2017 Annual Membership Meeting
Welcome!
Please review your Annual Meeting Packet and help yourself to refreshments. The meeting will convene at 3:05.
Welcome! Please review your Annual Meeting Packet and help yourself - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Welcome! Please review your Annual Meeting Packet and help yourself to refreshments. The meeting will convene at 3:05. 2017 Annual Membership Meeting Agenda Call to Order ___________________________________ 3:05 Minutes
2017 Annual Membership Meeting
Please review your Annual Meeting Packet and help yourself to refreshments. The meeting will convene at 3:05.
3/26/2017 2 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting
3:05 3:08 3:10 3:10 3:20 3:50 4:00 4:00 4:30 4:35 4:55 4:55 5:00
(Printed Reports)
Christina Sauve, Assistant Treasurer/COO
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 5 New loans opened in 2016 (approved loan amount and LOC limits) Homeownership $2.9 M Personal $1.9 M Small Business $1.2 M Loan funds disbursed in 2016 (LOC draws and term loan disbursements) Homeownership $3.0 M Personal $4.1 M Small Business $1.7 M Aggregate loan and LOC balances at 12/31/16 Homeownership $13.3M Personal $3.6 M Small Business $3.9 M Loans Outstanding $20.7 M Loans Granted $8.8 M Loans Opened $6.0 M
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 6
Strengthening neighborhoods. Building family assets.
Cynthia Lee got personal attention and hands-on support from Coop Fed’s First Home Club.
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 7
Home Loans Originated: 43 $2.9 million
Loans Opened 2016 ($)
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 8
Purchase Loans: 30 $1.9 M
(incl. 8 ROC homes)
Loans Opened 2016 ($)
– Purchase Loans: 30, $1.9 M
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 9
52% to First Time Homebuyers ($)
Loans Opened 2016 ($)
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 10
Foreclosure Rescue: 4, $151 K
(16% of non-purchase mortgages)
Loans Opened 2016 ($)
– Purchase Loans: 30, $1.9 M
– Foreclosure Rescue Loans: 4, $151 K
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 11
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 12
assistance matching grants in 2016
$26,500+ in savings
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 13
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 14
Affordable credit. Gateway to asset-building.
Rámon boosted his credit score and refinanced his car loan with Coop Fed – saving him $1,000 per year.
cards, lines of credit, and other personal uses
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 15
Personal Loans Originated: 425 $1.9 million
Loans Opened 2016 ($)
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 16
Alternative to Predatory: 200 $780 K
Loans Opened 2016 ($)
– Alternative to Predatory Loans: 200, $780 K
$2.3 million
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 17
management, homeownership, car buying and more
translators
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 18
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 19
Building an independent, local economy.
Coop Fed and Up Start helped Antonisha get working capital to grow her her business, AFICA, to the next level.
estate and responsible, local landlords
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 20
Business Loans Originated: 38 $1.2 M
Loans Opened 2016 ($)
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 21
43% owned or controlled by women
(63% of loan #)
Loans Opened 2016 ($)
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 22
– Average non-RE loan size: $14,300
– 65 local jobs supported
financing, and business plan feedback
assistance
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 23
3/13/2016 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 24
Hands-on learning in under-served communities.
Coop Fed brought Biz Kid$ lessons and activities to hundreds
and Henninger High Schools
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 25
member
members as of 12/31/16
Christina Sauve, Assistant Treasurer /COO
Ron Ehrenreich, Treasurer/CEO
*Please see the Welcome table for copies of our Summary Financial Statement, Ratio Analysis and FPR Guide
Development Financial Institutions (CDFIs)
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 28
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 29 0.0 0.1 0.1 0.2 0.2 0.3 0.3 0.4 0.4 0.5 12/12 12/13 12/14 12/15 12/16
Return On Average Assets (%)
Net Income / Average Assets (annualized) Peer
– Bailout – Interest rates crashed too
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 30
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 31 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Yield on Average Loans (%)
– Business Loan Connection & NY CDFI Loans – Special Loan Funds
– Referral to Enterprise & “Nettie” – Flex Auto Loans
– All CoopFed mortgages now serviced in-house – Owner’s Choice for Fannie, Freddie, FHA, VA, USDA
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 32
– From foreclosures, deed in lieu, death of members
– $12,482 net loss from sales in 2016
– Mostly tax delinquency referrals from the city
income, and eventually will bring savings
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 33
2 4 6 8 10 12 14 12/12 12/13 12/14 12/15 12/16
Net Worth To Assets (%)
Net Worth / Assets Peer
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 34
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 35
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 36 2 4 6 8 10 12 12/12 12/13 12/14 12/15 12/16
(a) Delinquency (%)
Delinquent loans / loans Peer Delinquency
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 37 2 4 6 8 10 12 12/12 12/13 12/14 12/15 12/16
(b) Net Charge-Offs (%)
Net Charge-offs / Averge Assets Peer Net Charge-offs
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 38
Development Credit Unions (CDCUS)… indicates that delinquency rates run higher in CDCUS than in other credit unions, but the charge-off rates are consistent with overall credit union rates.”
