CAMx Sensitivity SA Runs G. Pirovano, P. Brotto, J. Ferreira, Y. - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

▶
camx sensitivity sa runs
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

CAMx Sensitivity SA Runs G. Pirovano, P. Brotto, J. Ferreira, Y. - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Nov 25, 2022 279 likes •632 views

Technical Meeting WG3 Source Apport Zagreb, Croatia 27-29 June 2016 CAMx Sensitivity SA Runs G. Pirovano, P. Brotto, J. Ferreira, Y. Long, C. Emery, G. Yarwood, F. Pradelle, S. Pillon, A. Dalla Fontana, A. Poupkou, N. Liora, D. Melas What was

slide-1
SLIDE 1

Technical Meeting

Zagreb, Croatia 27-29 June 2016

WG3 Source Apport

  • G. Pirovano, P. Brotto, J. Ferreira, Y. Long, C. Emery, G. Yarwood, F. Pradelle,
  • S. Pillon, A. Dalla Fontana, A. Poupkou, N. Liora, D. Melas

CAMx Sensitivity SA Runs

slide-2
SLIDE 2

2

What was done?

  • benchmark case (RSE)
  • KV scheme changed in WRFCAMx (from YSU to CMAQ) (ARPAV)
  • nested domain switched off (influence of resolution on SA results)

(UAVR)

  • evaluate Organic aerosol trough VBS instead of SOAP (RE)
  • 10 receptors
  • 9 mandatory categories/ 15 optional
  • SOA PSAT – turned off
  • Two 3 month periods - seasons
  • Sensitivity analysis
  • Summer (01/06 – 31/08/2011)
  • Winter (15/11/2011 – 15/02/2012)
slide-3
SLIDE 3

3

Which categories/species?

PM25 EC POA SOA NO3 SO4 NH4 OPA-25 PM10 OPA-10

Species

slide-4
SLIDE 4

4

01 - Electric Energy production 02- BIO - Domestic heating (b. burning) 03-04 - Industrial processes 07 - Transport (all) 08 – Shipping 10 – Agriculture 11 - Dust 99 - Other Anthrop + MS2 other + SSalt + BVOC 01 - Electric Energy production 02-BIO - Domestic heating (biomass burning) 03-04 - Industrial processes 07-RTR - Transport (others) 71-RTG - Transport (gasoline) 72-RTD - Transport (heavy duty) 75-RTW - Transport (mopeds) 08 – Shipping 10 – Agriculture 11-DST – Dust 11-SLT – Sea Salt 11-BSO – Biogenic VOC 99 - Other Anthrop 02-OTH - Domestic heating (other) Mandatory categories Optional categories ALL_BC - contribution of boundary conditions

Which categories/species?

