Peer Review of Project Proposals You have been hired as consultants! - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Peer Review of Project Proposals

You have been hired as consultants!

• Dr. Chris Mayfield

Department of Computer Science James Madison University

Feb 04, 2020

Review process: Phase 1

Trade proposals with two other groups ◮ Ideally your “left and right” neighbors ◮ Give your third copy to the instructor Read the proposal

[5 min]

Discuss the content

[5 min]

◮ Make edits, write comments, mark things up! Apply the rubric

[5 min]

◮ In each row, circle and/or underline specific words

Feb 04, 2020 Peer Review of Project Proposals 2 of 3

Review process: Phase 2

On the top of each rubric, write an overall grade ◮ A = excellent, definitely “fund” this project ◮ B = good, just need to improve minor issues ◮ C = acceptable, but need to fix major flaws ◮ D = inadequate, or did not take it seriously Explain feedback

[5 min]

◮ What are the proposal’s strengths? ◮ How can the proposal be improved?

Feb 04, 2020 Peer Review of Project Proposals 3 of 3