1 2 We lc o me to L K F N T e rrito ry 3 De hc ho F irst - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

▶
1
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

1 2 We lc o me to L K F N T e rrito ry 3 De hc ho F irst - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Sep 09, 2023 325 likes •988 views

1 2 We lc o me to L K F N T e rrito ry 3 De hc ho F irst Na tio ns T e rrito ry From Deh Cho Atlas Version 2.b, July 2003 http://www.dehcholands.org/atlas/atlas_files/Pdfs/Deh%20Cho%20Atlas%20Version%202b.pdf 4 Pro po se d Pro je c t

slide-1
SLIDE 1

1

slide-2
SLIDE 2

We lc o me to L K F N T e rrito ry

2

slide-3
SLIDE 3

De hc ho F irst Na tio ns T e rrito ry

3

From Deh Cho Atlas Version 2.b, July 2003

http://www.dehcholands.org/atlas/atlas_files/Pdfs/Deh%20Cho%20Atlas%20Version%202b.pdf

slide-4
SLIDE 4

Pro po se d Pro je c t Are a

4

Map produced by the National Energy Board, July 2017

https://www.neb-one.gc.ca/pplctnflng/mjrpp/ln21rplcmnt/mg/mp-lg-eng.pdf

slide-5
SLIDE 5

Łíídlįį Kų́ę́ F

irst Na tio n

L K F N is a De ne Na tio n

Ma jo rity o f me mb e rs live in F

  • rt Simpso n

F

  • rt Simpso n a nd the surro unding a re a is

a t the he a rt o f L K F N te rrito ry E nb ridg e ’ s L ine

21 Re pla c e me nt Pro je c t is in the he a rt o f L K F N te rrito ry “We a re De ne , a nd this is o ur la nd.”

5

slide-6
SLIDE 6

L K F N L a nd a nd Rig hts

 L

K F N ha s ne ve r c e de d o r surre nde re d its la nd to the Cro wn o r Ca na da

 I

n 1921 Ca na da e nte re d into T re a ty 11 with L K F N

 T

re a ty 11 wa s no t a surre nde r o r c e ssio n o f la nd

6

slide-7
SLIDE 7

L K F N L a nd a nd Rig hts

 L

K F N ha ve a prima fac ie c la im to De ne title o ve r the ir la nd (Paule tte )

 L

K F N ha s a n inhe re nt rig ht to se lf- g o ve rnme nt a nd se lf-de te rmina tio n

 L

K F N ha s no t se ttle d a ny la nd c la im o r se lf-g o ve rnme nt a g re e me nts with Ca na da

7

slide-8
SLIDE 8

L K F N L a nd a nd Rig hts

 L

K F N ha ve a rig ht to pa rtic ipa te in de c isio n-ma king o n ma tte rs tha t impa c t its la nd, a c c o rding to its o wn pro c e dure s a nd institutio ns (UNDRI P)

 Ca na da ha s a n o b lig a tio n to o b ta in the

fre e , prio r, a nd info rme d c o nse nt o f L K F N

be for e a ppro ving the L

ine 21 Re pla c e me nt Pro je c t (UNDRI P)

8

slide-9
SLIDE 9

L K F N a nd L ine 21

 L

ine 21 wa s b uilt in 1985 witho ut L K F N’ s c o nse nt

 L

K F N wa s no t c o nsulte d o r a c c o mmo da te d

 L

ine 21 c o ntinue s to impa c t L K F N la nd a nd rig hts

 L

K F N ha s no t c o nse nte d to the pro po se d pro je c t, no r ha s L K F N b e e n pro pe rly e ng a g e d o r c o nsulte d

9

slide-10
SLIDE 10

Pro c e ss Co nc e rns

L K F N ha s b e e n o n the re c o rd in this

he a ring :

