Bloor West Village Avenue Study
Design Charrette Phase 2: Explore Ideas Saturday, April 08, 2017 DTAH | RE Millward Associates | WSP/MMM Group Swerhun | Taylor Hazell Architects | JC Williams Group
Bloor West Village Avenue Study Design Charrette Phase 2: Explore - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Bloor West Village Avenue Study Design Charrette Phase 2: Explore Ideas Saturday, April 08, 2017 DTAH | RE Millward Associates | WSP/MMM Group Swerhun | Taylor Hazell Architects | JC Williams Group Charrette Agenda No. Item Duration 1.0
Bloor West Village Avenue Study
Design Charrette Phase 2: Explore Ideas Saturday, April 08, 2017 DTAH | RE Millward Associates | WSP/MMM Group Swerhun | Taylor Hazell Architects | JC Williams Group
Charrette Agenda
No. Item Duration 1.0 Welcome and Introductions 10 minutes (9:30am - 9:40am) 2.0 Introductory Presentation 20 minutes (9:40am - 10:00am) 3.0 Planning and Design Exercises 2.25 hours (10:00am - 12:15pm) Lunch / Break 45 minutes (12:15pm - 1:00pm) 4.0 Synthesis Exercise 1 hour (1:00pm- 2:00pm) 5.0 Reporting Back 45 minutes (2:00pm - 2:45pm) 6.0 Wrap-Up and Next Steps 15 minutes (2:45pm - 3:00pm)
2
Study Schedule
BACKGROUND OPPORTUNTIES + CONSTRAINTS
Jan- March 2017
01 02
FUTURE CONDITIONS + DESIGN ALTERNATIVES
April - June 2017
03
SYNTHESIS + FINAL AVENUE STUDY REPORT
July - Oct 2017
Understand Context and Existing Conditions Property Owners Meeting #1 Feb 8, 2017 Community Stakeholder Meeting Feb 9, 2017 Public Meeting #1 Feb 27, 2017 Design Review Panel #1 March 23, 2017 Councillor Briefing #1 (Feb 6, 2017) City Project Team Meeting (CPMT #2) (Feb 2, 2017) CPMT #3 (April, 2017) Evaluate and Test Design Alternatives Local Advisory Committee Meeting (LAC) #1 CPMT #4 (May 2017) Identify Preferred Alternative Design Charrette (April 8, 2017) Councillor Briefing #2 (May 2017) LAC #2 (May 2017) Public Meeting #2 (June 2017)
We Are Here
Design Review Panel #2 (August 2017) Avenue Study Draft CPMT #3 (April 2017) Avenue Study Final Councillor Briefing #3 (Sept 2017) LAC #3 (Sept 2017) Public Meeting #3 (Sept 2017) Community Council Presentation (Oct 17, 2016)
3
What is an Avenue?
Defined by City of Toronto Official Plan
major transit routes defined as “Avenues”
intensification is intended to create new jobs and housing while improving local streetscapes, infrastructure and amenities
Green Space System Downtown and Central Waterfront Avenues Employment Districts Centres4
What is an Avenue Study?
No “One Size Fits All” Program
tailored to each Avenue
Plan developed with local residents, businesses, and
Dufferin Street Avenue Study (2014) Bloor-Dundas ‘Avenue’ Study (2009)
8
1 2 4
tj tj tj tj tj tj tj tj tj tj tj tj tj tj tj tj tj ffi tj tj tj tj es and approved developments tj3 5 6 7 8
5
Why this Avenue Study?
