Standards Process Briefing Toronto Technical Summit Richard Petrie, - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Standards Process Briefing Toronto Technical Summit Richard Petrie, building SMART International Agenda Welcome to New Members buildingSMART Role and Purpose New Organization - Key Strategic Principles New Organization - Overview and Key
Richard Petrie, buildingSMART International
Welcome to New Members buildingSMART Role and Purpose New Organization - Key Strategic Principles New Organization - Overview and Key Operational Principles Standards Process - Overview Standards Process - Development and Implementation
Why bSI and Why a New Standards Process?
Corporate Technical Specifications Private Standards Open Industry Standards National Standards Int’l Standards ISO
European Standards EN
High Low Low High
Why bSI and Why a New Standards Process?
Corporate Technical Specifications Private Standards Open Industry Standards National Standards Int’l Standards ISO
European Standards EN
High Low Low High
Why bSI and Why a New Standards Process?
Corporate Technical Specifications Private Standards Open Industry Standards National Standards Int’l Standards ISO
European Standards EN
High Low Low High
Welcome to New Members buildingSMART Role and Purpose New Organization - Key Strategic Principles New Organization - Overview and Key Operational Principles Standards Process - Overview Standards Process - Development and Implementation
Standards Body of Reference Vibrant Chapters Quality Mark in demand
Working Together Easy Access Momentum
together
conflicting approaches and confusion
without consensus
requires an industry body with broad engagement
Goal is to create an environment which satisfies these conditions:
mechanism to create international consensus
Controlling:
Give us the money
Enabling:
The market will decide Technically led Fragmented initiatives Restricted community Process led Open processes Broad engagement International reach Utilise crowd sourcing Accessible information
OGC = Open Geospatial Consortium http://www.opengeospatial.org/ W3C = World Wide Web Consortium http://www.w3.org/
Welcome to New Members buildingSMART Role and Purpose New Organization - Key Strategic Principles New Organization - Overview Standards Process - Overview Standards Process - Development and Implementation
Three Core Programs International Council ExCom Executive Strategic Advisory Council Compliance Standards Chapters
Room
Groups
Key Technical
Standards Committee
Standards Committee Executive
Technical Architecture Review Implement Review End User Review
Process Infrastructure
Guidelines CoBie TBC
Product
bSDD
MSG ISG TAG
Projects Regulator
Commercial Review
Chapters & Members Open Access
Projects Projects Projects Projects
Room
Groups
Key Technical
Standards Committee
Standards Committee Executive
Technical Architecture Review Implement Review End User Review
Process Infrastructure
Guidelines CoBie TBC
Product
bSDD
MSG ISG TAG
Projects Regulator
Commercial Review
Open Access
Projects Projects Projects Projects
Senior Governance Body: Appointed by Chapters and Members Votes on new Standards Defines Standards Process
Chapters & Members
Room
Groups
Key Technical
Standards Committee
Standards Committee Executive
Technical Architecture Review Implement Review End User Review
Process Infrastructure
Guidelines CoBie TBC
Product
bSDD
MSG ISG TAG
Projects Regulator
Commercial Review
Open Access
Projects Projects Projects Projects
Appointed by Standards Committee Runs Standards Process day to day
Chapters & Members
Room
Groups
Key Technical
Standards Committee
Standards Committee Executive
Technical Architecture Review Implement Review End User Review
Process Infrastructure
Guidelines CoBie TBC
Product
bSDD
MSG ISG TAG
Projects Regulator
Commercial Review
Open Access
Projects Projects Projects Projects
Rooms: Open access domain or subject focused to assess common needs and solutions
Chapters & Members
Room
Groups
Key Technical
Standards Committee
Standards Committee Executive
Technical Architecture Review Implement Review End User Review
Process Infrastructure
Guidelines CoBie TBC
Product
bSDD
MSG ISG TAG
Projects Regulator
Commercial Review
Open Access
Projects Projects Projects Projects
Groups: Defined purpose activity of a large
Two Types:
Chapters & Members
Room
Groups
Key Technical
Standards Committee
Standards Committee Executive
Technical Architecture Review Implement Review End User Review
Process Infrastructure
Guidelines CoBie TBC
Product
bSDD
MSG ISG TAG
Projects Regulator
Commercial Review
Open Access
Projects Projects Projects Projects
Projects: Specific activity with committed resources to create a new Standard
Chapters & Members
Room
Groups
Key Technical
Standards Committee
Standards Committee Executive
Technical Architecture Review Implement Review End User Review
Process Infrastructure
Guidelines CoBie TBC
Product
bSDD
MSG ISG TAG
Projects Regulator
Commercial Review
Open Access
Projects Projects Projects Projects
Voting authority transferred from old ITM and IUG
Chapters & Members
Room
Groups
Key Technical
Standards Committee
Standards Committee Executive
Technical Architecture Review Implement Review End User Review
Process Infrastructure
Guidelines CoBie TBC
Product
bSDD
MSG ISG TAG
Projects Regulator
Commercial Review
Open Access
Projects Projects Projects Projects
Chapters & Members
Rooms and Groups:
and follow the Standards Process
Room
Groups
Key Technical
Standards Committee
Standards Committee Executive
Technical Architecture Review Implement Review End User Review
Process Infrastructure
Guidelines CoBie TBC
Product
bSDD
MSG ISG TAG
Projects Regulator
Commercial Review
Open Access
Projects Projects Projects Projects
Former Technical Committee / ITM becomes the Technical Room
Chapters & Members
Room
Groups
Key Technical
Standards Committee
Standards Committee Executive
Technical Architecture Review Implement Review End User Review
Process Infrastructure
Guidelines CoBie TBC
Product
bSDD
MSG ISG TAG
Projects Regulator
Commercial Review
Open Access
Projects Projects Projects Projects
First new Room
Chapters & Members
Room
Groups
Key Technical
Standards Committee
Standards Committee Executive
Technical Architecture Review Implement Review End User Review
Process Infrastructure
Guidelines CoBie TBC
Product
bSDD
MSG ISG TAG
Projects Regulator
Commercial Review
Open Access
Projects Projects Projects Projects
Chapters & Members
Note: IUG repositioned to lead cross chapter engagement in Chapter Program
Existing SCE appointed by ExCom New Standards Process will be confirmed in March Summit (& will include election regime for SCE) Intent is that existing SCE should remain in place for first year at least. Elections no later than Autumn Summit 2016
Some clarifications: Summits are integral to standards process. They provide
meetings and hear about new projects.
