Voting, Preferences, and Fair Division @,=,4A(!124( - - PDF document

▶
voting preferences and fair division
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

Voting, Preferences, and Fair Division @,=,4A(!124( - - PDF document

Nov 07, 2022 368 likes •545 views

!"#$%&'()*+,-.(/0(012(3402&5/-2(6207224(( !*8+902&("-,24-2(/4:(;-*4*8,-. ( </==(#>??( Computational Social Choice: Voting, Preferences, and Fair Division @,=,4A(!124( B,=,4AC22-.D1/&E/&:D2:9(

slide-1
SLIDE 1

!"#$%&'()*+,-.(/0(012(3402&5/-2(6207224(( !*8+902&("-,24-2(/4:(;-*4*8,-.(

</==(#>??(

Computational Social Choice:

Voting, Preferences, and Fair Division

@,=,4A(!124(

B,=,4AC22-.D1/&E/&:D2:9( !*9&.2(726.,02'(1F+'GG777D22-.D1/&E/&:D2:9G-.#$%&G(

)*:/BH.(I=/4(

  • ;-*4*8,-.(/4:(!*8+90/J*4(
  • !"(#$%&(</==(#>??(0*+,-(/4:(.B==/69.(
  • ;K/8+=2(,:2/.(/4:(,..92.(
  • L(+22M(/0(012(02-14,-/=(&2.9=0.(NL&&*7H.(

,8+*..,6,=,0B(012*&28O(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

slide-2
SLIDE 2

!*8+902&("-,24-2(

  • ,.( 012( .09:B( /4:( 012( .-,24-2( *5( 012( 012*&2J-/=(

5*94:/J*4.(*5(,45*&8/J*4(/4:(-*8+90/J*4(/4:( 012,&( ,8+=28240/J*4( /4:( /++=,-/J*4( ,4(

  • *8+902&(.B.028.D(RS,M,+2:,/T(

– U9,=:,4A(.B.028.( – <NKO(VW( – X*7(5/.0(-/4(72(A20(012(/4.72&W( – <*-9.(*4(-*8+90/J*4/=(/4:(,45*&8/J*4/=(-*4.0&/,4.D(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

;-*4*8,-.(

  • ,.(012(.*-,/=(.-,24-2(01/0(.09:,2.(012(+&*:9-J*4Y(

:,.0&,69J*4Y(/4:(-*4.98+J*4(*5(A**:.(/4:( .2&E,-2.D(RS,M,+2:,/T(

– ;-*4*8,2.(N.B.028.O( – Z/4B(.2=5[,402&2.02:(/A240.( – LA240.H(+&252&24-2.G9J=,J2.(*E2&(*90-*82.( – LA240.H(,45*&8/J*4(/4:(62=,25.( – LA240.H(:2-,.,*4(8/M,4A( – \/82[012*&2J-(,402&/-J*4.(*5(/A240.(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

slide-3
SLIDE 3

)12(3402&5/-2(

  • !*8+902&(.B.028.(/&2(,4-&2/.,4A=B(62,4A(:2E2=*+2:(

/4:(9.2:(6B(89=J+=2(+/&J2.(7,01(:,]2&240(+&252&24-2.(

– I&2:,-0(.B.028(*90-*82.( – ^2.,A4(.B.028.(0*(/-1,2E2(:2.,&2:(*90-*82.(

  • ;-*4*8,-(+&*6=28.(.*82J82.(/&2(N1/&:O(
  • *8+90/J*4/=(+&*6=28.(

– _2.*9&-2(/==*-/J*4( – I&,-2(:,.-*E2&B(

Theories, algorithms, and systems that satisfy both economic and computational constraints.

