#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Public Debut of the Sierra-Cedar 20192020 HR Systems Survey Findings - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Public Debut of the Sierra-Cedar 20192020 HR Systems Survey Findings - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Public Debut of the Sierra-Cedar 20192020 HR Systems Survey Findings October 2, 2019 #SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR Sierra-Cedar Fast Facts 22 950+ 7 Years of Leading Employees Service & Solution Areas HR Systems Survey &
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Employees Service & Solution Areas
Application Services Business Intelligence Host & Managed Services Infrastructure Services Integration & Cloud Solutions Research Strategy Training
Delivering industry-focused client success by providing consulting, technical, and managed services for the deployment, management and optimization of next-generation applications and technology.
Industry Focus
Commercial Healthcare Higher Education Public Sector Justice & Public Safety
Sierra-Cedar Fast Facts
Years of Leading HR Systems Survey & Thought Leadership
7 22 950+ 5
2
Consulting Projects
1,500+
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Sierra-Cedar 2019–2020 HR Systems Survey
3
Over 22 years of continuous data gathering
The most comprehensive survey in the industry:
- Strategy, Process, and Structure
- Administrative and Service Delivery Applications
- Workforce Management Applications
- Talent Management Applications
- BI/Analytics/Workforce Planning Applications
- Integration and Implementation
- Emerging Technologies and Innovations
- Vendor Landscape
- Workforce and HR Expenditures
- Workforce Usage and Perception
BE COUNTED in the 23rd Annual Survey Download the 22nd Annual White Paper
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Demographics
All Respondents
Associations, Vendors & Media Outlets, Podcasts & Webinars, Radio Shows, Social Outreach, Clients, Prior Respondents, Prospects & Contacts
3,032 Entries
Manu- facturing Healthcare Financial Services Business/ Prof Services Education Retail/ Hosp/Whsl High Tech Non-profit Trans./Comm. Utilities Govt.
- Ag. Mining.
Const. Other
10,000+ 2,5000<
1,892 Organizations
Total Workforce = 22.2 Million Employees & Contingent Workers
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR 5
The Sierra-Cedar HCM Application Blueprint
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Key Themes 2019–2020 HR Systems Survey
6
Measure Outcomes that Matter From Transformation to Adoption Realize the Value of HR Know Your Culture Shift from Process to Outcomes Know Your Data Assign Responsibility Innovation is about the Data Cost & Functionality are Back
Realize the Value of HR Know the Culture of Your Organization
7
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Are HR Organizations Still Transforming?
8
73% 58% 42% 33%
Plans for Transforming HR Tech Environments
2016 2017 2018 2019
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Five Years of Technical Transformation
The View of HR has Improved by 20%
38% 41% 43% 44% 45% 46%
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 HR Viewed as Contributing Strategic Value
9
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
We Must Realize the Value in Human Resources
54%
43%
18% 38% 24% 15%
Perception of HR
Viewed as a Strategic Partner Contributing Some Value Compliance Focused
10
Executives Directors/Managers
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Decisions based on Talent
- Mature Career Planning
- Succession Management
- Metric Outcomes
- Employee Engagement
- Retention Risks
- Top Talent
Decisions based on Data
- Mature Workforce
Analytics
- 3+ Metrics
- 20%+ Managers/BI
- 3+ Data Sources
Talent Driven Data Driven
The Important Questions: Outcomes and Impact
Talent-Driven, Data-Driven, Socially Responsible Organizations, and Emerging Tech
11
Decisions based on Social Responsibility
- Diversity
- Family Leave
- Flexible Schedules
- Wellness
- Engagement
Socially Responsible Decisions based on Innovation
- Mobile Enabled HR
- Socially Enabled HR
- Use of Intelligent
Technologies
Emerging Tech
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Outcome Focused Organizations
12
Average Talent Average HR Average Business
Aggregate Talent Driven Data Driven Socially Responsible Emerging Technology
Talent Outcomes HR Outcomes Business Outcomes
Improved Neutral Declined
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
69% 67% 67% 70% 41% 41% 43% 40% Talent Driven Emerging Tech Data Driven Socially Responsible
Perception of Human Resources Strategic Value
Outcome Focused Organizations Are Partners
13
Δ63% Δ68% Δ56%
Everyone Else
Δ75%
Shifting From Transformation to Adoption
14
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Total HR Technology Costs per Employees by Size
