Alpine Cultural Heritage Protection: approaches and techniques - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Alpine Cultural Heritage Protection: approaches and techniques

CHEERS project: Insights on WP T3 Partner Meeting

Innsbruck, 12th-14th November 2019 Christian Iasio, Carola Mirgon (BRGM) Philippe Meresse, Ronan de Saint German (Entente Valabre) Franck Bourier, Philomene Favier (IRSTEA)

Expectations and Needs

1.What are the key expectations of the WP3?

WP T3 aims

• “Nature” of the potential damage to the exposed assets in relation

to different hazards

• Asset susceptibility, protection and salvaging techniques
• National and transnational governance of cultural heritage

protection: roles, responsibilities and funding sources

• Case histories, lessons learned and knowledge transfer

WP workload and products

• WP deliverables:

– D.T. 3.1.1 Case collection of threats and potential damages on cultural assets – D.T. 3.2.1 Portfolio and application guidelines of cultural heritage protection reference techniques – D.T. 3.3.1 Essential elements of the policy framework for cultural heritage protection in the Alps – D.T. 3.4.1 Format for Education & Training on the protection of cultural assets from natural hazards

A.T. 3.1 A.T. 3.2 A.T. 3.3 A.T. 3.4

Reference methodology source-book + ref. docs. Recommendations for innovative policy making and implementation Dedicated educational format

• Document type:

WP T3 general overview

• database review of threats and impacts
• Database review of the state of the art of

good practices applied at Alpine level to secure tangible cultural heritages

• education courses for Civil Protection

Operators on the multi-level governance scheme

• education and training courses for Civil

Protection Operators on good practices and reference protocols for rescuing cultural heritages

• formation of cultural heritage rescuing teams
• handbook on good practices and reference protocols (record

forms) relevant for cultural heritage protection and conservation

• guidelines on how to structure Civil Protection teams, both in

terms of technical (tools and techniques) and human resources, to oversee early rescuing activities of cultural heritages in case of natural event

• guidelines on how to orient multi-level governance schemes

towards more effective approaches in cultural heritages protection and conservation

• digital platform intended to host and make accessible the

databases of threats and good practices ?

• format (and content) of education and training course to Civil

Protection Operators

Activities Products

Expectations and Needs

1.What are the key expectations of the WP3? 2.What is the specific input/contributions/needs that the WP3 depends upon from other WPs?

Task 3.1 as deduction from to WP1 and WP2

Screening and survey of threats and potential damages to cultural assets exposed to natural hazards, including transnational case studies analysis

• Inventory of threats and potential

damages due to natural hazards impacts on cultural assets

D.T. 3.1.1 Preliminary stucture and PPs contributions

• 1. Information research

1.1. databases 1.2. sources of global informations 1.3. resources of associative origin 1.4. other sources 1.5. summary

• 2. Methodology for the description of disasters affecting cultural assets

2.1. General considerations and description of the forms 2.2. Form of the disaster 2.2. Form of the territorial administration 2.3. Form of the building or the curtural site 2.4. Form of the asset 2.5. References and communication

• 3. Emblematic events (by country)

3.1 France 3.1.1. Earthquake 30 November 1951, 06:08 AM 3.1.X. ….

Contributions from the different countries Contributions from the different countries Remarks and feedbacks from the partners, stakeholders and observers

Task 3.2 as follow up of Task 1.2

Reference protection techniques for safeguarding tangible cultural heritage at risk

• Portfolio and application guidelines
• f protection reference techniques,

based on an up-to-date domain knowledge and the analysis of innovative technology strongly

• riented to operativity and

comprehensiveness

• D.T. 3.2.1 Format and content

– Matrix « materials/techniques » – Matrix « mitigation actions/context »

Material Value alteration Critical weight Critical velocity Alteration type Restauration technique Notes Stones Céramic Glass Wood Textiles Documents Painting Metals Material Value alteration Critical time exposure Height Alteration type Restauration technique Notes Stones Céramic Glass Wood Textiles Documents Painting Metals Material Value alteration Critical time exposure Water quality Alteration type Restauration technique Notes Stones Céramic Glass Wood Textiles Documents Material Value alteration Critical time exposure Heat (degree °) Alteration type Restauration technique Notes Stones Céramic Glass Wood Heat Water Gravity (Fall) Energy (Impact)