E ng a g ing in disc ussio ns with E nb ridg e

Ca lling fo r a ro b ust o ve ra ll e nviro nme nta l

re vie w o f the impa c t o f re o pe ning this a g ing pipe line Ra ising c o nc e rns a b o ut the pro c e dura l

fa irne ss o f the pa ra lle l NE B a nd MVL WB pro c e sse s

10

slide-11
SLIDE 11

11

slide-12
SLIDE 12

A Sna psho t

 T

his da ta ha s b e e n g a the re d o ve r de c a de s o f wo rk with L K F N la nd use rs

 Da ta is no t c o mpre he nsive o r c o mple te ly

inc lusive o f a ll L K F N kno wle dg e , la nd use ,

  • r o c c upa nc y

 T

his info rma tio n is spe c ific to the pro po se d pro je c t

12

slide-13
SLIDE 13

L

  • c a l Study Are a (L

SA)

 L

  • c a l Study Are a inc lude s,

 1.5 km b uffe r a ro und a ll pro je c t

c o mpo ne nts

 8 km do wnstre a m o n the Ma c ke nzie  1 km upstre a m o n the Ma c ke nzie  500 m b uffe r o n the b a nks o f the Ma c ke nzie

13

slide-14
SLIDE 14

Re g io na l Study Are a (RSA)

 Re g io na l Study Are a inc lude s,

 T

he e ntire L SA

 20 km a ro und the e xte nd o f a ll pro je c t

c o mpo ne nts

14

slide-15
SLIDE 15

Ove rvie w o f Re sults

1287

to ta l site s ma ppe d in the RSA 626

to ta l site s ma ppe d within the L SA Ma ppe d site s re la te to ,

Wildlife ha b ita t a nd ha rve sting

Pla nts a nd re ne wa b le re so urc e s

Drinking wa te r so urc e s

He rita g e a nd c ultura l site s

E tc .

15

slide-16
SLIDE 16

T ra ditio na l E c o lo g ic a l K no wle dg e

16

Map Redacted

slide-17
SLIDE 17

T ra ditio na l E c o lo g ic a l K no wle dg e

17

Map Redacted

slide-18
SLIDE 18

T ra ditio na l E c o lo g ic a l K no wle dg e Da ta

115

T E K ma ppe d fe a ture s in the RSA, 57 within the L SA Ma ppe d fe a ture s within the L SA inc lude :

F ish ha b ita t, mig ra tio n ro ute s a nd spa wning

a re a s (4) L a nd ma mma l ha b ita t a nd mig ra tio n ro ute s

(8) Bird ha b ita t a nd mig ra tio n ro ute s (

17) I mpo rta nt Pla nt ha b ita t a re a s (

8)

18

slide-19
SLIDE 19

 Ma ppe d fe a ture s within the L

SA inc lude :

 Spe c ie s a t risk ha b ita t a nd mig ra tio n ro ute s

(12)

 Sa lt lic ks (1)  Na tura l drinking wa te r so urc e s (5 site s)  Cha ng e s to the la nd a nd e nviro nme nt (2)

re le vant fo r c umulative impac ts asse ssme nt

T ra ditio na l E c o lo g ic a l K no wle dg e Da ta

19

slide-20
SLIDE 20

T ra ditio na l E c o lo g ic a l K no wle dg e Da ta : Sa mple Pro je c t I nte ra c tio ns

 F

ish spa wning a nd mig ra tio n a re a s do wnstre a m o f pipe line c ro ssing lo c a tio ns

 Mo o se c a lving a nd mig ra tio n ha b ita ts a dja c e nt to

ROW within the L SA

 Duc k a nd c ra ne mig ra tio n ro ute s a c ro ss the

c o nflue nc e o f Ma c ke nzie a nd L ia rd Rive rs, a s we ll a s ne sting a re a s no rthwe st o f No rth Wo rk Site

