Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23
“H-COUP”で物理を探る
馬渡 健太郎
1
1. H-COUP とは ? 2. なぜ H-COUP ? 3. H-COUPでどのよう に物理を探るのか ? 4. まとめと展望
共同研究者: 兼村 晋哉 (大阪大) 菊地 真吏子 (北九州高専) 桜井 亘大 (Karlsruhe/大阪大) 柳生 慶 (大阪大)
H-COUP 1. H-COUP ? 2. H-COUP ? 3. H-COUP - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
H-COUP 1. H-COUP ? 2. H-COUP ? 3. H-COUP : ( ) ? ( )
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23
馬渡 健太郎
1
共同研究者: 兼村 晋哉 (大阪大) 菊地 真吏子 (北九州高専) 桜井 亘大 (Karlsruhe/大阪大) 柳生 慶 (大阪大)
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23
2
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23 3
Comput.Phys.Commun.233(2018)134 http://www-het.phys.sci.osaka-u.ac.jp/~kanemu/HCOUP_HP1013/HCOUP_HP .html
Loop effects on the Higgs decay widths in extended Higgs models [1803.01456, PLB] Full NLO calculations of Higgs boson decay rates in models with non-minimal scalar sectors [1906.10070]
+K. Mawatari
Version 2 is coming very soon!
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23
PATH to LoopTools
(HSM, THDMs, IDM)
4
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23
5
Input Output
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23
6
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23
新物理(New Physics)の兆候が未だに現れない…
7
SUSY(超対称性)粒子の 質量への制限
Model SignatureATLAS SUSY Searches* - 95% CL Lower Limits
July 2019ATLAS Preliminary
√s = 13 TeV *Only a selection of the available mass limits on new states or phenomena is shown. Many of the limits are based on simplified models, c.f. refs. for the assumptions made. Model ℓ, γ Jets† Emiss TATLAS Exotics Searches* - 95% CL Upper Exclusion Limits
Status: May 2019ATLAS Preliminary
Non-SUSY粒子(e.g. 余剰次元模型の Kaluza-Klein粒子)の質量への制限
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23
8
しかし、ヒッグスセクター の測定精度はまだまだ。 理論的にヒッグス2重項が1つである 理由はなく、新物理模型の多くはヒッ グスセクターの拡張を要請。
pp
500 µb−1 80 µb−1
W Z t¯ t t
t-chan
Wt
2.0 fb−1
H
total t¯ tH VBF VH
WW WZ ZZ t
s-chan
t¯ tW t¯ tZ
tZj WWW WWZ
10−1 1 101 102 103 104 105 106 1011
σ [pb]
Status: March 2019
ATLAS Preliminary Run 1,2 √s = 7,8,13 TeV
Theory LHC pp √s = 7 TeV Data 4.5 − 4.6 fb−1 LHC pp √s = 8 TeV Data 20.2 − 20.3 fb−1 LHC pp √s = 13 TeV Data 3.2 − 79.8 fb−1
Standard Model Total Production Cross Section Measurements
精密測定によるヒッグスセクター の究明が新物理探索の鍵!
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23
[free parameters]
[free parameters]
9
field mixing (tree) quantum effect by additional bosons (loop)
*愛甲さんのポスター 発表 (明日)
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23
10
ILC500 is necessary. ILC can improve significantly. Only ILC can measure. 180M Higgs (HL-LHC) + 0.6M (ILC250)
European strategy: ILC [1901.09829]
relatively clean even at the LHC.
より精密な予言 が必要不可欠 O(1%) の精度 H-COUP !
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23 11 Kanemura, Kikuchi, Yagyu [1511.06211, NPB]+[1608.01582, NPB] Kanemura, Okada, Senaha, Yuan [hep-ph/0408364, PRD] Kanemura, Kikuchi, Yagyu [1401.0515, PLB]+[1502.07716, NPB]
Singlet extension THDM
Z2 charge assignment
IDM
Kanemura, Kikuchi, Sakurai, Yagyu [1605.08520, PRD]
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23
12
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23
13 Kanemura, Kikuchi, Mawatari, Sakurai, Yagyu [1803.01456 (PLB), 1906.10070]
THDM THDM
pattern of the deviations ➡ selection of NP models magnitude of the deviations ➡ NP scales
*桜井さんのポスター発表 (去年)
250 500 750 1000
50 100
ILC250!
