SAE Consortium
International SAE Consortium, Ltd
An Int ernat ional Indust rial Biomedical Consort ium Researching t he Genet ic Basis of Drug Relat ed S erious Adverse Event s
JPDSC Meeting
October 16, 2009
1
JPDSC Meeting October 16, 2009 SAE Consortium 1 Introduction - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
International SAE Consortium, Ltd An Int ernat ional Indust rial Biomedical Consort ium Researching t he Genet ic Basis of Drug Relat ed S erious Adverse Event s JPDSC Meeting October 16, 2009 SAE Consortium 1 Introduction Thank you for
1
2
3
4
5
6
Drug Adverse Drug Reaction Genetic Risk Factor
Reaction Prevalence Risk Allele
Effect2
Clopidogrel Cardiovascular events 0.13
CYP2C19*2/ 3/ 4/ 5
0.03 3 Gefitinib Diarrhea 0.28
ABCG2 Q141K
0.07 5 Isoniazid Hepatotoxicity 0.15
CYP2E1*1 & NAT2
0.133 7 Co-amoxiclav Hepatotoxicity <0.001
HLA-DRB1*1501
0.20 10 Irinotecan Neutropenia 0.20 UGT1A1*28 0.32 28 Ticlopidine Hepatotoxicity (cholestatic) <0.001
HLA-A*3303
0.14 36 Tranilast Hyperbilirubinemia 0.12 UGT1A1*28 0.30 48 Flucloxacillin Hepatotoxicity <0.001 HLA-B*5701 0.04 81 Allopurinol Severe cutaneous reaction <0.001
HLA-B*5801
0.15 678 Abacavir Hypersensitivity reaction 0.08 HLA-B*5701 0.04 >1000 Carbamazepine Stevens-Johnson <0.001
HLA-B*1502
0.04 >1000
7
8
9
10
11
Top 5 SAEs
External Collaborators/Contributors
EUDRAGENE Spanish DILI Spanish DILI
12
12
Phase 1 Execution
analysis
13
SSR GWAS, Paper & DR1 DILI GWAS, Papers (3) & DRs 2 & 3 TdP GWAS, Paper (1) & DRs 4 Myopathy GWAS, Paper (1) & DRs 5 A-E GWAS, Paper (1) & DRs 6
EMR SAE Case Sourcing Pilots (3) SAE Cohorts Members Pilots (3)
DILI & Agranulocytosis Sequencing Pilots
14 14
company scientist requests [top requesters]
S A E C
SAE Clinical Trial Clinical Trial Clinical Trial Clinical Trial Clinical Trial Clinical Trial
Pharma Safety GroupsCentral Lab Columbia Database GALT dsCapture
Pharma PMS & Clinical Trials
DILI Pharmaco 5 Potential Cohorts PQT/TDP Pharmaco 1 Cohort Angio-Edema Pharmaco 1 Cohort SSR Pharmaco 1 Cohort AHSS Pharma ? Cohorts
16
Agranulocytosis Pharmaco 1 Cohort Control Cohorts (2)
EMR SAE Case Sourcing
Cerner Health Facts [15 million pts.]
2009-10 Feasibility Projects Focus: Using EMR and associated
research systems to determine the feasibility of yielding high quality SAE cases.
SAE targets/3/collaboration [of joint
interest]
SSR
Rhabdomyolosis/Myopathy
17
VA Health System [7 million pts.] HMORN 25 million pts.