 Co nc e ntra tio ns o f impo rta nt pla nt ha b ita t to the

no rth a nd e a st o f So uth Ca mp

 12 Spe c ie s a t Risk Ha b ita t a re a s (c o nc e ntra te d in

the vic inity o f the So uth Ca mp

20

slide-21
SLIDE 21

Cultura l Site s

21

Map Redacted

slide-22
SLIDE 22

Cultura l Site s

22

Map Redacted

slide-23
SLIDE 23

Cultura l Site s

80

c ultura l site s ma ppe d within in the RSA, 30 the L SA Ma ppe d fe a ture s within the L SA inc lude :

Histo ric a l se ttle me nts o r g a the ring pla c e s

(3) Co nte mpo ra ry g a the ring a re a s (

2) Buria l site s (

14) Spiritua l o r sa c re d site s (

2 site s)

23

slide-24
SLIDE 24

Cultura l site s (c o nt’ d)

 Ma ppe d fe a ture s within the L

SA inc lude :

 T

ra ditio na l pla c e na me s (5)

 De a th site s (3)  Othe r c ultura l lo c a tio ns (1)

24

slide-25
SLIDE 25

T ra ditio na l E c o lo g ic a l K no wle dg e Da ta : Sa mple Pro je c t I nte ra c tio ns

F ish spa wning a nd mig ra tio n

a re a s do wnstre a m o f pipe line c ro ssing lo c a tio ns Mo o se c a lving a nd mig ra tio n ha b ita ts a dja c e nt to

ROW within the L SA Duc k a nd c ra ne mig ra tio n ro ute s a c ro ss the

c o nflue nc e o f Ma c ke nzie a nd L ia rd Rive rs, a s we ll a s ne sting a re a s no rthwe st o f No rth Wo rk Site Co nc e ntra tio ns o f impo rta nt pla nt ha b ita t to the

no rth a nd e a st o f So uth Ca mp 12

Spe c ie s a t Risk Ha b ita t a re a s (c o nc e ntra te d in the vic inity o f the So uth Ca mp

25

slide-26
SLIDE 26

Cultura l site s: Sa mple Pro je c t I nte ra c tio ns

L

  • c a tio ns o f Histo ric a l se ttle me nts o ve rla p

with the No rth Wo rksite Co nte mpo ra ry g a the ring pla c e s within

1km o f the No rth Wo rksite Co nc e ntra tio ns o f b uria l site s in the vic inity

  • f No rth a nd So uth Wo rksite s

Spiritua l o r Sa c re d Site s: o ne just we st o f

the So uth Wo rksite , o ne just no rthwe st o f the No rth Wo rksite

More detailed information on Project Interactions can be found in LKFN’s Indigenous Knowledge and Land Use Study for the Line 21 Segment Replacement Project 26

slide-27
SLIDE 27

Sub siste nc e L a nd a nd Re so urc e Use

27

Map Redacted

slide-28
SLIDE 28

Sub siste nc e L a nd a nd Re so urc e Use

28

Map Redacted

slide-29
SLIDE 29

 610 ma ppe d fe a ture s in the RSA, 250

within the L SA

 Ma ppe d fe a ture s within the L

SA inc lude :

 Ma mma l a nd Sma ll Ga me Ha rve sting (86)  Bird Ha rve sting (51)  T

ra pping (no n-c o mme rc ial) (2)

 F

ishing (78)

 Pla nt a nd Na tura l Ma te ria l Ga the ring (33)

Sub siste nc e L a nd a nd Re so urc e Use (L SA)

29

slide-30
SLIDE 30

Sub siste nc e L a nd a nd Re so urc e Use (L SA, c o nt)

F ishing site s in the

L SA

78

site s I nc lude s ne t, line , a nd fish tra p

I nc lude s winte r fishing lo c a tio ns

Pla nt a nd Na tura l Ma te ria l Ga the ring

33

site s within the L SA

30

slide-31
SLIDE 31

Sub siste nc e L a nd a nd Re so urc e Use : Sa mple Pro je c t I nte ra c tio ns