15
Costs Per Employee
$274 $319 $196 $148
Average # of Applications
8.04 7.06 9.70 10.62
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
2019–2020 HR Tech Spending Trends Outlook
Spending Staying Virtually the Same
16
4% 55% 41%
2018–2019 Average HR Systems Spending Overall Increase Stay the Same Decrease
2%
Decrease
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
3 Year HR Tech Spending and Outlook
Large Organizations Planning More Spending This Year
12% 8% 5% 39% 53% 62% 49% 39% 33%
2017–2018
6% 4% 4% 46% 49% 58% 48% 47% 38%
2018–2019
Increase Stay the same Decrease
5% 6% 4% 43% 47% 61% 52% 47% 35%
2019–2020
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
HR Technology, Increasing Spending Categories
18
17% 18% 31% 33% 34% 35% 47% 59% Emerging Technologies Help Desk/Portal Workforce Management Applcations Payroll Applications Benefit Applications HR Business Intelligence Core HRMS Applications Talent Management Applications
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
25% 15% 11%
19% 14% 10% 19% 13% 9%
20% 15% 11%
Replacing in 12–24 Months
Large Organizations Planning More Replacements
19
13% 14% 15% 14% 15% 24% 14% 22% 15% 17% 19% 20%
Evaluating
HRMS Payroll WFM TM
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
All On Premise
Everything onsite
Current State HR Technology Ecosystem
All Cloud Environments Now Lead the Way
20
Reactive Focused High Risk Low Risk
All Cloud
Everything in the Cloud
Parallel/Patchwork
Mixed Combination Licensed and Cloud Solutions
Hybrid
ONLY TM or WFM apps in the Cloud
Licensed Hosted
Third Party & Public
48% 13% 23% 7% 9%
Increase
26% 25%
Decrease
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
22% 25% 7% 17% 16% 6% 16% 14% 7% 15% 24% 10%
Replacing in 12–24 Months
18% 12% 10% 20% 13% 12% 18% 13% 12% 20% 16% 16%
Evaluating
On Premise Planning More Replacements
21
All Cloud All OnPrem Hybrid
Increase
10%
HRMS Payroll WFM TM
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Talent Management Most Likely to Be Replaced
22
Average Deployment Length in Years When Planning to Change in 12–24 Months 8.56 8.78 7.12 5.57
Evaluating or Replacing
31%
Primary TM
30%
Recruiting
33%
Learning
Voice of the Customer I’m Back, Cost and Functionality
23
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Functionality Jumps to #1 System Gap in 2019
24
45% 37% 35% 29% 25% 25% 55% 40% 38% 40% 31% 26% 37% 42% 41% 30% 36% 21% 50% 44% 38% 36% 35% 26% Functionality Gaps Config/Cust Limitations Reporting Integration Issues Poor Usability Internal Knowledge
Buyers View on Current Application Gaps
Payroll HRMS Workforce Management Talent Management
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Vendor Satisfaction User Experience
25
Workday Ceridian DF UltiPro SF EC Oracle HCM Kronos WFC Oracle PS ADP WN Infor/Lawson SAP HCM Oracle EBS Paycom ADP GV Paycor SumTotal
Good Excellent Dissatisfied Very Satisfied Poor
PayChex
Cost and Functionality
Infor Cloud ADP E
Administrative HRMS
Average VS Score
3.1
Average UX Score
3.1
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
High and Low Vendor Satisfaction Drivers
26 19% 25% 28% 30% 32%
Functionality Not Specific for Industry Inability to Customize Poor Service & Support Poor User Experience High Costs
Top Challenges
29% 30% 30% 31% 39%
Best Practice Functionality Integrated Solution Ability to Customize Good Vendor Relationship Good Service & Support
Top Benefits
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
6.12 6.91 8.58 8.85
Total HR Technology Costs per Deployment
27
Average Costs By Deployment Model
All Cloud Deployments include
45%
More applications
- Avg. # of Applications
$277 $236 $213 $195
All On Premise Other Hybrid All Cloud
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR 28
Vendor Satisfaction User Experience
Workday Ceridian DF UltiPro Oracle HCM Kronos WFC Infor/WB SAP HCM Oracle PS Paycor Kronos WFR WorkForce Software
Very Satisfied Dissatisfied Good Excellent Poor
ADP WN
Workforce Management
ADP eTime Average VS Score
3.2
Average UX Score
3.2
Paycom PayChex
User Experience Cost
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Vendor Satisfaction User Experience
29
Workday UltiPro SF EC Oracle HCM C SilkRoad Oracle PS SAP HCM Ceridian DF ADP WN SumTotal CSOD Kenexa/IBM Saba Halogen/TS Paycor
Good Excellent Very Satisfied Poor Dissatisfied
Infor/Lawson iCIMS
Talent Management
Average VS Score
3.1
Average UX Score
3.0
Cost User Experience
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
“We recently rediscovered the recruiting and onboarding features within the application after previous employees left.” “We are finally learning the capability of the system and not all features are enabled.” “Implementation consultant did not provide the expertise we needed.”