(eg: Heritage Conservation District Study)
(High Park Area, Jane Area, corner sites, etc.)
projects is increasing
framework to guide change
Council and Staff as a priority for an Avenue Study
Two significant natural features (High Park + the Humber River) New development by High Park Village character 6
How is this Avenue Study different?
established and vibrant main street
Area in the world - 1970
features: High Park and the Humber River
connecting bus lines: » Old Mill » Jane » Runnymede » High Park » Keele
7
Study Area
Keele Street
Bloor Street West » both sides of street » High Park address
Runnymede, High Park, & Keele)
recommendations for) adjacent Neighbourhoods, Apartment Neighbourhoods, Parks, Open Spaces, and Natural Systems
Quebec Avenue High Park Avenue Clendenan Avenue Glendonwynne Road Runnymede Road Jane Street Armadale Avenue Willard Avenue Windermere Avenue Durie Street Keele Street Harcroft Rd. Durie Street Old Mill Drive Bloor Street West Humber River K e n n e d y P a r k R d High Park S Kingsway8
Draft Character Areas
High Park Frontage East Village Village Main Street West Village Humber Gateway
Bloor Street West
Quebec Avenue High Park Avenue Clendenan Avenue Glendonwynne Road Runnymede Road Jane Street Armadale Avenue Willard Avenue Windermere Avenue Durie Street Keele Street H a r c rHumber River
Kennedy Park RdHigh Park
S Kingswaybuilt form, heritage and public realm
Avenue Study recommendations
9
What We’ve Heard So Far
balancing growth with the area’s village feel » Redevelopment Potential » Future of Independent Retailers
» Cumulative impact of future development of High Park (especially hydrogeology)
scope/infmuence » Demonstrate the infmuence the Avenue Study will have » Define the role of heritage in the Avenue Study/upcoming HCD Study
» Anchor tenant desired (another grocery store) » Parking supply and demand » Excellent pedestrian environment
Intensification » Built Form » Public Realm Quality » Transportation » Site Access » Servicing » Community Services » Natural Heritage » Subsurface Hydrogeology
10
Bloor West Village Avenue Study / Phase 2 Charrette
Existing Conditions Summary
North Side: Today
narrow, mixed-use row buildings
consistent streetwall
12
South Side: Today
detached apartments, service stations, and other larger structures
frontages, and lot sizes contrast with the north side of Bloor West
13
apartment buildings and larger homes
High Park: Bloor Frontage
14
1913 1960s to 2015
High Park: Apartment Neighbourhood
15
Current Zoning
residential buildings opposite High Park and adjacent to the Humber
former municipal zoning by-laws).
Quebec A High Park A Glendenan A Glendowyne Road Runnymede Jane Str Armadale A Willard A Windermer Durie Str Harcroft Rd. Durie Street O l d M i l l D r i v e Bloor Street West High Park Humber Kennedy Park RdR Zone “Residential” CR Zone “Commercial Residential” R Zone “Residential”
Detached, Townhouse, Duplex, Triplex, Fourplex, Apartments
Townhouse, Duplex, Triplex, Fourplex, Apartments
16
Development Activity
Approved Rezonings and Applications Under Review
Quebec Avenue High Park Avenue Clendenan Avenue Glendonwynne Road Runnymede Road Jane Street Armadale Avenue Willard Avenue Windermere Avenue Durie Street Keele Street Harcroft Rd. Durie Street Old Mill Drive Bloor Street West Humber River Kennedy Park Rd High Park S K i n g s w a y One and Two Old Mill (2490 -2500 Bloor Street West) 2452 Bloor Street West 2265 Bloor Street West 2115-2117 Bloor Street West 2114-2130 Bloor Street West 12 High Park High Park Residences The High Park 1990 Bloor Street WestThe High Park (1990 Bloor West) One and Two Old Mill (2490 & 2500 Bloor West) High Park Residences 17
