SLIDE 1 UK Biomethane Market Update 50 Plants Injecting Gas by End 2015
15th June 2015
John Baldwin Managing Director CNG Services Ltd
john.baldwin@cngservices.co.uk www.cngservices.co.uk 07831 241217
SLIDE 2 UK Biomethane Market Update
“we have scratched the surface”
- 1. Biomethane Journey
- 2006 – 2010
- 2011 - 2015
- 2. 2013 – 15 Market Statistics
- 3. Selected projects
- 4. Benefits and Market Forecast
- 5. Conclusions
The fastest growing renewable technology?
SLIDE 3
BIOMETHANE JOURNEY REMINDER FROM UK BIOMETHANE DAY 26 JUNE 2012
SLIDE 4 Why Biomethane Injection?
1
- In 2007 we said:
- Biogas CHP often cannot use its waste heat
- UK has invested around £30 billion in its gas grid and even
more in appliances and central heating
- To meet EU Renewable Energy targets, we need to use
resources efficiently
- So, take the renewable methane to where it can be used
efficiently…..using the gas grid
SLIDE 5 2006 - 2008
- December 2006 – WRG – Wakefield
– Proved that vehicles could run on biomethane but this was not practical due to vehicle fill patterns and far too much gas – needed gas grid injection
- REA’s initial concept was for “equivalence”
– Otherwise no point injecting biomethane – Gaynor thought it seemed a good idea!
- Nov 2007 – Feb 2008 – United Utilities
– Feasibility Study for Grid Injection – National Grid strongly in favour
SLIDE 6 2008 - 2010
- Renewable Heat Incentive in Energy Act:
– In November 2008, REA concept of a premium for biomethane injected into grid accepted by DECC
– Proposal to Thames Water and SGN re Didcot flared gas project
– First biomethane injection from Thames Water’s Didcot plant
- REA work with DECC on RHI tariff levels to be set to give
equivalent returns to those from electricity generation
- Visits to other EU countries, especially Germany and Sweden
– Sweden has not much gas grid and lots of hydro so misleading – Germany has ‘expensive and slow’ regulations Didcot proved it could be done
SLIDE 7 2011 - 2012
- Not for Profit REAL Green Gas Certificate Scheme launched:
– April 2011
- Poundbury BtG Project identified:
– Start in June 2011 – Biomethane injection by Oct 2012
- Renewable Heat Incentive introduced:
– November 2011 tariff of 6.7 p/kWh
- EMIB review to bring down costs of entry and simplify processes:
– Sept 2011 – May 2012
– Agreed change in Oxygen limit to 1%, in place in Q2 2012 Poundbury 2012 was a key milestone
SLIDE 8 2006 – 2012 Conclusions
- In 2012, we said
- It has taken 6 years but we have:
– Attractive RHI tariff for projects starting in 2012 – Good regime that reduces costs, saves time and supports innovation – ‘Not for profit’ Green Gas Certificate Scheme that facilitates biomethane sales – Competitive supply chains starting to develop
This is the growth in Germany from start in 2006...we can follow this path
So what has happened since 2012?
