LNAPL A REVIEW OF COMMON MISCONCEPTIONS AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS IN - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

LNAPL – A REVIEW OF COMMON MISCONCEPTIONS AND THEIR IMPLICATIONS IN REMEDIATION BASED ON CASES FROM AROUND THE WORLD

ACLCA Lunchtime, Adelaide, September 23, 2013 Jeffery J.C. Paul, Golder Associates Inc.

LNAPL impressions

September 24, 2013 2

Light………. Only floats on water……………??

LNAPL Above and Below Water Table

Hydrostatic Case – LNAPL is like an iceberg Hydrodynamic Case pour in olive oil first, chase with water

Funnel

Olive oil Water

LNAPL Above and Below the Water Table

September 24, 2013 4

Smear Zone

September 24, 2013 5

LNAPL Conceptual Model

September 24, 2013 6

Unconventional LNAPL Remediation

September 24, 2013 7

n Stop gradient migration of LNAPL n Mass reduction n Stabilization of LNAPL

Break the chain

September 24, 2013 8

n

Goal to stop migration of the free product to

• ff-site locations or to receptors.

n

Technologies to break the flow.

n Typical

n pump n excavate n walls n trenches

n Newer processes

n Air / steam lancing n Secondary effect fracturing with

proppant

n Brines n ISCO foam in unsaturated zone

Gradient Breaking in Unsaturated Zone

September 24, 2013 9

n

A very difficult challenge is to break an LNAPL gradient in the unsaturated zone. An option may be to use foam technologies to “flood” the unsaturated zone with an active chemical based on a peroxide or persulphate. This has been successfully performed in The Caribbean and USA for one client by injecting hydrogen peroxide in a proprietary foam, currently the application is much more art than technology.

Mass reduction

September 24, 2013 10

n

Superoxygenated water

n

Surfactant / alcohol flooding (flushing)

n

Thermal conductive heating

n

Electrokinetics

n

Subsurface steam stripping

n

Denitrification

Break the Chain AND Mass Reduction

September 24, 2013 11

n

ISCO, in particular with activated sodium persulphate

n Determining the correct oxidant and the correct amount is important

to avoid interactions with site soils that will decrease effectiveness.

n Generally, more persistent oxidants in permeable and saturated soils

will have greater ROIs (up to 7.5 m). In fractured rock up to 30 m.

n Consider potential for clogging (iron, manganese etc.) n

Epsom salts (magnesium sulphate)

n Slow acting n ROI less than 10 m n Persistent

ISCO

September 24, 2013 12

n

Being used in many parts of the Americas to “Break the Chain” also for mass reduction

n

Example from North Alabama – Use of hydrogen peroxide injected at discrete depth intervals to break lateral LNAPL gradient in residuum soil

• ver limestone. Successful since 2006. Key issue was the natural

presence of greater than 5 mg/L Iron II. Also used in select areas for mass reduction of LNAPL

Epsom Salts

September 24, 2013 13

n

Rarely used, typically successful if there are no other carbon sources

• present. Produces hydrogen sulphide. Successful projects in India,

Saint Lucia, Sint Maarten, USA, UK.

n

Example from Sint Maarten. LNAPL was slowly entering a graveyard and towards the sea. Solution, emplace Epsom salts directly upgradient

• f grave yard. Outcome LNAPL gradient broken, LNAPL no longer

migrating to the sea.

Stabilization

September 24, 2013 14

n

Cement – being tried again by others, not seeing long term success

n

Injection of activated carbon or coal dust

n

Hot vegetable oils or hot expelled mustard plant species

Coal Dust

September 24, 2013 15

n

Numerous examples in Europe exist of petroleum LNAPL that does not pass through areas with coal dust in the subsurface. Injection technique is being applied at limited sites in the Americas and India. As an example, a site in India had a combination of virgin Diesel LNAPL in

• ne release and Diesel as LNAPL with dissolved pesticides in a second
• release. The release of virgin diesel resulted in migration of LNAPL

towards an off-site property. Coal dust was made into a slurry and injected in rows to produce an active “wall”. Migration of LNAPL was stopped.

Injection of Coal Dust

Hot Vegetable Product Injection

September 24, 2013 17

n

Hot vegetable oil and expelled brassica species are being used in The Americas, The Bahamas, Caribbean, UK, and to a minor extent in Bangladesh to physically stabilize LNAPL. The basis of the technology is the “nightmare” of mixing mineral oils and vegetable oils in a workshop An example is for a mineral spirits LNAPL release in Belize to stabilize LNAPL and hence preclude it entering a stream.

Over Time – Remediation Endpoints

n

1974

n

1970s

n

Later 70s

n

80s

n

Currently

n

Future?

n

Visual, generic hydrocarbons analysis

n

Concept of free product migration offsite, focused toxic chemical analysis

n

Dogmatic rules instituted with little to no basis in science

• r application of risk assessment

n

Some regulators/ stakeholders apply risk assessment . 25 mg/kg TPH limit for discharges to salt water

n

No offsite migration of free product. Risk assessment for dissolved plume gaining acceptance

n

No offsite migration of free product. Acceptance of residual product with applied institutional controls. Remediation of dissolved and potentially associated released metals based on risk assessment

September 24, 2013 18