Welcome to New Members buildingSMART Role and Purpose New Organization - Key Strategic Principles New Organization - Overview Standards Process - Overview Standards Process - Development and Implementation
Needs Identification Solution Development Deployment
Initiation Development Approval SCE
Standards Program Process
Filter
Chapter Funnel
Room
Room Funnel 3rd Party Funnel
SC
Needs Identification Solution Development Deployment
Initiation Development Approval SCE
Standards Program Process
Projects Projects bSI Final Standard
Working Groups
SC
Consensus Building
SC
Working Groups Filter
Chapter Funnel
Room
Room Funnel 3rd Party Funnel
SC
Needs Identification Solution Development Deployment
Initiation Development Approval SCE
Standards Program Process
Projects Projects bSI Final Standard
Working Groups
SC
Consensus Building
SC
Working Groups Filter
Chapter Funnel
Room
Room Funnel 3rd Party Funnel
SC
Needs Identification Solution Development Deployment
Initiation Development Approval SCE
Standards Program Process
User Training & Certification Industry Adoption
Software Implementation\
New Working Group
Approved
Standards Committee Vote Standards Committee Executive Review
Rooms:
Propose New Working Group
Rooms
Assess Priorities Secure Resources
From Chapters From Rooms From 3rd Parties
Initiation Development
Needs and Requirements
New Project or Standard Proposal
Approved
Proceed
Standards Committee Vote Standards Committee Executive Review
New Working Group
Approved
Rooms:
Propose New Working Group
Rooms
Assess Priorities Secure Resources
From Chapters From Rooms From 3rd Parties
Standards Committee Vote Standards Committee Executive Review
Project Plan Application Rooms or Working Groups:
New Project Proposal
Initiation Development
Needs and Requirements
Expert Panel Reviews
Project Execution
bSI Working Draft Standard
New Project
Proposal
Development Approval
SCE Confirmation Room/ Working Group Review
bSI Candidate Standard
Approved
Proceed
As Required Standards Committee Executive Confirms:
Outcome Completeness Consensus
Room / Working Group Review:
Recommend as bSI Standard
Expert Panel Review:
User Commercial Technical Implementer
SC
SCE Confirmation Room/ Working Group Review
bSI Candidate Standard
Approved
Project Execution
bSI Working Draft Standard
Development Approval Proceed
Expert Panel Reviews
New Project
Proposal As Required
Quarterly Public Progress Reports
Standards Committee Executive Confirms:
Outcome Completeness Consensus
Room / Working Group Review:
Recommend as bSI Standard
Expert Panel Review:
User Commercial Technical Implementer
Project
Extended Consensus Building Expert Panel Reviews Standards Committee Vote
bSI Candidate Standard
Approval Public Consultation
Standards Committee Executive Review
Software Implementation
bSI
Final Standard Approved
As Required
SC
Standards Committee Executive Review
Project
Extended Consensus Building
Approval Software Implementation
Expert Panel Reviews
bSI Candidate Standard
Public Consultation
Standards Committee Vote
bSI
Final Standard Approved
As Required
Quarterly Public Progress Reports
Needs Identification Solution Development Deployment
Filter
Working Groups
SC
Initiation Development SC Approval
Standards Program Process
bSI
Standard Proposal
bSI
Draft Standard
bSI
Working Draft Standard
bSI
Final Standard
bSI
Candidate Standard
SC SCE
Needs Identification Solution Development Deployment
Filter
Working Groups
SC
Initiation Development SC Approval
Standards Program Process
SC SCE Standards Committee Voting: 1 Simple majority of SC members 2 SC vote representing at least three chapters
to take part and nominate experts Standards Committee Executive voting: 1 Stage 2 Consensus requirements met. 2 SCE in favor. 3 No serious opposition if subject is to be a final product for test implementation Standards Committee Voting 1 Stage 3 Consensus requirements met 2 Majority in SCE will forward it to
3 65% of SC members in favor, not more than 10% of total votes cast are negative.
Needs Identification Solution Development Deployment
Filter
Working Groups
SC
Initiation Development SC Approval
Standards Program Process
bSI
Standard Proposal
bSI
Draft Standard
bSI
Working Draft Standard
bSI
Final Standard
bSI
Candidate Standard
SC SCE
ISO FDIS ISO DIS ISO CD ISO NWI
ISO PAS /TS
Development
Welcome to New Members buildingSMART Role and Purpose New Organization - Key Strategic Principles New Organization - Overview and Key Operational Principles Standards Process - Overview Standards Process - Development and Implementation
Standards Process Development:
the next two months until 31/12/14
possible and confirmed by 31/01/2015 We will start to operate the new process immediately
Charters Development:
Summit 2015
Standards Committee for vote
Richard Petrie, buildingSMART International