The Evolving Declaratory Judgment Standard , - - PDF document

• !"#$%&!"#$$''()*+

The Evolving Declaratory Judgment Standard

• , -*. / 00 1 2 $ * 3 +

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

9/8/2008 http://ip.law360.com/print_article/68174

3+>FG*34' .** ' +''' ''+4' *( +' .** ' + '? 1 +>*( 5' .** ' +'' +*'45 * ++ ''+5 00' ''?',,3(6'3*3' $0#-A5#/ A + ' ' ' . ' A5 ( . '++ + 45 4' * ' ''.'++ 1 <(%3+ 45 4' &' ' 5 ' ' . *'= ' ' ( . '++ 4' <(%; <<(3 5 ' 5ADA45 *(' **'+ C0H& A+ + 5' '( 45 4' !

• / (' ' ' * ' E 5 ' *' > + *

+ 5 ' . . '' + *' ' . 55 +''?+5 (.'+* 'I

• / <( '. A..( D5 A** ' -ADA/ + 5 + 5

('JE 5* '* ' (-'.' 5(' ''/I

• /('+5 5 '<(5 5* '

3 5 . 5 **( + * ' '' + 5 45 %' <( 3',.',(%',.'#$%$ ;-% 3/ % 3 + 5 '++( ' ' 45 4' <( ' 3 %' ' ' * ' %DAJ' E 5 3 '. ADA<3&* *' C0H& A.' 5'* ' E 5%'++(3K'ADA .> * . 5*('3+ ** *?> + '.'*''+'' @ +A111' 5? 3 5 + ' ( 45 4' 1 D' 3 + * K'>'.' * '(' D'?> ('.''? A + ' A5' $ % 3 9 ' 1 ( 7 6

9/8/2008 http://ip.law360.com/print_article/68174

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

9/8/2008 http://ip.law360.com/print_article/68174

C( <(+ 545 4' %3>5 (( 5 ' 5 ' *' ' ( 5 4'. 45 ('&'' * '? H ' '' ' ' *. ** +' '( ' *(45 ' @'-/5''''+++(

• /+ ' 5+' '-/' 4

++ 4.'-/*'(('5 '' -#/ ('. *' .'(.3 +* ' '+' +' '. '+'( ' *+'+(( 545 ' .( 5 45 4' ''*+ 0065 C 5'O P .,,

• !"#

!$$%

• A3 N0+61

9/8/2008 http://ip.law360.com/print_article/68174