slide-5
SLIDE 5

5

Global Results @ LENS

PARIS RUR_BKG2

slide-6
SLIDE 6

6

Results Totals @LENS

1 2 3 4 5 WIN SUM

NO3

ARPAV RSE UAVR

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 WIN SUM

EC

ARPAV RSE UAVR

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 WIN SUM

POA

ARPAV RSE UAVR

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 WIN SUM

SO4

ARPAV RSE UAVR

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 WIN SUM

NH4

ARPAV RSE UAVR

slide-7
SLIDE 7

7

Results Totals @LENS

1 2 3 4 5 6 WIN SUM

OPA-25

ARPAV RSE UAVR

2 4 6 8 10 12 WIN SUM

OPA-10

ARPAV RSE UAVR

0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 0.12 WIN SUM

SOA

ARPAV RSE UAVR

5 10 15 20 25 WIN SUM

PM10

ARPAV RSE UAVR

5 10 15 20 25 WIN SUM

PM2.5

ARPAV RSE UAVR

slide-8
SLIDE 8

8

Results Totals @PARIS

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 WIN SUM

EC

ARPAV RSE UAVR

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 WIN SUM

POA

ARPAV RSE UAVR

1 2 3 4 5 WIN SUM

NO3

ARPAV RSE UAVR

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 WIN SUM

SO4

ARPAV RSE UAVR

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 WIN SUM

NH4

ARPAV RSE UAVR

slide-9
SLIDE 9

9

Results Totals @PARIS

1 2 3 4 5 6 WIN SUM

OPA-25

ARPAV RSE UAVR

2 4 6 8 10 12 WIN SUM

OPA-10

ARPAV RSE UAVR

5 10 15 20 25 WIN SUM

PM10

ARPAV RSE UAVR

5 10 15 20 25 WIN SUM

PM2.5

ARPAV RSE UAVR

0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 0.12 WIN SUM

SOA

ARPAV RSE UAVR

slide-10
SLIDE 10

10

Results Totals @RUR_BKG2

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 WIN SUM

EC

ARPAV RSE UAVR

1 2 3 4 5 WIN SUM

NO3

ARPAV RSE UAVR

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 WIN SUM

SO4

ARPAV RSE UAVR

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 WIN SUM

NH4

ARPAV RSE UAVR

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 WIN SUM

POA

ARPAV RSE UAVR

slide-11
SLIDE 11

11

Results Totals @RUR_BKG2

1 2 3 4 5 6 WIN SUM

OPA-25

ARPAV RSE UAVR

2 4 6 8 10 12 WIN SUM

OPA-10

ARPAV RSE UAVR

0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.1 0.12 WIN SUM

SOA

ARPAV RSE UAVR

5 10 15 20 25 WIN SUM

PM2.5

ARPAV RSE UAVR

5 10 15 20 25 WIN SUM

PM10

ARPAV RSE UAVR

slide-12
SLIDE 12

12

Detailed Results @ LENS

slide-13
SLIDE 13

13

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman EC-25-ALLBC EC-25-99-OTH EC-25-11-DST EC-25-AGR EC-25-08-SHP EC-25-07-RTR EC-25-34-IND EC-25-02-BIO

Results

Summer Winter

EC

Man Opt

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt EC-25-ALLBC EC-25-99-OTH EC-25-11-BSO EC-25-11-SLT EC-25-11-DST EC-25-10-AGR EC-25-08-SHP EC-25-75-RTW EC-25-72-RTD EC-25-71-RTG EC-25-07-RTR EC-25-34-IND EC-25-02-BIO EC-25-02-OTH EC-25-01-ENI 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt EC-25-ALLBC EC-25-99-OTH EC-25-11-BSO EC-25-11-SLT EC-25-11-DST EC-25-10-AGR EC-25-08-SHP EC-25-75-RTW EC-25-72-RTD EC-25-71-RTG EC-25-07-RTR EC-25-34-IND EC-25-02-BIO EC-25-02-OTH EC-25-01-ENI

@LENS

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman EC-25-ALLBC EC-25-99-OTH EC-25-11-DST EC-25-AGR EC-25-08-SHP EC-25-07-RTR EC-25-34-IND EC-25-02-BIO

Similar contributions among runs but differences for different seasons

slide-14
SLIDE 14

14

Results

Summer Winter

EC

Opt

@LENS

RSEopt

EC-25-01-ENI EC-25-02-OTH EC-25-02-BIO EC-25-34-IND EC-25-07-RTR EC-25-71-RTG EC-25-72-RTD EC-25-75-RTW EC-25-08-SHP EC-25-10-AGR EC-25-11-DST EC-25-11-SLT EC-25-11-BSO EC-25-99-OTH EC-25-ALLBC

EC-25-01-ENI EC-25-02-OTH EC-25-02-BIO EC-25-34-IND EC-25-07-RTR EC-25-71-RTG EC-25-72-RTD EC-25-75-RTW EC-25-08-SHP EC-25-10-AGR EC-25-11-DST EC-25-11-SLT EC-25-11-BSO EC-25-99-OTH EC-25-ALLBC

UAVRopt ARPAVopt

NO3-25-01-ENI NO3-25-02-OTH NO3-25-02-BIO NO3-25-34-IND NO3-25-07-RTR NO3-25-71-RTG NO3-25-72-RTD NO3-25-75-RTW NO3-25-08-SHP NO3-25-10-AGR NO3-25-11-DST NO3-25-11-SLT NO3-25-11-BSO NO3-25-99-OTH NO3-25-ALLBC

RSEopt

NO3-25-01-ENI NO3-25-02-OTH NO3-25-02-BIO NO3-25-34-IND NO3-25-07-RTR NO3-25-71-RTG NO3-25-72-RTD NO3-25-75-RTW NO3-25-08-SHP NO3-25-10-AGR NO3-25-11-DST NO3-25-11-SLT NO3-25-11-BSO NO3-25-99-OTH NO3-25-ALLBC

