From RDA Data Cita-on Recommenda-ons to new paradigms for ci-ng data from VAMDC C.M. Zwölf and VAMDC consor-um Heidelberg June 2016
Importance of cita-on in building new knowledge Gives credits to the author of the intellectual product cited Cita%on is a key element in the produc-on of new knowledge
Importance of cita-on in building new knowledge Gives credits to the author of the intellectual product cited Cita%on is a key Makes the processes described into the ci-ng ar-cle element in the reproducible produc-on of new knowledge
Importance of cita-on in building new knowledge Gives credits to the author of the intellectual product cited Cita%on is a key Makes the processes described into the ci-ng ar-cle element in the reproducible produc-on of new knowledge Enhance trust: the new results are based on proven/ solid bases. Each author does not need to prove again an used result
Importance of cita-on in building new knowledge Gives credits to the author of the intellectual product cited Cita%on is a key Makes the processes described into the ci-ng ar-cle element in the reproducible produc-on of new knowledge Enhance trust: the new results are based on proven/ solid bases. Each author does not need to prove again an used result The nowadays adopted cita-on model works well for papers. It cannot be easily transposed to cita-on of digital data…
Issues in data cita-on: case of the Atomic and Molecular data The evolu-on of digital data: Is very rapid • Is not systema-cally • reported
Issues in data cita-on: case of the Atomic and Molecular data A database may evolve over -me. The evolu-on of digital Piskunov et Al. Ryabchikova et Al. VALD (1995) (2015) data: Is very rapid • -me Is not systema-cally • Dubernet et Al. Dubernet et Al. Basecol (2006) (2013) reported
Issues in data cita-on: case of the Atomic and Molecular data A database may evolve over -me. The evolu-on of digital Piskunov et Al. Ryabchikova et Al. VALD (1995) (2015) data: Is very rapid • -me Is not systema-cally • Dubernet et Al. Dubernet et Al. Basecol (2006) (2013) reported It may happen that some evolu-ons (usually minor) of these databases are not systema-cally reported through new publica-ons
Issues in data cita-on: case of the Atomic and Molecular data A database may evolve over -me. The evolu-on of digital Piskunov et Al. Ryabchikova et Al. VALD (1995) (2015) data: Is very rapid • -me Is not systema-cally • Dubernet et Al. Dubernet et Al. Basecol (2006) (2013) reported It may happen that some evolu-ons (usually minor) of these databases are not systema-cally reported through new publica-ons A huge number of digital data are used nowadays in papers.
Issues in data cita-on: case of the Atomic and Molecular data A database may evolve over -me. The evolu-on of digital Piskunov et Al. Ryabchikova et Al. VALD (1995) (2015) data: Is very rapid • -me Is not systema-cally • Dubernet et Al. Dubernet et Al. Basecol (2006) (2013) reported It may happen that some evolu-ons (usually minor) of these databases are not systema-cally reported through new publica-ons The volume of digital data is wide and constantly growing. A huge number of digital A given surveys may use thousands of spectroscopic data coming from many experimental/theore-cal authors. data are used nowadays in papers.
Issues in data cita-on: case of the Atomic and Molecular data A database may evolve over -me. The evolu-on of digital Piskunov et Al. Ryabchikova et Al. VALD (1995) (2015) data: Is very rapid • -me Is not systema-cally • Dubernet et Al. Dubernet et Al. Basecol (2006) (2013) reported It may happen that some evolu-ons (usually minor) of these databases are not systema-cally reported through new publica-ons The volume of digital data is wide and constantly growing. A huge number of digital A given surveys may use thousands of spectroscopic data coming from many experimental/theore-cal authors. data are used nowadays in papers. It is impossible to effec-vely cite the origin of thousand of data with the required fine grained granularity.
Issues in data cita-on: case of the Atomic and Molecular data The evolu-on of digital data: Is very rapid • Is not systema-cally • reported Cita-on of data is incompa-ble with the hand- made classic cita-on mechanisms. A huge number of digital data are used nowadays in papers.
Issues in data cita-on: case of the Atomic and Molecular data The survey by [Ginard et al. (2012)] covers The evolu-on of digital frequencies from 83302Mhz to 262404Mhz data: detec-ng emission from about 36 species: Is very rapid • • They used catalogues from two public Is not systema-cally • databases [Picket et al. (1998)] and [Müller et reported al (2005)] and a private communica-on from Cita-on of data J. Cernicharo. is incompa-ble • There is no knowledge of the exact dataset with the hand- used à Their analysis is not reproducible . made classic cita-on • There is no cita-on of the authors who mechanisms. produced the spectroscopic data used in their analysis. A huge number of digital • The collisional data are properly cited. data are used nowadays • Dozen of papers for collisional data vs. in papers. hundreds of papers for spectroscopic data.
Issues in data cita-on: case of the Atomic and Molecular data The evolu-on of digital Track the data: versioning of Is very rapid • Is not systema-cally • data reported Cita-on of data is incompa-ble with the hand- made classic cita-on mechanisms. Having a mechanisms A huge number of digital to speed up data are used nowadays the cita-on in papers. process
Issues in data cita-on: case of the Atomic and Molecular data o Address these issues at the The evolu-on of digital VAMDC Track the data: federated level versioning of Is very rapid • (not database by Is not systema-cally • data database) reported Cita-on of data o Discuss these is incompa-ble issues at the with the hand- data-community made classic level: we joined cita-on (spring 2014) the mechanisms. RDA Data Having a Cita7on Working mechanisms Group . A huge number of digital to speed up data are used nowadays the cita-on VAMDC has become in papers. process one of the RDA use- cases.
Recommend
More recommend
