SLIDE 1
How to read “Difficult Texts” A difficult text, by definition, is one that permits, stands up to, even insists upon interpretive works. Students cannot learn to do interpretive work in a curriculum devoid of difficult texts. …read like a detective and write like an investigative reporter. -David Coleman There are no uninteresting things in the world, only uninterested people. ~Lord Chesterton Anything becomes interesting if you look at it long enough. ~ Gustave Flaubert Active Reading summarized/adapted from John Bean, Engaging Ideas, Chapter. 8 Roots of poor student reading skills
- Assuming that reading should be speed reading, not laborious and slow
Experts read slowly and reread often They write “gist” statements in the margins as they read They question the text as they read They link the text with other readings and/or personal experience
- Failing to adjust reading strategies for different texts and circumstances
Experts use skimming, close scrutiny, application
- Failing to perceive an argument’s structure as they read
Experts “chunk” the complex material into parts with describable functions
- Difficulty in assimilating or accepting the unfamiliar
The deep harbors the strange and sometimes terrifying
- Difficulty seeing the rhetorical/cultural context in which a text exists
Appreciate political biases, varying levels of scholarship, author as real person…
- Difficulty in seeing themselves engaged in the text’s (the author's) broader conversation
Carry on a silent conversation as both skeptic and believer
- Failing to know the allusions and cultural references of a text
Knowledge of cultural codes is often essential to making meaning of the text
- Possessing an inadequate vocabulary, and resistance to looking up words
How does the context affect word meanings Develop an "ear" for irony and/or humor
- Difficulty in understanding difficult and unfamiliar syntax (sentence structure)
Isolate main clauses in complex sentence structure
- Failing to see how discourse varies from discipline to discipline