SLIDE 1 INTERACTIONS BETWEEN SUPERCONDUCTING QUBITS MEDIATED BY TRAVELLING PHOTONS
Kevin Lalumière1, B. C. Sanders2, A. F. van Loo3, A. Fedorov3, A. Wallraff3, and
1Université de Sherbrooke, Canada 2University of Calgary, Canada 3University of Zurich, Switzerland
Science, in press
SLIDE 2
PLAN
SLIDE 3
PLAN
What I do
SLIDE 4
PLAN
What I do Physics primer: EM waves and electrical circuits
SLIDE 5
PLAN
What I do Physics primer: EM waves and electrical circuits Waveguide QED
SLIDE 6
PLAN
What I do Physics primer: EM waves and electrical circuits Waveguide QED Many qubits waveguide QED (our contribution)
SLIDE 7
WHAT I DO
SLIDE 8
WHAT I DO
SLIDE 9
WHAT I DO
SLIDE 10
PHYSICS PRIMER: ELECTRICAL CURRENT AND EM WAVES
SLIDE 11
PHYSICS PRIMER: ELECTRICAL CURRENT AND EM WAVES
SLIDE 12
PHYSICS PRIMER: ELECTRICAL CURRENT AND EM WAVES
SLIDE 13
PHYSICS PRIMER: ELECTRICAL CURRENT AND EM WAVES
SLIDE 14
PHYSICS PRIMER: ELECTRICAL CIRCUITS
SLIDE 15
Circuits element schematics
PHYSICS PRIMER: ELECTRICAL CIRCUITS
SLIDE 16
Circuits element schematics Wire
PHYSICS PRIMER: ELECTRICAL CIRCUITS
SLIDE 17
Circuits element schematics Wire Ground
PHYSICS PRIMER: ELECTRICAL CIRCUITS
SLIDE 18
Circuits element schematics Wire Ground Capacitor
PHYSICS PRIMER: ELECTRICAL CIRCUITS
SLIDE 19
Circuits element schematics Wire Ground Capacitor Voltage source
PHYSICS PRIMER: ELECTRICAL CIRCUITS
SLIDE 20
Circuits element schematics Wire Ground Capacitor Voltage source Oscilloscope (to measure)
PHYSICS PRIMER: ELECTRICAL CIRCUITS
SLIDE 21
Circuits element schematics Wire Ground Capacitor Voltage source Oscilloscope (to measure) Josephson junction
PHYSICS PRIMER: ELECTRICAL CIRCUITS
SLIDE 22
Circuits element schematics Wire Ground Capacitor Voltage source Oscilloscope (to measure) Josephson junction
PHYSICS PRIMER: ELECTRICAL CIRCUITS
SLIDE 23
Circuits element schematics Wire Ground Capacitor Voltage source Oscilloscope (to measure) Josephson junction
PHYSICS PRIMER: ELECTRICAL CIRCUITS
SLIDE 24
WAVEGUIDE QED EXPERIMENT
SLIDE 25
WAVEGUIDE QED EXPERIMENT
SLIDE 26 WAVEGUIDE QED EXPERIMENT
SLIDE 27 WAVEGUIDE QED EXPERIMENT
SLIDE 28 WAVEGUIDE QED EXPERIMENT
SLIDE 29 WAVEGUIDE QED EXPERIMENT
SLIDE 30 WAVEGUIDE QED EXPERIMENT
SLIDE 31 WAVEGUIDE QED EXPERIMENT
SLIDE 32 WAVEGUIDE QED EXPERIMENT
SLIDE 33 WAVEGUIDE QED EXPERIMENT
SLIDE 34 WAVEGUIDE QED EXPERIMENT
SLIDE 35
WAVEGUIDE QED LOW INTENSITY Vin(t)
SLIDE 36 WAVEGUIDE QED LOW INTENSITY Vin(t)
5 10 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
