Welcome to Today’s Webinar
October 20, 2020
Welcome to Todays Webinar October 20, 2020 Managing Your Historic - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Welcome to Todays Webinar October 20, 2020 Managing Your Historic Campus Facilities in Todays Resource- Constrained Environment Managing Your Historic Campus Facilities in Todays Resource-Constrained Environment A collaborative
October 20, 2020
A collaborative webinar presented by
Managing Your Historic Campus Facilities in Today’s Resource-Constrained Environment
Continuing Education Units AIA LU/HSW 1.0 Unit Learning Outcomes 1. Identify and prioritize needed historic maintenance and upgrades in the current resource-starved environment, including health, safety, and well-being concerns. 2. Analyze campus facilities stock and prioritize efforts that create long-term sustainable solutions for healthier local and global environments. 3. Consider available strategies to update HVAC systems in historic buildings, including safer interior environments to prevent the spread of coronavirus. 4. Discuss best practices for the composition of planning teams who have oversight
A collaborative webinar presented by
Managing Your Historic Campus Facilities in Today’s Resource-Constrained Environment
The Association for Preservation Technology International
Barbara A. Campagna bcampagna@bcampagna.com Lori Ferriss lori.ferriss@goodyclancy.com Thomas E. Newbold tnewbold@lfginc.com
Preservation Architect Historian Planners Engineers Structural/Forensic Conservators Landscape Architects Sustainable Preservation Facility Team: Planners Chief Architect Facility Manager Preservation Officer
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 1
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 2
into Building Renewals Case Study
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 3
Paris Agreement 2015 – commit to cap global temperature rise to 1.5° to 2° C to avert catastrophic and irreversible impacts of climate change
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 4
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 5
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 6
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 7
Carbon neutrality
Target date Interim milestones
Resilience
Meet defined thresholds Interim milestones
Tracking Education Research
*as defined by Second Nature
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 8
Cultural Stewardship Environmental Stewardship Physical and Financial Stewardship
BUILDING REUSE AS CLIMATE ACTION
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 10
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 11
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 12
ZERO NET CARBON COLLABORATION FOR EXISTING AND HISTORIC BUILDINGS, 2019
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 14
Project Team
Owner: Mt. Holyoke College Owners Project Manager: CSL Architect: Goody Clancy Building analytics and envelope: Thornton Tomasetti MEP engineering: Van Zelm Engineers Construction Manager: Cutler
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 15
initiative to reprogram underutilized spaces
Strategic Plan Greener U Scoping Audit Greenhouse Gas Mitigation Strategy Building Envelope Assessments Deferred Maintenance Logs Utility Master Planning (concurrent with study)
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 16
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 17
Create a project that:
Eablih a mdel f deigig a ma eeg retrofit, one which reduces total carbon emissions in the near-term
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 18
125 Scope Options 50 Energy Conservation Measures (ECMs)
End-of-Life Replacements
replacement
Zone-Level HVAC Upgrades
system
Envelope Upgrades
Primary Energy Source
hot water
gas boilers
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 19
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 20
Window/Louver Uninsulated opaque wall Insulated opaque wall
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 21
Thermal modeling Parametric energy modeling Life cycle assessment Summer comfort
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 22
22
Existing Bay Window, R-1.9 Bay Overclad Option, R-10
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 23
Operational Carbon Savings (mtCO2e/yr)
Envelope End-of-Life Replacements
50 100 150 200 250
Zone-Level HVAC Upgrades Envelope Upgrades Primary Energy Source Potential
TOP 10 ENERGY CONSERVATION MEASURES
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 24 SIPS Spray Foam (for reference only) SIPS Wood Fiber Mineral Wool Wood Fiber
100 200 300 400 500 600 700
Window - Double Glazed Window - Triple Glazed Roof - R30 Roof - R60 Exterior Doors Full Overclad Full Overclad Bay Overclad 1 1/2" Interior Insulation 3 5/8" Interior Insulation 1 1/2" Partial Interior Insulation 3 5/8" Partial Interior Insulation
GWP (MTco2e)
Envelope End-of-Life Replacements Envelope Upgrades
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 25
SIPS Spray Foam SIPS Wood Fiber Mineral Wool Wood Fiber
2 4 6 8 10
Window - Double Glazed Window - Triple Glazed Roof - R30 Roof - R60 Exterior Doors Full Overclad Full Overclad Bay Overclad 1 1/2" Interior Insulation 3 5/8" Interior Insulation 1 1/2" Partial Interior Insulation 3 5/8" Partial Interior Insulation
CARBON POSITIVE
Envelope End-of-Life Replacements Envelope Upgrades YEARS
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 26
Decision- making criteria Total scenario cost User-selection
Comprehensive list of scope items sorted by category
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 27
dramatic improvements to energy performance.
carbon return on investment.
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 29
Reusing existing buildings is a critical strategy for carbon neutrality policies and climate action plans Colleges and Universities have a key role to play:
Leverage existing buildings towards carbon reduction on heritage campuses Build on legacies of stewardship Educate communities about environmental benefits of building reuse Model cutting-edge solutions to global challenges
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 30
Boston Society for Architecture 12-part series https://www.architects.org/embodied- carbon-101 Carbon Leadership Forum http://carbonleadershipforum.org https://secondnature.org/signatory- handbook/the-commitments/ http://climateheritage.org/ https://www.culturexclimate.org/
Climate Action through Reuse of Historic Facilities SCUP/APT WEBINAR, OCTOBER 20, 2020 31
Courtesy of Carel Inc.
~30-35 CFM/PERSON
A collaborative webinar presented by
Managing Your Historic Campus Facilities in Today’s Resource-Constrained Environment
Please feel free to contact us: Michael Patrick mpatrick@barnesvanze.com Barbara A. Campagna bcampagna@bcampagna.com Lori Ferriss lori.ferriss@goodyclancy.com Thomas E. Newbold tnewbold@lfginc.com
THANK YOU!
Upcoming Events: see these and others at these APT web links:
https://www.apti.org/upcoming-previous-conferences https://www.apti.org/other-conferences-training https://www.apti.org/training-education
Association for Preservation Technology
December 9 & 10 10:00 AM to 2:30 PM Central Time - Virtual via Zoom Webinar
Historic Bridges Workshop
October 21 & 22 14:00 to 16:00 CET - Virtual via Zoom Webinar
Response to Disaster in the Time of Covid
November 9 through 13 FIve days of events - Virtual Conference
Traditional Building Conference
October 29 through November 1 Washington, DC
APT Annual Conference Washington, DC 2021
November 11 through 14 FIve days of events - Virtual Conference
Frank Lloyd Wright Building Conservancy Conference
October 23 | Workshop
SCUP Virtual Planning Institute: Foundations Laying the Groundwork for Strategic Planning
October 28 | Webinar
Higher Education Institutions: Partners in Social & Economic Community Resilience
November 12-13 | Workshop
SCUP Virtual Planning Institute: Design Developing and Implementing a Strategic Plan