1 | [footer text here] Sarah Puryear, MD MPH
What’s new in HIV-associated tuberculosis?
December 14, 2019
1
Disclosure
I have no relevant financial relationships with any companies related to the content of this course.
2
Whats new in HIV-associated tuberculosis? December 14, 2019 Sarah - - PDF document
Whats new in HIV-associated tuberculosis? December 14, 2019 Sarah Puryear, MD MPH 1 Disclosure I have no relevant financial relationships with any companies related to the content of this course. 2 1 | [footer text here] Objectives
1 | [footer text here] Sarah Puryear, MD MPH
December 14, 2019
1
I have no relevant financial relationships with any companies related to the content of this course.
2
2 | [footer text here]
§ Select and interpret diagnostic tests for latent tuberculosis
infection (LTBI) in HIV-infected patients
§ Design an LTBI treatment plan that accounts for ART drug
interactions
§ Identify appropriate methods to screen for LTBI vs. diagnose
active TB
§ Describe when to start ART in TB and major rifamycin-ART
interactions
§ Manage TB immune reconstitution inflammatory syndrome
(IRIS) 3
WHO, Global Tuberculosis Report 2019
§ 2018:
cases/year
deaths/year
§ #1 cause of
death among PLHIV 4
3 | [footer text here]
Tuberculosis Cases in United States, 1980-2015 Centers for Disease Control (CDC). Reported Tuberculosis in the United States, 2015 Atlanta, GA: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, CDC; 2016.
5
California Department of Public Health (CDPH). TB Fact Sheet 2017, Sacramento, CA; 2018.
each year
6
4 | [footer text here]
How many people have you started on latent TB treatment in the past year?
A B C D
7
§ A 41 year-old man from San Francisco presents to your
clinic for evaluation. Two weeks ago, he was diagnosed with HIV.
§ Initial labs show:
§ He denies any history of TB infection and does not know of
any contacts with TB
§ He has experienced homelessness and has had brief periods
8
5 | [footer text here]
41M from SF with new HIV (CD4 120, VL 75K) and indeterminate IGRA
What is the correct interpretation of this indeterminate IGRA result and what is your next step?
A.
TB infected; rule out active TB and treat him
B.
TB exposed, uninfected; do nothing
C.
TB infection cannot be determined; re-test when CD4 is higher
D.
TB exposed OR BCG vaccinated; obtain a PPD “tie-breaker”
E.
TB infection cannot be determined; obtain a PPD “tie-breaker”
A B C D E
9
§ WHO?
risk factors
§ WHY?
active disease
disease
§ WHEN?
care
& CD4<200 à repeat after ART started & CD4>200
exposure to active TB: Screen annually
TB case
DHHS OI Guidelines, 2019
10
6 | [footer text here]
Badje, Lancet Global Health, 2017
Probability of Death
11
Option 1: Tuberculin Skin Test Option 2: Interferon Gamma Release Assay
Neither distinguishes between latent and active disease Negative does NOT rule out active disease 48 to 72 hours later ≥ 5 mm positive in HIV+ pts QuantiFERON-TB Gold-Plus ELISA T-SPOT.TB ELISPOT
12
7 | [footer text here]
Both 65-70% sensitive in PLHIV
Diagnostic Approach Strengths Limitations TST § Vast experience, abundant data § Cheaper § Requires 2 visits § False positives possible with BCG* § Can remain positive after LTBI, active TB tx IGRAs § Requires 1 visit § Interpretation not subjective § More specific than TST § Unaffected by BCG § Technical errors § Must be processed in 8-30hrs § False positives with some other mycobacteria § Limited data in children, recent TB exposure, CD4<200 § Can remain positive after LTBI, active TB tx
*BCG status should NOT affect PPD interpretation
13
§ 4th generation IGRA FDA approved 6/2017 § Advances/Advantages1
§ PLHIV2
immunosuppression
1APHL Press Release, 2018. 2Telisinghe, IJTLD, 2017.
