Quality of L ife Me a sure s in Atopic De r ma titis Clinic a l Ca re and Re se arc h and Re se arc h
She hla Adma ni, MD Ma g da le ne Do hil, MD
Ra dy Childre n’ s Ho spita l Unive rsity o f Ca lifo rnia , Sa n Die g o
Quality of L ife Me a sure s in Atopic De r ma titis Clinic a l Ca - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Quality of L ife Me a sure s in Atopic De r ma titis Clinic a l Ca re and Re se arc h and Re se arc h She hla Adma ni, MD Ma g da le ne Do hil, MD Ra dy Childre n s Ho spita l Unive rsity o f Ca lifo rnia , Sa n Die g o HOME Cor e Me
Ra dy Childre n’ s Ho spita l Unive rsity o f Ca lifo rnia , Sa n Die g o
Jour na l of the E ur
ma tolog y a nd Ve ne r e olog y
9 JAN 2013 DOI: 10.1111/ jdv.12090 http:/ / o nline lib ra ry.wile y.c o m/ do i/ 10.1111/ jdv.12090/ full# jdv12090-fig -0001
nal c onsiste nc y: T
he de g re e o f inte rre la te dne ss a mo ng the ite ms
he e xte nt to whic h sc o re s fo r pa tie nts who ha ve no t c ha ng e d a re the sa me fo r re pe a te d me a sure me nt unde r se ve ra l c o nditio ns
e me nt e r r
: T
he syste ma tic a nd ra ndo m e rro r o f a pa tie nt’ s sc o re tha t is no t a ttrib ute d to true c ha ng e s in the c o nstruc t to b e me a sure d
he de g re e to whic h the c o nte nt o f a n HR-PRO
he de g re e to whic h the c o nte nt o f a n HR-PRO instrume nt is a n a de q ua te re fle c tio n o f the c o nstruc t to b e me a sure d
uc t validity: T
he de g re e to whic h the sc o re s o f a n HR-PRO instrume nt a re c o nsiste nt with hypo the se s
ite r ion validity: T
he de g re e to whic h the sc o re s o f a n HR-PRO instrume nt a re a n a de q ua te re fle c tio n o f a ‘ ‘ g o ld sta nda rd’ ’
he a b ility o f a n HR-PRO instrume nt to de te c t c ha ng e o ve rtime in the c o nstruc t to b e me a sure d
pr e tability: T
he de g re e to whic h o ne c a n a ssig n q ua lita tive me a ning to a n instrume nt’ s q ua ntita tive sc o re s o r c ha ng e in sc o re s
ADV T a skfo rc e re c o mme nda tio ns a nd the COSMI N c he c klist a s a g uide line , we sta rte d with a b ro a d lite ra ture se a rc h to find the mo st c o mmo nly use d QOLa sse ssme nts in AD lite ra ture
–
L it Se ar c h 1: Ato pic De rma titis AND Qua lity o f L
ife
e va lua ting the psyc ho me tric pro pe rtie s o f the se QOLto o ls
–
L it Se ar c h 2: Ato pic De rma titis AND Qua lity o f L
ife AND
–
L it Se ar c h 2: Ato pic De rma titis AND Qua lity o f L
ife AND Que stio nna ire OR I nstrume nt OR T e st OR I nve nto ry OR Sc a le OR I nde x OR Surve y
n a dditio n, we se a rc he d fo r so me o f the se le c te d a sse ssme nts b y na me to re vie w the irva lida tio n
e pr agmatic appr
asse ssme nts that ar e alr e ady validate d and c ommonly use d as the se will be mor e like ly to be unive r sally ac c e pte d and put into both c linic al c ar e and r e se ar c h pr ac tic e s
T able 2. Quality of life sc ale s.