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

`*0.(*5(!*8+2==,4A(L++=,-/J*4.(

$GP?G??(

  • 3402&420(Z*42Ja/J*4'(

(\**A=2Y(@/1**bY(Z,-&*.*c(/&2(9.,4A(/9-J*4.(0*(.2==(/:.(

  • Z/&M20.(/&2(9.2:(5*&(,45*&8/J*4(/AA&2A/J*4(

– \**A=2Y(@/1**bY(Z,-&*.*cY(\;Y(20-D(1/E2(,402&4/=(+&2:,-J*4( 8/&M20.(

  • "*-,/=(4207*&M(/4:("*-,/=()/AA,4A'(

(</-26**MY()7,F2&Y(ZB"+/-2Y(`,4M2:34Y(<=,-M&Y(`,6&/&B)1,4A( (d(

!"(#$%&(</==Q??(

slide-4
SLIDE 4

)1,.(!*9&.2(

  • _*0/J4A(0*+,-(-*9&.2(
  • I&2E,*9.(

– </==(#>?>D(345*&8/J*4Y(I&2:,-J*4Y(/4:(!*==2-JE2( 3402==,A24-2( – </==(#>>eD(L..,A48240Y(Z/0-1,4AY(/4:(^B4/8,-.( – </==(#>>$D("*-,/=(!*8+9J4A( – "+&,4A(#>>$D(!*8+90/J*4/=(<,4/4-2( – "+&,4A(#>>fD(!*8+90/J*4/=(Z2-1/4,.8(^2.,A4( – "+&,4A(#>>%D(Z9=J[/A240(`2/&4,4A(/4:(38+=28240/J*4( d((

  • "28,4/&(.0B=2(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

!*9&.2(\*/=.(

  • I&*E,:2(/4(,40&*:9-J*4(0*(/4(282&A,4AY(

,402&:,.-,+=,4/&B(=,02&/09&2((

  • ^2E2=*+(/(=2E2=(*5(-*85*&0(7,01(6*01(

2-*4*8,-(/4:(-*8+90/J*4/=(01,4M,4A((

  • ^2E2=*+(A242&/=(.M,==.(&2=/02:(0*(&2/:,4A(

+/+2&.Y(,:24J5B,4A(&2.2/&-1(g92.J*4.((

  • I&*E,:2(/(6/.,.(5*&(-*4J492:(&2.2/&-1D(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

slide-5
SLIDE 5

</==(#>??(

  • !*8+90/J*4/=("*-,/=(!1*,-2(
  • L=A*&,018,-Y(A/82(012*&2J-Y(/4:(-*4-2+09/=(

g92.J*4.(&2=/02:(0*(!"#$#"#%&#'#()&)*+,-%Y( !"#$#"#%&#'+.."#.+,-%Y($+)"'/)0)1)-%Y(/4:( "+%2)%.D((

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

;K/8+=2'(I&252&24-2(LAA&2A/J*4(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

h6/8/(i(Z-!/,4(i(j/:2&( Z-!/,4(i(j/:2&(i(h6/8/( j/:2&(i(h6/8/(i(Z-!/,4(( k*J4A( S,442&W((

slide-6
SLIDE 6

I&252&24-2(LAA&2A/J*4(/.(/4( ;-*4*8,-(I&*6=28(

  • S1/0(8/M2.(/(A**:(-*==2-JE2(:2-,.,*4W(!(

72=5/&2(2-*4*8,-.(

  • \,E24(/(E*J4A(&9=2Y(7,==(/A240.(0&90159==B(

&2+*&0(012,&(+&252&24-2.W(!(A/82(012*&B(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

I&252&24-2(LAA&2A/J*4(/.(/( !*8+90/J*4/=(I&*6=28((

  • "*-,/=(-1*,-2(594-J*4(

– 34+90(K(V(l/A240.H(+&252&24-2.m( – h90+90("S<NKO(V(7,442&(*5(012(2=2-J*4(

  • LA240(8/4,+9=/J*4(

– 34+90(K(V(l/A240.H(+&252&24-2.m( – h90+90(ZNKO(V(/(&2+*&0(01/0(-/4(8/M2(82(62F2&(*](