UAVRopt

Different contributions from energy, small combustion, transport among runs

slide-15
SLIDE 15

15

Results

Summer Winter

POA

Man Opt

0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman POA-25-ALLBC POA-25-99-OTH POA-25-11-DST POA-25-10-AGR POA-25-08-SHP POA-25-07-RTR POA-25-34-IND POA-25-02-BIO POA-25-01-ENI 0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt POA-25-ALLBC POA-25-99-OTH POA-25-11-BSO POA-25-11-SLT POA-25-11-DST POA-25-10-AGR POA-25-08-SHP POA-25-75-RTW POA-25-72-RTD POA-25-71-RTG POA-25-07-RTR POA-25-34-IND POA-25-02-BIO POA-25-02-OTH POA-25-01-ENI 0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman POA-25-ALLBC POA-25-99-OTH POA-25-11-DST POA-25-10-AGR POA-25-08-SHP POA-25-07-RTR POA-25-34-IND POA-25-02-BIO POA-25-01-ENI 0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt POA-25-ALLBC POA-25-99-OTH POA-25-11-BSO POA-25-11-SLT POA-25-11-DST POA-25-10-AGR POA-25-08-SHP POA-25-75-RTW POA-25-72-RTD POA-25-71-RTG POA-25-07-RTR POA-25-34-IND POA-25-02-BIO POA-25-02-OTH POA-25-01-ENI

@LENS

Similar contributions among runs but differences for different seasons – biomass burning

slide-16
SLIDE 16

16

Results

Summer Winter

NO3

Man Opt

@LENS

0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt NO3-25-ALLBC NO3-25-99-OTH NO3-25-11-BSO NO3-25-11-SLT NO3-25-11-DST NO3-25-10-AGR NO3-25-08-SHP NO3-25-75-RTW NO3-25-72-RTD NO3-25-71-RTG NO3-25-07-RTR NO3-25-34-IND NO3-25-02-BIO NO3-25-02-OTH NO3-25-01-ENI 0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman NO3-25-ALLBC NO3-25-99-OTH NO3-25-11-DST NO3-25-10-AGR NO3-25-08-SHP NO3-25-07-RTR NO3-25-34-IND NO3-25-02-BIO NO3-25-01-ENI 0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman NO3-25-ALLBC NO3-25-99-OTH NO3-25-11-DST NO3-25-10-AGR NO3-25-08-SHP NO3-25-07-RTR NO3-25-34-IND NO3-25-02-BIO NO3-25-01-ENI 0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt NO3-25-ALLBC NO3-25-99-OTH NO3-25-11-BSO NO3-25-11-SLT NO3-25-11-DST NO3-25-10-AGR NO3-25-08-SHP NO3-25-75-RTW NO3-25-72-RTD NO3-25-71-RTG NO3-25-07-RTR NO3-25-34-IND NO3-25-02-BIO NO3-25-02-OTH NO3-25-01-ENI

Different contributions among runs and seasons

slide-17
SLIDE 17

17

Results

Summer Winter

NO3

Opt

@LENS

RSEopt

NO3-25-01-ENI NO3-25-02-OTH NO3-25-02-BIO NO3-25-34-IND NO3-25-07-RTR NO3-25-71-RTG NO3-25-72-RTD NO3-25-75-RTW NO3-25-08-SHP NO3-25-10-AGR NO3-25-11-DST NO3-25-11-SLT NO3-25-11-BSO NO3-25-99-OTH NO3-25-ALLBC

UAVRopt ARPAVopt

NO3-25-01-ENI NO3-25-02-OTH NO3-25-02-BIO NO3-25-34-IND NO3-25-07-RTR NO3-25-71-RTG NO3-25-72-RTD NO3-25-75-RTW NO3-25-08-SHP NO3-25-10-AGR NO3-25-11-DST NO3-25-11-SLT NO3-25-11-BSO NO3-25-99-OTH NO3-25-ALLBC

RSEopt

NO3-25-01-ENI NO3-25-02-OTH NO3-25-02-BIO NO3-25-34-IND NO3-25-07-RTR NO3-25-71-RTG NO3-25-72-RTD NO3-25-75-RTW NO3-25-08-SHP NO3-25-10-AGR NO3-25-11-DST NO3-25-11-SLT NO3-25-11-BSO NO3-25-99-OTH NO3-25-ALLBC

