Making Comics AS Qualitative Research Marcus Weaver-Hightower - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Jan 12, 2023 •238 likes •810 views

Making Comics AS Qualitative Research Marcus Weaver-Hightower University of North Dakota EQRC 2018 First, How am I defining comics? Comics are a form, not a genre Comics are a form, not a genre Comics are a form, not a genre

Making Comics AS Qualitative Research Marcus Weaver-Hightower University of North Dakota EQRC 2018
First, How am I defining “comics”?
Comics are a form, not a genre
Comics are a form, not a genre
Comics are a form, not a genre
Comics are a form, not a genre
Comics are a form, not a genre
Comics are a form, not a genre
Comics are a form, not a genre
Comics are a form, not a genre
Comics are a form, not a genre
Comics are a form, not a genre I can make it!
Comics are a form, not a genre I can make I can make it! it across the canyon!
Comics are a form, not a genre I can make I can make it! it across the canyon!
Comics are multimodal A B C
Chris Ware: “I believe that the expressive potentials of comics as a compositional art–with its combination of drawing, poetry, color, writing, pattern, rhythm, typography, and ‘music’ —allow for the greatest possible recreation of the complexity of experience that a printed page can offer.” (quoted in Rhoades, 2008, p. 36)
Comics-Based Research (CBR)
We use the term "comics-based research" to refer to a broad set of practices that use the comics form to collect, analyze, and/or disseminate scholarly research. Kuttner, Sousanis, and Weaver-Hightower (2017, p. 397)
Williams, R. M. C. (2012). Can you picture this? Activism, art, and public scholarship. Visual Arts Research, 38, 87-98.
Movement Speech Thought Description Narration Setting Sound Smells Gestures Time Expressions All things that we use in Emotion empirical qualitative inquiry!
Comic Artists’ Choices (McCloud, Making Comics, 2006) • Moment • Frame • Image • Word • Flow
All of these choices and affordances ≅ Traditional schema for analysis of Qualitative Data
“Traditional” Comic Topic Selection Topic Selection Literature Review Literature Review Interview Data Collection Observation & Informal Talk Restorying Data Analysis Thematizing Page Layouts Member Checking Validity/Trustworthiness Peer Debriefing Reflexive Journaling Choosing Words & Images Reporting Panel, Page and Comic Flow Citations
Examples
Published in Journal of Medical Humanities (2017; Online First 2015)
Part of the Process was very Traditional
Original Interview Comic Script Transcript (~2,300 words) (~13,000 words)

Download Presentation

Download Policy: The content available on the website is offered to you 'AS IS' for your personal information and use only. It cannot be commercialized, licensed, or distributed on other websites without prior consent from the author. To download a presentation, simply click this link. If you encounter any difficulties during the download process, it's possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.

Recommend

DC COMICS EARLY HISTORY DC Comics (aka Detective Comics) was founded in 1937 by pulp writer

BY: COLTON CAYWARD DC COMICS EARLY HISTORY DC Comics (aka Detective Comics) was founded in 1937 by pulp writer Wheeler-Nicholson and magazine distributers Harry Donenfeld and Jack Liebowitz Wheeler was unable to pay debts to his cofounders

393 views • 11 slides

Qualitative Research I. What is it? II. Conducting qualitative research: prep, sampling, data

Qualitative Research I. What is it? II. Conducting qualitative research: prep, sampling, data collection III. Strengths and Weaknesses 1 I. What is qualitative research? Being in the field Anthropology, journalism Social

385 views • 9 slides

Qualitative Research Theoretical Orientations ScWk 240 Week 10 Slides 1 Why Qualitative

Qualitative Research Theoretical Orientations ScWk 240 Week 10 Slides 1 Why Qualitative Research? Unlike quantitative research, qualitative research relies on reasons behind various aspects of behavior. Simply put, it

269 views • 16 slides

Introduction to Qualitative Research ScWk 240 Week 9 Slides 1 What is Qualitative Research?

Introduction to Qualitative Research ScWk 240 Week 9 Slides 1 What is Qualitative Research? Being in the field Anthropology, journalism Social context, comprehensiveness, rich texture of life Patterns, themes,

698 views • 16 slides

REVIEW OF QUALITATIVE RESEARCH AND PRINCIPLES OF QUALITATIVE ANALYSIS SCWK 242 SESSION 2

REVIEW OF QUALITATIVE RESEARCH AND PRINCIPLES OF QUALITATIVE ANALYSIS SCWK 242 SESSION 2 SLIDES Review of Qualitative Designs 2 In Qualitative Research: We do not test hypothesis or previous theories. We may try to develop new

640 views • 16 slides

Qualitative Research Adapted From Dapzury Valenzuela ?? Definitions The qualitative research

Interview as a Method for Qualitative Research Adapted From Dapzury Valenzuela ?? Definitions The qualitative research interview seeks to describe the meanings of central themes in the life world of the subjects. The main task in

1.52k views • 89 slides

Comics to Consoles Antony Johnston Games & Comics: Commonalities Interactive

Comics to Consoles Antony Johnston Games & Comics: Commonalities Interactive Outcast Media Abstraction of both Iconography & Activity Audience controls the pace of experience A Brief Word On Concept (...Or, why

689 views • 57 slides

Qualitative approaches to research Dr Dean Whitehead SoNM Why qualitative research? The

Qualitative approaches to research Dr Dean Whitehead SoNM Why qualitative research? The post-modernist backlash Post-modernism (anti-positivism) Different worldviews science versus philosophy phenomenology