Re ha l B, Armstro ng A (2011) He a lth Outc o me Me a sure s in Ato pic De rma titis: A Syste ma tic Re vie w o f T re nds in Dise a se Se ve rity a nd Qua lity-o f-L ife Instrume nts 1985–2010. PL
http:/ / www.plo so ne .o rg / a rtic le / info :do i/ 10.1371/ jo urna l.po ne .0017520
iption
–
Mo st c o mmo nly use d g e ne ric HRQOLinstrume nt
–
36 ite ms
–
8 d o ma ins: physic a l func tio ning , ro le limita tio ns d ue to physic a l pro b le ms, b o d ily pa in, g e ne ra l he a lth pe rc e ptio ns, vita lity, so c ia l func tio ning , ro le limita tio ns d ue to e mo tio na l pro b le ms a nd me nta l he a lth
–
Physic a l Co mpo ne nt Sc o re (PCS) a nd Me nta l Co mpo ne nt Sc o re (MCS)
–
T
–
Inte rna lc o nsiste nc y, te st/ re te st re lia b ility, c o nstruc t va lid ity a nd re spo nsive ne ss ha ve b e e n te ste d (no t a ll in AD pa tie nts)
–
In AD, c o nstruc t va lid ity ha s b e e n te ste d , MCS c o rre la te s with d ise a se se ve rity (E ASIa nd SCORAD)
–
Also in AD, +/ - Re spo nsive ne ss
–
T a ke s 5 minute s to c o mple te (sho rte r ve rsio ns e xist SF
–
PCS d o e s no t c o rre la te with d ise a se se ve rity (no t se nsitive to physic a l d isa b ility c a use d b y AD)
iption
–
Mo st c o mmo nly use d QOLto o l in d e rma to lo g y
–
10 ite ms whic h fo c us o n 6 d ime nsio ns: ‘ sympto ms’ , ‘ d a ily a c tivitie s’ , ‘ le isure ’ , ‘ wo rk’ , ‘ pe rso na l re la tio nships’ a nd ‘ tre a tme nt.’
–
T
–
Inte rna lc o nsiste nc y a nd te st/ re te st re lia b ility, c o nstruc t va lid ity, re spo nsive ne ss a nd inte rpre ta b ility ha ve b e e n te ste d (no t a ll in AD) Re spo nsive ne ss a nd c o nstruc t va lid ity te ste d in AD (Co rre la te s with d ise a se
–
Re spo nsive ne ss a nd c o nstruc t va lid ity te ste d in AD (Co rre la te s with d ise a se se ve rity, E ASI, SCORAD)
–
T a ke s 2 minute s to c o mple te
–
Ma y b e g e nd e r d iffe re nc e s (so me sc o re s c o rre la te mo re fo r wo me n tha n me n mo stly in re g a rd s to visib le d ise a se )
–
Ne w a na lysis ha s shown the r e ma y be misfitting ite ms, diffe r e ntia l ite m func tioning by dise a se , a g e a nd g e nde r , disor de r e d r e sponse thr e shold a nd ina de qua te me a sur e me nt of mild dise a se
mo o d, sle e p (2 q ue stio ns), pla y, fa mily a c tivitie s, me a ltime s, tre a tme nts, dre ssing a nd b a thing
(wo rst) (wo rst)
g re a te rimpa irme nt)
e st/ re -te st re lia b ility ha s b e e n te ste d
a ke s a ppro xima te ly 2 minute s to c o mple te
imita tio ns a nd Be ha vio r, F a mily a nd So c ia l F unc tio n, Pa re nt Sle e p, a nd Pa re nt E mo tio ns Pa re nt E mo tio ns
nte rna l c o nsiste nc y, c o nte nt va lidity, te st-re te st re lia b ility, c o nc urre nt va lidity, disc rimina tive va lidity, re spo nsive ne ss ha ve b e e n te ste d
a ke s 6 minute s to c o mple te (sho rte r ve rsio n wa s use d in a n I ta lia n study a nd sho we d g o o d psyc ho me tric pro pe rtie s)
with AD a ffe c ts QOLo f fa mily
a c h q ue stio n ha s fo ur re spo nse s: no t a t a ll = 0, a little = 1, a lo t = 2 a nd ve ry muc h = 3.
ha ve b e e n te ste d
ASI
a ke s 2 minute s to c o mple te
de rma titis. I nt J De rma to l. 2010 Se p;49(9):1063-7.