14
8 | [footer text here]
Measure IFN-γ by ELISA
Incubate
15
Nil (IU/ml) TB1 minus Nil (IU/ml) TB2 minus Nil (IU/ml) Mitogen minus Nil (IU/ml) QFT-Plus Result Report/ Interpretation ≦8.0 ≥0.35 and ≥25% Nil Any Any Positive
infection likely Any ≥0.35 and ≥25% Nil <0.35 OR ≥0.35 and <25% Nil ≥0.5 Negative
infection NOT likely <0.5 Indeterminate Likelihood of M. tuberculosis infection cannot be determined >8.0 Any Any
Qualitative Quantitative
16
9 | [footer text here]
§ 294 HIV positive San Franciscans underwent TST & Quanteriferon1
§ BUT if one test was positive: only 28% had concordance
1Luetkemeyer, Am J Respir Crit Care Med, 2007; 2Mazurek, MMWR, June 2010.
“…the predictive value of this approach is not clear, and its adoption would be more expensive and more difficult to
screen for LTBI is not recommended in the United States”2
17
§ You start him on Descovy (TAF/FTC) and Dolutegravir § 3 month labs demonstrate:
§ He is asymptomatic § CXR is within normal limits
You decide to treat him for LTBI.
41M from SF with new HIV (CD4 120, VL 75K) and indeterminate IGRA
18
10 | [footer text here]
41M from SF with new HIV (CD4 230, VL UD) on TAF/FTC/DTG with positive IGRA
Which one of the following regimens do you select to treat LTBI in this patient?
pyridoxine for 2 months
B.
Isoniazid and pyridoxine daily for 9 months
C.
Isoniazid and pyridoxine daily for 6 months
D.
Isoniazid and pyridoxine plus rifapentine weekly for 3 months
A B C D
19
§ Preferred
§ Alternative
§ **High risk of hepatotoxicity**
†Rifapentine and isoniazid recommended only with Efavirenz and Raltegravir + ABC/3TC or TDF/FTC.
DHHS OI Guidelines, 2019
H= isoniazid R=Rifampin P=RifaPentine Z=PyraZinamide
20
11 | [footer text here]
Regimen Adult Dosage Durations, Months Evidence Rating in HIV-Positive Pts Isoniazid* daily 300 mg/day 9 A I Isoniazid* daily 300 mg/day 6 C I Rifampin daily 600 mg/day 4 B I Rifapentine + isoniazid*† weekly Maximum: 900 mg/900 mg (+/- DOT) 3 A II
*Give pyridoxine 10-50 mg/day with isoniazid to prevent neuropathy in HIV-positive pts.
†Rifapentine and isoniazid recommended only with Efavirenz and Raltegravir + ABC/3TC or TDF/FTC.
DHHS OI Guidelines, 2019; Borisov, MMWR, 2018.
21
Menzies, NEJM, 2018; DHHS OI Guidelines, 2019
(Only 255 PLHIV)
OFF THE
PRESS
à DHHS 2019: 4R recommended in LTBI patients who cannot receive INH
22
12 | [footer text here]
§ 2011: 3HP recommended for LTBI in PLHIV NOT on ART § 2018 CDC updates & 2019 DHHS updates:
DHHS OI Guidelines, 2019; Borisov, MMWR, 2018; Sterling (PREVENT TB), AIDS, 2016
OFF THE
PRESS
23
Rifapentine and Antiretrovirals
§ Efavirenz (n=87)1
§ Raltegravir (n=16)2
à Weekly rifapentine + RAL acceptable; daily is not
§ Dolutegravir?