725 views • 68 slides

From sampling and choosing cases to analysis in qualitative research Nick Emmel Qualitative

From sampling and choosing cases to analysis in qualitative research Nick Emmel Qualitative longitudinal methods: research into practice Overview Our qualitative longitudinal studies (1999 and ongoing) in a geographically bounded low-income

457 views • 12 slides

Indie Comics in St. Louis Why Indie? Mainstream comics limited in scope diversity

Indie Comics in St. Louis Why Indie? Mainstream comics limited in scope diversity limitation on new ideas Creators want to tell own stories Gain experience creating your own stuff to add to your portfolio Print

117 views • 11 slides

Qualitative research for Kingdom impact Qualitative research for Kingdom impact Not everything

Qualitative research for Kingdom impact Qualitative research for Kingdom impact Not everything that can be counted counts. Not everything that counts can be counted. sociologist William Bruce Cameron Qualitative methods attempt to

741 views • 33 slides

Lattice polynomial functions and their use in qualitative decision making AAA83 . . . . .

. . Lattice polynomial functions and their use in qualitative decision making AAA83 . . . . . Miguel Couceiro Jointly with D. Dubois, J.-L. Marichal, T. Waldhauser, . . . University of Luxembourg March 2012 Decision making DM Main

1.09k views • 69 slides

Introduction to Qualitative Research & Coding Josu Melndez Rodrguez, MA, MSW

Introduction to Qualitative Research & Coding Josu Melndez Rodrguez, MA, MSW Qualitative Research Lead, D-Lab PhD Student, School of Social Welfare University of California, Berkeley some slides were adapted from Dr. Zawadi

540 views • 19 slides

Localism Qualitative and Quantitative Research February 2019 1 Localism Qualitative and

Localism Qualitative and Quantitative Research February 2019 1 Localism Qualitative and Quantitative Research February 2019 Topics Our approach Summary of findings Detailed data Levels of support for localism Types

954 views • 31 slides

Asking the Right Question: Qualitative Research Design and Analysis Presenter: Jennifer Sikov,

Asking the Right Question: Qualitative Research Design and Analysis Presenter: Jennifer Sikov, BA Senior Research Assistant, Psychiatry Department Learning Objectives To develop an understanding of different approaches to qualitative

902 views • 34 slides

Benefits and Challenges of Analyzing Qualitative Data Sheelagh Carpendale empirical research

Benefits and Challenges of Analyzing Qualitative Data Sheelagh Carpendale empirical research binary? qualitative or quantitative spectrum quantitative qualitative spectrum quantitative qualitative we will look at the qualitative part of

402 views • 17 slides

Genetic Hearing Loss Jing Shen M.D. Faculty Advisor: Ronald Deskin M.D. The University of Texas

Genetic Hearing Loss Jing Shen M.D. Faculty Advisor: Ronald Deskin M.D. The University of Texas Medical Branch Department of Otolaryngology Grand Rounds Presentation March 2004 1 Epidemiology Hearing loss occurs in 1 out of every 1,000

660 views • 46 slides

Looking forward: How can mercury contamination harm the next generation - the need for

Looking forward: How can mercury contamination harm the next generation - the need for precaution Philippe Grandjean University of Southern Denmark Harvard School of Public Health Presenter: Philippe Grandjean, MD, DMSc Professor and Chair,

468 views • 14 slides

Midatech Corporate Overview & Update April 2019 Using our forefront platform technologies to

Midatech Corporate Overview & Update April 2019 Using our forefront platform technologies to make a difference for patients and, in so doing, create value for all stakeholders Di Disclaimer THIS PRESENTATION MAY NOT BE COPIED OR REPRODUCED

490 views • 25 slides

Organ Donation: Honoring Generosity, Saving Lives Alan Woodworth New England Organ Bank

Organ Donation: Honoring Generosity, Saving Lives Alan Woodworth New England Organ Bank Hospital and Family Relations Organ Procurement Organizations The generosity of donors and their families make the gifts of organ and tissue donation

516 views • 33 slides

Treatment of the Child with Severe Impairments Jacqueline Grimenstein, PT, C/NDT, CKTP

Treatment of the Child with Severe Impairments Jacqueline Grimenstein, PT, C/NDT, CKTP jgrimenstein@gmail.com 1 Introduction What defines a child with severe impairments Treating children with severe impairments presents a unique

797 views • 62 slides

Genomic signatures predict the immunogenicity of BRCA-deficient breast cancer Adam A Kraya et al.

Genomic signatures predict the immunogenicity of BRCA-deficient breast cancer Adam A Kraya et al. 2019/03, AACR Taehoon Ha Introduction Mutations in BRCA1 and BRCA2 are the most common causes of hereditary breast cancer. BRCA1 and 2 play

737 views • 26 slides

HEREDITARY BREAST OVARIAN CANCER SYNDROME: THE AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE Gillian Mitchell BC Cancer

HEREDITARY BREAST OVARIAN CANCER SYNDROME: THE AUSTRALIAN EXPERIENCE Gillian Mitchell BC Cancer Agency Vancouver Disclosures AstraZeneca Advisory Board, honoraria AbbVie Coordinating Chief Investigator No off-label drug use

637 views • 30 slides

Using social networking and ar1ficial intelligence to collect FHx Brandon M Welch, MS, PhD

Using social networking and ar1ficial intelligence to collect FHx Brandon M Welch, MS, PhD Assistant Professor Medical University of South Carolina Family history is important Cancer runs in families Life6me risk for breast cancer 70% 60%

714 views • 47 slides