• D.T. 3.2.1 Format and content

– Matrix « materials/techniques »

Task 3.2 as follow up of Task 1.2

Proxy data, if availables

• 1. Regulatory framework

a) General remarks b) Classification of cultural heritage c) Protection of CH collections d) Protection of documents e) Protection of monumental sites f) Protections of archeological sites g) Protection of « Patrimoine modeste » (vernaculaire) h) Summary (table) and conclusions sur la sauvegarde

• 2. Best practices [IF ANY!] *_*

a) Emergency plan of site i. Document description ii. Implementation example(s) b) Emergency plan of municipality and supra communal authorities i. Document(s) description ii. Operational compatibility among authorities iii. Implementation example(s)

• 3. Needs and recommendations (cfr. Table 3.3.1 Annex)

Task 3.3 as extent of D.T.1.1.1 chapter

Survey on governance framework regulating the matter of cultural heritage management & protection

• Collection of essential

elements and examples of the policy framework for cultural heritage protection in the Alps

• Compilation of

recommendation into dedicated policy briefs targeted to specific governance levels

D.T. 3.3.1 Preliminary stucture (by country)

• Decree of September 13, 2005 for the “Organisation de

la réponse de sécurité civile”, article 8 (France)

• Act for the establishment of the natural risk prevention

plans (PPRN), of the 22 July 1987 (France)

• Loi Bachelot”, act n° 2003-699 – article 42 (France)
• PRASSI DI RIFERIMENTO UNI/PdR 47.1:2018 : Civil

Protection - Technical-organisational guidelines for a local Civil Protection system (Italy)

• …
• Ord. X
• Ord. Y

Gap

Prevention ACC Preparedness Anticipation Warning Rescue Recovery

Components of regulations

• 3. Needs and recommandations (Table 3.3.1 Annex)

Risk management measures, needs & recommendations Annex

Task 3.3 as extent of D.T.1.1.1 chapter

Task 3.4 as overall experience capitalization

Education & Training format on the Cultural Heritage and Risk management cycle

– Local education & training activities, which will contextually set up specialized rescue teams composed by cultural heritage managers, public

• fficers and civil protection operators

– Collection of experience and lessons learnt into an original educational format

Main challenges and pressing points

1.Please outline the main challenges/pressing issues you recognise so far.

WP T3 deadlines

• Timeline and deadlines ( ): request for procrastination

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 A.T3.1 A.T3.2 A.T3.3 A.T3.4 2019 2020 WP T3

WP T3

Risk management phases of interest

Main challenges and pressing points (All WPs)

1.Please outline the main challenges/pressing issues you recognise so far. 2.What specific interventions/information/inputs could address this challenge/es?

D.T. 3.2.1 structure criteria

• Protection techniques portfolio

18

• __________
• __________
• ________
• ________

Prevention ACC

Preparednes s Anticipation

Warning Rescue Relief

Source Run-out Deposition

passive mitigation Target site Active mitigation

Main challenges and pressing points (All WPs)

• 1. Please outline the main challenges/pressing issues

you recognise so far.

• 2. What specific interventions/information/inputs

could address this challenge/es?

• 3. Please specify two-three particularly

relevant/pressing points to be addressed/answered during the upcoming partner meeting.

State of the art about the technologies

• Protection tools portfolio
• Master BOX
• Comm Hot Spot
• Rugged on field tablet
• Stereo camera small format
• Mirrorless Camera Full Format
• Multispectral Camera
• Fly System Hand On Size
• Slam based Hand Size LIDAR
• Watcher Signal Target
• Hand On Self Learning Procedural Manual
• Multiligual Tutorial

4-6 December, Rome

Watchers RS

20

• __________
• __________
• ________
• ________

Prevention ACC

Preparednes s Anticipation

Warning Rescue Relief

Other points

Common information classification

21

• __________
• __________
• ________
• ________

Prevention ACC

Preparednes s Anticipation

Warning Rescue Relief

• Regulations and laws

expertise

• Glossary

Suggestions are welcome! Thanks