1. Introduction butterfillS@ceu.hu butterfillS@ceu.hu first - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

1. Introduction butterfillS@ceu.hu butterfillS@ceu.hu

first challenge

second challenge

“ We are stuck with our two main ways of describing and explaining things, one which treats objects and events as mindless, and the other which treats objects and events as having propositional attitudes. I see no way of bridging the gap ” (Davidson 2003: 697)

third challenge third challenge

“perception, action, and cognition are grounded in social interaction” (Sebanz & Knoblich 2008)

“the unique aspects of human cognition ... were driven by, or even constituted by, social co-operation” (Moll & Tomasello 2007) “perception, action, and cognition are grounded in social interaction” (Sebanz & Knoblich 2008)

fourth challenge

philosophical tools

What Are Mental States? Tracking, Measuring and Representing Beliefs What is Core Knowledge (or Modularity)? Radical Interpretation Actions, Intentions and Goals Goal Ascription: the Teleological Stance and Motor Awareness What Is Joint Action? Shared Intention and Motor Representation in Joint Action

October 10: Sugden, R. (2000). Team preferences. October 24: Matthews, R. J. (1994). The measure of mind. October 31: Davidson, D. ([1984] 1973). Radical interpretation. November 14: Bratman, M. (1984). Two faces of intention.

not adequately understanding

Objectivity Could there be mindreaders who are able to identify differences in belief despite not understanding what it is for a belief to be true or false? Self-awareness Does being a mindreader entail being able, sometimes, to identify one's own mental states and actions? Evidential basis What evidence could in principle support the ascription of a particular belief to a given subject, and how does the evidence support the ascription? Holism Could there be mindreaders who can identify intentions and knowledge states but not beliefs?

a puzzle

Infants’ false-belief tracking abilities (Southgate et al 2007)

Infants’ false-belief tracking abilities Violation of expectations (Onishi & Baillargeon 2005) - with change of location (He et al 2011) - with deceptive contents (Song et al 2008; Scott et al 2012) - observing verbal comm n Anticipating action (Southgate et al 2007) (Clements et al 1994) - looking (Knudsen & Liszkowski 2011) - pointing

Onishi & Baillargeon (2005)

Yellow Green Onishi & Baillargeon (2005)

Onishi & Baillargeon (2005)

Yuck Knudsen & Liszkowski (2011)

I have to clean Yuck this up Knudsen & Liszkowski (2011)

I’ll leave my toy I have to here [target clean container] Yuck this up Knudsen & Liszkowski (2011)

I’ll leave my toy I have to here [target clean container] Yuck this up E1 left toy here Knudsen & Liszkowski (2011)

I have to clean Yuck this up This is E2. She is cleaning up E1 left toy here Knudsen & Liszkowski (2011)

I have to clean Yuck this up E1 left toy here Knudsen & Liszkowski (2011)

I’ll put it [the toy] in my I have to pocket clean Yuck this up E1 left toy here Knudsen & Liszkowski (2011)

I have to clean Yuck this up E1 is coming back E1 left toy here Knudsen & Liszkowski (2011)

Infants’ false-belief tracking abilities Violation of expectations (Onishi & Baillargeon 2005) - with change of location (He et al 2011) - with deceptive contents (Song et al 2008; Scott et al 2012) - observing verbal comm n Anticipating action (Southgate et al 2007) (Clements et al 1994) - looking (Knudsen & Liszkowski 2011) - pointing

Infants’ false-belief tracking abilities Violation of expectations (Onishi & Baillargeon 2005) - with change of location (He et al 2011) - with deceptive contents (Song et al 2008; Scott et al 2012) - observing verbal comm n Anticipating action (Southgate et al 2007) (Clements et al 1994) - looking (Knudsen & Liszkowski 2011) - pointing Helping (Buttlemann et al 2009) Communicating (Southgate et al 2010) Altercentric interference (Kovacs et al 2010)

Infants’ false-belief tracking abilities Violation of expectations (Onishi & Baillargeon 2005) - with change of location (He et al 2011) - with deceptive contents (Song et al 2008; Scott et al 2012) - observing verbal comm n Anticipating action (Southgate et al 2007) (Clements et al 1994) - looking A-tasks (Knudsen & Liszkowski 2011) - pointing Helping (Buttlemann et al 2009) Communicating (Southgate et al 2010) Altercentric interference (Kovacs et al 2010)

1. There are subjects who can pass A-tasks 2. These subjects’ success on A-tasks is explained by the fact that they can represent (false) beliefs

3-year-olds fail false belief tasks prediction (Wimmer & Perner 1983) - action (Astington & Gopnik 1991) - desire (Wimmer & Mayringer 1998) retrodiction or explanation (Bartsch & London 2000) select a suitable argument (Gopnik & Slaughter 1991) own beliefs (first person) involvement (deception) (Chandler et al 1989) nonverbal response (Call et al 1999; Low 2010 exp.2) test questions word-for-word (Gopnik et al 1994; identical to desire and pretence Cluster 1996) tasks

1. Introduction butterfillS@ceu.hu butterfillS@ceu.hu first - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

1. Introduction butterfillS@ceu.hu butterfillS@ceu.hu first challenge second challenge We are stuck with our two main ways of describing and explaining things, one which treats objects and events as mindless, and the other which treats

INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION

INTRODUCTION Introduction 2/42 INTRODUCTION Alternations I am giving bread to the

Introduction Introduction Introduction Introduction Outline Motivation Failures

Introduction Introduction Introduction Nationwide Cause for Concern 1

DAQ introduction Purpose of this talk : (1) Introduction for those who have not been in every

INTRODUCTION cf. Schneider, Chapter 1 INTRODUCTION THEY ARE OUT TO GET YOU INTRODUCTION WHAT

Overview Introduction to SMIL Introduction to W3C and XML Introduction to SMIL

14 Introduction Introduction Bad guys can put malware into Example: hosts

Previous Lecture Introduction to SMIL 2 Introduction to W3C and XML Introduction to SMIL

Lecture 1 Andreas Habegger Introduction Zynq Introduction Zynq Introduction Zynq PS vs. PL

2018.06 01 SMILE5 Introduction S E 5 02 Alpha Cloud M I L 03 Company Introduction 04

Introduction to CICS Course introduction Course introduction What is CICS? What is an

Network Visualization Introduction Presented by Shahed Introduction Introduction Basic

Introduction Introduction (1) Main argument of the paper: universities are not only

Introduction Introduction to storage and to storage and filesystems filesystems Introduction

JABLOTRON JA-100 introduction November 2011 Introduction Todays goals First introduction of

Text Classification Diyi Yang Some slides borrowed from Jacob Eisenstein (was at GT) and Dan

Anticipation in cybernetic systems: A case against mindless antirepresentationalism Lambert

Overview (SEL)? What is social and emotional learning? What is mindfulness? Social

Multi-agent learning Teaching strategies Gerard Vreeswijk , Intelligent Systems Group, Computer

APNA 30th Annual Conference Session 4035: October 22, 2016 SELF-REFLECTIVE PRACTICE: A

An Architecture A Day Keeps The Hacker Away David A. Holland, Ada T. Lim, Margo I. Seltzer

Welcome to CSci 1113 Introduction to C/C++ Programming for Scientists and Engineers Instructor

Develop Your Data Mindset Module 3 - Aligning Answerable Questions With School Initiatives Part