SLIDE 9
BIOMETHANE JOURNEY HOW HAVE WE PROGRESSED SINCE 2012? END 2015 STATS
SLIDE 10
Biomethane projects per year 2010-2015
1 in 2012, 2 in 2013, total of 50 projects injecting gas by end 2015
SLIDE 11 Proportion of Projects in Each Feedstock Category
GGG Feedstock Category Number projects in Category % Sewage Sludge 5 10% Agricultural 29 58% Food Waste 11 22% Food Processing 4 8% Biodegradable 1 2% Unknown 0% Total Projects 50
SLIDE 12 GDN Number of Projects % NG 17 34% SGN 16 32% WWU 12 24% NGN 5 10% Total Projects 50
Proportion of Projects in Each GDN area
SLIDE 13 Biogas Ncmh Number of Projects % 0 - 400 3 6% 400 - 800 8 16% 800 - 1200 29 58% 1200 + 10 20% Total Projects 50
Proportion of Projects by Biogas Flow-rate
SLIDE 14 Technology Number of Projects % Water Wash 13 26% Membrane 34 68% Chemical Wash 3 6% TBC 0% Total Projects 50
Proportion of Projects by CO2 Removal Technology
SLIDE 15 Annual Biomethane to Grid and RHI for 2012-2015
Note – RHI commitment is max based on capacity, actual lower in 2015 due to project build up
Biomethane to grid is RHI technology with highest kWh
SLIDE 16
BIOMETHANE JOURNEY SELECTED PROJECTS
SLIDE 17
Poundbury
UK’s first commercial project
SLIDE 18
Vale Green
Tomatoes just love CO2
SLIDE 19
Saria Widnes
Is this the largest food waste to biomethane plant on earth???
SLIDE 20
Severn Trent Water Minworth
Inject to LTS, no propane needed……and highly energy efficient solution
SLIDE 21
Greener for Life Fraddon
Most westerly food waste to biomethane plant in EU!
SLIDE 22
Wyke Farms
Most sustainable cheese in the UK….
SLIDE 23
Welsh Water Five Fords
Launched project May 2014, injecting gas April 2015
SLIDE 24
Geneco Avonmouth
Is this the best PR ever for a biomethane project in UK?
SLIDE 25
Raynham
National Grid – 19 bar Hexel One (Plastic) pipe
SLIDE 26
Euston
Remote compression into 42 bar LTS
SLIDE 27
BIOMETHANE JOURNEY BENEFITS AND MARKET FORECASTS
SLIDE 28 Benefits – Using the Gas Grid
– 85% of domestic market connected to grid – 95% of industry – Power generation back up to wind
- To build gas grid and central heating etc would
cost around £60 - 100 billion
- All our Grid Owners are very supportive and
have created an attractive regime to allow projects to go ahead at lower cost/quicker
SLIDE 29 Benefits - CO2 Impact
- Forecast 2 TWh injected into gas grid in 2016
- 140,000 tonnes of gas
- 140 x (44/16) = 385,000 tonnes of CO2 saved at the burner tip
- Marginal gas to UK is Qatar LNG
- The 140,000 tonnes of biomethane displaces 140,000 tonnes of LNG
– 15% higher CO2 than UKCS gas on a “Well to Tank” basis – 7% CO2 vented in Qatar – So around 50,000 tonnes on top
- So, around 430,000 tonnes/annum benefit
- Material contribution towards 2020 renewable energy targets
- And we have only scratched the surface….
SLIDE 30 Benefits – Investment and Jobs
- 50 projects by end 2015
- Capex £6 - £20 Million
- Estimated total capex of around £500 Million
- Increasing % of UK supply chain – estimated 70%
- Job Survey needed to support continuing DECC investment
SLIDE 31 Biomethane Market Forecast
- UK total gas demand now is around 750 TWh/annum
- Around 50% domestic heating, 25% power gen and 25% industry
- Biomethane by 2030 is around 20 TWh, though we have only scratched the
surface…..
- For heat in cities there are few practical/economic alternatives
- Biomass (air quality), heat pumps (do not work in very cold weather), district
heating (too late to dig up cities)
SLIDE 32 Biomethane to Grid Conclusions
- Over 50 projects by end 2015, further 100 by end 2020 if tariffs OK
- 46 projects completed in period 1 June 2014 to 31 Dec 2015
- Around 2 TWh by end 2015
- UK total gas demand 750 TWh
- 140,000 tonnes of LNG not imported
- Focus on reducing capital and operating costs
- No Letter of Direction
- Tariff fixed
- Competition as established supply chains
- Lower cost of finance?
- To be discussed tomorrow…..
UK biomethane market growing fast, delivering significant benefits and helping meet 2020 renewable energy targets