Solar Finance Breakfast Briefing Steven M. Kaplan Anjali Garg - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Solar Finance Breakfast Briefing

Nadav Klugman

Partner 312.701.8433

nklugman@mayerbrown.com

April 19, 2017

Steven M. Kaplan

Partner 202.263.3005

skaplan@mayerbrown.com

Anjali Garg

Associate 202.263.3419

agarg@mayerbrown.com

Roadmap

• Background on the types of solar financing available to

consumers and potential financing structures

• Overview of federal and state laws that may apply to

residential solar products offered to consumers

• Key areas of potential legal risk associated with consumer

financial protection laws

• Policy issues affecting the industry
• Examples of financing structures
• How to mitigate risk

2

INTRODUCTION

3

Types of Solar Financing

• Loans

– Same as cash (deferred interest) – Fixed rate unsecured – Combination loans

• Leases
• Leases
• Power purchase agreements (“PPAs”)

– Purchasing power from a third-party owned solar system

• Property-assessed clean energy (“PACE”) programs

– Financing secured with a lien on the underlying property

• Community solar

– Solar subscription involving the purchase of solar credits

4

Financing Structures

• Partnership flip structures
• Sale-leaseback structures
• Pass-thru lease structures

5

POTENTIALLY APPLICABLE LAWS

6

Potentially Applicable Federal Consumer Financial Protection Laws

• Truth in Lending Act (“TILA”) and Regulation Z
• Consumer Leasing Act (Regulation M – part of TILA)
• Prohibition on unfair, deceptive, or abusive acts or

practices (“UDAAP” or “UDAP”)

• Federal Trade Commission Holder Rule
• Federal Trade Commission Holder Rule
• Electronic Funds Transfer Act and Regulation E
• Telephone Consumer Protection Act
• Servicemembers’ Civil Relief Act
• Fair Credit Reporting Act and Regulation V
• Equal Credit Opportunity Act

7

Truth in Lending Act and Regulation Z

• 12 C.F.R. part 1026
• Regulation Z provides rules around disclosures that must

be provided in connection with loan products.

• Penalties:

Actual damages and statutory damages (of not less than $200 – Actual damages and statutory damages (of not less than $200 and not more than $2,000). – Willingly and knowingly failing to comply with TILA requirements may also be subject to criminal liability, including up to a $5,000 fine and up to one year imprisonment. – TILA also provides for assignee liability for violations that are “apparent on the face” of the documents.

8

Consumer Leasing Act (Regulation M)

• 12 C.F.R. part 1013
• This regulation requires leases to include key contract

terms such as payment schedules, security filings and warranties.

• Applies to leases not exceeding $54,600.
• Applies to leases not exceeding $54,600.
• Regulation M also contains restrictions around advertising

leases.

• TILA penalties will apply.

9

UDAAP/UDAP

• Sections 1031 and 1036 of the Dodd-Frank Act
• Section 5 of the FTC Act
• “Advertisements” extends beyond the traditional print, television

and radio mediums, and includes information contained on websites, sales practices at the point of sale and customer service scripts. scripts.

• Deception: an act or practice is deceptive if:

– It misleads or is likely to mislead the consumer; – The consumer’s interpretation of the act or practice is reasonable under the circumstances; and – The misleading act or practice is material.

• States also may have mini-UDAP statutes.

10

UDAAP/UDAP

• Consider the 4 P’s:

– The prominence of the statement; – The manner in which the statement is presented to the consumer; – Whether the statement is placed in a location where a consumer can be reasonably expected to observe and understand it; and – In the case of a disclaimer, the proximity of the disclaimer to the statement qualified.

11

UDAAP/UDAP Reviews

• Disclosures for “triggering” terms, including the terms

and conditions of credit product being offered

• Information regarding the impact of breaking the lease or

loan term

• Disclosures regarding terms of the contract, including the
• Disclosures regarding terms of the contract, including the

length of the loan or lease, warranties, eligibility for tax credits, energy savings and environmental benefits

• Compliance with the FTC’s Green Guides
• Compliance with the FTC’s Endorsement Guide
• Use of the term “free”

12

UDAAP/UDAP Remedies

• CFPB:

– Relief for consumers – Civil money penalties of up to $5,437 per day for a general violation, up to $27,186 per day for a reckless violation, and up to $1,087,450 million per day for a knowing violations to $1,087,450 million per day for a knowing violations

• FTC:

– There is no private right of action under the FTC Act; however, many states have corollary statutes that may include private rights of action. – The FTC may impose penalties of up to $40,000 per violation on a violator. – The FTC can also require restitution, disgorgement, and/or reformation or rescission of contracts.

13

Holder Rule

• 16 C.F.R. § 433.2
• Sellers must include the following notice in certain

consumer credit contracts (“Holder Notice”):

– Any holder of this consumer credit contract is subject to all – Any holder of this consumer credit contract is subject to all claims and defenses which the debtor could assert against the seller of goods or services obtained pursuant hereto or with the proceeds hereof. Recovery hereunder by the debtor shall not exceed amounts paid by the debtor hereunder.