1Podany, CID, 2015; 2Weiner, J Antimicrob Chemotherapy, 2014
No PIs NRTI Backbone: TDF/FTC Or ABC/3TC not TAF …more on this later
24
13 | [footer text here]
Previous study:1
1Brooks, CID, 2018; 2Dooley, CROI 2019
OFF THE
PRESS
DOLPHIN Study (n=60)
§ HIV+ adults suppressed on EFV-based ART § Switched to DTG qD+TDF/FTC x 8 weeks then started on 3HP § HP decreased DTG bioavailability by 29%,
§ Viral suppression maintained, no adverse events
à Dolutegravir may be given with 3HP
Dooley, et al, CROI 2019, Abstract 80LB
25
BRIEF-TB: Multinational, randomized, open-label, phase III trial
§ Intervention: Rifapentine 600mg + Isoniazid 300 mg QD x 28 days § Control: Isoniazid 300mg daily x 9 months § Population: HIV infected, ≥13 years old, without active TB § Median CD4 470(IQR 346-635), 50% on ART § Findings: 24 TB cases in 1HP
, 29 cases in 9H -à Noninferior
§ Completion rates: 97% in 1HP
, 90% in 9H à Author Conclusion: 1HP safe and effective in preventing TB disease compared to 9H at 156 week follow up
Swindells, NEJM, 2019
26
14 | [footer text here]
My generalized approach
Is your patient
Check for medication interactions and contraindicated co-morbidities before initiating any regimen! *Data for 4R in HIV+ patients is inferior to data for 3HP. If using RAL with 4R, increase RAL dose
27
My generalized approach
Is your patient
No: Are you going to start now?
Check for medication interactions and contraindicated co-morbidities before initiating any regimen! *Data for 4R in HIV+ patients is inferior to data for 3HP. If using RAL with 4R, increase RAL dose
28
15 | [footer text here]
My generalized approach
Is your patient
Yes: Is it RAL or EFV based w/o TAF? No: Are you going to start now? No: Choose by frequency, SE, med interactions tor THIS pt.
(this is rare)
Yes: Proceed to
Check for medication interactions and contraindicated co-morbidities before initiating any regimen! *Data for 4R in HIV+ patients is inferior to data for 3HP. If using RAL with 4R, increase RAL dose
29
My generalized approach
Is your patient
Yes: Is it RAL or EFV based w/o TAF? No: Are you going to start now? No: Can/should you change their regimen? Do you want to? Yes: 3HP or 4R* (Or 9H) No: Choose by frequency, SE, med interactions tor THIS pt.
(this is rare)
Yes: Proceed to
Check for medication interactions and contraindicated co-morbidities before initiating any regimen! *Data for 4R in HIV+ patients is inferior to data for 3HP. If using RAL with 4R, increase RAL dose
30
16 | [footer text here]
My generalized approach
Is your patient
Yes: Is it RAL or EFV based w/o TAF? No: Are you going to start now? No: Can/should you change their regimen? Do you want to? Yes: 3HP or 4R* (Or 9H) No: Choose by frequency, SE, med interactions tor THIS pt.
(this is rare)
Yes: Proceed to
Yes: Consider RAL
TAF!) while on 3HP or 4R*
(rare)
No: Choose 9H
(Most common) Check for medication interactions and contraindicated co-morbidities before initiating any regimen! *Data for 4R in HIV+ patients is inferior to data for 3HP. If using RAL with 4R, increase RAL dose
31
1.
New positive LTBI test and negative workup for active TB
2.
Close contact with active TB and negative workup for active TB à BCG history should not affect the decision to treat in HIV positive individuals for LTBI
32
17 | [footer text here]
§ Occurred in 15.1% immediate group vs 15.2% deferred group
àIn high prevalence TB setting, safer to defer IPT until 12 weeks postpartum in WLHIV on ART (unless recent TB exposure)
Gupta, NEJM, 2019
OFF THE
PRESS
33
§ Baseline LFTs in all HIV-positive individuals on ART § Repeat LFTs if:
§ Elevated LFTs—when to stop?
34
18 | [footer text here]
§ 27 year old woman from El Salvador is admitted with
cough, fevers, and an 18 pound weight loss over the past month
§ Chest x-ray shows a diffuse infiltrate § HIV test is positive: CD4
30 cells/mm3, viral load pending
§ AFB smear of sputum is negative § PJP negative § Pregnancy test is negative
35
With a focus on PULMONARY TB
§ Clinical suspicion is a must!
