In summary, since March, Herts Highways appear to have taken the - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

▶
in summary since march herts highways appear to have
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

In summary, since March, Herts Highways appear to have taken the - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Dec 10, 2022 400 likes •848 views

Alasdair DV Massie CEng MIStructE CTC Right to Ride Representative, North Herts I thought that it might be useful to resend the a4ached message, as a reminder of what we were saying in March and why this Scru;ny is taking place. You will

slide-1
SLIDE 1

Alasdair DV Massie CEng MIStructE

CTC Right to Ride Representative, North Herts

slide-2
SLIDE 2

I thought that it might be useful to re‐send the a4ached message, as a reminder of what we were saying in March and why this Scru;ny is taking place. You will note that:

 Roadside footway conversion con;nues as the

“solu;on of choice” for Herts Highways, despite being at the very bo4om of the Hierarchy of Measures, despite the HerEordshire Cycling Strategy and all current na;onal guidelines, and despite opposi;on from user groups. Since we wrote to you in March, EVERY proposal that we have seen has been based on roadside footway conversion. Examples include Weston Way in Baldock, Baldock / Jubilee Road in Letchworth, Hitchin Sta;on forecourt, Bedford Road in Hitchin and Burns Road in Royston. In NONE of those loca;ons should pavement conversion have been the first choice of solu;on.

slide-3
SLIDE 3

 Highway Schemes are clearly NOT being reviewed to see

how improvements for cycling can be incorporated within them. As examples we have the Baldock High Street re‐ build (£2.25 million), where access has been blocked through Church Street, effec;vely preven;ng local residents from cycling to and from the High Street other than by a long detour on main

  • roads. We also have the nearby example of the North Road /

Ickneild Way junc;on where again people are losing access to residen;al streets. We have the Letchworth town centre re‐build where for the second ;me in 10 years the opportunity has been ignored to restore two way cycle access to the popular shopping streets in the town centre. And of course we have Bedford Road in Hitchin where the chance to remove the awful gyratory system has been ignored in favour of a nasty, narrow and wholly unsa;sfactory pavement conversion. Likewise at Baldock Road in Letchworth where designers refused to make any space for cycling in a 30m wide road that had been bypassed and has twice the capacity needed for current traffic levels, and instead are forcing cyclists onto a thoroughly unsa;sfactory footway.

slide-4
SLIDE 4

In summary, since March, Herts Highways appear to have taken the a]tude that they will NOT do as we have requested (ie to follow the recommenda;ons and stated policy of the HerEordshire Cycling Strategy). On the contrary, they appear to be working to a policy of deliberately and systema;cally doing the opposite. We do not believe that Herts Highways have shown any will to address these issues construc;vely.

Regards

Alasdair DV Massie CEng MIStructE

CTC Right to Ride Representative, North Herts

slide-5
SLIDE 5

Stephen Wragg St Albans Cycle Campaign STACC founder member, 1998 Chair for the last 18 months 470 paid-up members We are the largest Campaigning group in Herts, and we make the needs of cyclists known locally. In an ideal world we wouldn't exist! Less 'campaigning' more supporting initiatives, organising regular rides etc (more like SPOKES in Watford).

slide-6
SLIDE 6

S T A L B A N S

C Y C L E C A M P A I G N

MEETING

PUBLIC

TUES 4

T H

DEC 2007 @ 7.30 P M

slide-7
SLIDE 7

Myself

Designer / photographer STACC decided to produce a map of the Alban Way 2003 Researched, Wrote, Photographed, Designed part way through the process Groundwork provided money to print...

slide-8
SLIDE 8
slide-9
SLIDE 9

Mapmaking

Motivation is enthusiasm for cycling, and wanting to share with others. Not bidding for more money for my business...! What is a cyclemap, to show you were you can cycle...? Implying there are places where you canʼt... I am looking forward to when this type of map is not necessary!

slide-10
SLIDE 10

Countywide mapping

Maps have been done locally, managed by many different organisations / individuals, Councils, CMS, Groundwork, HCC... Consolidate expertise, advice - countywide. 2 maps currently - are the people managing these productions getting support?

slide-11
SLIDE 11

Promotion / distribution

Commisioned & Printed, but are they available in all chosen outlets? Where are they distributed from? Are they visible (St A TI)! Direct member of public request...

slide-12
SLIDE 12

Scrutiny process Using Watford as evidence of conformity to Cycle Strategy?

...what made Watford different?

slide-13
SLIDE 13

Tim Woolridge led in-house design / build process, efficiently harvesting Sec106. Evidence we have been shown: Pre-dates HCC Cycle Strategy 2007 Administered by WBC Herts Highways ʻrubber-stampedʼ schemes.

slide-14
SLIDE 14
  • Cycle route through ped. shopping area
  • Useful cycle routes, cut-throughs,
  • Cycle paths alongside dual-carriageway
  • Dedicated cycle map 2005, 2007
  • ASL's at signalled junctions
  • 20mph zones
  • Permeable developments

Not a product of County, HH, Cycle Strategy 2007. Work slowed since 2007... worries for the future... no forums, no dialogue.

slide-15
SLIDE 15

Watford is not representitive...