Co nc e ntra tio ns b ird hunting site s in the

vic inity o f the So uth Ca mp a nd the No rth Wo rksite a nd within a nd a lo ng the sho re line s o f the Ma c ke nzie Rive r Sna re line pe rpe ndic ula r to pipe line ROW,

so uth o f the So uth Wo rk Site

More detailed information on Project Interactions can be found in LKFN’s Indigenous Knowledge and Land Use Study for the Line 21 Segment Replacement Project 31

slide-32
SLIDE 32

Sub siste nc e L a nd a nd Re so urc e Use : Sa mple Pro je c t I nte ra c tio ns

 F

ishing upstre a m, do wnstre a m a nd dire c tly a dja c e nt to the HDD c ro ssing

 F

ishing in the vic inity o f No rth Wo rk Site , So uth Ca mp a nd pipe line ROW

 F

ishing a lo ng the b a nk o f the L ia rd Rive r, a dja c e nt to the So uth L a ydo wn a nd Sto ra g e Are a s

 Pla nt a nd na tura l ma te ria l g a the ring a dja c e nt to

No rth Wo rk Site a nd So uth Ca mp a nd a lo ng no rth a nd so uth sho re line s o f the Ma c ke nzie Rive r, inc luding the g a the ring o f pla nts use d fo r fo o d a nd me dic ina l purpo se s

More detailed information on Project Interactions can be found in LKFN’s Indigenous Knowledge and Land Use Study for the Line 21 Segment Replacement Project 32

slide-33
SLIDE 33

Co mme rc ia l L a nd a nd Re so urc e Use

33

Map Redacted

slide-34
SLIDE 34

Co mme rc ia l L a nd a nd Re so urc e Use

34

Map Redacted

slide-35
SLIDE 35

Co mme rc ia l L a nd a nd Re so urc e Use

 95 ma ppe d fe a ture s in the RSA, 73 within

the L SA

 Ma ppe d fe a ture s within the L

SA inc lude :

 Co mme rc ia l tra pline da ta po ints (73)

35

slide-36
SLIDE 36

Co mme rc ia l L a nd a nd Re so urc e Use : Sa mple Pro je c t I nte ra c tio ns

 Nume ro us tra pline s inte rse c t with a nd run

thro ug ho ut the L SA

 Co nc e ntra tio ns o f tra pline s o n the no rth

sho re line o f the Ma c ke nzie Rive r a nd in c lo se pro ximity to the So uth Ca mp

More detailed information on Project Interactions can be found in LKFN’s Indigenous Knowledge and Land Use Study for the Line 21 Segment Replacement Project 36

slide-37
SLIDE 37

Oc c upa nc y a nd Ac c e ss Are a s

37

Map Redacted

slide-38
SLIDE 38

Oc c upa nc y a nd Ac c e ss Are a s

38

Map Redacted

slide-39
SLIDE 39

Oc c upa nc y a nd Ac c e ss Are a s

 387 ma ppe d fe a ture s in the RSA, 216

within the L SA

 Ma ppe d fe a ture s within the L

SA inc lude :

 De mo g ra phic site s (6)  Ove rnig ht L

  • c a tio ns (23)

 Ac c e ss a re a s a nd ro ute s (187)

39

slide-40
SLIDE 40

Oc c upa nc y a nd Ac c e ss Are a s: Sa mple Pro je c t I nte ra c tio ns

 Co nc e ntra tio ns o f o c c upa nc y site s in the

vic inity o f the No rth Wo rk Site , So uth L a ydo wn a nd Sto ra g e a nd Ac c e ss Pullo ut # 2