chest pain
appetite loss, weight-loss, fatigability
§ Testing options
36
19 | [footer text here]
§ Obtain a chest x-ray if: positive IGRA /TST, TB exposure, or TB sxs § CXR can be normal in HIV positive individuals with active TB 873 HIV/PTB cases 21% normal CXR with CD4<50
1Cain, NEJM, 2010; ; 2Chamie, IJTLD, 2010 1
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 0-50 51-100 101-150 151-200 201-250 251-300 301-350 351-400 401-450 451-500 >500 CD4 Cell Count (cells/μL) % Normal Chest X-ray
2
37
§ Overall sensitivity of sputum microscopy ~50% § Lower in HIV+
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35%
0-50 51-100 101-150 151-200 201-250 251-300 301-350 351-400 401-450 451-500 >500
CD4 Cell Count (cells/μL) % Negative AFB Smear
Chamie, IJTLD 2010
38
20 | [footer text here]
§ More sensitive and specific than smear § Methods
§ SLOW
§ 7-12 days § Problematic for non-sputum
39
Xpert Assay
§ More sensitive
than smear
§ Useful in
children and EPTB samples
§ Screens for Rif
resistance
Boehme, NEJM, 2010
40
21 | [footer text here]
§ High sensitivity1
§ 97% sensitive in smear + / culture + § 61% sensitive in smear - / culture +
§ High specificity
1Steingart, Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 2014; 2Luetkemeyer, CID, 2016
41
§ Two different amplification targets/new design § Designed to overcome lower sensitivity in smear negative pulmonary
TB
§ PTB diagnostic accuracy study: 8 countries
§ Greater loss in specificity if history of prior TB
1Dorman, Lancet ID, 2018
42
22 | [footer text here]
27F from El Salvador with new dx HIV (CD4 30, VL pend) presents with pulmonary infiltrates, fever, cough, wt loss x 1 month
§ The GeneXpert returns positive § No Rif resistance detected § You start the patient on RIPE therapy
43
27F from El Salvador with new dx HIV (CD4 30, VL pend) presents with with pulmonary TB now on RIPE
A.
In 2 months, when she starts consolidation phase
B.
Within 2 weeks of TB therapy start
C.
After she completes TB therapy
D.
Within 8 weeks of TB therapy start
A B C D
44
23 | [footer text here]
CAMELIA3
1Havlir, NEJM, 2011; 2Abdool Karim NEJM 2011; 3Blanc, NEJM 2011
STRIDE1 SAPiT2
45
Trial Location Median CD4 (IQR) Arms Effect of Earlier Rx on Mortality SAPIT1
(Karim 2010)
South Africa 150 (77-254) Integrated (6 wks) vs. Sequential (39 wks) ê56%
(subanalysis 67% in CD4<50)
CAMELIA2
(Blanc 2011)
Cambodia 25 (10-56) Immediate (2 wks) vs Early (8 wks) ê34% STRIDE3
(Havlir 2011)
Multi- national 77 (36-145) Immediate (2 wks) vs Early (8-12 wks) ê40% in CD4<50 group only *Studies excluded CNS TB
1Havlir, NEJM, 2011; 2Blanc, NEJM 2011; 3Abdool Karim NEJM 2011
46
24 | [footer text here]
§ ART recommended in all PLHIV with TB (AI)1 § CD4 <50 cells/mm3, initiate ART ASAP,
within 2 weeks of TB treatment start (AI)1
§ CD4>= 50 cells/mm3, initiate ART within 8 weeks (AI)1
1DHHS OI Guidelines, 2019; 2Torok, CID, 2011.
