SLIDE 1
Should the government control what we eat?
Rachel Griffith 13 February 2018
1 / 28
Governments try to influence what people eat
2 / 28
Should the government control what we eat? Rachel Griffith 13 - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Should the government control what we eat? Rachel Griffith 13 - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Should the government control what we eat? Rachel Griffith 13 February 2018 1 / 28 Governments try to influence what people eat 2 / 28 Should the government tell people what to eat? Some people believe that the government should mind its
SLIDE 2
SLIDE 3
Should the government tell people what to eat?
◮ Some people believe that the government should mind its own
business
◮ let people decide for themselves
◮ Others argues that consumers need protection from themselves
and from outside temptation
◮ What should governments do and how can they do it?
3 / 28
SLIDE 4
If market functions well, people make appropriate trade-offs
4 / 28
SLIDE 5
Obesity is a world wide problem
5 / 28
Women Men
SLIDE 6
Obesity is a problem in the UK
6 / 28
SLIDE 7
Obesity has increased in the UK
7 / 28
SLIDE 8
Obesity is more common in poorer households
8 / 28
SLIDE 9
Obesity is more common in less educated households
9 / 28
SLIDE 10
Obesity has increased across all social classes
10 / 28
SLIDE 11
Obesity is also high in children
11 / 28
SLIDE 12
Obesity is more common in the most deprived areas
12 / 28
SLIDE 13
Obese children become obese adults
13 / 28
SLIDE 14
What are the consequences of these bad choices? Externalities
14 / 28
SLIDE 15
What are the consequences of these bad choices? Internalities
15 / 28
ւ ց
SLIDE 16
Why are people making bad choices? They lack information?
16 / 28
SLIDE 17
Why are people making bad choices? Cognitive overload?
17 / 28
SLIDE 18
Why are people making bad choices? Lack of self-control?
18 / 28
20 40 60 80 100 Google search intensity: diet 01jan2013 01jan2014 01jan2015 01jan2016 01jan2017 US UK
SLIDE 19
Why are people making bad choices? Advertising?
19 / 28
SLIDE 20
How do policies aim to correct these problems?
20 / 28
information: cognitive overload: self-control: advertising:
SLIDE 21
How effective are policies?
Evaluation methods help us understand which policies are effective:
◮ how do consumers respond? which consumers respond? ◮ how do firms respond? ◮ we can look at a policy reform, identify a control group, and
compare outcomes before and after the policy is implement in the “treatment” and in the “control” group
◮ ex post analysis
◮ we can also use economic theory to help us figure out both what
will happen if the policy is implemented and what will happen in the absence of the policy (i.e. what will happen to both the “treatment” and the “control” group)
◮ ex ante analysis 21 / 28
SLIDE 22
Example of an ex post analysis
Impact of introduction of tax on sugar-sweetened beverages in Berkeley CA
22 / 28
SLIDE 23
Example of an ex ante analysis
Likely impact of a soda tax in the UK
23 / 28
SLIDE 24
Example of an ex ante analysis of how firms respond
◮ Advertising of crisps
◮ lowers people’s willingness to pay for healthier products ◮ lowers their price sensitivity ◮ encourages people to switch to larger pack sizes ◮ banning advertising would lead consumer to reduce crisps
consumption by around 15%
◮ The offsetting effects of firms’ response
◮ banning advertising makes consumers more responsive to prices ◮ this intensifies competition in prices ◮ prices in the market would fall by 4% on average ◮ in equilibrium the effect of the advertising ban is to lower demand
for potato chips by around 10%
24 / 28
SLIDE 25
Potential additional confounding factors
25 / 28
SLIDE 26
Potential additional confounding factors from a ban on advertising unhealthy foods
26 / 28
SLIDE 27
Group topics and presentations
◮ 10 minutes to come up with key bullet points
- 1. Should the government use policy to try to influence people’s food
choices?
- 2. Will banning advertising of junk foods reduce consumption of junk
foods and so improve health?
- 3. Will increasing the nutritional information on food packaging reduce
consumption of junk foods and so improve health?
- 4. Will welfare policies that transfer income to poor households help to
reduce obesity?
27 / 28
SLIDE 28
Wrap up
◮ Key points
◮ Where markets work well consumers make the best choices for
themselves and society more generally
◮ Where markets fail government intervention can improve things, but
it is important that the policy intervention works well and targets the market failure
◮ Understanding whether and how policy affects outcomes is what
economists do, it can be complicated, but we can often help guide better policy design
28 / 28