S A E C
SAE Clinical Trial Clinical Trial Clinical Trial Clinical Trial Clinical Trial Clinical Trial
Pharma Safety GroupsCentral Lab Columbia Database GALT dsCapture
Pharma PMS & Clinical Trials
Group Health Cooperative Marshfield Kaiser
18
Health Partners Geisinger
DILI SSR
EWG-Anti Psych
19
20
EUDRAGENE
105 Cases SAEC Members ~70 Cases ~700 Controls Clinical Cohort Sourcing Global DACC Global SAEC GT Core
Diligen
4800 WTCCC Controls Spanish DI LI
53 Cases
Scotland
46 Cases
Texas (Lee) 46 Sweden
(Bjornsson)
60+ Japan
(Takikawa)
30 Singapore
(Gee)
25 France
(Larrey)
50
20
Discovery Cases ~ 500 Population Controls ~ 700 WTCCC Controls ~ 4800 214 Cases
21
Total cases 505 Sex
Race
Country/
Europeans
22
Drug (group) Diligen EUDRA Scotlnd Malaga Abbott T otal Coamoxiclav 78 25 13 58 174 Flucloxacillin 70 6 76 Coamoxi or Fluclox 8 8 Zileuton 71 71 Diclofenac 25 3 28 IRPE 25 1 26 NSAIDs 33 33 Other 20 44 25 89 Total 226 106 44 58 71 505
23 23
24 24
Drug / Drug groups Number of cases /controls Major Results Pending action items Flucloxacillin
77 UK cases / 282 POPRES 1. HLA-B*5701 (OR ~ 80) is a major risk factor 2. Paper published in Nat ure Genet ics
Coamoxiclav
142 Caucasian cases / 651 POPRES / 4900 WTCCC
1. DR2 Tag SNP is associated, with genome-
wide significance (OR=2.5) 2. Top associated SNP (OR=2.9) is in HLA class II region, and indicates a signal independent
3. Independent association in class I (OR=2.1) 1. HLA sequencing
2. Publication
Ant i-TB
14 Caucasian cases / 282 POPRES Interesting association in chr 8 (OR=8; p=10^-6), close to gene NAT1 1. Publication
Diclofenac
22 cases/282 controls None
COXIBS
10 cases/40 controls None
NIMESULIDE
12 cases /48 controls None All NS
AIDs
57 cases/228 controls Interesting association in chr 6 (OR=4; p=4x10^- 6), close to genes IL22RA2 and IL20RA
All cases not caused by flucloxacillin or coamoxiclav
151 cases / 650 controls Interesting but not genome-wide significant association of a SNP from chr 4 (OR=3; p=9x10^- 8), close to gene S
LC34A2
26 26
Top SNP: rs2395029 Case genotypes 4/39/8 P-value 10-30 Allelic OR 14 Dominant OR 35 MAF in controls 0.05 Tags HLA-B*5701 r2 = 1 Daly et al. (2009) Nat. Genet. 41:816-9
27
DR2 (HLA-DRB1*1501-DQA1*0102-DQB1*0602)
28
Representative SNP @ MHC II Position chr:Mb OR P-value Genome-wide adjusted P-value P-value conditioned
rs9274407 6:32.74 2.9 1.2e-10 < 0.0003 0.0004 rs3135388 (DR2) 6:32.52 2.5 4.8e-8 0.022 NA
29
Class I SNP Position Chr:Mb Logistic regression Conditioned on Class II (rs9274407) P OR P OR Adjusted-P in MHC rs2523822 (A* 0201) 6:29.9 2.7e-7 2.1 6.0e-7 2.1 0.001 rs1632933 6:29.9 2.6e-6 0.5 4.3e-5 0.55 0.048
30
Ethnicity White 70 Black 5 Other 2 Gender Female 48 Male 29 Age 48 ± 15 Max ALT (xUNL) 7.8 ± 6
Northern- Central EU (57 cases, 203 controls)
All Caucasians (66 cases, 235 controls) NC-EU (57 cases, 203 controls) Updated cohort (58 cases, 207 controls) MAF in WTCCC 2 (~4800) MAF in UK POPRE S (282) SNP Chr: Mb Gene P-value MAF contr
OR P-value MAF contr