 Co nc e ntra tio ns o f de mo g ra phic site s

no rthwe st o f No rth a nd So uth Wo rksite s

More detailed information on Project Interactions can be found in LKFN’s Indigenous Knowledge and Land Use Study for the Line 21 Segment Replacement Project 40

slide-41
SLIDE 41

Oc c upa nc y a nd Ac c e ss Are a s: Sa mple Pro je c t I nte ra c tio ns

 Ove rnig ht lo c a tio ns within the vic inity o f the

No rth Wo rksite a nd a lo ng the no rth sho re o f the Ma c ke nzie Rive r

 Ove rnig ht lo c a tio ns ne a r So uth L

a ydo wn a nd Sto ra g e Are a s

 187 a c c e ss a re a s a nd ro ute s thro ug ho ut the

L SA: inc luding nume ro us ro ute s a lo ng the L ia rd a nd Ma c ke nzie Rive rs a nd ro ute s tha t inte rc e pt dire c tly with pro je c t c o mpo ne nts

More detailed information on Project Interactions can be found in LKFN’s Indigenous Knowledge and Land Use Study for the Line 21 Segment Replacement Project 41

slide-42
SLIDE 42

42

slide-43
SLIDE 43

HDD a nd F ra c Out

 F

ra c o ut – drilling mud se e ps thro ug h the g ro und during HDD a nd e sc a pe s to the surfa c e o r rive r b e d

 Re sults in drilling mud b e ing re le a se to the

e nviro nme nt

 A fra c o ut in the Ma c ke nzie Rive r po se s

risks to a q ua tic life

 E

ve n with no n-to xic drilling mud

43

slide-44
SLIDE 44

F ra c Out Risks

F ra c

  • uts in wa te r c a n:

De stro y fish spa wning ha b ita t

Smo the r fish re a ring ha b ita t

Re duc e pre y a va ila b ility

Suffo c a te inve rte b ra te c o mmunitie s

I nhib it juve nile fish g ro wth

Cha ng e fish c o mmunity struc ture

44

slide-45
SLIDE 45

F ra c Out Risks (c o nt)

Ca use de c line in fish spe c ie s, o r

re pla c e me nt o f o ne spe c ie s b y a no the r Re duc e fish pro duc tio n

Ca use fish kills

45

slide-46
SLIDE 46

Pro po se d Co nditio ns – HDD a nd F ra c Outs

 L

K F N/ DF N-le d mo nito ring

46

slide-47
SLIDE 47

So c io -E c o no mic I mpa c ts

 I

nflux o f o utside wo rke r b ring s a risk o f:

 I

nc re a se d vio le nc e to wa rds I ndig e no us wo me n a nd g irls

 I

nc re a se d hunting / fishing / ha rve sting o n L K F N la nd b y no n-L K F N me mb e rs

 I

nc re a se d drug / a lc o ho l a b use

 Oppo rtunitie s fo r L

K F N/ lo c a l e mplo yme nt, a nd fo r b usine ss c o ntra c ts

 During c o nstruc tio n a nd po st-c o nstruc tio n

47

slide-48
SLIDE 48

Pro po se d Co nditio ns – So c io - E c o no mic I mpa c ts

 Wo me n’ s Adviso ry Co unc il

 Sa fe g ua rd he a lth o f wo me n/ g irls  Ma ximize e mplo yme nt o f wo me n

 Ma ximize e mplo yme nt/ c o ntra c ting  T

ra ining o ppo rtunitie s fo r L K F N me mb e rs

 No hunting / fishing fo r o utside wo rke rs

 L

imit impa c ts o f o utside wo rke rs o n the la nd/ L K F N ha rve sting

48

slide-49
SLIDE 49

Pe rma fro st

 Pe rma fro st in the De hc ho re g io n is

tha wing a nd de g ra ding

 Pe rma fro st tha w a nd de g ra da tio n

impa c ts the la ndsc a pe a nd e c o syste ms

 Ca n impa c t L

K F N rig hts

 Ca n c a use g ro und shifting

 Cle a ring fo re st/ ve g e ta tio n, a nd c re a ting

line a r disturb a nc e , c a n c a use pe rma fro st tha w/ de g ra da tio n

49

slide-50
SLIDE 50

Pe rma fro st

Pe rma fro st tha w/ de g ra da tio n a lo ng a

pipe line c o rrido r c a n e xte nd b e yo nd the e dg e o f the c le a re d ROW E nb ridg e ha s no t a de q ua te ly a sse sse d

pe rma fro st c o nditio ns in a ll pro je c t wo rk a re a s, o r ide ntifie d a ppro pria te mitig a tio n me a sure s