Just a few Customer Comments….
30
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
HR Tech Application Attach Rates with HRMS
Small and Medium Organization Vendors
31 84% 41% 54% 30% 28% 19% 15%
Payroll Benefits WFM Recruit Onboard Learn Perf Comp Succ ADP WN
91% 50% 60% 52% 29%
Paycor
93% 62% 66% 69% 66% 59% 41% 24%
Ultimate UltiPro
8%
Ceridian Dayforce
91% 70% 83% 52% 60% 31% 8% 14% 14%
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
HR Tech Application Attach Rates, With HRMS
Large and Complex Organizations
32 83% 20% 17%
Payroll Benefits WFM Recruit Onboard Learn Perf Comp Succ ADP Enterprise
8% 35% 25% 58% 55% 43% 40% 54%
SAP SF EC
37% 33% 33% 15% 30% 15% 52% 56% 15%
Oracle HCM
67% 54% 64% 60% 74% 23% 68% 64% 38%
Workday
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Who Owns Configuration Decisions?
33 1% 3% 3% 9% 31% 48%
All Cloud Role Primarily Responsible for HR System Configurations
2% 5% 11% 26% 29% 26%
On Premise
HRIS/HRIT Functional HR IT Leadership/CIO IT Role HR Tech Vendor Governance Committee
80%
More Likely to Own
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
HRMS Implementation Outcomes
34 18% 23% 36% 37% 72% 63% 57% 52% 10% 14% 7% 11%
Budget Adoption Timeline Resourcing
How Would You Rate these Outcomes?
Fell Short of Expectations Met Expectations Exceeded Expectations
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
17% 10% 18% 12% 4% 6% 13% 11% Budget Timeline Adoption Resourcing
Exceeded Implementation Outcome Expectations
Certified HR/HRIT Not Certified HR/HRIT
Does Resourcing Certification Matter?
35
Δ66% Δ3X Δ38%
Shifting from a Process Focused HR to Outcome Focused HR
36
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
`
Do You Know Who is Using your HR Tech?
37
12% 9% 10% 26%
Measure HR Technology Use, By Size
Outcome Focused
2X
more likely to Assess HR Technology Usage
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Do You Know Where You Capture Your Data?
38
12% 16% 23% 25% 25% 37% 44% 53% 61% 72% 86%
Environmental Sensors Audio Monitoring Biometric Sensors Personal Mobile Devices Social Media Internet/Screen Monitor Pulse Surveys Video Monitoring Wearables/Badges/RFID Employee Surveys Exit Interviews
Methods of Capturing Employee Data
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Do You Know Your Employee Data Footprint?
39 12% 12% 76%
Do You Have a Strategy for Aggregating your Employee Data Footprint?
Yes In Development No
42%
Did Not Know if They had a Strategy Emerging Tech Orgs
3X
More likely to have one in Development
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR 4% 10% 13% 13% 52% 8%
On Premise
2% 7% 12% 22% 25% 32%
All Cloud
Who Owns Data Privacy & Content Security?