OR P MAF OR rs12464471 2: 63.5 C2orf86 / MDH1 / UGP2 etc 5.4e-8 0.14 4.3 1.9e-7 0.15 4.3 9.9e-8 0.14 4.6 0.22 0.18 rs12470478 2: 63.6 1.1e-7 0.16 3.9 2.1e-7 0.16 4.2 2.7e-7 0.16 4 0.24 0.20 rs7671181 4: 21.3 KCNIP4 2.3e-6 0.17 3.1 2.0e-6 0.18 3.5 2e-5 0.18 2.9 0.24 0.23 rs12600361 17: 72.6 C17orf86 / SCARNA1 6 5.8e-6 0.043 5.1 2.5e-6 0.04 6.7 5.9e-6 0.048 5.3 0.066 0.059 rs10915448 1: 4.1 None 5.5e-6 0.25 3.1 2.4e-6 0.24 3.5 0.00015 0.25 2.7 0.28 0.26
Note: all SNPs are nominally associated with the second eigen vector
35
36
GSK Cohorts 73 Cases
RegiSCAR
400 Cases Japan NI HR ~69 Clinical Cohorts Global DACC Global SAEC GT Core
Discovery Cohort 81
Columbia University
140 Controls Small Collabs 18 Cases
EUDRAGENE
Italy 20 GATC 19 8 Cases
37
39
39
SNPs chr Position Genes Function of the genes rs17137412
7 7767212
RP A3
cellular response to replication stress and DNA damage. immunoglobulin diversification
40
41
SNP Chr: Mb Type closest gene Overall cases (71 vs 417 ) n-EU cohort (46 vs 4250) s-EU cohort (22 vs 80) logistic Fisher Exact test logistic Controls MAF p-value OR Controls MAF p-value OR Controls MAF p-value OR
rs981946 Chr 6: 3.3 Intronic SLC22A23 0.32 8.6E-07 2.7 0.36 0.002 1.9 0.29 0.0065 2.8 rs1079284 Chr 6: 3.3 Intronic SLC22A23 0.32 8.6E-07 2.7 0.36 0.002 1.9 0.29 0.0065 2.8 rs17137412 Chr 7: 7.8 Intronic RPA3 / GLCCI1 0.12 0.00022 2.3 0.11 1.3E-08 4.0 0.12 0.52 0.66 rs4532807 Chr 5: 162 Intronic ATF6 0.046 0.00003 2.7 0.036 2.8E-05 4.5 0.056 0.31 0.32
42
3 Japanese Allopurinol SJS/TEN/DIHS HLA-B*5801 All pos. 40 Japanese Multiple SJS/TEN HLA-A*0206 5.5 Genetic [HLA] marker variance across ethnicity & drug
43
44
45
46
47
49
Members
SMC
50
51
52
Top Priority – Network Support
Medium Priority – Via Collabs/ Min. I nvestment
Disease spectrum, with potentially important common genetic factors
An Integrated Model of Genetic Predisposition
Maculopapular eruption
SSR Tolerant
SJS and TEN Hypersensitivity syndrom e Death Extra-cutaneous
( Liver, Kidney ,Lung)
Source: Munir Pirmohamed et al , modified by SAEC
54
Drug Adverse Drug Reaction Genetic Risk Factor
Reaction Prevalence Risk Allele
Effect2
Clopidogrel Cardiovascular events 0.13
CYP2C19*2/ 3/ 4/ 5
0.03 3 Gefitinib Diarrhea 0.28
ABCG2 Q141K
0.07 5 Isoniazid Hepatotoxicity 0.15
CYP2E1*1 & NAT2
0.133 7 Co-amoxiclav Hepatotoxicity <0.001
HLA-DRB1*1501
0.20 10 Irinotecan Neutropenia 0.20 UGT1A1*28 0.32 28 Ticlopidine Hepatotoxicity (cholestatic) <0.001
HLA-A*3303
0.14 36 Tranilast Hyperbilirubinemia 0.12 UGT1A1*28 0.30 48 Flucloxacillin Hepatotoxicity <0.001 HLA-B*5701 0.04 81 Allopurinol Severe cutaneous reaction <0.001
HLA-B*5801
0.15 678 Abacavir Hypersensitivity reaction 0.08 HLA-B*5701 0.04 >1000 Carbamazepine Stevens-Johnson <0.001
HLA-B*1502
0.04 >1000
SAEC Members / Pharmacos
Web Based Clinical Network
SAEC DACC
DNA Repository
TBD based
Guru Aithal & Ann Daly
300 Cases
Spanish Network
VA HMORN SAEC Members / Pharmacos
DI LI I nvestigator Network [8] – Bjornsson, Takikawa, Gee, & Larrey, etc.
SAEC Genomics Core
TBD based
TBD based
Japanese NI HR Cerner 2b
DI LI N NI DDK
I nt. TB Study Menzies et al (Montreal)
56
Four Major SAEs
Potential + Phase 2 Members
Phase 1 Members
57
3 months 6 Months
Development
SAEC Phase 2 Launch!
Dec ` 09
58