environmental Materials and Environmental Concerns Concerns Concerns Concerns -
- Printed Wiring Boards
Printed Wiring Boards Printed Wiring Boards Printed Wiring Boards
- !$,%
"- $ &" . &" )
&"
. & &"
( )
/0
- #
1 "&"& ( (
&"
1.7 kg microchip 1.7 kg microchip 1.7 kg microchip 1.7 kg microchip
<
Production of Hyper Production of Hyper Production of Hyper Production of Hyper-
- Pure Silicon
Pure Silicon Pure Silicon Pure Silicon
- I >&1 >&I
&. 8
- > !&1
!& >! &@$ ""
- "/
!& >!1 > !& 9 " &
- :
Czochralski Czochralski Czochralski Czochralski crystal pulling crystal pulling crystal pulling crystal pulling
1.7 kg microchip 1.7 kg microchip 1.7 kg microchip 1.7 kg microchip
<
1.7 kg microchip 1.7 kg microchip 1.7 kg microchip 1.7 kg microchip
<
<
Materials Inventory for Fabrication of a 15.5 Materials Inventory for Fabrication of a 15.5 Materials Inventory for Fabrication of a 15.5 Materials Inventory for Fabrication of a 15.5 kg monitor and a 9 kg CPU. kg monitor and a 9 kg CPU. kg monitor and a 9 kg CPU. kg monitor and a 9 kg CPU.
F <
Hybrid I/O Analysis Hybrid I/O Analysis Hybrid I/O Analysis Hybrid I/O Analysis
Process Process Process Process Model Model Model Model
)
- I/
)AI(.
From Williams’ Hybrid Model From Williams’ Hybrid Model From Williams’ Hybrid Model From Williams’ Hybrid Model
Williams’ Hybrid Estimate Williams’ Hybrid Estimate Williams’ Hybrid Estimate Williams’ Hybrid Estimate
; 8"* >(.9 >@ A *^
- *$-)(/
Williams Hybrid Results Williams Hybrid Results Williams Hybrid Results Williams Hybrid Results
Compare with the EI/O Model Compare with the EI/O Model Compare with the EI/O Model Compare with the EI/O Model
; 0AA:::#.AA 0_5++A+53*_4,4 ; 0AA:::A ` '0
- _4,4' 7A_*C,'57
&:H:C'++7
- (8)(E
I&)=G W8 (=69(&86)=G W8 =GW&I=@)I= 9I(=69(&86)=G W8 =GW&I=@)I= 9I(8)(E I&)=GW8
9 ( &( &9
&(
- <
- 9
- <
- (
- <
- &9
- <
- 9
- a
- &9
- a
- (
- a
- &(
- a
- =@)I==8
82
- &9
- &9
- !
- &9
- &9
- !
- 9
- 9
- !
- :
( : (
- !
- &(
- &(
- !
- 9
- 9
- !
- &(
- &(
- !
- 9
&9
a
- (
&(
a
- (
&(
<
- 9
&9
<
- &@&9
&@9 &@( &@&(
Exergy Exergy Exergy Exergy Analysis and Second Law Efficiency Analysis and Second Law Efficiency Analysis and Second Law Efficiency Analysis and Second Law Efficiency
% 32 & ; T ; T ; 9"&# ; &@$L8IT
E:"
- (
- (
- +
4
- @
- <(
- <(
- +
!
- A(
==
&("
Metallic Input Materials Limestone, Alloys 1.03 tons Gray Iron Products 1.00 tons Slag 0.73 tons Gasses 1,572 kg Dust 0.4 tons Metallurgical Coke 87 kg
Boundaries are drawn around the entire facility so that all components are at standard pressure and temperature
Natural Gas (Afterburners) 4.05 kg Air and Oxygen 1,508 kg
Gray Iron Products 1.00 tons Slag Dust 0.1 tons
)("
Metallic Input Materials Alloys 1.03 tons Tacit Electricity 5282 MJ
Boundaries are drawn around the entire facility so that all components are at standard pressure and temperature
Tacit Energy = Energy Used at the Melter * 3 (approximate grid efficiency in the US)
Second Law Efficiency of Melting: Second Law Efficiency of Melting: Second Law Efficiency of Melting: Second Law Efficiency of Melting: Cupola Cupola Cupola Cupola Melter Melter Melter Melter
T)) *-!)/A-a&&#/ +3+-7/AC -7/1 'D
7
+3+
!)*
- C54
) 7
C,3
8" $& 4+++ 8 %7A 3'' " %7AUF ++' !&"
- CC4+
&# %7A , !9 6A #!A
Second Law Efficiency of Melting: Second Law Efficiency of Melting: Second Law Efficiency of Melting: Second Law Efficiency of Melting:
Electric Induction Electric Induction Electric Induction Electric Induction Melter Melter Melter Melter
T)) *-!)/A-Q &&#/ +53-7/A4,-7/1 +D
7
+53
!)*
- C,C5 4
) 7
4,4
8" & ', 8 %7AUF ++' !&" %7A , !9 7A #!A
&.")
