Drivers of Fish Occurrence in Arctic Lakes Arnab Shuvo, Derek Gray - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Drivers of Fish Occurrence in Arctic Lakes

Arnab Shuvo, Derek Gray and Sapna Sharma York University SCL – CCFFR 2019

Background Information

• Lakes along Dempster highway -

Inuvik, NWT

• Albedo effect
• Impacts of permafrost thaw

Lakes in Inuvik with and without fish

• Lakes with fish
• Depauperate fish communities
• Fish top predators
• Lakes without fish
• Benthic invertebrates - top predators
• Dense community of invertebrates

Research Questions

Are there differences in lake characteristics between lakes that have fish present or absent? What are the major environmental variables structuring the fish community?

Hypotheses

Lake characteristics would differ between lakes with and without fish. Mean depth would be the most important variable structing the fish community.

Study Site – 28 lakes sampled

Lakes sampled for fish occurrence

Ontario Broadscale Monitoring (BSM) protocol

• Gill nets were set for 16-22 hours
• Large gill nets caught fish > 20cm
• Small gill nets caught fish < 20cm

Phantom Midge (Chaoborus) – paleoindicator of fish populations

Lakes with fish

• Chaoborus extirpated

Lakes without fish

• Chaoborus larvae - top invertebrate

(e.g. Chaoborus americanus: non- migratory)

Note: Chaoborus mandibles well preserved in sediment - used to infer changes in past fish populations

Sweetman & Smol, 2006

Environmental Data Collection

Lake morphometry:

• Surface area, mean depth, and

max depth Water quality:

• Secchi depth, turbidity,

conductivity, dissolved oxygen, pH, water temperature, and chlorophyll.

Research questions

Are there differences in lake characteristics between lakes that have fish present or absent? What are the major environmental variables structuring the fish community?

Are there differences in characteristics between lakes that have fish present or absent?

T-test with a Bonferroni correction (P/A)

• Compares means for 2

samples

• Corrects for multiple

comparisons

No significant differences in lake conductivity

No significant differences in water clarity

No significant differences in lake size

There are similar environmental conditions in all sampled lakes – oligotrophic

• High water clarity and low

turbidity

• Conductivity
• Natural lakes : < 200 NTU
• Gravel pit lakes: ~ 1000 NTU
• Consistent water temperatures,

pH, and chlorophyll

Research questions

Are there differences in lake characteristics between lakes that have fish present or absent? What are the major environmental variables structuring the fish community?

Multivariate analysis tests the most significant environmental variable structuring fish communities

Redundancy analysis (RDA)

• Direct gradient multivariate

analysis

• Linear relationships between

response variables - explained by set of explanatory variables. Predictor variables: Environmental variables Response variables: Fish occurrence

Fish P/A RDA – suggests surface area is the significant environmental variable structuring fish occurrence in Inuvik, NWT lakes. Explains 11.3% of variation

Species-area relationship – as area increases, more species are present (possible - greater abundances)

Low variation suggests homogenization of fish community

• Homogenized fish

community

• Dominant species
• Generalists species

Heino & Mykra, 2008

Environmental Filtering - similar species are found in lakes with similar environmental conditions

Environmental Filtering

Prey-predator relationships - alters fish community structure

A B

Winterkill alters fish community composition by decreasing fish populations

• Macroinvertebrate populations

increase in the absence of fish

• Juvenile Pike shift diet to small

invertebrates

• Occupy macroinvertebrate-rich

habitats

• Recolonization formerly dominated

habitats

Conclusions

No difference in lake characteristics between lakes that have fish present or absent Surface area is the significant environmental variable structuring fish communities in Inuvik lakes

Future work

• Lake connectivity
• Fish migratory rates
• Trophic interactions

Acknowledgments

Sapna Sharma Derek Gray Matt Teillet Lori Waters Carly Tward Jasmina Vucic Rachel Cohen Lianna Lopez Alyssa Murdoch Yvette Langille