– Albert E Burger & Mary Zellmer, in Strategic Opportunities in Serving Low to Moderate Income Members
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 39
– Using our resources to improve communities – Local and socially responsible
– Meeting community needs – Achieving a sustainable scale
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 40
– Households, individuals, businesses and organizations
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 41
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 42 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 12/12 12/13 12/14 12/15 12/16
Loan Growth (%)
Loan Growth Peer Loan
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 43
Coop Fed growth in 2016: 0.06% Net Growth Peer Group growth in 2016: -0.66% (shrinking)
1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
Members (#)
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 44
“Declassification” project
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 45
558 568 522 335 279 617
100 200 300 400 500 600 700 2014 2015 2016
Membership Changes (#)
New Members
'82 '83 '84 '85 '86 '87 '88 '89 '90 '91 '92 '93 '94 '95 '96 '97 '98 '99 '00 '01 '02 '03 '04 '05 '06 '07 '08 '09 '10 '11 '12 '13 '14 '15 '16
2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24
Growth of Assets
1982 to Present
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 46
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 47
stock market investments, Euro funds, or gold
working in the local economy
members
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 48 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 12/12 12/13 12/14 12/15 12/16
Loans To Assets (%)
Loans / Assets Peer
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 49 $0 $10 $20
2013 Deposits 2013 Loans 2014 Deposits 2014 Loans 2015 Deposits 2015 Loans 2016 Deposits 2016 Loans Millions
Loans to Shares
Member Deposits Nonmember Deposits Loans
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 50
– Business Opportunity Lending (details later!) – Homes, Autos, and Cooperatives – Lending in support of economic development
Ron Ehrenreich, Treasurer/CEO
Christina Sauve, Assistant Treasurer/COO
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 56
staff by providing functional, reliable technology.
training.
paying a living wage.
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 57
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 58
updated infrastructure
in progress
coming by April 30
April 30
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 59
– Training Survey twice per year, starting Dec. 2016
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 60
in constant fear of the next illness, of small increases in the price of food, or about the dangers of eviction or foreclosure or repossession.“
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 61
in constant fear of the next illness, of small increases in the price of food, or about the dangers of eviction or foreclosure or repossession.“
$11.56/hr
without dependents with employer-provided health insurance
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 62
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 63
– Coop Fed pays 50% of single premium for any employee
– No cost to employee
Sam Eschenbrenner, Member Service Rep
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 65
516 Burt Street
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 66
Service where we’re needed
Outside of Downtown and the Hill, bank branches are lacking and car
Map: SU Community Geography, 2013
No Car Ownership and Bank/CU Locations
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 67
Opportunity for high-impact growth
Lighter cluster of lending activity in surrounding neighborhood Relocation with SHA during I-81 renewal Loans Opened 2012-2016
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 68
Join us! Friday, April 28 at 2 pm 516 Burt Street
Ron Ehrenreich, Treasurer/CEO Carolyn Evans-Dean, Business Loan Officer & Advisor
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 70
more small and micro businesses.
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 71
$- $0.20 $0.40 $0.60 $0.80 $1.00 $1.20 $1.40
2013 2014 2015 2016 Millions
Business Loans Opened
$- $0.20 $0.40 $0.60 $0.80 $1.00 $1.20 $1.40
2013 2014 2015 2016 Millions
Business Loans Opened
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 72
37% average annual growth
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 73
– Plus 6 more through collaboration with Alternatives FCU
expansion zone
do
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 74
Coop Fed 2014-2016 Other Loans
Business Loans
62% of business borrowers have Syracuse addresses
(prior years 85%)
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 75
Coop Fed 2014-2016 Other Loans
Business Loans
Developing plans to focus outreach in metro areas as well as rural communities
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 76
access bank loans
discrimination
businesses
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 77
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 78
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 79
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 80
Carolyn Ron Greg
Meagan Weatherby, Program Sustainability Coordinator
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 82
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 83
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 84
Apartheid regime; countering discrimination
fuels & nukes; serving marginalized communities
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 85
participation, mutual aid!
stuffing envelopes, tellering………
reaching out
3/26/2017 Cooperative Federal Annual Meeting 86
credit cards
present on demand
Presentation from Workers’ Center of CNY
Door Prizes, Turn in Common Cents Ballots…. and Join us for Dinner!