14

Holder Rule

• The Holder Rule shifts the risk of a seller’s breach of

contract or other misconduct to the assignee of that contract by enabling a consumer to raise defenses to defeat or diminish the right of a creditor to be paid under the contract, and arguably to assert affirmative claims the contract, and arguably to assert affirmative claims against the holder.

• For example, if the solar contractor delivers defective

panels to the consumer and then goes out of business, the consumer would then have recourse against the assignee of the associated credit contract.

15

Electronic Funds Transfer Act and Regulation E

• 12 C.F.R. part 1005
• Provides protections to consumers who effect electronic

fund transfers, including preauthorized automatic payments from a consumer’s accounts

– Disclosures, notifications of changes in terms and procedures for error resolution – Extension of credit cannot be conditioned on payment via ACH

16

Electronic Funds Transfer Act and Regulation E

• Penalties:

– No express assignee liability, but servicers must comply. – Statutory damages can range from $100 to $1,000 in an individual action and up to the lesser of $500,000 or 1% of the defendant’s net worth in a class action. defendant’s net worth in a class action. – Knowingly and willfully failing to comply with the EFTA may also result in criminal penalties, including a fine of not more than $5,000 and imprisonment for a term of up to a year per violation.

17

Telephone Consumer Protection Act (“TCPA”)

• 47 U.S.C. § 227
• Provides restrictions on soliciting consumers via cell

phones using auto-dialer technologies (including predictive dialers)

– Prior express written consent is required for telemarketing calls. – Prior express written consent is required for telemarketing calls.

• Penalties:

– The TCPA provides consumers with a private right of action under which a plaintiff may recover actual monetary loss or $500 per violation. – For willful or knowing violations of the TCPA, a court may award treble damages, i.e., up to $1,500 per violation.

18

Servicemembers Civil Relief Act

• 50 U.S.C. § 3901 et seq.
• SCRA generally protects members of the Armed Forces who are

called to active duty, including, among other protections, the imposition of a 6% interest rate cap on obligations incurred prior to a call to active duty and protection from default judgments. to a call to active duty and protection from default judgments.

• SCRA applies directly to loan holders and their servicers.
• Penalties:

– Civil action for monetary and equitable relief, attorneys’ fees and costs and punitive damages. – Court also may award a civil penalty of up to $55,000 for a first violation, and up to $110,000 for any subsequent violation. – Knowing violations may subject a person to criminal penalties, including a fine, imprisonment for up to one year or both.

19

Fair Credit Reporting Act and Regulation V

• 12 C.F.R. part 1022
• Contains restrictions regarding the use of consumer reports

for solicitations (i.e. prescreened offers) and in connection with credit decisions (i.e. using a consumer’s FICO score in connection with offering a credit product). connection with offering a credit product).

• To the extent the provider uses consumer report

information in making the credit decision, FCRA requires adverse action notices.

• In the context of servicing, if the servicer is reporting

information about the consumer to credit reporting agencies, FCRA regulates that conduct (the “Furnisher Rule”).

20

Fair Credit Reporting Act and Regulation V

• There is no express liability for a violation of FCRA for any

party other than the violator.

• Penalties:

– Consumer remediation – Civil money penalties – Negligent noncompliance with FCRA can result in actual damages, costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees. – Willful noncompliance with FCRA can result in actual damages (of not less than $100 and not more than $1,000), punitive damages, costs, and reasonable attorneys’ fees.

21

Equal Credit Opportunity Act and Regulation B

• 12 C.F.R. part 1002
• Prohibits creditors from discriminating on a prohibited basis in any

aspect of a credit transaction, and requires that creditors provide certain notifications of action taken on an application for credit.

• Contains requirements to provide adverse action notices taken in

connection with originating certain credit products. connection with originating certain credit products.

• No express assignee liability, unless the assignee participates in the

credit decision.

• Penalties:

– Actual damages and punitive damages of up to $10,000 in an individual action and up to the lesser of $500,000 or 1% of the defendant’s net worth in a class action. – Costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees.

22

Potentially Applicable State Laws

• Licensing and notifications

– Lending – Leasing – Servicing – Contractor-related licenses – Contractor-related licenses

• Home solicitation laws

– 3-day right of rescission – Practice restrictions

• UCC-1 filings
• Do not call laws
• Mini-UDAP

23

POLICY ISSUES AFFECTING THE INDUSTRY

24

State Issues: Net Metering

• Net metering allows consumers to:

– Provide unused energy generated from solar panels back to the energy grid. – Receive a credit for extra energy generated and returned to the grid.

• States take different approaches to net metering, including Nevada,

which recently tried to phase-out net metering. which recently tried to phase-out net metering.

• Policy issues include whether the price assigned to this generated

energy should be above or below the retail rate.

