Implementing the MNO Self Government Agreement
Presentation to PCMNO (July 26, 2020) Jason Madden & Alexandria Winterburn, Pape Salter Teillet LLP
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
Implementing the MNO Self Government Agreement Presentation to - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Implementing the MNO Self Government Agreement Presentation to PCMNO (July 26, 2020) Jason Madden & Alexandria Winterburn, Pape Salter Teillet LLP Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged Presentation Overview Part 1: Review/Recap of
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
2
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
4
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
5
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
6
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
7
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
8
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
9
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
10
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
11
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
MNA and MNS (who also each have MGRSAs) in a Multi-Party negotiations process with Canada to develop templates of some of the common steps/requirements
be customized to fit the needs and circumstances of the MNO and Métis self-government in Ontario
the MGRSA negotiations, by developing a template version (with MNA and MNS) that was customized to meet MNO’s distinct circumstance/needs
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
Internal Self-Government Readiness Work (Consultation with Citizens, Constitution, Core Set of Laws, Ratification by Citizens) Bilateral Negotiations between Canada and MNA based on Existing Framework Agreement and MGRSA Multi-Party Negotiations between Canada and Métis Governments based Common Issues Identified in MGRSA Implementation Renewed Nation-to- Nation, Government-to- Government Relationship Métis Government Recognition and Self-Government Agreement Implementation Métis Governments Relying on Corporate Structures to Act as their Legal and Administrative Arms
Métis Nation
Métis Nation- Saskatchewan Métis Nation
Internal Self-Government Readiness Work (Consultation with Citizens, Constitution, Core Set of Laws, Ratification by Citizens) Bilateral Negotiations between Canada and MN-S based on Existing Framework Agreement and MGRSA Multi-Party Negotiations between Canada and Métis Governments based Common Issues Identified in MGRSA Implementation Internal Self-Government Readiness Work (Consultation with Citizens, Constitution, Core Set of Laws, Ratification by Citizens) Trilateral Negotiations between MNO, Canada and Ontario based on Existing Framework Agreement and MGRSA Multi-Party Negotiations between Canada and Métis Governments based Common Issues Identified in MGRSA Implementation
Three Democratic, Self-Determining Métis Governments with Stable Funding and Capacity that are Improving the Quality of Life of their Citizens, Advancing and Protecting Métis Rights and Recognized as Indigenous Governments in Canadian Law
with Canada
Process Outcome
Constitution Citizenship and Registry Law Internal Structures, Operations, Procedures and Financial Management Law Election Law Engagement, Consultation and Ratification by Citizens
Métis Nation
Métis Nation- Saskatchewan Métis Nation
Each Métis Government Develops their Own Internal Processes, Workplan and Structures to Achieve the Following Pillars for Self- Government
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
Bilateral Negotiations on Subject Matters in Framework Agreement & Consultation Agreement MGRSA Implementation – Common Issues with Other Métis Governments
Bilateral Negotiations on Subject Matters in Framework Agreement & Other Agreements MGRSA Implementation – Common Issues with Other Métis Governments
Bilateral Negotiations on Subject Matters in Framework Agreement & NW Métis Community Agreement MGRSA Implementation – Common Issues with Other Métis Governments
Multi-Party MGRSA Common Issues Table
Fiscal Issues Interim Fiscal Financing Agreements Negotiating Fiscal Financing Agreements for Core Governance Other Fiscal Issues Co-Developed Template Agreements
Intergovernmental Relations Agreements (MGRSA, Chapter 18) Fiscal Template Agreements (MGRSA, Chapter 19) Transition Plans (MGRSA, Chapter 21) MGRSA Implementation Legislation Federal Recognition Legislation (MGRSA, Chapter 4) Addressing Outstanding Métis Claims Policy Tool to Address Métis Claims to further MGRSA Implementation Mandated Processes to Address Métis Land and Related Claims Métis Access to Specific Claims Process
Parties to Table: Canada, MNA, MNS & MNO
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
Government recognized in Canadian law, including to:
Métis Constitution and core laws;
ratification;
technology; and
18
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
place processes to advance the MNO internal work on implementing the Métis Self Government Agreement and meeting the MGRSA requirements
Constitution and core laws; and
development of the Constitution, core laws, and MGRSA in preparation for a ratification vote by citizens
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
Constitution Citizenship and Registry Law Internal Structures, Operations, Procedures and Financial Management Law Election Law Engagement, Consultation and Ratification by Citizens
20
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
21
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
24
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
including implementing the MGRSA to:
communities;
Constitution development and core laws; and
commitments in it
1) Terms of Reference for Negotiation Process (draft) 2) Regional Implementation Agreements & Workplans
25
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
MGRSA and advance the Framework Agreement, as well as advance claims-related negotiating including the Northwestern Ontario Métis Community Agreement negotiations.”
is organizing and advancing all the work flowing from the MGRSA implementation and the Framework Agreements.