SLIDE 37 WAVEGUIDE QED LOW INTENSITY Vin(t)
5 10 0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
SLIDE 38
WAVEGUIDE QED HIGH INTENSITY Vin(t)
SLIDE 39 WAVEGUIDE QED HIGH INTENSITY Vin(t)
5 10 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
SLIDE 40 WAVEGUIDE QED HIGH INTENSITY Vin(t)
5 10 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
SLIDE 41 WAVEGUIDE QED HIGH INTENSITY Vin(t)
5 10 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
SLIDE 42 WAVEGUIDE QED HIGH INTENSITY Vin(t)
5 10 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
SLIDE 43 WAVEGUIDE QED HIGH INTENSITY Vin(t)
5 10 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
SLIDE 44 WAVEGUIDE QED HIGH INTENSITY Vin(t)
5 10 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
SLIDE 45 WAVEGUIDE QED HIGH INTENSITY Vin(t)
5 10 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
SLIDE 46 WAVEGUIDE QED HIGH INTENSITY Vin(t)
5 10 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
SLIDE 47 WAVEGUIDE QED HIGH INTENSITY Vin(t)
5 10 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
SLIDE 48 WAVEGUIDE QED HIGH INTENSITY V(t)
50 100 1 2 3
A
/2 (MHz) 0 +
- 0 –
- S (10-24 W/Hz)
- O. Astafiev et al. Science 327, 840 (2010)
I.-O. Hio et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 073601 (2011)
SLIDE 49 WAVEGUIDE QED HIGH INTENSITY V(t)
Observed experimentally
50 100 1 2 3
A
/2 (MHz) 0 +
- 0 –
- S (10-24 W/Hz)
- O. Astafiev et al. Science 327, 840 (2010)
I.-O. Hio et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 073601 (2011)
SLIDE 50 WAVEGUIDE QED HIGH INTENSITY V(t)
Observed experimentally Important experiment for physicists
50 100 1 2 3
A
/2 (MHz) 0 +
- 0 –
- S (10-24 W/Hz)
- O. Astafiev et al. Science 327, 840 (2010)
I.-O. Hio et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 073601 (2011)
SLIDE 51 WAVEGUIDE QED HIGH INTENSITY V(t)
Observed experimentally Important experiment for physicists Usually, qubits (atoms) move
50 100 1 2 3
A
/2 (MHz) 0 +
- 0 –
- S (10-24 W/Hz)
- O. Astafiev et al. Science 327, 840 (2010)
I.-O. Hio et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 073601 (2011)
SLIDE 52 WAVEGUIDE QED HIGH INTENSITY V(t)
Observed experimentally Important experiment for physicists Usually, qubits (atoms) move Hard to couple to drive signal
50 100 1 2 3
A
/2 (MHz) 0 +
- 0 –
- S (10-24 W/Hz)
- O. Astafiev et al. Science 327, 840 (2010)
I.-O. Hio et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 073601 (2011)
