peer review of project proposals
play

Peer Review of Project Proposals You have been hired as consultants! - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Jan 30, 2023 •234 likes •274 views

Peer Review of Project Proposals You have been hired as consultants! Dr. Chris Mayfield Department of Computer Science James Madison University Feb 04, 2020 Review process: Phase 1 Trade proposals with two other groups Ideally your

  1. Peer Review of Project Proposals You have been hired as consultants! Dr. Chris Mayfield Department of Computer Science James Madison University Feb 04, 2020

  2. Review process: Phase 1 Trade proposals with two other groups ◮ Ideally your “left and right” neighbors ◮ Give your third copy to the instructor Read the proposal [5 min] Discuss the content [5 min] ◮ Make edits, write comments, mark things up! Apply the rubric [5 min] ◮ In each row, circle and/or underline specific words Feb 04, 2020 Peer Review of Project Proposals 2 of 3

  3. Review process: Phase 2 On the top of each rubric, write an overall grade ◮ A = excellent, definitely “fund” this project ◮ B = good, just need to improve minor issues ◮ C = acceptable, but need to fix major flaws ◮ D = inadequate, or did not take it seriously Explain feedback [5 min] ◮ What are the proposal’s strengths? ◮ How can the proposal be improved? Feb 04, 2020 Peer Review of Project Proposals 3 of 3

Download Presentation
Download Policy: The content available on the website is offered to you 'AS IS' for your personal information and use only. It cannot be commercialized, licensed, or distributed on other websites without prior consent from the author. To download a presentation, simply click this link. If you encounter any difficulties during the download process, it's possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.

Recommend

AGA Peer Review AUDIT A Voluntary Safety & Operational Practices Program The Peer Review

AGA Peer Review AUDIT A Voluntary Safety & Operational Practices Program The Peer Review

2019 AGAs Peer Review Luke Litteken Senior Vice President, Gas Xcel Energy On Behalf of American Gas Association AGA Peer Review AUDIT A Voluntary Safety & Operational Practices Program The Peer Review Program gives member companies

413 views • 13 slides
Buckman Direct Diversion Project Independent Peer Review (IPR) Presentation of Draft Findings

Buckman Direct Diversion Project Independent Peer Review (IPR) Presentation of Draft Findings

Buckman Direct Diversion Project Independent Peer Review (IPR) Presentation of Draft Findings September 30, 2010 1 Objectives of Today's Meeting 1. Provide summary of the independent peer review and preliminary results 2. Describe how the

1.46k views • 62 slides
Peer Review: Protecting Your Investment Peer Review: Protecting Your Investment So

Peer Review: Protecting Your Investment Peer Review: Protecting Your Investment So

Peer Review: Protecting Your Investment Peer Review: Protecting Your Investment So Hospitals will be paid less unless: Good scores on Incentive payments Meeting 17 clinical processes Funded by 1% cut in base (aspirin,

418 views • 8 slides
Peer Review: Protecting Your Investment Peer Review: Protecting Your Investment So

Peer Review: Protecting Your Investment Peer Review: Protecting Your Investment So

Peer Review: Protecting Your Investment Peer Review: Protecting Your Investment So Hospitals will be paid less unless: Good scores on Incentive payments Meeting 17 clinical processes Funded by 1% cut in base (aspirin,

614 views • 7 slides
PEER REVIEW T R A I N I N G W E B I N A R PEER REVIEW TRAINING WEBINAR Program Purpose

PEER REVIEW T R A I N I N G W E B I N A R PEER REVIEW TRAINING WEBINAR Program Purpose

PEER REVIEW T R A I N I N G W E B I N A R PEER REVIEW TRAINING WEBINAR Program Purpose Resources and Tips for Reviewing the Grant Applications Program Goals and Priorities Navigating the on-line Grants Management System

585 views • 34 slides
SEND Peer Review 5 th July 2019 www.local.gov.uk SEND Peer Review Presentation of findings

SEND Peer Review 5 th July 2019 www.local.gov.uk SEND Peer Review Presentation of findings