EXCEPTION: TB meningitis2à early ART associated with increased AE, exercise caution
47
§ Pill burden: 4 drugs for TB + HIV Meds § Overlapping toxicities: Common side effects § Coordination of the programs: TB care and HIV care are
not always linked
§ First line TB regimens should contain a rifamycin
(rifampin, rifabutin)
Excellent review article: Meintjes, Management of active tuberculosis in adults with HIV, Lancet HIV, 2019
48
25 | [footer text here]
§ TDF/FTC & ABC/3TC
§ TAF à Do NOT use TAF with Rifamycins..yet
OFF THE
PRESS
Custodio, European AIDS Conference 2017, Abstract PS13/4
§ BID TAF + rifampin vs. qD TAF alone
§ TAF qD + Rifampin (n=21) in HIV-negative individuals
Cerrone, J Antimicrob Chemother 2019
49
§ Dolutegravir: RIF reduces plasma levels of DTGà Overcome by
BID dosing
à Supports the BID DTG recommendation
§ Bictegravir:
à Co-administration not recommended
Dooley et al, CID, 2019. “INSPIRING” Study Custodio et al, CROI 2018. Abstract 34
OFF THE
PRESS
50
26 | [footer text here]
Rifampin Rifabutin Rifapentine NRTIs TDF/FTC & ABC/3TC TAF NNRTIs Efavirenz
(increase RFB)
Etravirine
(potentially)
Rilpivirine
(potentially)
Doravirine
(DOR BID)
PI/r
Dose 150mg QD
PI/cobi
Dose 150mg QD
INSTI Raltegravir
(800mg BID)
Elvitegravir Dolutegravir
(50mg BID)
Bictegravir
51
27F from El Salvador with new dx HIV (CD4 30, VL pend) and pulmonary TB, recently started on RIPE and ART
§ Your patient has now been on TB therapy for 20 days and on ART
for 10 days
§ She has recurrent fevers and notes worsening dyspnea and cough § You obtain a repeat CXR, which now shows progression of
pulmonary infiltrates
§ You suspect Immune Reconstitution Inflammatory Syndrome (IRIS)
52
27 | [footer text here]
27F from El Salvador with new dx HIV (CD4 30, VL pend) and pulmonary TB, recently started on RIPE and ART with concern for IRIS
What is the best way to manage her symptoms?
A B C D
53
Timing:
ART; most w/in 3 months Epidemiology:
15.7%1
Predictors:
ART VL
Treatment:
1Muller, Lancet ID, 2010. 2DHHS OI Guidelines, 2019.
54
28 | [footer text here]
weeksà0.75mg/kg/day x 2 weeks)
procedures (equiv 1 hospital day)
à Placebo 3 days (IQR 0-9), Prednisone 0 days (IQR 0-3). No increase infections
55
Prednisone as IRIS Prevention: PredART Trial1
RCT double-blind of placebo vs. prednisone (40mg/day x 2 weeksà20mg/day x 2 weeks) at time of ART start
2019 DHHS OI Guidelines2: Recommends pre-emptive prednisone for patients at high risk of developing TB-IRIS
1Meintjes (PredART Team) NEJM, 2018; 2DHHS OI Guidelines, 2019.
OFF THE
PRESS
56
29 | [footer text here]
Tait et. al NEJM, 2019
§ Population: 3289 HIV-negative adults in Africa § Exposure: 2 doses of the M72/AS01E candidate vaccine vs 2 doses
§ Result: Mean 2.7 years' follow-up:
§ Overall 36-month efficacy was 49.7%.
57
1.
Screen all PLHIV for TB at diagnosis or entry into care
2.
TST or IGRA can be used to screen for LTBI
3.
Treat LTBI: It prevents TB and reduces mortality
4.
9 months of INH is the preferred LTBI treatment regimen; alternatives exist, but beware of drug-drug interactions
5.
CO-TREATMENT OF HIV AND TB SAVES LIVES
6.
Rifamycins have multiple interactions with ART
7.
Prednisone has a role in prevention and treatment of TB- IRIS
58
30 | [footer text here]
Special thanks to the following for their contributions to this presentation:
59
§ Population: ART-naïve HIV/TB co-infected patients on <8 weeks of
rifampin-based TB treatment. Excludes TB meningitis. N=456
§ Exposure: RAL 400mg BID +3Tc/TDF vs. EFV 600mg qD+3Tc/TDF § Non-inferiority margin: -12%
3.7
margin
4 8
RAL + 3TC/TDF EFV + 3TC/TDF
Virologic Nonresponse HIV-1 RNA < 50 c/mL No Virologic Data Patients (%) 60 100 80 20 40 66 61 22 29 12 10 RAL + 3TC/TDF EFV + 3TC/TDF Virologic Outcomes (FDA Snapshot) RAL-EFV Treatment Difference (95% CI)
Ø At Wk 48, RAL did not meet criteria for noninferior virologic efficacy vs EFV
De Castro, IAS 2019, MOAB0101
60