UAVRopt

Different contributions among runs and seasons from energy, transport sources, boundaries

slide-18
SLIDE 18

18

Results

Summer Winter

SO4

Man Opt

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt SO4-25-ALLBC SO4-25-99-OTH SO4-25-11-BSO SO4-25-11-SLT SO4-25-11-DST SO4-25-10-AGR SO4-25-08-SHP SO4-25-75-RTW SO4-25-72-RTD SO4-25-71-RTG SO4-25-07-RTR SO4-25-34-IND SO4-25-02-BIO SO4-25-02-OTH SO4-25-01-ENI 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman SO4-25-ALLBC SO4-25-99-OTH SO4-25-11-DST SO4-25-10-AGR SO4-25-08-SHP SO4-25-07-RTR SO4-25-34-IND SO4-25-02-BIO SO4-25-01-ENI 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman SO4-25-ALLBC SO4-25-99-OTH SO4-25-11-DST SO4-25-10-AGR SO4-25-08-SHP SO4-25-07-RTR SO4-25-34-IND SO4-25-02-BIO SO4-25-01-ENI 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt SO4-25-ALLBC SO4-25-99-OTH SO4-25-11-BSO SO4-25-11-SLT SO4-25-11-DST SO4-25-10-AGR SO4-25-08-SHP SO4-25-75-RTW SO4-25-72-RTD SO4-25-71-RTG SO4-25-07-RTR SO4-25-34-IND SO4-25-02-BIO SO4-25-02-OTH SO4-25-01-ENI

@LENS

slide-19
SLIDE 19

19

Results

Summer Winter

SO4

Opt

@LENS

RSEopt

SO4-25-01-ENI SO4-25-02-OTH SO4-25-02-BIO SO4-25-34-IND SO4-25-07-RTR SO4-25-71-RTG SO4-25-72-RTD SO4-25-75-RTW SO4-25-08-SHP SO4-25-10-AGR SO4-25-11-DST SO4-25-11-SLT SO4-25-11-BSO SO4-25-99-OTH SO4-25-ALLBC

SO4-25-01-ENI SO4-25-02-OTH SO4-25-02-BIO SO4-25-34-IND SO4-25-07-RTR SO4-25-71-RTG SO4-25-72-RTD SO4-25-75-RTW SO4-25-08-SHP SO4-25-10-AGR SO4-25-11-DST SO4-25-11-SLT SO4-25-11-BSO SO4-25-99-OTH SO4-25-ALLBC

ARPAVopt

SO4-25-01-ENI SO4-25-02-OTH SO4-25-02-BIO SO4-25-34-IND SO4-25-07-RTR SO4-25-71-RTG SO4-25-72-RTD SO4-25-75-RTW SO4-25-08-SHP SO4-25-10-AGR SO4-25-11-DST SO4-25-11-SLT SO4-25-11-BSO SO4-25-99-OTH SO4-25-ALLBC

RSEopt

SO4-25-01-ENI SO4-25-02-OTH SO4-25-02-BIO SO4-25-34-IND SO4-25-07-RTR SO4-25-71-RTG SO4-25-72-RTD SO4-25-75-RTW SO4-25-08-SHP SO4-25-10-AGR SO4-25-11-DST SO4-25-11-SLT SO4-25-11-BSO SO4-25-99-OTH SO4-25-ALLBC

UAVRopt UAVRopt

higher contribution

  • f boundaries

Different contribution of boundaries and industry

slide-20
SLIDE 20

20

Results

Summer Winter

NH4

Man Opt

0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt NH4-25-ALLBC NH4-25-99-OTH NH4-25-11-BSO NH4-25-11-SLT NH4-25-11-DST NH4-25-10-AGR NH4-25-08-SHP NH4-25-75-RTW NH4-25-72-RTD NH4-25-71-RTG NH4-25-07-RTR NH4-25-34-IND NH4-25-02-BIO NH4-25-02-OTH NH4-25-01-ENI 0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman NH4-25-ALLBC NH4-25-99-OTH NH4-25-11-DST NH4-25-10-AGR NH4-25-08-SHP NH4-25-07-RTR NH4-25-34-IND NH4-25-02-BIO NH4-25-01-ENI 0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman NH4-25-ALLBC NH4-25-99-OTH NH4-25-11-DST NH4-25-10-AGR NH4-25-08-SHP NH4-25-07-RTR NH4-25-34-IND NH4-25-02-BIO NH4-25-01-ENI 0.4 0.8 1.2 1.6 2 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt NH4-25-ALLBC NH4-25-99-OTH NH4-25-11-BSO NH4-25-11-SLT NH4-25-11-DST NH4-25-10-AGR NH4-25-08-SHP NH4-25-75-RTW NH4-25-72-RTD NH4-25-71-RTG NH4-25-07-RTR NH4-25-34-IND NH4-25-02-BIO NH4-25-02-OTH NH4-25-01-ENI