• Alternatives include compensating consumers for the value of the

solar rate (“VOST”) of the extra energy.

25

Tax Credits

• Consumers may be eligible for energy-saving tax credits

depending on the nature of the credit contract.

• Providers may sell the Solar Renewable Energy Credits

(“SRECs”) to the utility.

• States/localities may offer tax credits or rebates for solar

usage.

• States/localities may impose monthly fees for solar usage

that negate potential rebates or credits.

• States may use tax credits to make up for lower net

metering benefits.

26

Scrutiny by State Regulators

• Even if the credit product is unsecured, solar providers

may file a UCC-1.

• The UCC filing is a public notice indicating that the solar

provider owns a piece of personal property attached to the real property. the real property.

• Regulators have expressed concern about whether those

fixture filings represent a lien on the real property.

– A lien could affect the consumer’s ability to obtain financing or sell the real property.

• Banks have successfully argued, in some foreclosure

proceedings, that the panels are fixtures.

27

FINANCING STRUCTURES

28

Partnership Flip Structure

OFFTAKER Energy INVESTOR DEVELOPER PROJECT CO. 99% / 5% 1% / 95% Energy Payments Other Project Contract Counterparties

• A portfolio of consumer contracts (typically, either leases and PPAs, or loans, but not both) is

financed with some combination of Developer equity, tax equity and debt.

29

financed with some combination of Developer equity, tax equity and debt.

– Tax equity investor acquires an interest in the project company for cash – Tax equity investor typically purchases “tranches” of projects that have achieved a level of development, but have not been placed-in-service for tax purposes – The Developer typically takes out “back-leverage” debt, secured by the Developer’s interest in Project Co., though in some cases tax equity investors have begun to permit debt at the Project Co. level, subject to forbearance rights

• Investor is initially allocated as much as 99% of tax items (ITC and depreciation) and

subsequently “flips” down to 5% after achieving a specified after-tax IRR.

• Cash may be distributed in the same manner that tax items are allocated, or Developer may

have a cash preference for some period.

• Developer generally has purchase option, either at a fixed time or after the later of the flip

point and a fixed time after the 5-year ITC recapture period has expired.

Sale-Leaseback Structure

PPA/energy payments sale/purchase price lease/rental payments DEVELOPER/ SPE (lessee) OFFTAKER INVESTOR (lessor)

• Project is sold by Developer to Investor and then immediately leased back

to Developer or more typically, an SPE-owned by Developer.

30

to Developer or more typically, an SPE-owned by Developer.

– Developer delivers power to offtaker via PPA.

• Investor as owner/lessor claims:

– ITC – Tax depreciation

• Developer as lessee retains option to purchase the project at the end of the

lease term (and sometimes at one or more specified times prior to the end

• f the term) at fair market value.

Pass-Thru Lease Structure

PPA/energy payments lease/rental payments O&M/O&M payments INVESTOR (lessee) DEVELOPER (lessor) OFFTAKER

• Project is leased by Developer to Investor and Developer makes election to

allow lessee to claim the investment tax credit.

31

allow lessee to claim the investment tax credit.

– Lease may be prepaid or monetized by financing lease stream. – Developer operates the project on behalf of Investor pursuant to an operation & maintenance agreement (“O&M”). – Investor delivers power to offtaker via PPA.

• Developer as owner/lessor claims tax depreciation.
• Investor as lessee claims tax deductions for rental payments in lieu of tax

depreciation.

• Project automatically reverts to Developer at the end of the lease term.

MITIGATING RISKS

32

Mitigating Risks

• Due diligence:

– Licensing – Compliance with applicable laws – Compliance management system (board and management

• versight, consumer complaints, training, policies and
• versight, consumer complaints, training, policies and

procedures, vendor management) – Consumer-facing documents – Provider due diligence of program sponsors/contractors selling the financing products

• Consumer satisfaction certificates/surveys
• Enforceable arbitration agreements
• Indemnities

33

QUESTIONS?

34

Mayer Brown is a global legal services provider comprising legal practices that are separate entities (the "Mayer Brown Practices"). The Mayer Brown Practices are: Mayer Brown LLP and Mayer Brown Europe-Brussels LLP, both limited liability partnerships established in Illinois USA; Mayer Brown International LLP, a limited liability partnership incorporated in England and Wales (authorized and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority and registered in England and Wales number OC 303359); Mayer Brown, a SELAS established in France; Mayer Brown Mexico, S.C., a sociedad civil formed under the laws of the State of Durango, Mexico; Mayer Brown JSM, a Hong Kong partnership and its associated legal practices in Asia; and Tauil & Chequer Advogados, a Brazilian law partnership with which Mayer Brown is associated. Mayer Brown Consulting (Singapore) Pte. Ltd and its subsidiary, which are affiliated with Mayer Brown, provide customs and trade advisory and consultancy services, not legal services. "Mayer Brown" and the Mayer Brown logo are the trademarks of the Mayer Brown Practices in their respective jurisdictions.