National Western Citizens Advisory Committee August 28, 2014
National Western Citizens Advisory Committee August 28, 2014 - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
National Western Citizens Advisory Committee August 28, 2014 - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
National Western Citizens Advisory Committee August 28, 2014 National Western Center M aster Plan NWC Partners / Design Team Work S ession Inspiration Initial Site Options June 2, 2014 STUDY AREA ASSETS Coliseum 1952 Livestock Exchange
NWC Partners / Design Team Work S ession Initial Site Options June 2, 2014
National Western Center M aster Plan Inspiration
STUDY AREA ASSETS
Coliseum 1952 Livestock Exchange 1916 Stadium Arena 1909 Armour and Co. Administration 1917
UNDER I-70
PRECEDENTS – PROGRAM M ING BENEATH INFRASTRUCTURE
A8ernA, Netherlands A8ernA, Netherlands BM X Course, S eattle
PRECEDENTS – PROGRAM M ING BENEATH INFRASTRUCTURE
DELGANY INTERCEPTOR
PRECEDENTS – TERRACED WATERFRONTS
PRECEDENTS – TERRACED WATERFRONTS
NWC Partners / Design Team Work Session Initial Site Options June 2, 2014
National Western Center M aster Plan Site Alternatives
SITE WITHIN CONTEXT NEIGHBORHOODS & OPEN SP ACE
SITE WITHIN CONTEXT CONNECTIONS
WASHINGTON Y ORK EXISTING CONNECTIONS DESIRED CONNECTIONS
TOD EXPO HALL/ ARENA
Option A
M UL TI-USE LIVESTOCK EQUESTRIAN PARTNERS
Diagrams from July 31, 2014 NWCAC M eeting
Conceptual Representations -Not Final - Preliminary draft for discussion purposes only
TOD EXPO HALL/ ARENA
Option B
M UL TI-USE LIVESTOCK EQUESTRIAN PARTNERS
Diagrams from July 31, 2014 NWCAC M eeting
Conceptual Representations -Not Final - Preliminary draft for discussion purposes only
Option C
EXPO LIVESTOCK HALL/ ARENA ARENA CROPS EXPO HALL EVENTS PAVILION / Y ARDS EQUESTRIAN M UL TI-USE LIVESTOCK EQUESTRIAN PARTNERS
Diagrams from July 31, 2014 NWCAC M eeting
Conceptual Representations -Not Final - Preliminary draft for discussion purposes only
NWC PROGRAM LOCATION OPTIONS
Diagrams from July 31, 2014 NWCAC M eeting
Conceptual Representations -Not Final - Preliminary draft for discussion purposes only
A C B
CONNECTION OPTIONS
5 5 6 4 3 1 1 2 2 Possible East/ West Connections
- 1. 53rd Ave./ Franklin/ Race Ct.
Existing Connection Possible New Connection Vehicular Structure Rail Crossing Existing River Crossing New River Crossing
Legend
- 2. 51st Ave./ 49th Ave.
- 3. 49th Ave./ 48th Ave.
- 4. 49th Ave./ 47th Ave.
- 5. 46th Ave./ 46th Ave.
- 6. 46th Ave./ 44th Ave.
RAIL CONSOLIDATION STUDY RIVER RAIL NW DRIVE RAIL JERSEY CUTOFF BNSF / RTD
NWC PROGRAM
PLAN FRAM EWORKS
1 2 3
Conceptual Representations -Not Final - Preliminary draft for discussion purposes only
1
WASHINGTON BRIGHTON 47TH 46TH 51ST 48TH GLOBEVILLE EL YRIA WASHINGTON 51st AVEUNE 49th AVE. 47th AVE. 46th AVE. BRIGHTON I-70 I-70
PLAN FRAM EWORK
Conceptual Representations -Not Final - Preliminary draft for discussion purposes only
2
WASHINGTON BRIGHTON 47TH 46TH 51ST 48TH GLOBEVILLE EL YRIA 51st AVEUNE 49th AVE. BRIGHTON 47th AVE. 46th AVE. I-70 I-70 WASHINGTON NATIONAL
PLAN FRAM EWORK
Conceptual Representations -Not Final - Preliminary draft for discussion purposes only
3
WASHINGTON BRIGHTON 47TH 46TH 51ST 48TH GLOBEVILLE EL YRIA 51st AVEUNE 49th AVE. 48th AVE. BRIGHTON 47th AVE. 46th AVE. I-70 I-70 WASHINGTON
PLAN FRAM EWORK
Conceptual Representations -Not Final - Preliminary draft for discussion purposes only
FRAM EWORKS PAIRED WITH PROGRAM SETS TO CREATE PLAN VERSIONS 1 v1 1 v2 Framework 1
Conceptual Representations -Not Final - Preliminary draft for discussion purposes only
FRAM EWORK 1 v1
EQUESTRIAN SOUTH
+ utilizes current land ownership to the fullest
- not ideal for large equestrian shows
and requires relocation of Forney
Y ARDS ALONG RIVER
+ creates event space along river
- ff-site program elements:
2 AC dirt 5 AC livestock RV ARENA/ EXPO P ARTNER F ACILITIES LIVESTOCK EQUESTRIAN PRIVATE DEVELOPMENT WASHINGTON I-70 BRIGHTON GLOBEVILLE EL YRIA NORTHSIDE P ARK GLOBEVILLE LANDING P ARK COLISEUM 47th AVE.
T
Conceptual Representations -Not Final - Preliminary draft for discussion purposes only
48th AVE.