40
Role Primarily Responsible for HR System Content Security and Data Privacy
HRIS/HRIT IT HR Tech Vendor Functional HR Risk/Audit No One/Other
3X
More Likely to Own
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR Embedded HR Platform BI Visualization Data Warehouse Statistical Tools HR Workforce Analytics Data Lakes
33% 48% 42% 67% 55% 66% 87% 13% 17% 23% 35% 41% 43% 55%
Adoption of HR Business Intelligence Apps
41
What HR Business Intelligence Applications are In Use?
Data Driven Aggregate
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
15% 25% 22% 43% 49% 67% 85% 87% 14% 21% 22% 31% 51% 68% 83% 89% 14% 17% 23% 41% 42% 52% 63% 74%
Productivity Learning Performance Absence Compensation Recruiting Demographics Turnover
Do You Know What You Are Reporting?
42
Which Metrics are Included in Your Regular HR Reporting?
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
HR Staff HRIT Executives Managers Finance Staff Shared Services All Employees
11% 22% 49% 75% 67% 67% 89% 7% 11% 38% 41% 46% 47% 88%
Who Uses HR Business Intelligence Apps?
43
Who Are the Users of Your HR BI/Analytics Tools?
80%
More Likely
Data Driven Aggregate
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
15% 18% 19% 26% 29% 31% 39% 47% 47% 49% 52% HR Cost Management Compliance Engagement Retention Top Talent Workforce Readiness Work Assignments Productivity Customer Satisfaction Improved Innovation Competitive Advantage 24% 22% 22% 42% 47% 44% 58% 69% 71% 56% 69%
What Are You Achieving With Analytics?
44
What Are You Currently Using HR BI to Accomplish?
Data Driven Aggregate
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Benchmarking Platform as a Service Predictive Analytics Sentiment Analysis Machine Learning Robotic Process Blockchain 14% 41% 38% 32% 50% 32% 72% 7% 11% 16% 9% 28% 13% 12% 15% 20% 22% 14% 16% 19% 6% 4% 9% 9% 9% 17% 20% 29% 2% 7% 7% 3% 14% 4% 6% 11% 15% 18% 13% 22% 17% 16%
Adoption of Emerging Technology Apps
45
What Emerging Tech Applications are In Use?
Today 12 Months Evaluating
Emerging Tech Aggregate
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
What Are You Achieving with HR Technology?
80% 79% 69% 52% 38%
Replaces HR Paper-Based Processes Employees & Managers Input/ Access Information Monitor and Report Compliance Influences Workforce Business Decisions Informs Business Strategy
Level of HR Technology Utilization
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Value Achieved in Enterprise Workforce Planning
47 50% 70%
31% 47% Inform Overall Business Strategy Influence Workforce Business Decisions
How is Your HR Technology Being Used?
Enteprise Workforce Planning No EWP
Δ61% Δ50%
Honestly, What Makes a Difference?
48
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
What Are Business Outcomes?
49
Market Share Customer Sat Profitability Innovation Competitive Advantage
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
What Doesn’t Matter Business Outcomes
- Vendors
- Deployment Models
- Process Maturity
- Outsourcing
- Years of Ownership
- Total Technology in Use
- Resourcing Numbers
50
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
A Regularly Updated HR Systems Strategy
51
- Reviewed every 12 to 18 Months
- Tied to enterprise Outcomes
- Current state analysis
- Phased roadmaps
- Key Performance Indicators
- Governance Models
Regularly Updated HR Systems Strategy
10%
Higher Business Outcomes
Top Factor Aligned with 2019 Business Outcomes
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
A Regularly Updated Integration Strategy
52
Regularly Updated HR SystemsStrategy
- Reviewed every 12 to 18 Months
- Enterprise Approach
- Master Data Governance Model
- Data Sharing Map
- Preferred Integration Standards
- Vendor Requirements
Regularly Updated Integration Strategy
12%
Higher Business Outcomes
Top Factor Aligned with 2019 Business Outcomes
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Invest in Supporting Human Resources
53
- Not Viewed as a Compliance Function
- Contributing Value to Business Leaders
- Respect at Multiple Management Levels
- Outcome Focused HR:
– Vision/Goals – Business Model – Culture – Leadership Approach – Workforce Planning HR Viewed as Adding Strategic Value HR Viewed as Adding Strategic Value
23%
Higher Business Outcomes
Top Factor Aligned with 2019 Business Outcomes
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Invest in a Culture of Change Management
54
- Shift from Project CM to Culture of CM
- Prepare for Constant Change
- Assess HR Technology Adoption (8%)
- Governance and Role Definition
- Continuous communication tools
- Transparency, Feedback, Iterations
- Transformational Learning Processes
Culture of Change Management
28%
Higher Business Outcomes
Top Factor Aligned with 2019 Business Outcomes
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Year-over-Year Impact of Investment in…..