@LENS

slide-21
SLIDE 21

21

Results

Summer Winter

SOA

Man Opt

0.02 0.04 0.06 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman SOA-25-99-OTH 0.02 0.04 0.06 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt SOA-25-99-OTH SOA-25-11-BSO 0.02 0.04 0.06 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt SOA-25-99-OTH SOA-25-11-BSO 0.02 0.04 0.06 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman SOA-25-99-OTH

@LENS

Different contributions among runs

slide-22
SLIDE 22

22

Results

Summer Winter

OPA10

Man Opt

1 2 3 4 5 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman OPA-10-ALLBC OPA-10-99-OTH OPA-10-11-DST OPA-10-10-AGR OPA-10-08-SHP OPA-10-07-RTR OPA-10-34-IND OPA-10-02-BIO OPA-10-01-ENI 1 2 3 4 5 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt OPA-10-ALLBC OPA-10-99-OTH OPA-10-11-BSO OPA-10-11-SLT OPA-10-11-DST OPA-10-10-AGR OPA-10-08-SHP OPA-10-75-RTW OPA-10-72-RTD OPA-10-71-RTG OPA-10-07-RTR OPA-10-34-IND OPA-10-02-BIO OPA-10-02-OTH OPA-10-01-ENI 1 2 3 4 5 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman OPA-10-ALLBC OPA-10-99-OTH OPA-10-11-DST OPA-10-10-AGR OPA-10-08-SHP OPA-10-07-RTR OPA-10-34-IND OPA-10-02-BIO OPA-10-01-ENI 1 2 3 4 5 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt OPA-10-ALLBC OPA-10-99-OTH OPA-10-11-BSO OPA-10-11-SLT OPA-10-11-DST OPA-10-10-AGR OPA-10-08-SHP OPA-10-75-RTW OPA-10-72-RTD OPA-10-71-RTG OPA-10-07-RTR OPA-10-34-IND OPA-10-02-BIO OPA-10-02-OTH OPA-10-01-ENI

@LENS

higher contribution of boundaries

slide-23
SLIDE 23

23

Results

Summer Winter

OPA2.5

Man Opt

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt OPA-25-ALLBC OPA-25-99-OTH OPA-25-11-BSO OPA-25-11-SLT OPA-25-11-DST OPA-25-10-AGR OPA-25-08-SHP OPA-25-75-RTW OPA-25-72-RTD OPA-25-71-RTG OPA-25-07-RTR OPA-25-34-IND OPA-25-02-BIO OPA-25-02-OTH OPA-25-01-ENI 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman OPA-25-ALLBC OPA-25-99-OTH OPA-25-11-DST OPA-25-10-AGR OPA-25-08-SHP OPA-25-07-RTR OPA-25-34-IND OPA-25-02-BIO OPA-25-01-ENI

@LENS

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt OPA-25-ALLBC OPA-25-99-OTH OPA-25-11-BSO OPA-25-11-SLT OPA-25-11-DST OPA-25-10-AGR OPA-25-08-SHP OPA-25-75-RTW OPA-25-72-RTD OPA-25-71-RTG OPA-25-07-RTR OPA-25-34-IND OPA-25-02-BIO OPA-25-02-OTH OPA-25-01-ENI 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman OPA-25-ALLBC OPA-25-99-OTH OPA-25-11-DST OPA-25-10-AGR OPA-25-08-SHP OPA-25-07-RTR OPA-25-34-IND OPA-25-02-BIO OPA-25-01-ENI

Slightly higher contribution

  • f sea salt
slide-24
SLIDE 24

24

Results

Summer Winter

OPA2.5

Opt

@LENS

RSEopt

OPA-25-01-ENI OPA-25-02-OTH OPA-25-02-BIO OPA-25-34-IND OPA-25-07-RTR OPA-25-71-RTG OPA-25-72-RTD OPA-25-75-RTW OPA-25-08-SHP OPA-25-10-AGR OPA-25-11-DST OPA-25-11-SLT OPA-25-11-BSO OPA-25-99-OTH OPA-25-ALLBC