  • L=A*&,018.(0*(-/=-9=/02("S<NKO(/4:(ZNKO(
  • !*8+90/J*4/=(-*8+=2K,0B(*5(-/=-9=/J4A("S<NKO(

/4:(ZNKO(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

slide-7
SLIDE 7

"0&9-09&2(*5(012(!*9&.2(

  • 340&*:9-0*&B(=2-09&2.((N%(=2-09&2.O(

– )1,.(*42Y(A/82(012*&B(N#OY(/4:(6/.,-.(*5(

  • *8+90/J*4/=(E*J4A(012*&B(NPO(
  • _2.2/&-1(I/+2&.((

– !*8+90/J*4/=(E*J4A(012*&B(( – _/4M,4AY(0&9.0Y(/4:(&2+90/J*4 ( ( (( – </,&(^,E,.,*4 ( (( – I&252&24-2(2=,-,0/J*4( ( ((

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

I&2&2g9,.,02.(

  • Z/01(6/-MA&*94:(,.(,8+*&0/40b(L0(=2/.0(/(6/.,-(
  • *9&.2(,4(=,42/&(/=A26&/(N.9-1(/.(Z(#?6Y(LZ(#?6Y(

*&(2g9,E/=240O(((

  • L4(/=A*&,018(-*9&.2(N!"(?#nY(*&(2g9,E/=240O(
  • </8,=,/&,0B(7,01(012(-*4-2+0(*5(&/J*4/=,0BD(L4(L3(
  • *9&.2(*&(/4(2-*4*8,-.GA/82(012*&B(-*9&.2D((

(L:E/4-2:(-*9&.2(,4(/=A*&,018.Y(8,-&*2-*4*8,-.Y(A/82(

012*&BY(*&(=,42/&(+&*A&/88,4A(/&2(12=+59=(690(!"#( &2g9,&2:D((

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

slide-8
SLIDE 8

_2/:,4A(Z/02&,/=.(

  • <*&(2/-1(-=/..Y(72(1/E2(+&*E,:2:(.*82(&2/:,4A(

8/02&,/=.D(S2(/.M(B*9(0*(&2/:(0128(/4:(.968,0( B*9&(-*88240.(6B(8,:4,A10(625*&2(-=/..D((

  • S2(7,==(+&*E,:2(&2/:,4A(g92.J*4.(5*&(2/-1(-=/..D((

– @*9&(-*88240.(.1*9=:(,4-=9:2(A**:(5/,01(/4.72&.(0*( 012.2(g92.J*4.D(( – )12(g92.J*4.(/&2(:2.,A42:(0*(5/-,=,0/02(,4( 94:2&.0/4:,4A(*&(0*(24-*9&/A2(:,.-9..,*4D(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

\&/:,4A(

I&*6=28(.20.( #op( #(1*827*&M(+&*6=28(.20.( I/&J-,+/J*4( #op( _2/:,4A(+/+2&.Y(.968,q4A(-*88240.( 625*&2(-=/..Y(/4:(+/&J-,+/J4A(,4(-=/..( :,.-9..,*4D(Nj*02'(L6.240(.09:240.( &/&2=B(-*40&,6902(0*(:,.-9..,*4.DO( I&2.240/J*4(*5( *42(*&(07*( &2.2/&-1(+/+2&.( ?op( L(.1*&0(.9&E2B(/4:(-&,Jg92(*5(012( +/+2&.D(`2/:(-=/..(:,.-9..,*4D( I&*r2-0( Pop( I&*r2-0(+&*+*./=Y(-=/..(+&2.240/J*4Y( /4:(s4/=(&2+*&0D(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