SLIDE 53 WAVEGUIDE QED HIGH INTENSITY V(t)
Observed experimentally Important experiment for physicists Usually, qubits (atoms) move Hard to couple to drive signal Hard to read output signal
50 100 1 2 3
A
/2 (MHz) 0 +
- 0 –
- S (10-24 W/Hz)
- O. Astafiev et al. Science 327, 840 (2010)
I.-O. Hio et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 073601 (2011)
SLIDE 54 NEW WAVEGUIDE QED EXPERIMENT
SLIDE 55 NEW WAVEGUIDE QED EXPERIMENT
SLIDE 56 NEW WAVEGUIDE QED EXPERIMENT
SLIDE 57 NEW WAVEGUIDE QED EXPERIMENT
SLIDE 58 NEW WAVEGUIDE QED EXPERIMENT
Phase acquired by EM wave between qubits
SLIDE 59
φ=nπ SUPER- AND SUBRADIANCE
SLIDE 60
φ=nπ SUPER- AND SUBRADIANCE
SLIDE 61
φ=nπ SUPER- AND SUBRADIANCE
SLIDE 62
φ=nπ SUPER- AND SUBRADIANCE
SLIDE 63
φ=nπ SUPER- AND SUBRADIANCE
SLIDE 64
φ=nπ SUPER- AND SUBRADIANCE
SLIDE 65
Superradiance
φ=nπ SUPER- AND SUBRADIANCE
SLIDE 66
Subradiance (not drive tone) Superradiance
φ=nπ SUPER- AND SUBRADIANCE
SLIDE 67
First observation of this signature of subradiance Subradiance (not drive tone) Superradiance
φ=nπ SUPER- AND SUBRADIANCE
SLIDE 68
First observation of this signature of subradiance Decoherence free subspace? Subradiance (not drive tone) Superradiance
φ=nπ SUPER- AND SUBRADIANCE
SLIDE 69
φ=(2n+1)π/2 COHERENT INTERACTION
SLIDE 70
φ=(2n+1)π/2 COHERENT INTERACTION
SLIDE 71
φ=(2n+1)π/2 COHERENT INTERACTION
SLIDE 72
φ=(2n+1)π/2 COHERENT INTERACTION
SLIDE 73
φ=(2n+1)π/2 COHERENT INTERACTION
Vacuum fluctuations of EM waves
SLIDE 74
φ=(2n+1)π/2 COHERENT INTERACTION
Because of symmetry, coherent interaction is 0 for φ=nπ Vacuum fluctuations of EM waves
SLIDE 75
φ=(2n+1)π/2 COHERENT INTERACTION
Because of symmetry, coherent interaction is 0 for φ=nπ It is maximal around φ=(2n+1)π/2 Vacuum fluctuations of EM waves
SLIDE 76
φ=(2n+1)π/2 COHERENT INTERACTION
Because of symmetry, coherent interaction is 0 for φ=nπ It is maximal around φ=(2n+1)π/2 Vacuum fluctuations of EM waves
SLIDE 77
φ=(2n+1)π/2 COHERENT INTERACTION
Because of symmetry, coherent interaction is 0 for φ=nπ It is maximal around φ=(2n+1)π/2 Vacuum fluctuations of EM waves
SLIDE 78
φ=(2n+1)π/2 COHERENT INTERACTION
Because of symmetry, coherent interaction is 0 for φ=nπ It is maximal around φ=(2n+1)π/2 Vacuum fluctuations of EM waves
SLIDE 79
φ=(2n+1)π/2 COHERENT INTERACTION
SLIDE 80
φ=(2n+1)π/2 COHERENT INTERACTION
SLIDE 81
φ=(2n+1)π/2 COHERENT INTERACTION
SLIDE 82 φ=(2n+1)π/2 COHERENT INTERACTION
First observation of signature
- f exchange interaction in
these kind of systems.