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23
250 500 750 1000
√s (GeV)
100 200 300 400
Cross section (ab)
hγ (unpol) P(e
−, e +) = (−0.8, 0.3)
15
How much can new physics enhance (or reduce) the production rate?
κV H±(±) κf κV γ h e− e+
crossing symmetry with h→Zff
κf (=t) κV H+ H++ IDM 1 1 ○ × ITM (Y=1) 1 1 ○ ○ THDM sβ-α
sβ-α ○ ×
Kanemura, Mawatari, Sakurai [1808.10268, PRD]
*馬渡の口頭発表 (去年)
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23
16 Kanemura, Tsumura, Yagyu, Yokoya [1406.3294, PRD] Kanemura, Kikuchi, Mawatari, Sakurai, Yagyu [1906.10070]
LO NLO in EW+QCD
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23
17
excluded by unitarity
Mmin≠0 Mmin=0 0 < M 2 < m2
Φ
<latexit sha1_base64="4sDUxIzK/DrXyj2eLTlegZsIBWc=">ACcXichVHLSgMxFD0d3/XRqhvFTbEoglBuq6BIFwU3boS2WhXUlpkx2uC8mJkWtPgD/oCKwUR8TPc+AMu/ARxWcGNC2+nA6Ki3pDk5OSem5NEcwzp+URPEaWjs6u7p7cv2j8wOBSLD49seHbN1UVJtw3b3dJUTxjSEiVf+obYclyhmpohNrXD5db+Zl24nrStdf/IEbumemDJfamrPlNlyq6WM1mzspOvynKmEk9SioJI/ATpECQRt6O32AHe7ChowYTAhZ8xgZUeNy2kQbBYW4XDeZcRjLYFzhBlLU1zhKcoTJ7yOMBr7ZD1uJ1q6YXqHU+xeDusjKBKXqkW2rSA93RM73/WqsR1Gh5OeJZa2uFU4mdjq29/asyefZR/VT96dnHPhYDr5K9OwHTuoXe1tePz5prS8WpxjRd0Qv7v6QnucbWPVX/bogiheI8gekvz/3T7CRSaXnUpnCfDK3GH5FLyYwiRl+7wXksI8Snyui3Nc4irSVMaVhDLZTlUioWYUX0KZ/QDCMI5a</latexit>New physics effects of the EW corrections: m2
Φ ∼ λv2 + M 2
<latexit sha1_base64="aW1uq9YjCv9laGxzjmg/a7iD4uc=">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</latexit>m2
Φ ∼ M 2 :
m2
Φ ∼ λv2 :
<latexit sha1_base64="slWAGjbFME1/9Z2GlrHOTUonoU=">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</latexit>Decoupling Non-decoupling
h Φ Φ
∼ 𝜇𝑤
(Φ=H,A,H+)
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23
Precision of the Higgs branching ratios at future colliders
18 Higgs physics at the HL-LHC [1902.00134]
1σ 13% 6.7% 1.9% 1.4% 0.89% 27% (3.2% 2σ 26% 13.4% 3.8% 2.8% 1.78% 54% 6.4%
ILC250 [1710.07621] 2000 fb-1
A) BW W
NP
∼ BW W
SM
B) BW W
NP
> BW W
SM
C) BW W
NP
< BW W
SM
<latexit sha1_base64="9+N0+K/3be1kGSCfyZs7P1aM/q4=">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</latexit>Let’s consider 3 scenarios:
for Bcc)
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23
19
1.5 < tan β < 10 0 < M 2 < m2
Φ
300 < mΦ < 1000 GeV
<latexit sha1_base64="8IPlIvVgqIVGakK6J8Uz3del2iM=">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</latexit>600 < mΦ < 1000 GeV (dark)
<latexit sha1_base64="/OMJhcp2r4R0ClCjbiaXx0PYVXE=">ACiHichVHLSiNBFD1pZzTGUaNuBDfBoChIuB3Fy6Cs5hZxkeiYEvobktTpF90dwIx+AH6Ay5cKQwyuHA7s57N/IALP0FcKriZxdx0GoZR1FtU1alT9w6VWV4lgxCotuE0vXhY3dPsjfV96l/YDA9NFwO3LpvipLpWq6/beiBsKQjSqEMLbHt+UK3DUtsGbXP7f2thvAD6TqbYdMTu7Z+4Mh9aeohU5V0dnKeaMWuaMWqXFGJSJtpab6d+SLK2szUnu7Xpo84i3IUReYlUGOQRxFN30JDXtwYaIOGwIOQsYWdATcdqC4DG3ixZzPiMZ7QscIcXaOmcJztCZrfF4wKudmHV43a4ZRGqT7G4+6zMYIJu6Ds90G+6ojv682qtVlSj7aXJs9HRCq8yeDK68fSuyuY5RPWf6k3PIfaxGHmV7N2LmPYtzI6+cXj6sLG8PtGapAu6Z/ndEu/+AZO49H8tibWz5DiD1CfP/dLUM7n1Nlcfm0uW1iMvyKJMYxjit97AQV8RElPvcY1/iBn0pKIWVBWeqkKolYM4L/Qln9Czh0lJY=</latexit>A) BW W
NP
∼ BW W
SM
<latexit sha1_base64="l+R+X24gThO2ThF268T5bDkGU=">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</latexit>HSM, IDM
correlations depending
Yukawa int.