- )
"
- )
" $%%G +>(,2G $>(21G ''(),G $'<%$2* =)2)(=* )<=%>* ,<)%+*
)
- "
$%%G ++ D 53D )+(+%G ++D )$(=)G =+(%,G
&
- ,,7
(I"
- $$<>'1*
: +7 =G
- (#/
)<>+2* +47 E9 )<=)2*
- ,<)++*
&."I
- I
"
- I
" $%%G ++ D +C'D 11(++G 2<+%,* 7 4 7 2<)=$* ) $%%G ,D +D +33D 1>(>$G &
- 2<'%=*
: 3347 4 +7 $ , 7
- 2<)$)*
4
$ %# #"
- *
"&
- $
.# .&6
- "
- (
( ( (
E =G (# ) & & = G
- �&
- &
- &%
&% ( (
- E<
- E<
- "
: ( E<
) & = G
- �)
- )
- (
- E<
- "
: ( E<
Cupola Melting Carbon Emissions Cupola Melting Carbon Emissions Cupola Melting Carbon Emissions Cupola Melting Carbon Emissions
- .&
,%% ::0;7-;07J
- +
,+,& C+ G 4 =G .&
!" #$
- '+
,+,& 4 %"4 5/4,&%" + E 4 =G 34 &%
F&I ?.A8
Electric Induction Batch Melting Electric Induction Batch Melting Electric Induction Batch Melting Electric Induction Batch Melting Carbon Emissions (2006 model) Carbon Emissions (2006 model) Carbon Emissions (2006 model) Carbon Emissions (2006 model)
%& =%% ::0;7;::0:37J
- +
,+,& C+ G 4 =G .&
!" $ %'&'
34 ,+,&
F&I ?.A8
Electric Induction Heel Melting Electric Induction Heel Melting Electric Induction Heel Melting Electric Induction Heel Melting Carbon Emissions (1970’s model) Carbon Emissions (1970’s model) Carbon Emissions (1970’s model) Carbon Emissions (1970’s model)
%&( ,>% ::0;7;::3;7J
- +
,+,& C+ G 4 =G .&
!" )* %'&'(
'C4 ,+,&
F&I ?.A8
+4 +4 +4
- 9"
,>% 'C4
)K !
=%% 34
)K
- ,%%
34
&
8F&I ?.A8
- 8"
Carbon Intensity of Foundries Carbon Intensity of Foundries Carbon Intensity of Foundries Carbon Intensity of Foundries (Kg CO2 Equivalent/ (Kg CO2 Equivalent/ (Kg CO2 Equivalent/ (Kg CO2 Equivalent/Tonne Tonne Tonne Tonne of Metal Melt)
- f Metal Melt)
- f Metal Melt)
- f Metal Melt)
&@ $-&@$/
','33 5+,553
6%6 B
334 +++,4
#)* C
C+53 ++4
#*6 D .*6
'+3,C ++3453
#6& E*
- #
' . ' ### # ' ##
- +
&!
)% ####
++++7
4
&+
CC3 C +' 5'4
)#% BF) %)#
43,4 ' CC'
%6* >E*
&#!
CC5 ++++''
##*" G
- H
- degree of perfection /P = 5.33*10-7
Plasma enhanced CVD Plasma enhanced CVD Plasma enhanced CVD Plasma enhanced CVD
8I
#666%) *6&%### *6&%### 4
&+
####%) 6*#&* #### ##)#6
- %# ,%.
##)& &*&%. #" #**.6 E ####& .%.%)% #6"" %)66 D ####"6 )).%6 6)# &*#%6 B
- #' #
. . ' ### # ' ## +
&!
". ####) ##%%&) D
- degree of perfection
/P = 5.83*10-8
Wet Oxidation Process Wet Oxidation Process Wet Oxidation Process Wet Oxidation Process
!:%`4
- %
- 8)/
- &"
%-> % #% .
- &"%'4%
'4%
- '