SLIDE 1 Pennsylvania State University
- Dept. of Architectural Engineering
Spring 2003 Structural Option Eric Sobel
2941 Fairview Park
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
SLIDE 2
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
SLIDE 3 PROJECT TEAM
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
2941 Fairview L.L.P.
The David Orr Company
- Contractor: Clark Construction
- Architect:
Boggs & Partners
Cagley & Associates
Allen & Shariff
PCC Consultants
SLIDE 4 BUILDING
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- $38 Million
- 361,101 gross sq. ft
- 15 rentable stories
- Mechanical Penthouse
- Basement
- Offices
- Atrium
- Café
- Restaurant
SLIDE 5
- VAV System
- Chilled Water
- 65 Ton AC Units
- Electric Heating Coils
- Series fan VAV Units
SYSTEMS
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- Circuit Breaker Panelboards
- K-4 Rated Transformers
- Electrical:
- Mechanical:
SLIDE 6 CURTAIN WALL
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- METAL PANEL
- PRECAST CONCRETE
- E-W:
- N-S:
SLIDE 7
PLAN
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
TYPICAL TOWER FLOOR PLAN
SLIDE 8
- Composite A992 Steel
- 5 ¼” LW Conc. On Metal Deck
- N-S: 2 Braced Frames
- E-W: 5 Braced Frames & 5 Moment Frames
- Typical Spread Foundations
- Buried Mat Foundation
EXISTING STRUCTURE
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- Gravity System:
- Lateral System:
- Foundations:
SLIDE 9
PLAN
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
FOURTH FLOOR PLAN
SLIDE 10
REDESIGN
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- Increase Serviceability
- Decrease Initial Cost
- Decrease Construction Time
- Minimal Architectural Change
- Advantages:
- Quality Control
- Durability
- Material Strength
- Architectural Finish
- Quicker Erection
- Disadvantages:
- Increased Weight
- Transportation
SLIDE 11 OUTLINE
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- Building Core
- Gravity System
- Building Envelope
- 4D CAD
- Schedule
- Estimate
- Members:
- Construction:
SLIDE 12
PLAN
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
TYPICAL TOWER FLOOR PLAN
SLIDE 13
- 8” Hollowcore Planks
- Lightweight Concrete
- 6 straight ½” tendons
- f’c = 5,000 psi
HOLLOWCORE PLANKS
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
SLIDE 14
- 20” x 30” Inverted Tees
- Normal Weight Concrete
- 4” x 10” Ledges
- Straight Tendons
- f’c = 8,000 psi
INVERTED TEES
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
SLIDE 15 COLUMNS
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- 20” x 20”
- 4 floor pieces
- f’c ranging from 5,000-12,000 psi
- Upper Floors: Lightweight
- Corbels
- Precast:
SLIDE 16 SPANDREL
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- Composition
- 3” Concrete
- (2) 1 ½” Insulation
- Metal Facing
- Reduced Members
- Bearing Connection
- Construction
SLIDE 17 WINDOWS
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- Installation
- Inside
- Simple
- Waussau Window System
SLIDE 18
FOUNDATIONS
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- Adequate Strength
- Cost Effective
- Rigid Support for Shearwalls
- Pinned Support for Columns
SLIDE 19
CONNECTIONS
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- Define Structural Response
- Influences Construction Schedule
- High Repetition
- Relieve Induced Stresses
- Easy Erection
- Simple Formwork
SLIDE 20 BEAM - COLUMN
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- Goals:
- Description:
- Analysis:
- Diaphragm Action
- Induced Stresses
- Quick Erection
- Columns Stability
- Mastecord Bearing Pads
- Supporting Angle
- PCI Design Guide
- PCHELP
SLIDE 21
- Goals:
- Description:
- Analysis:
PRECAST - SITECAST
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- Transfer Gravity & Lateral Forces
- Simple Formwork
- JVI-Inc. BSF 200/40
- “The Invisible Corbel”