the direct searches/flavor constraints significantly reduce the allowed regions.
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23
20
1.5 < tan β < 10 0 < M 2 < m2
Φ
300 < mΦ < 1000 GeV
<latexit sha1_base64="8IPlIvVgqIVGakK6J8Uz3del2iM=">ACpnichVFNSxtRFD2ObdVoa6obwU1oMLgo4U5iqZQsFBe6aYkfSQRH05nxGR/OFzMvAQ35A/4BF65aKEH8Gd102Vb/AnFpUI3XhnMlBaXuHe/c8+657z3rMCRkSK6GtKGHzx8NDI6lhmfePxkMvt0qh757dAWNdt3/HDbMiPhSE/UlFSO2A5CYbqWIxrW0Uq83uiIMJK+t6WOA7Hrmi1PHkjbVEw1s8sFvfiYijTMyhzIpOhpEpUOX1XqniNo3qodwrxUyZKM25hMh43jVCN7cq6r1mNk9FSiJ3H+gpyCONqp/tw8A+fNhow4WAB8XYgYmIvx3oIATM7aLXMhIJusCPWRY2+YqwRUms0c8tjbSVmP87hnlKht3sXhP2RlDnP0hS7ohj7RJX2n3/t1U16xF6OebYGWhE0J09nNn/8V+XyrHD4S/VPzwoHWEy8SvYeJEx8Cnug75yc3Wy+2pjrFug9XbP/d3RFH/kEXufW/rAuNs6R4QfQ/7zu+6BeKurlYml9Ib+0mD7FKGbxDPN83y+xhDVUeN9+/iMr/imzWtvtJrWGJRqQ6lmGr+F9vYOxamedg=</latexit>600 < mΦ < 1000 GeV (dark)
<latexit sha1_base64="/OMJhcp2r4R0ClCjbiaXx0PYVXE=">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</latexit>B) BW W
NP
> BW W
SM
<latexit sha1_base64="rNLjOuMw3ne+Dja7kEksQuJCm8=">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</latexit>C) BW W
NP
< BW W
SM
<latexit sha1_base64="IEfaOrkuJim98NbL8VwBH7mHO+0=">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</latexit>Since the BRs are correlated among all the decay modes, each model predicts a particular pattern of the deviations for each scenario.
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23
21
The measurement of h→cc is very important to disentangle the models.
ILC is necessary!
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23
22
Synergy
Kentarou Mawatari (Osaka U.) PPP2019 - Kyoto - 2019.7.30 /23
couplings at one-loop EW+QCD in various extended Higgs models (singlet extension, THDMs, inert doublet model).
ratios at one-loop EW+QCD in various extended Higgs models (singlet extension, THDMs, inert doublet model).
23 Kanemura, Kikuchi, Mawatari, Sakurai, Yagyu [1803.01456, PLB] + [1906.10070] Kanemura, Kikuchi, Sakurai, Yagyu [1710.04603, CPC] e+e−→hγ; Kanemura, Mawatari, Sakurai [1808.10268, PRD]
H-COUP webpage: http://www-het.phys.sci.osaka-u.ac.jp/~kanemu/HCOUP_HP1013/HCOUP_HP .html
精密測定によるヒッグスセクターの究明が新物理探索の鍵!