UAVRopt ARPAVopt

OPA-25-01-ENI OPA-25-02-OTH OPA-25-02-BIO OPA-25-34-IND OPA-25-07-RTR OPA-25-71-RTG OPA-25-72-RTD OPA-25-75-RTW OPA-25-08-SHP OPA-25-10-AGR OPA-25-11-DST OPA-25-11-SLT OPA-25-11-BSO OPA-25-99-OTH OPA-25-ALLBC

RSEopt

OPA-25-01-ENI OPA-25-02-OTH OPA-25-02-BIO OPA-25-34-IND OPA-25-07-RTR OPA-25-71-RTG OPA-25-72-RTD OPA-25-75-RTW OPA-25-08-SHP OPA-25-10-AGR OPA-25-11-DST OPA-25-11-SLT OPA-25-11-BSO OPA-25-99-OTH OPA-25-ALLBC

UAVRopt

OPA-25-01-ENI OPA-25-02-OTH OPA-25-02-BIO OPA-25-34-IND OPA-25-07-RTR OPA-25-71-RTG OPA-25-72-RTD OPA-25-75-RTW OPA-25-08-SHP OPA-25-10-AGR OPA-25-11-DST OPA-25-11-SLT OPA-25-11-BSO OPA-25-99-OTH OPA-25-ALLBC

Slightly higher contribution

  • f sea salt

Seosonal different contributions of biomass burning

slide-25
SLIDE 25

25

4 8 12 16 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt PM25-ALLBC PM25-99-OTH PM25-11-BSO PM25-11-SLT PM25-11-DST PM25-10-AGR PM25-08-SHP PM25-75-RTW PM25-72-RTD PM25-71-RTG PM25-07-RTR PM25-34-IND PM25-02-BIO PM25-02-OTH PM25-01-ENI 4 8 12 16 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman PM25-ALLBC PM25-99-OTH PM25-11-DST PM25-10-AGR PM25-08-SHP PM25-07-RTR PM25-34-IND PM25-02-BIO PM25-01-ENI

Results

Summer Winter

PM2.5

Man Opt

@LENS

4 8 12 16 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt PM25-ALLBC PM25-99-OTH PM25-11-BSO PM25-11-SLT PM25-11-DST PM25-10-AGR PM25-08-SHP PM25-75-RTW PM25-72-RTD PM25-71-RTG PM25-07-RTR PM25-34-IND PM25-02-BIO PM25-02-OTH PM25-01-ENI 4 8 12 16 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman PM25-ALLBC PM25-99-OTH PM25-11-DST PM25-10-AGR PM25-08-SHP PM25-07-RTR PM25-34-IND PM25-02-BIO PM25-01-ENI

slide-26
SLIDE 26

26

Results

Summer Winter

PM10

Man Opt

4 8 12 16 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman PM10-ALLBC PM10-99-OTH PM10-11-DST PM10-10-AGR PM10-08-SHP PM10-07-RTR PM10-34-IND PM10-02-BIO PM10-01-ENI 4 8 12 16 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt PM10-ALLBC PM10-99-OTH PM10-11-BSO PM10-11-SLT PM10-11-DST PM10-10-AGR PM10-08-SHP PM10-75-RTW PM10-72-RTD PM10-71-RTG PM10-07-RTR PM10-34-IND PM10-02-BIO PM10-02-OTH PM10-01-ENI 4 8 12 16 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman PM10-ALLBC PM10-99-OTH PM10-11-DST PM10-10-AGR PM10-08-SHP PM10-07-RTR PM10-34-IND PM10-02-BIO PM10-01-ENI 4 8 12 16 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt PM10-ALLBC PM10-99-OTH PM10-11-BSO PM10-11-SLT PM10-11-DST PM10-10-AGR PM10-08-SHP PM10-75-RTW PM10-72-RTD PM10-71-RTG PM10-07-RTR PM10-34-IND PM10-02-BIO PM10-02-OTH PM10-01-ENI

@LENS

slide-27
SLIDE 27

27

Detailed Results @ PARIS

slide-28
SLIDE 28

28

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman EC-25-ALLBC EC-25-99-OTH EC-25-11-DST EC-25-AGR EC-25-08-SHP EC-25-07-RTR EC-25-34-IND EC-25-02-BIO 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman EC-25-ALLBC EC-25-99-OTH EC-25-11-DST EC-25-AGR EC-25-08-SHP EC-25-07-RTR EC-25-34-IND EC-25-02-BIO