FRAM EWORK 1 v2
EQUES TRIAN NORTH
+ consolidates Stock Show program & better accommodates large horse shows
- additional business relocation is
necessary in initial phases
CSU SOUTH
+ allows for prime river access and reuse of a major City asset
- current program may not be large
enough to locate here and disperse throughout campus as desired
- does not achieve a critical mass for
private development
- ff-site program elements:
2 AC dirt 5 AC livestock RV 3 AC storage ARENA/ EXPO P ARTNER F ACILITIES LIVESTOCK EQUESTRIAN PRIVATE DEVELOPMENT GLOBEVILLE EL YRIA WASHINGTON NORTHSIDE P ARK BRIGHTON I-70 GLOBEVILLE LANDING P ARK COLISEUM 47th AVE.
T
Conceptual Representations -Not Final - Preliminary draft for discussion purposes only
FRAM EWORKS PAIRED WITH PROGRAM SETS TO CREATE PLAN VERSIONS 2 v2 2 v1 Framework 2
Conceptual Representations -Not Final - Preliminary draft for discussion purposes only
FRAM EWORK 2 v1
NW DRIVE ALONG RIVER
+ enhances public accessibility to river and can remain open during events
CSU M ORE FOCUSED ON WASHINGTON
+ opens up private development south and still allows for river access
PRIVATE SOUTH
+ creates a tax base for the City on desirable Brighton frontage
- may take time to develop and finding
a user for coliseum and 1909 building may be a challenge
- ff-site program elements:
5 AC dirt 5 AC livestock RV 5 AC storage ARENA/ EXPO P ARTNER F ACILITIES LIVESTOCK EQUESTRIAN PRIVATE DEVELOPMENT GLOBEVILLE EL YRIA WASHINGTON NORTHSIDE P ARK BRIGHTON GLOBEVILLE LANDING P ARK 47th AVE. I-70
T
51st AVE.
Conceptual Representations -Not Final - Preliminary draft for discussion purposes only
FRAM EWORK 2 v2
LIVES TOCK ALONG RIVER
+ allows for equestrian to have a front door on 47th and allows for phased acquisition for yards and cattle ties
- event space along rail/ Race is not as
desirable as along river
- ff-site program elements:
5 AC dirt 5 AC livestock RV 5 AC storage ARENA/ EXPO P ARTNER F ACILITIES LIVESTOCK EQUESTRIAN PRIVATE DEVELOPMENT GLOBEVILLE EL YRIA WASHINGTON NORTHSIDE P ARK BRIGHTON 47th AVE. I-70
T
GLOBEVILLE LANDING P ARK 51st AVE.
Conceptual Representations -Not Final - Preliminary draft for discussion purposes only
FRAM EWORKS PAIRED WITH PROGRAM SETS TO CREATE PLAN VERSIONS 3 v1 3 v2 Framework 3
Conceptual Representations -Not Final - Preliminary draft for discussion purposes only
FRAM EWORK 3 v1
CONSOLIDATE DRI RAIL ALONG BSNF TRACKS
+ removes dividing line between livestock facilities to create a more flexible facilities layout and pedestrians do not have to cross rail at grade
- will still be desirable to suspend rail
traffic during certain events and increases tunnel length for east-west connections
- ff-site program elements:
5 AC dirt 5 AC livestock RV 3 AC storage ARENA/ EXPO P ARTNER F ACILITIES LIVESTOCK EQUESTRIAN PRIVATE DEVELOPMENT I-70 GLOBEVILLE WASHINGTON NORTHSIDE P ARK
T
GLOBEVILLE LANDING P ARK BRIGHTON 47th AVE. 51st AVE. COLISEUM
Conceptual Representations -Not Final - Preliminary draft for discussion purposes only
FRAM EWORK 3 v2
ARENA AND EXPO HALL ALONG THE RIVER
+ imbeds the largest buildings in the center of the site to prevent placing a hard edge on the neighborhoods
- site phasing is difficult and there may
be potential impact on neighborhood from event space
- difficult site access into center of site
LIVES TOCK ON BRIGHTON
+ locates livestock adjacent to equestrian
- misaligns 47th at Brighton due to area
needed for Livestock Arena and service
- ff-site program elements:
5 AC dirt 3 AC storage ARENA/ EXPO P ARTNER F ACILITIES LIVESTOCK EQUESTRIAN PRIVATE DEVELOPMENT I-70 GLOBEVILLE WASHINGTON NORTHSIDE P ARK
T
GLOBEVILLE LANDING P ARK BRIGHTON 47th AVE. 51st AVE. COLISEUM
Conceptual Representations -Not Final - Preliminary draft for discussion purposes only
PROGRAM USE COM PARISON 1 v1 2 v2 1 v2 3 v1 2 v1 3 v2
Conceptual Representations -Not Final - Preliminary draft for discussion purposes only
RECOM M ENDED PLANS 1 v1 2 v1 3 v2
Conceptual Representations -Not Final - Preliminary draft for discussion purposes only
Next Steps
- CAC to review plans presented and provide any
additional comments back to CRL by September 19, 2014.
- Design team to review alternatives with Partners
and make modifications as necessary to meet their program needs.
- Design team to make recommendation for 2
alternatives for review at the next CAC meeting September 26.
August September October November December January February M arch
GLOBEVILLE EL YRIA & SWANSEA NWC
Preferred Alternative Draft M aster Plan Planning Board City Council
- Dec. 19, 2014
- Feb. 4, 2015
Plan Drafting
M arch 9, 2015
Planning Board City Council Alternatives Development Plan Drafting Draft Plan Release Planning Board City Council Draft Plan Release
- Sep. 30, 2014
- Nov. 5, 2014
- Dec. 15, 2014
- Feb. 9, 2015
- Jan. 7, 2015
- Nov. 12, 2014