M, Ca lde ira AP. Qua lity o f life in pe dia tric pa tie nts with a to pic de rma titis. J Pe dia tr (Rio J). 2009 Se p- Oc t;85(5):415-20.
, Amo n U, Sc hro th MJ, K üste r W, e t a l. Ge rma n a da pta tio n o f the Skinde x-29 q ue stio nna ire o n q ua lity
, Ma rdzia h A, No rzila MZ. Childho o d a to pic de rma titis: a me a sure me nt o f q ua lity o f life a nd fa mily impa c t. Me d J Ma la ysia . 2002 Se p;57(3):329-39.
, L e wis-Jo ne s MS. An a udit o f the impa c t o f a c o nsulta tio n with a pa e dia tric de rma to lo g y te a m o n q ua lity o f life in infa nts with a to pic e c ze ma a nd the ir fa milie s: furthe r va lida tio n o f the I nfa nts' De rma titis Qua lity o f L ife I nde x a nd De rma titis F a mily I mpa c t sc o re . Br J De rma to l. 2006 De c ;155(6):1249-55.
, Ha y RJ. Are q ua lity o f fa mily life a nd dise a se se ve rity re la te d in c hildho o d a to pic de rma titis? J E ur Ac a d De rma to l Ve ne re o l. 2002 Se p;16(5):455-62.
, Ha y RJ. Qua lity o f life a nd dise a se se ve rity a re c o rre la te d in c hildre n with a to pic de rma titis. Br J De rma to l. 2004 F e b ;150(2):284-90.
, Ha rpe r R, Jo ne s NM, O'Ca tha in A, T ho ma s K J, e t a l. Va lida ting the SF
, Ha rpe r R, Jo ne s NM, O'Ca tha in A, T ho ma s K J, e t a l. Va lida ting the SF
me a sure fo r prima ry c a re . BMJ. 1992 Jul 18;305(6846):160-4.
, Ce lla D, F rie de n I J, Willia ms ML , Ma nc ini AJ, L a i JS, Chre n MM. De ve lo pme nt o f the Childho o d Ato pic De rma titis I mpa c t Sc a le : initia l va lida tio n o f a q ua lity-o f-life me a sure fo r yo ung c hildre n with a to pic de rma titis a nd the ir fa milie s. J I nve st De rma to l. 2005 De c ;125(6):1106-11.
, L a i JS, Ce lla D, F rie de n I J, Willia ms ML , e t a l. Childho o d Ato pic De rma titis I mpa c t Sc a le : re lia b ility, disc rimina tive a nd c o nc urre nt va lidity, a nd re spo nsive ne ss. Arc h De rma to l. 2007 Jun;143(6):768-72.
nt J De rma to l. 2012 Ma r;51(3):290-4.
a se k RJ, F lo c ke SA, Zyza nski SJ. I mpro ve d disc rimina tive a nd e va lua tive c a pa b ility o f a re fine d ve rsio n o f Skinde x, a q ua lity-o f-life instrume nt fo r pa tie nts with skin dise a se s. Arc h De rma to l. 1997 No v;133(11):1433-40.
a se k RJ, Quinn L M, Co vinsky K E . Co nve rg e nt a nd disc rimina nt va lidity o f a g e ne ric a nd a dise a se -spe c ific instrume nt to me a sure q ua lity o f life in pa tie nts with skin dise a se . J I nve st De rma to l. 1997 Ja n;108(1):103-7.
a se k RJ, Quinn L M, Mo sto w E N, Zyza nski SJ. Skinde x, a q ua lity-o f-life me a sure fo r pa tie nts with skin dise a se : re lia b ility, va lidity, a nd re spo nsive ne ss. J I nve st De rma to l. 1996 No v;107(5):707-13.
, Ao ki V. Qua lity o f life is se ve re ly c o mpro mise d in a dult pa tie nts with a to pic de rma titis in Bra zil, e spe c ia lly due to me nta l c o mpo ne nts. Clinic s (Sa o Pa ulo ). 2007 Jun;62(3):235-42.