Results

Summer Winter

EC

Man Opt

@PARIS

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt EC-25-ALLBC EC-25-99-OTH EC-25-11-BSO EC-25-11-SLT EC-25-11-DST EC-25-10-AGR EC-25-08-SHP EC-25-75-RTW EC-25-72-RTD EC-25-71-RTG EC-25-07-RTR EC-25-34-IND EC-25-02-BIO EC-25-02-OTH EC-25-01-ENI 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt EC-25-ALLBC EC-25-99-OTH EC-25-11-BSO EC-25-11-SLT EC-25-11-DST EC-25-10-AGR EC-25-08-SHP EC-25-75-RTW EC-25-72-RTD EC-25-71-RTG EC-25-07-RTR EC-25-34-IND EC-25-02-BIO EC-25-02-OTH EC-25-01-ENI

slide-29
SLIDE 29

29

Results

Summer Winter

EC

Opt

@PARIS

EC-25-01-ENI EC-25-02-OTH EC-25-02-BIO EC-25-34-IND EC-25-07-RTR EC-25-71-RTG EC-25-72-RTD EC-25-75-RTW EC-25-08-SHP EC-25-10-AGR EC-25-11-DST EC-25-11-SLT EC-25-11-BSO EC-25-99-OTH EC-25-ALLBC

RSEopt

EC-25-01-ENI EC-25-02-OTH EC-25-02-BIO EC-25-34-IND EC-25-07-RTR EC-25-71-RTG EC-25-72-RTD EC-25-75-RTW EC-25-08-SHP EC-25-10-AGR EC-25-11-DST EC-25-11-SLT EC-25-11-BSO EC-25-99-OTH EC-25-ALLBC

UAVRopt ARPAVopt

EC-25-01-ENI EC-25-02-OTH EC-25-02-BIO EC-25-34-IND EC-25-07-RTR EC-25-71-RTG EC-25-72-RTD EC-25-75-RTW EC-25-08-SHP EC-25-10-AGR EC-25-11-DST EC-25-11-SLT EC-25-11-BSO EC-25-99-OTH EC-25-ALLBC

RSEopt

EC-25-01-ENI EC-25-02-OTH EC-25-02-BIO EC-25-34-IND EC-25-07-RTR EC-25-71-RTG EC-25-72-RTD EC-25-75-RTW EC-25-08-SHP EC-25-10-AGR EC-25-11-DST EC-25-11-SLT EC-25-11-BSO EC-25-99-OTH EC-25-ALLBC

UAVRopt

Different contribution from heavy duty vehicles Seosonal different contributions of biomass burning

slide-30
SLIDE 30

30

Results

Summer Winter

POA

Man Opt

@PARIS

0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman POA-25-ALLBC POA-25-99-OTH POA-25-11-DST POA-25-10-AGR POA-25-08-SHP POA-25-07-RTR POA-25-34-IND POA-25-02-BIO POA-25-01-ENI 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt POA-25-ALLBC POA-25-99-OTH POA-25-11-BSO POA-25-11-SLT POA-25-11-DST POA-25-10-AGR POA-25-08-SHP POA-25-75-RTW POA-25-72-RTD POA-25-71-RTG POA-25-07-RTR POA-25-34-IND POA-25-02-BIO POA-25-02-OTH POA-25-01-ENI 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt POA-25-ALLBC POA-25-99-OTH POA-25-11-BSO POA-25-11-SLT POA-25-11-DST POA-25-10-AGR POA-25-08-SHP POA-25-75-RTW POA-25-72-RTD POA-25-71-RTG POA-25-07-RTR POA-25-34-IND POA-25-02-BIO POA-25-02-OTH POA-25-01-ENI 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman POA-25-ALLBC POA-25-99-OTH POA-25-11-DST POA-25-10-AGR POA-25-08-SHP POA-25-07-RTR POA-25-34-IND POA-25-02-BIO POA-25-01-ENI

slide-31
SLIDE 31

31

Results

Summer Winter

POA

Opt

@PARIS

ARPAVopt

POA-25-01-ENI POA-25-02-OTH POA-25-02-BIO POA-25-34-IND POA-25-07-RTR POA-25-71-RTG POA-25-72-RTD POA-25-75-RTW POA-25-08-SHP POA-25-10-AGR POA-25-11-DST POA-25-11-SLT POA-25-11-BSO POA-25-99-OTH POA-25-ALLBC