Na tura l re ve g e ta tio n no t a de q ua te to

mitig a te pe rma fro st tha w

50

slide-51
SLIDE 51

Pe rma fro st a nd Pipe line s

 T

ha w slumping / g ro und sub side nc e / la nd slide s c o uld ha ve impa c ts o n pipe line sta b ility a lo ng the e ntire le ng th o f the a g ing L ine 21

 Pe rma fro st-re la te d impa c ts ra ise c o nc e rns a b o ut,

 Spill/ le a k risk a sso c ia te d with g ro und

mo ve me nt/ stre ss o n the pipe line

 L

imite d a b ility to de te c t o il le a ks, pa rtic ula rly in winte r

 Optio ns fo r/ impa c ts o f c le a n-up a nd re me dia tio n

  • f o il le a ks in a re a s o f tha we d pe rma fro st

 Se ve rity a nd e xte nt o f o il le a ks in a re a s o f tha we d

pe rma fro st

51

slide-52
SLIDE 52

Pro po se d Co nditio ns - Pe rma fro st

Pipe line s a nd wo rksite s sho uld a vo id

pe rma fro st te rra in Pe rma fro st c o nditio ns sho uld b e a sse sse d

in a ll wo rk a re a s prio r to pro je c t wo rk L K F N/

DF N-le d o ng o ing mo nito ring

Pe rma fro st c o nditio ns o n a nd o ff ROW

Gro und mo ve me nt a nd pipe line sta b ility

Oil spills/ le a ks

52

slide-53
SLIDE 53

Sumps

Drilling wa ste sho uld no t b e dispo se d in

sumps Use o f sumps c o uld c a use impa c t

pe rma fro st T he re is no e vide nc e to e sta b lish use o f

sumps is sa fe

E nb ridg e is ta king b e st

  • pra c tic e s fro m

g uide line s de ve lo pe d fo r Alb e rta whic h a re no t suita b le fo r a pe rma fro st e nviro nme nt

53

slide-54
SLIDE 54

Pro po se d Co nditio ns - Sumps

 All wa ste sho uld b e re mo ve d a nd

tra nspo rte d o ff site to re c e iving fa c ilitie s

54

slide-55
SLIDE 55

Pro duc t Spill

 L

ine 21 is o ld a nd ha s a histo ry o f le a ks a nd stre ss c o rro sio n c ra c king

 E

nb ridg e ha s no t a sse sse d the impa c ts a sso c ia te d with pro duc t spills o n the e nviro nme nt o r L K F N rig hts

 Asse ssme nts must a lso b e do ne b y

inde pe nde nt te c hnic a l e xpe rts

 L

K F N must b e invo lve d in de ve lo ping / a ppro ving spill re spo nse pla ns

55

slide-56
SLIDE 56

Pro duc t Spill

 Appro va l o f this pro je c t ha s implic a tio ns

fo r spill risk a lo ng the le ng th o f L ine 21

 Pie c e me a l re pa irs do no t a llo w fo r full

c o mme nt o n the risks o r impa c ts o f spills

 E

nb ridg e ha s no t pro vide d L K F N a de q ua te info rma tio n o n spill risks a nd re spo nse fo r L ine 21

 E

ffic a c y o f in-line inspe c tio n to o ls a nd

  • the r de te c tio n me tho ds is unc e rta in

56

slide-57
SLIDE 57

Pro po se d Co nditio ns – Spill Risks

 L

K F N/ DF N-le d mo nito ring

 Bo o ts o n the g ro und is e sse ntia l to

de te c ting o il le a ks

 Pro pe r a sse ssme nt o f the spill/ le a ks risks o f

L ine 21c o nside ring ,

 T

he pipe line is o ld with a histo ry o f spills

 Cha ng ing pe rma fro st c o nditio ns ma y b e

impa c ting pipe line inte g rity

57

slide-58
SLIDE 58

Mo nito ring a nd Gua rdia nship

L K F N a nd

DF N le d mo nito ring (g ua rdia nship) must b e a re q uire me nt fo r a ll a spe c ts o f c o nstruc tio n a nd o pe ra tio n