, I e mo li E , Ro dig hie ro V, Nic o la L , De Ve c c hi E , Pic o ni S. E ffe c ts o f L a c to b a c illus sa liva rius L S01 (DSM 22775) tre a tme nt
nt J I mmuno pa tho l Pha rma c o l. 2011 Oc t- De c ;24(4):1037-48.
uro Qo l Gro up. E uro Qo l--a ne w fa c ility fo r the me a sure me nt o f he a lth-re la te d q ua lity o f life . He a lth Po lic y. 1990 De c ;16(3):199-208.
inla y AY, K ha n GK . De rma to lo g y L ife Qua lity I nde x (DL QI )--a simple pra c tic a l me a sure fo r ro utine c linic a l use . Clin E xp De rma to l. 1994 Ma y;19(3):210-6.
ive nso n D, Arno ld RJ, K a nie c ki DJ, Co he n JL , F re c h F , F inla y AY. T he e ffe c t o f a to pic de rma titis o n to ta l b urde n o f illne ss a nd q ua lity o f life o n a dults a nd c hildre n in a la rg e ma na g e d c a re o rg a niza tio n. J Ma na g Ca re Pha rm. 2002 Se p-Oc t;8(5):333-42.
indb e rg M, Wa hlg re n CF . Qua lity o f life in Swe dish c hildre n with e c ze ma . Ac ta De rm Ve ne re o l. 2007;87(4):345-9.
A, E sma nn S, Je me c GB. Do e s visib le a to pic de rma titis a ffe c t q ua lity o f life mo re in wo me n tha n in me n? Ge nd Me d. 2004 De c ;1(2):125-30.
A, Wulf HC, Ste g ma nn H, Je me c GB. L ife q ua lity a sse ssme nt a mo ng pa tie nts with a to pic e c ze ma . Br J De rma to l. 2006 Apr;154(4):719-25.
L , K a m WY, L a m MC, L e ung T F , Ng PC. CDL QI , SCORAD a nd NE SS: a re the y c o rre la te d? Qua l L ife Re s. 2006
L , K a m WY, L a m MC, L e ung T F , Ng PC. CDL QI , SCORAD a nd NE SS: a re the y c o rre la te d? Qua l L ife Re s. 2006 De c ;15(10):1551-8.
ie b e rt G, So re nse n SV, Re vic ki D, F a g a n SC, Do yle JJ, Co he n J, F ive nso n D. Ato pic de rma titis is a sso c ia te d with a de c re me nt in he a lth-re la te d q ua lity o f life . I nt J De rma to l. 2002 Ma r;41(3):151-8.
e wis-Jo ne s MS, F inla y AY. T he Childre n's De rma to lo g y L ife Qua lity I nde x (CDL QI ): initia l va lida tio n a nd pra c tic a l use . Br J De rma to l. 1995 Jun;132(6):942-9.
e wis-Jo ne s MS, F inla y AY, Dyke s PJ. T he I nfa nts' De rma titis Qua lity o f L ife I nde x. Br J De rma to l. 2001 Ja n;144(1):104-10.
undb e rg L , Jo ha nne sso n M, Silve rda hl M, He rma nsso n C, L indb e rg M. He a lth-re la te d q ua lity o f life in pa tie nts with pso ria sis a nd a to pic de rma titis me a sure d with SF
QIa nd a sub je c tive me a sure o f dise a se a c tivity. Ac ta De rm Ve ne re o l. 2000 No v-De c ;80(6):430-4.
e nna SP, Do wa rd L C, Nie ro M, E rdma n R. De ve lo pme nt o f ne e ds-b a se d q ua lity o f life instrume nts. Va lue He a lth. 2004 Se p-Oc t;7 Suppl 1:S17-21.
, F inla y AY, Ma rtin N, Bo usse tta S, Ng uye n C, Myo n E , T a ie b C. Ato pic de rma titis: impa c t o n the q ua lity o f life o f pa tie nts a nd the ir pa rtne rs. De rma to lo g y. 2007;215(2):123-9.