implementation work;
in advancing the MGRSA and Framework Agreement negotiations and implementation; and
the MGRSA internal MNO work while, at the same time, continuing Framework Agreement and other negotiations
27
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
28
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
A. Framework Agreement Negotiations, MGRSA Implementation and working with MNO Communities on land and claims issues B. Multi-Party MGRSA Implementation (with MNA, MNS, and Canada) on common issues C. Internal MNO work with citizens and communities
29
MNO Internal Work MGRSA Multi- party work MNO Framework Agreement
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
implementation of the MGRSA;
Common Issues Table (with Canada, MNA, and MNS);
the Common Issues Table or Sub-Tables); and
approval (section 5.4)
briefed and kept updated on meetings and that the Negotiations Team is accountable to PCMNO (section 5.8)
decisions about any agreements, policies, legislation etc. will be made by PCMNO (section 5.10)
30
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
Framework Agreement and working to improve the quality of life and wellbeing of Métis citizens (section 6)
Agreement, Intergovernmental Relations Agreement, and Transition Plan)(section 7)
address specific priority issues (such as those identified in the Framework Agreement)and appoint “Negotiations Leads” that are responsible for these specific subject areas (section 6 and 7)
31
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
and
32
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
negotiations related to other Métis claims related to lands or other federal Crown duties
work with the Métis Communities Represented by the MNO to manage and oversee research related to these claims (section 8.3)
a claim. . . that is held by a Métis Community Represented by the MNO includes representation from that Community, and that any arrangement or agreement that impacts such a claim will require the approval of the relevant Community.” (section 8.4)
negotiations under the Northwestern Ontario Métis Community Agreement (section 8.5) and outlines specific roles and responsibilities for a Negotiations Lead (to be appointed by the Northwestern Ontario Métis Community) related to these negotiations (section 8.6 and 8.7)
33
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
34
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
Table with Canada and the MNA and MNS
Intergovernmental Relations Agreement, and Transition Plan)
appoint an “MGRSA Technical Lead” and will be represented by a smaller group of technical and legal experts at the Common Issues Table (section 9.4)
supported by MNO technical or support staff (section 9.8)
35
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
the Common Issues Table;
Common Issues Table; and
documents and next steps (section 9.7)
(which is, in turn, accountable to PCMNO) and will seek the Negotiation Team’s feedback and direction on the development of all template agreements, policies, legislation or other documents (section 9.9 and 9.10)
36
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
37
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
responsible for advancing the internal MGRSA implementation work
Métis Constitution and core laws, etc.)
Government and Constitution development, gathering feedback, etc.);
development of Métis Government laws and Constitution); and
38
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
and report back to the Senior Officials’ Table on specific issues (e.g. Métis Government Laws and Constitution, Historic Research, etc.) (section 10.5)
legal, as well as other technical support may be required (section 10.7-10.10)
39
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
advance of the meeting;
(section 10.11)
PCMNO’s approval of any draft agreements and other documents or plans.
by the MNO require PCMNO’s direction and approval, or approval through the Constitution or ratification process (section 10.14-10.16)
40
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
41
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
work contemplated under this TOR” (section 11).
Agreement negotiations, and NWOMC Agreement negotiations;
Technical Lead to advance and fulfill their responsibilities in the TOR, MGRSA, or Framework Agreement, as required;
Table, MNO Negotiating Team, as required; and
as requested.
42
any other agreements between the MNO and Canada or Ontario (section 12.2)
related processes or discussions (section 12.4)
(section 12.5)
government (section 12.6)
and account for lessons learned (section 12.8)
43
44
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
46
commitments, including to:
the MNO Constitution development and core laws;
Local levels (e.g. community councils) of the future Métis Government;
align with the Self-Government Agreement (e.g. consulting with Métis citizens), while providing flexibility for customization to the unique needs and concerns of each Region.
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
47
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
48
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
as part implementing the MGRSA and RIA.
Government Constitution and core laws (including any Region specific supplemental consultation processes);
Region by either:
1. Setting up a temporary Regional Corporation using the MNO Act (MNO Region would be able to receive funding directly, employ staff, implement enhanced agreed-to core governance activities) 2. Continuing to work with MNO Secretariat to strengthen core governance in the MNO Region (MNO would administer funding and assist, as required, in agreed-to core governance initiatives)
49
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
50
commitments is to incorporate using the MNO Act as a Regional Corporation
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged 1.Regional Implementation Agreement (RIA) is signed 2.RIA Workplan and funding/capacity support agreed upon 3.Regional Corporation Bylaws are developed 4.Regional Corporation and MNO develop and sign a Regional Government Agreement (setting out roles and responsibilities of the Regional Corporation and how it will work with the MNO, similar to the Charter Agreements on Consultation) 5.Letters patent filed and the Ontario Minister responsible for the MNO Act is notified (the Minister must add the Regional Corporation to a regulation under the MNO Act) 6.MNO can then transfer funds to the Regional Corporation, that can hold assets, employ staff, etc.
51
Regional Corporations would… Regional Corporations would NOT… allow the Regional Corporation to receive funds and hold assets, employ staff, etc. NOT be a vehicle for economic development Allow the Regional Corporation to still be connected to the MNO Secretariat but take on additional governance responsibilities NOT exist outside of the MNO Act structure Facilitate the Region building core self-governance capacity NOT (at least initially) be used to develop program or services outside of the core MGRSA commitments (e.g. NOT about programs for health, education, etc.) Be a transitional measure NOT be a long-term or permanent option Increase the Regions ability to implement MNO MGRSA commitments in a way that works for them through enhancements and increased customization NOT be a way for Regions to develop independent policies or programs
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
52
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
MNO Regions with Regional Corporations MNO Regions that Do Not Incorporate
Transition/Implementation Phase
53
MNO and Region Implement RIA Workplan:
Regional Manager/Capacity Support Regional Corporation (If Region wants) Consultation Plan Initial Core Gov Activities
MNO and Region discuss process for receiving initial funding & capacity MNO and Region appoint Regional Implementation Committee members Finalize and Sign RIA Workplan Sign Regional Implementation Agreement (RIA) MNO MGRSA (June 27, 2019)
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
and begin to develop individual workplans, including funding/capacity for designing process for community education and consultation on the Self-Government Agreement and the Métis Government Constitution
Intergovernmental Relations Agreement, and Transition Plan)
successful, MNO will become the “Métis Government” on a agree-upon date.
54
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged
Confidential and Solicitor-Client Privileged