Existing Properties
Street West
medium (<7m-20m) and wide lots (<20m)
area 7m or less. Majority on north side between Jane and Kennedy
Main Street properties
considered shallow lots (22-41m depth)
Wide lots (>20m) Narrow lots (7m or less) Medium (>7m-20m)
18
Existing Building Types
Main Street Mixed Use Heritage Townhouses Mixed Use Commercial Office Mid-Rise Apartments House Forms Taller Buildings Low-Rise Apartments 19
Building Height_Existing
throughout (1-4 storeys)
in area just northwest of High Park (5-8 storeys)
Jane and across from High Park (+8 storeys)
taller (approx. +8 storey) mid-rise (approx. 5-8 storey) low rise (approx. 1-4 storey)
Quebec Avenue High Park Avenue Clendenan Avenue Glendonwynne Road Runnymede Road Jane Street Armadale Avenue Willard Avenue Windermere Avenue Durie Street Keele Street Harcroft Rd. Durie Street Old Mill Drive Kennedy Park Rd S K i n g s w a y Humber River High Park Bloor Street West20
Building Height_ Current Maximum (Zoning)
Bloor Street West Quebec Avenue High Park Avenue Clendenan Avenue Glendonwynne Road Runnymede Road Jane Street Armadale Avenue Willard Avenue Windermere Avenue Durie Street Keele Street Harcroft Rd. Durie Street Old Mill Drive Humber River Kennedy Park Rd High Park S K i n g s w a y14.0m 23.0m 9.0m 14.0m
that defines height (i.e, recent approved developments)
21
Building Height_Midrise Building Performance Standards_2016
» Bloor West: Max Building Height 80% of Right-of-Way » High Park: Max Building Height 100% of Right-of-Way
» Humber to Riverside: Neighbourhoods (low rise) » Riverside to Jane: 30m ROW=30.0m (8-10 storeys) » Jane to Armadale: 30m ROW at 80%=24.0m (6-8 storeys) » Armadale to Clendenan: 27m ROW at 80%=21.6m (5-7 storeys) » Clendenan to Keele: 27.0m ROW=27.0m (7-9 storeys)
Bloor Street West Quebec Avenue High Park Avenue Clendenan Avenue Glendonwynne Road Runnymede Road Jane Street Armadale Avenue Willard Avenue Windermere Avenue Durie Street Keele Street Harcroft Rd. Durie Street Old Mill Drive Humber River Kennedy Park Rd High Park S K i n g s w a y21.6m 27.0m 30.0m24.0m Neighbourhoods
22
Views + Vistas
Bloor Street West Quebec Avenue High Park Avenue Clendenan Avenue Glendonwynne Road Runnymede Road Jane Street Armadale Avenue Willard Avenue Windermere Avenue Durie Street Keele Street Harcroft Rd. Durie Street Old Mill Drive Humber River K e n n e d y P a r k R d High Park S Kingsway* * *
* * * *
*
* * * * ** * * * ** * *
Offset street grid / Views of Natural Heritage Areas and Heritage Resources Heritage Buildings Topography 23
Parks, Open Spaces, and Natural Features
City’s largest, most prominent and environmentally significant green spaces - Humber River Valley and High Park
Bloor Street West
between two areas with differing levels of parkland provision
24
Bloor West Village Avenue Study / Phase 2 Charrette
Built Form Exercises
Built Form Exercises: 3 x 30 minutes
26
Built Form Exercises: Study Segments
Quebec Avenue High Park Avenue Clendenan Avenue Glendonwynne Road Runnymede Road Kennedy Avenue Beresford Avenue Jane Street Armadale Avenue Willard Avenue Windermere Avenue Durie Street Keele Street Harcroft Rd. Durie Street Old Mill Drive Bloor Street West Humber River K e n n e d y P a r k R d High Park S Kingsway Riverview GardensVillage and West Village Village and East Village High Park Frontage
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
Sample Questions: Built Form Exercises
rise buildings along the Bloor West Village properties. What works? What needs to be changed?
work and not work?
transition to adjacent areas?
the street differ? How are they the same?
to enhance placemaking and the quality of the public realm?