Salford City Council SEND Peer Review 5 th July 2019 www.local.gov.uk SEND Peer Review Presentation of findings Strengths Areas for further consideration Recommendations The peer team Sue Butcher, Social Care Consultant,

872 views • 23 slides
Moodle Workshop Feature (Peer Review) 0 Flips the classroom 0 My research questions: Is online

Moodle Workshop Feature (Peer Review) 0 Flips the classroom 0 My research questions: Is online

Moodle Workshop Feature (Peer Review) 0 Flips the classroom 0 My research questions: Is online peer review more or less effective than traditional, inclass peer review? Are students more motivated and engaged when their review efforts

413 views • 14 slides
1 4 characteristics of peer 2 things to remember w hen review ers preparing a review

1 4 characteristics of peer 2 things to remember w hen review ers preparing a review

Department of Epidemiology Welch Center for Prevention, Epidemiology, and Clinical Research Review ing a paper for a scientific publication p for dummies Eliseo Guallar, MD, DrPH eguallar@jhsph.edu Objectives of peer review 3 types of

507 views • 3 slides
Peer Review of Town Wide Underground Utilities Master Plan Summary of Report Findings Town of

Peer Review of Town Wide Underground Utilities Master Plan Summary of Report Findings Town of

Peer Review of Town Wide Underground Utilities Master Plan Summary of Report Findings Town of Palm Beach Presented by: Anthony Hanson December 12, 2017 Project Overview Perform independent, technical peer review of the

290 views • 11 slides
FY 17Forestry Project Proposals Wachusett Section DWSP Internal Review of Proposed Forest

FY 17Forestry Project Proposals Wachusett Section DWSP Internal Review of Proposed Forest

Commonwealth of Massachusetts Department of Conservation and Recreation Division of Water Supply Protection FY 17Forestry Project Proposals Wachusett Section DWSP Internal Review of Proposed Forest Management Operations Each year, all

173 views • 14 slides
FY 18Forestry Project Proposals Wachusett Section DWSP Internal Review of Proposed Forest

FY 18Forestry Project Proposals Wachusett Section DWSP Internal Review of Proposed Forest

Commonwealth of Massachusetts Department of Conservation and Recreation Division of Water Supply Protection FY 18Forestry Project Proposals Wachusett Section DWSP Internal Review of Proposed Forest Management Operations Each year, all

274 views • 14 slides
Peer Review Presented by Trudy Brown Ripin, MPH & Molly Gwisc, MPH Shoreline Health

Peer Review Presented by Trudy Brown Ripin, MPH & Molly Gwisc, MPH Shoreline Health

Pennsylvania Association of Community Health Centers Peer Review Presented by Trudy Brown Ripin, MPH & Molly Gwisc, MPH Shoreline Health Solutions Peer Review Overview Peer review is a systematic process for clinical providers to

734 views • 38 slides
Chris Rouse Windham 1 Brannon, PC Peer Review Whats going on Agenda AICPA Audit

Chris Rouse Windham 1 Brannon, PC Peer Review Whats going on Agenda AICPA Audit

Peer Review Whats going on, and how to get through it Presented by Chris Rouse Windham 1 Brannon, PC Peer Review Whats going on Agenda AICPA Audit Quality Initiative Peer Review Future How to Have a Successful Peer

517 views • 19 slides
Deans Teleconference Lawrence A. Tabak, D.D.S., Ph.D. On behalf of: ACD WG on Peer Review SC

Deans Teleconference Lawrence A. Tabak, D.D.S., Ph.D. On behalf of: ACD WG on Peer Review SC

http://enhancing-peer-review.nih.gov/ Deans Teleconference Lawrence A. Tabak, D.D.S., Ph.D. On behalf of: ACD WG on Peer Review SC WG on Peer Review http://enhancing-peer-review.nih.gov/ A Self-Study by the NIH in Partnership with the

608 views • 14 slides
The Reviewing Process Bijan Parsia <bijan.parsia@manchester.ac.uk> 1 Peer Review Peer

The Reviewing Process Bijan Parsia <bijan.parsia@manchester.ac.uk> 1 Peer Review Peer

The Reviewing Process Bijan Parsia <bijan.parsia@manchester.ac.uk> 1 Peer Review Peer review is a keystone of modern academia Evaluation by people of similar competence Where theres a fairly high bar for minimally

497 views • 11 slides
Opening up the review process: alternative peer review tools in scholarly publishing 20. 01.