B, T e rwe e CB, Pa tric k DL , Alo nso J, Stra tfo rd PW, e t a l. T he COSMI N c he c klist fo r a sse ssing the me tho do lo g ic a l q ua lity o f studie s o n me a sure me nt pro pe rtie s o f he a lth sta tus me a sure me nt instrume nts: a n inte rna tio na l De lphi study. Qua l L ife Re s. 2010 Ma y;19(4):539-49.
B, T e rwe e CB, Pa tric k DL , Alo nso J, Stra tfo rd PW, e t a l. T he COSMI N study re a c he d inte rna tio na l c o nse nsus o n ta xo no my, te rmino lo g y, a nd de finitio ns o f me a sure me nt pro pe rtie s fo r he a lth-re la te d pa tie nt-re po rte d o utc o me s. J Clin E pide mio l. 2010 Jul;63(7):737-45.
, Ag o stini F , Go b b i F , Ne ri E , Sc hia nc hi S, Arc a ng e li F . Qua lity o f life me a sure s in I ta lia n c hildre n with a to pic de rma titis a nd the irfa milie s. I ta l J Pe dia tr. 2011 De c 22;37:59. do i: 10.1186/ 1824-7288-37-59.
, Ag o stini F , Gre mig ni P, Go b b i F , Ca su G, Cha mlin SL , Mo nti F . I ta lia n va lida tio n o f the Childho o d Ato pic De rma titis I mpa c t Sc a le : a c o ntrib utio n to its c linic a l a pplic a tio n. J I nve st De rma to l. 2012 No v;132(11):2534-43. do i: 10.1038/ jid.2012.199.
se ve re a to pic de rma titis tre a te d with ta c ro limus o intme nt vs. to pic a l c o rtic o ste ro ids. J E ur Ac a d De rma to l Ve ne re o l. 2010 Jun;24(6):674-8.
, Sa le k SS, e t a l. Me a sure me nt o f he a lth-re la te d q ua lity o f life in de rma to lo g ic a l re se a rc h a nd pra c tic e : o utc o me o f the E ADV T a skfo rc e o n Qua lity o f L ife . J E ur Ac a d De rma to l Ve ne re o l. 2013 Ja n 9.
q ua lity-o f-life instrume nts 1985-2010. PL
M, Go re shi R, Simpso n E L . A pilo t study o f a n o ra l pho spho die ste ra se inhib ito r (a pre mila st) fo r a to pic
M, Go re shi R, Simpso n E L . A pilo t study o f a n o ra l pho spho die ste ra se inhib ito r (a pre mila st) fo r a to pic de rma titis in a dults. Arc h De rma to l. 2012 Aug ;148(8):890-7.
ho ma s K , Cha lme rs J, e t a l. T
re se a rc h: re sults o f the HOME I Ime e ting . Alle rg y. 2012 Se p;67(9):1111-7.
wiss J, Me a ds DM, Pre sto n E P, Cra wfo rd SR, Mc K e nna SP. Ca n we re ly o n the De rma to lo g y L ife Qua lity I nde x a s a me a sure o f the impa c t o f pso ria sis o r a to pic de rma titis? J I nve st De rma to l. 2012 Ja n;132(1):76-84.
its re la tio nship to dise a se se ve rity in c hildre n with a to pic de rma titis in g e ne ra l pra c tic e . Ac ta De rm Ve ne re o l. 2011 Ma r;91(2):147-51.
e nna SP, De wa r AL , E rdma n RA, K
, e t a l. A ne w instrume nt fo r a sse ssing q ua lity o f life in a to pic de rma titis: inte rna tio na l de ve lo pme nt o f the Qua lity o f L ife I nde x fo r Ato pic De rma titis (Qo L IAD). Br J De rma to l. 2004 F e b ;150(2):274-83.
b se n H, Mo rte nse n JT , Wulf HC. De rma to lo g y life q ua lity inde x: da ta fro m Da nish inpa tie nts a nd