- Box cast in beam
- “Knife” cast in column
- Weld Plate
- JVI Design Aids
SLIDE 22
CONSTRUCTION
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
DAY 1
SLIDE 23
CONSTRUCTION
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
DAY 1 DAY 2
SLIDE 24
DAY 1 DAY 2 DAY 3
CONSTRUCTION
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
SLIDE 25
DAY 1 DAY 2 DAY 3 DAY 4
CONSTRUCTION
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
SLIDE 26
CONSTRUCTION
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
DAY 1 DAY 2 DAY 3 DAY 4 DAY 5
SLIDE 27
CONSTRUCTION
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
SLIDE 28
SCHEDULE
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel PRECAST COMPOSITE STEEL
SLIDE 29
$5.95 million
$6.07 million
ESTIMATE
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
Steel Precast
Site Cast Flooring Columns Foundations
$ Million
SLIDE 30
650 Additional sq. ft.
CONCLUSIONS
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
Varies
Similar
4 Weeks Quicker
30% Stiffer
10 dB STL & INR
SLIDE 31
Thanks to:
THANKS
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel Joe Ajello, PE Jimmy Lakey, PE All others at Cagley & Associates Mark Tayor Mike Patton Clement Enyeji Prof’s: Parffit, Geschwindner, Boothby, & Burnette All other AE Faculty AE Class of 2003 Karen My Family
SLIDE 32 Questions?
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- Members
- Connections
- Construction
- Trades Affected
SLIDE 33
- East-West:
- North-South:
- General:
SHEARWALLS
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- (4) 22’-8” Shearwall
- 24” Thick
- (2) Shearwall / Moment Frame Lines
- 20” Thick
- Deep Beams
- Locations matched existing braced frame locations
- Loadbearing => R=4.0
SLIDE 34
- Location:
- Goals:
- Description:
MOMENT FRAME
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- Along grid Line H
- Lower Portion
- Increase stiffness to region
- Free up Space
- Site cast
- Spans parallel to plank
SLIDE 35 EXPANSION JOINT
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- Goals:
- Description:
- Transfer gravity loads
- Transfer E-W lateral loads
- Separate N-S lateral loads
- Slotted Connector
- Teflon bearing pad
SLIDE 36 GROUTED KEYS
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- Goals:
- Description:
- Member Connectivity
- Diaphragm Action
- Grouted Keys
SLIDE 37
- Goals:
- Description:
- Analysis:
PLANK – INVERTED TEE
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- Diaphragm Action
- Induced Stresses
- Quick Erection
- Mastecord Bearing Pads
- Supporting Angle
- PCI Design Guide
SLIDE 38
- Goals:
- Description:
- Analysis:
DAPPED BEAM
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- Transfer Gravity & Lateral Forces
- Simple Connection
- Mastecord Bearing Pad
- PCI Design Method
- PCHELP
SLIDE 39
DAPPED BEAM
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
SLIDE 40 Goals: Description: Analysis:
COLUMN SPLICE
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- Aesthetically pleasing
- Transfer only axial and shear loads
- Simple erection
- Bolted connection
- Grouted
- Splice occurs just above floor level
- PCI design aids
SLIDE 41
- Architectural Atrium
- Entrance Plaza
- ME/TC rooms per floor
- Tenant Build-Out
- Superb Landscaping
FEATURES
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
SLIDE 42
SCHEDULE
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
- 20 columns / day
- 20 beams / day
- 40 planks / day
- Core: 1 level / week
- Windows: 1 level / week
- 2 weeks ahead
- 2 weeks behind
SLIDE 43
DETAIL
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
BUILDING END DETAIL
SLIDE 44
CRANES
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
SLIDE 45
TRANSPORTATION
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
SLIDE 46
TRADES AFFECTED
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel
SLIDE 47
TRADES AFFECTED
2941 Fairview Park Eric Sobel