RSEopt

POA-25-01-ENI POA-25-02-OTH POA-25-02-BIO POA-25-34-IND POA-25-07-RTR POA-25-71-RTG POA-25-72-RTD POA-25-75-RTW POA-25-08-SHP POA-25-10-AGR POA-25-11-DST POA-25-11-SLT POA-25-11-BSO POA-25-99-OTH POA-25-ALLBC

UAVRopt

Different contribution from biomass burning among runs

RSEopt UAVRopt

POA-25-01-ENI POA-25-02-OTH POA-25-02-BIO POA-25-34-IND POA-25-07-RTR POA-25-71-RTG POA-25-72-RTD POA-25-75-RTW POA-25-08-SHP POA-25-10-AGR POA-25-11-DST POA-25-11-SLT POA-25-11-BSO POA-25-99-OTH POA-25-ALLBC

Seosonal different contributions of biomass burning

slide-32
SLIDE 32

32

Results

Summer Winter

OPA10

Man Opt

@PARIS

2 4 6 8 10 12 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman OPA-10-ALLBC OPA-10-99-OTH OPA-10-11-DST OPA-10-10-AGR OPA-10-08-SHP OPA-10-07-RTR OPA-10-34-IND OPA-10-02-BIO OPA-10-01-ENI 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt POA-25-ALLBC POA-25-99-OTH POA-25-11-BSO POA-25-11-SLT POA-25-11-DST POA-25-10-AGR POA-25-08-SHP POA-25-75-RTW POA-25-72-RTD POA-25-71-RTG POA-25-07-RTR POA-25-34-IND POA-25-02-BIO POA-25-02-OTH POA-25-01-ENI 2 4 6 8 10 12 ARPAVman RSEman UAVRman OPA-10-ALLBC OPA-10-99-OTH OPA-10-11-DST OPA-10-10-AGR OPA-10-08-SHP OPA-10-07-RTR OPA-10-34-IND OPA-10-02-BIO OPA-10-01-ENI 2 4 6 8 10 12 ARPAVopt RSEopt UAVRopt OPA-10-ALLBC OPA-10-99-OTH OPA-10-11-BSO OPA-10-11-SLT OPA-10-11-DST OPA-10-10-AGR OPA-10-08-SHP OPA-10-75-RTW OPA-10-72-RTD OPA-10-71-RTG OPA-10-07-RTR OPA-10-34-IND OPA-10-02-BIO OPA-10-02-OTH OPA-10-01-ENI

slide-33
SLIDE 33

33

Results

Summer Winter

OPA10

Opt

@PARIS

RSEopt

OPA-10-01-ENI OPA-10-02-OTH OPA-10-02-BIO OPA-10-34-IND OPA-10-07-RTR OPA-10-71-RTG OPA-10-72-RTD OPA-10-75-RTW OPA-10-08-SHP OPA-10-10-AGR OPA-10-11-DST OPA-10-11-SLT OPA-10-11-BSO OPA-10-99-OTH OPA-10-ALLBC

UAVRopt

OPA-10-01-ENI OPA-10-02-OTH OPA-10-02-BIO OPA-10-34-IND OPA-10-07-RTR OPA-10-71-RTG OPA-10-72-RTD OPA-10-75-RTW OPA-10-08-SHP OPA-10-10-AGR OPA-10-11-DST OPA-10-11-SLT OPA-10-11-BSO OPA-10-99-OTH OPA-10-ALLBC

ARPAVopt

OPA-10-01-ENI OPA-10-02-OTH OPA-10-02-BIO OPA-10-34-IND OPA-10-07-RTR OPA-10-71-RTG OPA-10-72-RTD OPA-10-75-RTW OPA-10-08-SHP OPA-10-10-AGR OPA-10-11-DST OPA-10-11-SLT OPA-10-11-BSO OPA-10-99-OTH OPA-10-ALLBC

RSEopt

OPA-10-01-ENI OPA-10-02-OTH OPA-10-02-BIO OPA-10-34-IND OPA-10-07-RTR OPA-10-71-RTG OPA-10-72-RTD OPA-10-75-RTW OPA-10-08-SHP OPA-10-10-AGR OPA-10-11-DST OPA-10-11-SLT OPA-10-11-BSO OPA-10-99-OTH OPA-10-ALLBC

UAVRopt

Seosonal different contributions of biomass burning, industry, sea salt

slide-34
SLIDE 34

34

Thank you!

Questions? Comments? Suggestions?