slide-9
SLIDE 9

I&*r2-0(

  • $"%&'(:2E2=*+(/(:22+(94:2&.0/4:,4A(*5(/(.+2-,s-(&2.2/&-1(

/&2/(/4:(0*(012(2K024:(+*..,6=2(0*(7*&M(*4(/4(*+24( &2.2/&-1(+&*6=28D((

  • !/4(62(012*&2J-/=Y(-*8+90/J*4/=Y(2K+2&,8240/=Y(*&(

28+,&,-/=D(

  • !/4(7&,02(/4(2K+*.,J*4(+/+2&Y(690(422:.(4*E2=0Bb(
  • L(=,.0(*5(1,A1[=2E2=(+&*r2-0(0*+,-.(7,==(62(+&*E,:2:D()"*(%+,(

,!-"*+%.,/(#"(0+"0"1,(2"*+("3!(#"04-(5"+(%00+"6%&7(

  • )240/JE2(+&*r2-0(:92(:/02.'(

– <&,:/B(?>G#$'(+&*r2-0(+&*+*./=(:92( – Z*4:/B(?#Go'(6&,25(+&*r2-0(+&2.240/J*4( – S2:42.:/B(?#Gf'(+&*r2-0(&2+*&0(:92(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

`*A,.J-.(

  • )<'(Z,M2(_962&&B(
  • ht-2(X*9&.(

– @,=,4A((

  • )*:/BY(#'P>(u(P'P>Y(Z^(PPe(
  • S2:42.:/B(eGfY(#'P>(u(P'P>Y(Z^(PPe(
  • Lc2&(eG$Y(2E2&B(Z*4:/B(#'P>(u(P'P>Y(Z^(PPe(

– `/02&(7,==(/::(*t-2(1*9&.(=,M2=B(*4()19&.:/B.(0*(8220(7,01( .09:240.(,4(/:E/4-2(*5(+&2.24J4A(+/+2&.( – Z,M2'(S2:(??[?#Y(Z^(.2-*4:(v**&(=*94A2(

(Z,..2:(-*9&.2(8/02&,/=.(5&*8(012()<(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

slide-10
SLIDE 10

;K/8+=2(3:2/.(/4:(3..92.(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

!*4:*&-20(I/&/:*K(,4(k*J4A(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

Z/&g9,.(:2( !*4:*&-20( N?fnP(u(?fenO(

  • !*4:*&-20(8201*:'(2=2-0(012(/=02&4/JE2(01/0(

:252/0.(2E2&B(*012&(/=02&4/JE2(,4(+/,&7,.2(

  • *8+/&,.*4D(

h6/8/(i(Z-!/,4(i(j/:2&( Z-!/,4(i(j/:2&(i(h6/8/( j/:2&(i(h6/8/(i(Z-!/,4((

  • !*4:*&-20(+/&/:*K'(012(.*-,/=(+&252&24-2(/--*&:,4A(0*(012(

4/09&/=(8/r*&,0B(&9=2(-/4(62(-B-=,-b((

S2(-/&2(/6*90(N?O(71/0(/&2(-*4.,:2&2:(wA**:x(-*==2-JE2(:2-,.,*4.( /4:(N#O(712012&(,0H.(+*..,6=2(N*&(,8+*..,6=2O(0*(:2.,A4(&9=2.(0*( /-1,2E2(0128D(

slide-11
SLIDE 11

k*02(Z/4,+9=/J*4(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

h6/8/(i(Z-!/,4(i(j/:2&( Z-!/,4(i(j/:2&(i(h6/8/( j/:2&(i(h6/8/(i(Z-!/,4(( "9++*.2(72(9.2(/(+=9&/=,0B(&9=2(/4:(6&2/M(J2.(/=+1/62J-/==BD(( ,.(62F2&(*](6B(&2+*&J4A( h6/8/(i(j/:2&(i(Z-!/,4( S2(-/&2(/6*90(.0&/02AB+&**5422.b(