SLIDE 83 φ=(2n+1)π/2 COHERENT INTERACTION
First observation of signature
- f exchange interaction in
these kind of systems. Two qubits gate
SLIDE 84 φ=(2n+1)π/2 COHERENT INTERACTION
First observation of signature
- f exchange interaction in
these kind of systems. Two qubits gate Quantum interaction of
SLIDE 85 CONCLUSIONS
Science, in press
SLIDE 86 Using cold electrical circuits and Josephson junctions
CONCLUSIONS
Science, in press
SLIDE 87 Using cold electrical circuits and Josephson junctions We can build many-qubits quantum devices that exhibits interesting physical effects such as
CONCLUSIONS
Science, in press
SLIDE 88 Using cold electrical circuits and Josephson junctions We can build many-qubits quantum devices that exhibits interesting physical effects such as Mollow triplets
CONCLUSIONS
Science, in press
50 100 1 2 3
A
/2 (MHz) 0 +
SLIDE 89 Using cold electrical circuits and Josephson junctions We can build many-qubits quantum devices that exhibits interesting physical effects such as Mollow triplets Subradiance
CONCLUSIONS
Science, in press
50 100 1 2 3
A
/2 (MHz) 0 +
SLIDE 90 Using cold electrical circuits and Josephson junctions We can build many-qubits quantum devices that exhibits interesting physical effects such as Mollow triplets Subradiance Quantum coherent interaction
CONCLUSIONS
Science, in press
50 100 1 2 3
A
/2 (MHz) 0 +
SLIDE 91 Using cold electrical circuits and Josephson junctions We can build many-qubits quantum devices that exhibits interesting physical effects such as Mollow triplets Subradiance Quantum coherent interaction
CONCLUSIONS
THANKS
Science, in press
50 100 1 2 3
A
/2 (MHz) 0 +
SLIDE 92 Qubit-qubit interaction (4.8 GHz; 3λ/4)
- Qubit-qubit interaction: emission of (virtual) photons at all ω ≠ ω01
- Contribution to J from ω: g1 g2/(ω01 - ω)
- Sum over all ω is finite because of sign changes around 3λ/4
- J =0 at λ, λ/2...
g1 g2
SLIDE 93 Qubit-qubit interaction (4.8 GHz; 3λ/4)
- Qubit-qubit interaction: emission of (virtual) photons at all ω ≠ ω01
- Contribution to J from ω: g1 g2/(ω01 - ω)
- Sum over all ω is finite because of sign changes around 3λ/4
- J =0 at λ, λ/2...
g1 g2
SLIDE 94 Qubit-qubit interaction (4.8 GHz; 3λ/4)
- Qubit-qubit interaction: emission of (virtual) photons at all ω ≠ ω01
- Contribution to J from ω: g1 g2/(ω01 - ω)
- Sum over all ω is finite because of sign changes around 3λ/4
- J =0 at λ, λ/2...
g1 > 0, g2 > 0, ω01 - ω < 0 g1 g2
SLIDE 95 Qubit-qubit interaction (4.8 GHz; 3λ/4)
- Qubit-qubit interaction: emission of (virtual) photons at all ω ≠ ω01
- Contribution to J from ω: g1 g2/(ω01 - ω)
- Sum over all ω is finite because of sign changes around 3λ/4
- J =0 at λ, λ/2...
g1 > 0, g2 > 0, ω01 - ω < 0 g1 g2 ⇒ -
SLIDE 96 Qubit-qubit interaction (4.8 GHz; 3λ/4)
- Qubit-qubit interaction: emission of (virtual) photons at all ω ≠ ω01
- Contribution to J from ω: g1 g2/(ω01 - ω)
- Sum over all ω is finite because of sign changes around 3λ/4
- J =0 at λ, λ/2...
g1 > 0, g2 > 0, ω01 - ω < 0 g1 g2 ⇒ -
SLIDE 97 Qubit-qubit interaction (4.8 GHz; 3λ/4)
- Qubit-qubit interaction: emission of (virtual) photons at all ω ≠ ω01
- Contribution to J from ω: g1 g2/(ω01 - ω)
- Sum over all ω is finite because of sign changes around 3λ/4
- J =0 at λ, λ/2...
g1 > 0, g2 > 0, ω01 - ω < 0 g1 g2 ⇒ - g1 > 0, g2 < 0, ω01 - ω > 0
SLIDE 98 Qubit-qubit interaction (4.8 GHz; 3λ/4)
- Qubit-qubit interaction: emission of (virtual) photons at all ω ≠ ω01
- Contribution to J from ω: g1 g2/(ω01 - ω)
- Sum over all ω is finite because of sign changes around 3λ/4
- J =0 at λ, λ/2...
g1 > 0, g2 > 0, ω01 - ω < 0 g1 g2 ⇒ - g1 > 0, g2 < 0, ω01 - ω > 0 ⇒ -