35
Bloor West Village Avenue Study / Phase 2 Charrette
Street Design Exercise
Street Design Exercise: 30 minutes
37
High Park Frontage
38
Avenue / Main Street (26m ROW)
39
Avenue / Main Street (30m ROW)
40
Existing Streetscape Character
» Armadale to Humber: 30m » Keele to Armadale: 26m (OP 27m)
varies along the length
experiences on north and south side of street
Bloor Street West
Retail, commercial 2-3 storey Retail, commercial NORTH BLOOR STREET WEST (26m ROW) SOUTH 26m Right-of-Way Setback Varies Setback Varies Boulevard 4.5-6m Boulevard 4.5-6m Layby Roadway 14-16.5m BLOOR STREET WEST (30m ROW) NORTH SOUTH 30m Right-of-Way Setback Varies Setback Varies Boulevard 5-7m Boulevard 5-7m Roadway 16-20m Retail, commercial41
Sidewalks
Furnishing and Planting Zone Pedestrian Clearway Zone Frontage and Marketing Zone Setback <1.2m 2.1min 1-2m Varies
42
Current State
Flanking Streets: underutilized Street Trees Bump outs Multiple entrances and canopies Flanking Streets: Spill out spaces Clutter 43
THEN Auto-Mobility Automobile Safety NOW Multi-modal Mobility + Access Public Health/Safety Economic Development Environmental Quality Livability/Quality of Life Equity
Outside In Centre Line Out
Street Design Goals Have Changed
Source: Toronto Complete Streets Guidelines (2017: Draft) 44
8.1
ROADWAY DESIGN PRINCIPLES
Aspiration : A More Complete Street
45
Aspiration : A More Complete Street
Toronto Complete Streets Guidelines Toronto Complete Streets Guidelines 75 74 4.1 Street Design for Pedestrians Sidewalk Design Principles Street Design for Pedestrians Sidewalk Design Principles 4.1PEDESTRIAN DESIGN PRINCIPLES
4.1
46
Green Infrastructure Opportunities
Toronto Complete Streets Guidelines Toronto Complete Streets Guidelines 111 110 Street Design for Green Infrastructure Green Infrastructure Design Principles Street Design for Green Infrastructure Green Infrastructure Design Principles 7.1 7.1GREEN INFRASTRUCTURE DESIGN PRINCIPLES
7.1
47
Sample Questions: Street Design Exercise
you think are most important to support the kind of place Bloor West Village is today and in the future?
arrangements of elements to best support overall transportation needs and placemaking?
enhance the quality of the public realm?
are possible on the side streets that intersect with Bloor West?
48
Charrette Agenda
No. Item Duration 1.0 Welcome and Introductions 10 minutes (9:30am - 9:40am) 2.0 Introductory Presentation 20 minutes (9:40am - 10:00am) 3.0 Planning and Design Exercises 2.25 hours (10:00am - 12:15pm) Dinner Break 45 minutes (12:15pm - 1:00pm) 4.0 Synthesis Exercise 1 hour (1:00pm- 2:00pm) 5.0 Reporting Back 45 minutes (2:00pm - 2:45pm) 6.0 Wrap-Up and Next Steps 15 minutes (2:45pm - 3:00pm)
Bloor West Village Avenue Study / Phase 2 Charrette
Synthesis Exercise
Entire Study Area » Built Form » Street Design » Placemaking
taker for reporting back
Synthesis Exercise: 60 minutes
51
Charrette Agenda
No. Item Duration 1.0 Welcome and Introductions 10 minutes (9:30am - 9:40am) 2.0 Introductory Presentation 20 minutes (9:40am - 10:00am) 3.0 Planning and Design Exercises 2.25 hours (10:00am - 12:15pm) Dinner Break 45 minutes (12:15pm - 1:00pm) 4.0 Synthesis Exercise 1 hour (1:00pm- 2:00pm) 5.0 Reporting Back 45 minutes (2:00pm - 2:45pm) 6.0 Wrap-Up and Next Steps 15 minutes (2:45pm - 3:00pm)
Next Steps
Informed by Charrette and other input recieved to date
Friday April 21
Draft Design Alternatives Monday April 24
Draft Preferred Design Alternative Late May (TBD)
Draft Preferred Design Alternative Mid-late June (TBD)
53
Further Information and Contacts
Greg Byrne Senior Planner 416-394-8238 Greg.Byrne@toronto.ca Allison Reid Senior Urban Designer 416-392-1295 Allison.Reid@toronto.ca Councillor Sarah Doucette 416-392-4072 councillor_doucette@toronto.ca www.toronto.ca/bwv-avenuestudy
54