Strategy, Integration, Change Management, and Respect,
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Average 5-Year Outcome Differences
Strategy, Integration, Culture of Change, and High HR Value No Strategy, No Integration, Low Change, and Compliance HR
55
Improved Neutral Declined
15%
Higher Outcomes per Year
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Year-over-Year Impact of No Investment in…..
When HR is Not Viewed as a Strategic Business Partner
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
5 Year, Average Outcome Differences
Aggregate Yes Aggregate No Compliance
56
19%
Lower Outcomes
Improved Neutral Declined
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Key Themes 2019–2020 HR Systems Survey
57
Measure Outcomes that Matter From Transformation to Adoption Realize the Value of HR Know Your Culture Shift from Process to Outcomes Know Your Data Assign Responsibility Innovation is about the Data Cost & Functionality are Back
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
HR Technology Adoption Trends by Vendor – See Who’s Acquiring New Clients. New Insights Shared Services, Communications, Outsourcing, and Benefits Vendor Specific Client Averages and Client Feedback on Vendor Satisfaction Data Updates Implementation and Maintenance practices, timelines, updates, work assignments Lots of extra Industry, Size, and Organization Type Breakouts of
- ur traditional data.
What We Couldn’t Fit In Today!
58
59 #SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Thank you!
THE HR SYSTEMS SURVEY COMMUNITY
TOGETHER, WE CAN BUILD A BETTER HR
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Why Organizations Participate?
60
- Obtain a personalized benchmarking snapshot filtered by
size, region, or industry
- Value conducting a review of their own enterprise HR
Systems environment annually
- Need data to build their own HR Technology strategy or
business case for change
- Believe it is important to support the broader HR Technology
community
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Sierra-Cedar 2019–2020 HR Systems Survey
Demographics: International and Global Organizations
82% 5% 5% 7%
Average Global organization has operations in over
26
different countries
336
Non-U.S. HQ International Organizations (18%)
609
Global Organizations (33%)
61 1%
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR 4.7% 24.0% 35.2% 33.5% 2.6% Greatest Gen
1930–1945
Average Generational Compositions
No Major Differences by Organizational Size
62 4.3% 20.4% 36.1% 35.5% 3.7% 5.7% 24.4% 33.7% 33.7% 2.5% Baby Boomer
1946–1964
Gen X
1965–1980
Millennials
1981–2000
Gen Z
2001–2010
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Who Responds to Our Survey?
52% 28% 14% 6%
Participants by Role
Manager/Director Individual contributor Executive Other 63 66% 11% 9% 5% 2%7%
Participants by Function
Human Resources Finance Information Tech Line of Business TM & Learning Other 50% 17% 19% 9% 5%
Organizations Types
Privately Owned Publicly Traded Nonprofit Government Owned Subsidiary/Other
#SCHRSurvey19 @StaceyHarrisHR
Fun Facts About Survey Participants
50% 50% NO YES
HR & IT Certifications
64 4% 35% 46% 5% 9% 1% Doctorate/ Professional Degree Master's/ Graduate Degree Bachelor's/ Undergraduate Degree Associates Degree Some College H.S. Graduate/ Equivalent
Education Level
19% 18% 20% 30% 13% >10 Years 5–10 Years 3–5 Years 1–3 Years <1 Year
Years in Role