</=.2[j/82[I&**542..(

  • 3402&420(E*J4A(62-*82.(+*+9=/&(
  • !&2/J4A(5/M2(,:24JJ2.(,.(-12/+(
  • ;AD(E*02(5*&(012(62.0(!"(:2+/&08240(,4(y"(

N:/4A2&*9.bO(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

X*7(-/4(72(+*..,6=B(/-1,2E2(5/=.2[4/82[+&**542..W(

slide-12
SLIDE 12

;=2-J4A(/(!*88,F22(

  • "9++*.2(72(422:(0*(2=2-0(/(-*88,F22(*5(M(

82862&.(*90(*5(4(-/4:,:/02D((

  • ((((((((+*..,6=2(*90-*82.(
  • y4&2/.*4/6=2(/4:(-*.0=B(0*(/.M(E*02&.(0*(

.968,0(012,&(59==(+&252&24-2.(*E2&(/==( /=02&4/JE2.(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

N?O X*7(-/4(72(2t-,240=B(2=,-,0(+/&J/=(+&252&24-2.W( N#O X*7(-/4(72(:2.,A4(E*J4A(&9=2.(01/0(7*&M(72==( 7,01(+/&J/=(+&252&24-2.W((

_/4M,4A(Z/F2&.(

  • U9B2&.(+&*E,:2(&2E,27.(*5(.2==2&.(*4(2=2-0&*4,-(

8/&M20+=/-2.(

  • L(&2+90/J*4(.B.028(9.2.(/4(/AA&2A/J*4(

594-J*4(0*(+&2.240(012(/AA&2A/02:(1,.0*&,-/=( 522:6/-M(0*(5909&2(69B2&.(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

S,==(/AA&2A/J*4(594-J*4.(/]2-0(012(.2==2&(621/E,*&W((

slide-13
SLIDE 13

!/M2(!9q4A(

  • L.(/(820/+1*&(5*&(/==*-/J4A(1202&*A242*9.Y((

:,E,.,6=2(A**:(N2AD(J82Y(4207*&M(6/4:7,:01O(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

N?O </,&42..'(S1/0(,.(,0W(I&*0*-*=.(0*(/-1,2E2(,0D(( N#O ;t-,24-B'(8/K,8,a2(012(0*0/=(1/++,42..(*5(/A240.( NPO )&90159=42..'(,4-24JE,a2(/A240.(0*(&2+*&0(012,&(0&92(+&252&24-2.( NnO h4=,42(.2q4A'(/A240.(-*82(/4:(A*(

^,.0&,6902:(j2A*J/J*4(

  • L==*-/J4A(,4:,E,.,6=2(A**:.(
  • S2(7,==(4*0(:,.-9..(/9-J*4.Y(71,-1(/&2(/(-=/..(

*5(4/09&/=(82-1/4,.8.(5*&(&2.*9&-2(/==*-/J*4(

– !240&/=,a2:(/4:(,4E*=E,4A(8*42B(

  • S2H==(-*4.,:2&(:,.0&,6902:(/++&*/-1(7,01(=*-/=(

42A*J/J*4D(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

(S2(-/&2(/6*90(012(&2=/J*4.1,+(6207224(012( 42A*J/J*4(.0&/02A,2.(9.2:(=*-/==B(/4:(012( /==*-/J*4(01/0(282&A2.(A=*6/==BD((

slide-14
SLIDE 14

L(I22M(/0(012()2-14,-/=(_2.9=0.(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

L&&*7H.(38+*..,6,=,0B()12*&28(

  • <,&.0(+&*E2:(6B(z244201({D(L&&*7(,4(?eo?(
  • L&A9/6=B(012(8*.0(5/8*9.(012*&28(,4(.*-,/=(
  • 1*,-2(012*&B(
  • )12(012*&28(.1*7.(01/0(4*(82-1/4,.8(5*&(

/AA&2A/J4A(,4:,E,:9/=(+&252&24-2.(,40*(/( .*-,/=(+&252&24-2.(-/4(.,89=0/42*9.=B(./J.5B(/( .20(*5(.228,4A=B(&2/.*4/6=2(/4:(4/09&/=( /K,*8.D((