  • f L

ine 21 L K F N a nd o the r a ffe c te d F irst Na tio ns must

ha ve invo lve me nt in de ve lo ping a nd a ppro ving a ll pla ns fo r e nviro nme nta l pro te c tio n a nd e me rg e nc y/ spill re spo nse

58

slide-59
SLIDE 59

59

slide-60
SLIDE 60

Duty to Co nsult

 Ob lig a tio n fo r c o nsulta tio n is o n the

Cro wn

 T

he duty is fo r de e p c o nsulta tio n in this c a se

 L

K F N rig hts a nd title a re we ll e sta b lishe d

 T

he risk is hig h

 L

K F N ha s no t b e e n a de q ua te ly c o nsulte d

60

slide-61
SLIDE 61

E ng a g e me nt b y E nb ridg e

 E

ng a g e me nt b y pro po ne nt, in a “de e p” c o nsulta tio n pro c e ss, sho uld:

 Pro vide suffic ie nt info rma tio n a nd re so urc e s to

a ssist Ab o rig ina l pa rtie s to de ve lo p a full unde rsta nding o f pro je c t, inc luding its te c hnic a l c o mpo ne nts whic h ma y a ffe c t Ab o rig ina l rig hts

 Pro vide Ab o rig ina l pa rtie s the o ppo rtunity to

pro vide fe e db a c k o n issue s o f c o nc e rn

 De mo nstra te tha t c o nc e rns re g a rding impa c ts o n

Ab o rig ina l rig hts a re de mo nstra b ly tie d to mo dific a tio ns to the pro je c t, if ne c e ssa ry

 Allo w suffic ie nt time fo r the se ste ps  Build re la tio nships b e twe e n the pro po ne nt a nd

Ab o rig ina l pa rtie s

 E

nb ridg e ’ s e ng a g e me nt ha s no t me t the se g o a ls

61

slide-62
SLIDE 62

Re q uire d E ng a g e me nt

 Applic a nts a re re q uire d to sub mit:

 E

ng a g e me nt Summa ry

 E

ng a g e me nt Pla n

 E

nb ridg e ha s no t sub mitte d a n E ng a g e me nt Pla n with its Applic a tio ns

 E

nb ridg e ’ s E ng a g e me nt Summa ry is insuffic ie nt a nd misle a ding

62

slide-63
SLIDE 63

E ng a g e me nt Summa ry

E nb ridg e ’ s e ng a g e me nt summa ry fa ils to :

Ac c ura te ly re fle c t the na ture o f the

disc ussio ns b e twe e n E nb ridg e a nd L K F N L ist a ll issue s ra ise d b y L K F N

Re fle c t the c o nc e rns tha t L K F N c o nsiste ntly

ra ise d a b o ut impa c ts o n T re a ty rig hts a nd De ne rig hts Re c o rd unre so lve d pro je c t

  • re la te d issue s

b e twe e n E nb ridg e a nd L K F N

63

slide-64
SLIDE 64

I na de q ua te E ng a g e me nt

 Ove ra ll, E

nb ridg e ha s no t:

 Pro vide d L

K F N a de q ua te info rma tio n to fully unde rsta nd the pro je c t o r a sse ss pro je c t-a sso c ia te d risks

 E

nc o ura g e d a c o lla b o ra tive re la tio nship with L K F N

 Unde rsto o d o r c o nside re d L

K F N’ s c o nc e rns

 Ma de a tte mpts to wo rk c o lla b o ra tive ly with

L K F N

64