Opening up the review process: alternative peer review tools in scholarly publishing 20. 01.

Opening up the review process: alternative peer review tools in scholarly publishing 20. 01. 2017 Leibniz Journal Management Workshop - Berlin 1 Our mission pening UP new methods, indicators and tools for dissemination peer impact Topics

234 views • 19 slides
Training Students for Successful Peer Response in Wri6ng Classes

Training Students for Successful Peer Response in Wri6ng Classes

Training Students for Successful Peer Response in Wri6ng Classes Heidi Evans and Gail Ibele University of Wisconsin-Madison For discussion What

600 views • 21 slides
HEALTH PROMOTION: PEER REVIEW Christine Johnston, MPH Assistant Director, Alcohol & Other

HEALTH PROMOTION: PEER REVIEW Christine Johnston, MPH Assistant Director, Alcohol & Other

HEALTH PROMOTION: PEER REVIEW Christine Johnston, MPH Assistant Director, Alcohol & Other Drug Education and Health Promotion Springfield College Emily Pagano, MS Introductions Alcohol and Other Drug Education Coordinator University

872 views • 20 slides
Publishing Your Engineering Education Research in JEE: Lessons Learned from Studying the Peer

Publishing Your Engineering Education Research in JEE: Lessons Learned from Studying the Peer

Publishing Your Engineering Education Research in JEE: Lessons Learned from Studying the Peer Review Process Facilitated by Stephanie Cutler and Kacey Beddoes Disclaimer! This workshop and its facilitators are NOT associated with or sponsored by

388 views • 17 slides
A Proposed Currency System for Academic Peer Review Payments Using the BlockChain Technology

A Proposed Currency System for Academic Peer Review Payments Using the BlockChain Technology

A Proposed Currency System for Academic Peer Review Payments Using the BlockChain Technology Almost every research academic is aware of the current environment in which both institutions and individuals are subject to some form of assessment

528 views • 15 slides
Peer-reviewed open research data: results of a pilot Marjan Grootveld & Jeff van Egmond DANS

Peer-reviewed open research data: results of a pilot Marjan Grootveld & Jeff van Egmond DANS

Data Archiving and Networked Services Peer-reviewed open research data: results of a pilot Marjan Grootveld & Jeff van Egmond DANS is an institute of KNAW and NWO Agenda Who is DANS? Peer review pilot study: What we did What we

449 views • 19 slides
CONVERGENT CONTEMPORARY SOFTWARE PEER REVIEW PRACTICES Presented by Tresa Varghese

CONVERGENT CONTEMPORARY SOFTWARE PEER REVIEW PRACTICES Presented by Tresa Varghese

CONVERGENT CONTEMPORARY SOFTWARE PEER REVIEW PRACTICES Presented by Tresa Varghese Rose(101017725) Peer review is the practice of inspecting code by other authors to find defects and thus improve software quality. Even if bug inspection

355 views • 20 slides
Grant applications for PhD students #2 Eirkur Smri Sigurarson Director of Research, School

Grant applications for PhD students #2 Eirkur Smri Sigurarson Director of Research, School

Grant applications for PhD students #2 Eirkur Smri Sigurarson Director of Research, School of Humanities 23 June 2020 On the presentation Submit questions via chat: I will answer during or after presentation, or after group

505 views • 31 slides
Welcome We will begin at 7:30 pm Central Time Logistics We will meet every Wednesday for 90

Welcome We will begin at 7:30 pm Central Time Logistics We will meet every Wednesday for 90

Welcome We will begin at 7:30 pm Central Time Logistics We will meet every Wednesday for 90 minutes. If you cannot attend, inform your fellows leader, if you have one, and email fellows@ofa.us This is an interactive training. A recording of

850 views • 53 slides

More recommend