St Albans HH Local Office shown no interest / inclination to work for cyclists... There is no interface... we donʼt meet... If we want something we talk to Dave Burt... (The Scrutiny panel have not been shown the full picture of performance countywide).

slide-16
SLIDE 16

Let’s compare Watford to St Albans

  • Cycle route through ped. shopping area?
  • Useful cycle routes, cut-throughs?
  • Cycle paths alongside dual-carriageway?
  • Dedicated cycle map?
  • 20mph zones?
  • Permeable developments?
  • ASL's at signalled junctions? (see photo)
slide-17
SLIDE 17

Advanced Stop Line - London

slide-18
SLIDE 18

Recently redesigned junction in St Albans - no ASL

slide-19
SLIDE 19

Why are we different to Watford...

Local Cycle Officer We have a St Albans Cycle Strategy 2008, but the action plan was never written... Slow frustrating progress... Highfield Park... Cycling on District land - parks

...how about in other areas?

slide-20
SLIDE 20

A Cyclist's Journey 1998 - 2009

We want off-road facilities... “Don't ask for off carriageway solutions” We want cycle lanes everywhere... “But they can be less safe” Cycle infrastructure is expensive, ...so slow to implement... Solution...

slide-21
SLIDE 21

Continental town centre

slide-22
SLIDE 22

Continental town centre

slide-23
SLIDE 23

St Peters Street St Albans

slide-24
SLIDE 24

Why are off-road facilities less desirable...?

slide-25
SLIDE 25

A more desirable solution at side junctions, cyclists do not lose priority.

slide-26
SLIDE 26

User Hierachy

(Cycle Strategy p48)

slide-27
SLIDE 27

User Hierachy

(CS p48) “I am guessing that it may be from The Traffic Management Act 2004 which requires us to establish these. If that is the case, we have not yet done this exercise and it will be some time until we do”.

“Our LTP is the document in which our approach is currently explained and it does not contain a hierarchy as you have explained it”. “Our members have not wished to go in that direction up to now”. Rob Smith 12/2005

slide-28
SLIDE 28

Is Herts Highways working to the User Hierarchy as defined in the Cycle Strategy. Did it get embodied into LTP 06/07-10/11? "of course cyclists are at the top of the hierarchy... on a cycle route..." 10/2009

slide-29
SLIDE 29

Hierarchy of Provision

p55

Not being adopted - for example NCN6 St Albans 2009 Long detour around 'unsafe section'... To turn right...

  • nto pavement,

and dismount to cross beyond the junction, and then double-back. Cyclists experience: Inconvenient, Slow, Less safe Why - no attempt to change the motorized vehicle experience?

slide-30
SLIDE 30

Where NCN 6 was intended to go in St Albans, but deemed unsafe due to vehicle speed. Anti-slip surface facilitates speeding, NCN route redirected around adjacent back streets.

slide-31
SLIDE 31

Attempt to reduce the effectiveness of the published Cycle Strategy

P58 ʻ...whilst the following are not policies...ʼ

  • Advanced stop lines at urban signalled junctions
  • Horizontal traffic calming will have cycle bypass
  • 'Continental' roundabouts...
  • Cycle routes will have adequate maintenance...
  • Cycle tracks will not have barriers or other
  • bstructions...
  • Cycle tracks will not be created through conversion
  • f footways - ideally...
  • ʻCyclist Dismountʼ signs will not be used unless

there is an overriding reason to do so...

slide-32
SLIDE 32

Pinch points, with no cycle by-pass continue to be installed

slide-33
SLIDE 33

Inappropriate “Cyclist Dismount” sign where cycle route rejoins carriageway

slide-34
SLIDE 34

Published Cycle Strategy

somethings not included...

  • Cycle facilities on Dual-Carriageways
slide-35
SLIDE 35

A414 South of St Albans Cyclists are expected to use the road...

slide-36
SLIDE 36

...rather than the adjacent usable path

slide-37
SLIDE 37

Delivery of Cycle Strategy in St Albans via St Albans Urban Transport Plan 2009

“Develop Walking and Cycling Priority Feasibility Study” £40k (but with no funds for implementation)

slide-38
SLIDE 38
slide-39
SLIDE 39

Site specific Schemes Out of 20 schemes listed.... 7 items are for cycling measures 340k over 5 years

but... "Look for Developer Contributions / DfT Cycle Demonstration Town / Cycle England funding where possible"

Total UTP spend: £2.86m

slide-40
SLIDE 40

20mph

20 mile per hour zones are not without difficulty: they require considerable signage and potential engineering measures, which may be inappropriate in the conservation area; they could, if poorly planned encourage rat-running; and are difficult to enforce by the police who have limited resources. Ideally, therefore, 20 mph zones should be ʻself-enforcingʼ but this would mean the introduction of traffic-calming measures, which may prove unpopular to those living resident in the affected streets. That said, there is great public interest in such measures and it would be beneficial to pilot 20 mph zones in suitable areas. 7.7 St Albans Urban Transport Plan 2009

“ ”

slide-41
SLIDE 41

20mph Portsmouth

slide-42
SLIDE 42

20mph Portsmouth Hertforshire would refuse to do this - on grounds that it is not ʻself-enforcingʼ

slide-43
SLIDE 43

Thanks to Dave Burt with two full-time jobs...