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

slide-15
SLIDE 15

)12("2q4A(

  • L(s4,02(.20(*5(/=02&4/JE2.'(3'
  • L(s4,02(.20(*5(,4:,E,:9/=.'(4'5'678'9'8'%:'
  • ;/-1(,4:,E,:9/=(,(1/.(/(+&252&24-2(*&:2&,4A(;)'Y(

71,-1(,.(/(.0&,-0(=,42/&(*&:2&(*E2&(3'

  • L(+&252&24-2(+&*s=2(<;7'8'9'8';%='-*4.,.0.(*5(

012(+&252&24-2(*&:2&,4A(*5(2/-1(,4:,E,:9/=((

  • L(.*-,/=(72=5/&2(594-J*4(N"S<O(8/+.(5&*8(012(

+&252&24-2(+&*s=2(0*(/(.*-,/=(+&252&24-2( *&:2&,4A(;D((

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

3.(012&2(/("S<(01/0(1/.(wA**:(+&*+2&J2.xW((

LK,*8/J-(L++&*/-1(

"*82(.228,4A=B(&2/.*4/6=2(+&*+2&J2.(

  • I/&20*(2t-,24-B(N94/4,8,0BO'(,5(2E2&B(,4:,E,:9/=(

+&252&.(>(*E2&(?Y(0124(012(.*-,/=(+&252&24-2( *&:2&,4A(.1*9=:(/=.*(+&252&(>(*E2&(?'

  • 34:2+24:24-2(*5(,&&2=2E/40(/=02&4/JE2.'(.*-,/=(

+&252&24-2(*5(>(*E2&(?(.1*9=:(4*0(62(/]2-02:(,5( ,4:,E,:9/=.(-1/4A2(012,&(+&252&24-2.(*E2&(*012&( /=02&4/JE2.(

  • j*4[:,-0/0*&,/='(4*(,4:,E,:9/=(-/4(:,-0/02(/(.*-,/=(

+&252&24-2(*&:2&,4A(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

slide-16
SLIDE 16

L&&*7H.(38+*..,6,=,0B()12*&28(

  • RL&&*7Y(?eo?T((35(|L|(i(#Y(012&2(2K,.0.(4*("S<(

01/0(.,89=0/42*9.=B(./J.5B(/==(*5(012(+&2E,*9.( 01&22(/K,*8.D((

  • j*02(01/0(5*&(|L|(V(#(N07*(/=02&4/JE2.OY(012(

8/r*&,0B(&9=2(./J.s2.(/==(01&22(/K,*8.D((

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

!"(#$%&(ED.D(!"(?$%(

  • !"(?$%'(;-*4*8,-.(/4:(!*8+90/J*4Y(I&*5D(^/E,:(

I/&M2.Y())1(??'P>[?D((

  • U*01(/&2(/6*90(;-*4*8,-.(/4:(!*8+90/J*4(
  • ?$%(,.(6&*/:2&}(,0(.9&E2B.(8/4B(:,]2&240(0*+,-.(,4(012(

s2=:(

  • #$%&(,.(:22+2&}(,0(5*-9.2.(*4(/(.96[s2=:(/4:(2K+=*&2.(

&2-240(&2.2/&-1(g92.J*4.(7,01,4(012(.96[s2=:(

  • ?$%(,.(0/9A10(,4(=2-09&2(.0B=2Y(71,=2(#$%&(,.(/(&2.2/&-1(

.28,4/&(-*9&.2(

$GP?G??( !"(#$%&(</==Q??(

slide-17
SLIDE 17
  • Wed. 9/7
  • Lecture on games with complete information
  • Submit comments on Chapter 3 and Chapter 5.1 of

Multiagent Systems book before midnight 9/6

  • download the readings from the Schedule page of the

course website

  • Reading questions have been posted on the Schedule page
  • Please give the TF your email address so that we can

register you for the comment submission system

  • You can only view others’ comments after submitting

your own