January 31 & February 1, 2015
Santa Monica Civic Auditorium
Community Workshop #2
Santa Monica Civic Auditorium Community Workshop #2 January 31 - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Santa Monica Civic Auditorium Community Workshop #2 January 31 & February 1, 2015 Introduction Today we will explore options for the Civic Auditorium and site. Workshop 1 September 27, 2014 Workshop 2: Site program & funding options
January 31 & February 1, 2015
Santa Monica Civic Auditorium
Community Workshop #2
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 3
Today we will explore options for the Civic Auditorium and site.
Workshop 3: Future vision
March 21, 2015
Workshop 2: Site program & funding options
Today, January 31, 2015 February 1, 2015
Workshop 1
September 27, 2014
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 4
The Civic is at the heart of a 10-acre site being considered for reuse into a mixed-use cultural district.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 5
from intimate to high-profile, including the Oscars.
historically landmarked in 2001
The Civic has a rich history.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 6
I-10 and the largely vacant Civic Center area have separated Downtown Santa Monica from Ocean Park for decades.
Downtown Santa Monica Ocean Park Civic Center District Interstate 10 Samohi
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 7
New open space, mixed-use housing and transit connections to Downtown LA have begun to revitalize the Civic Center District.
Civic Auditorium Civic Center Village Tongva Park Ken Genser Square New Expo Line Station
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 8
Re-imagining the Civic could complete the District and support its vibrancy.
Civic Auditorium Site
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 9
and retain artists.
events, with ongoing impacts possible.
increase density, although could create a vibrant arts and cultural district.
could have significant impacts on City finances.
Breathing life back into the Civic will have effects on its neighbors and the community as whole.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 10
Please go to your table.
There are some key considerations in planning an arts and cultural district:
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 11
The 10-acre site could accommodate a number of uses, but a significant portion of it is already committed.
New Early Childhood Education Center (ECEC) Existing Civic Auditorium Footprint
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 12
The Civic and ECEC have a combined footprint of 4 acres, leaving roughly 4.3 acres available after considering circulation.
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 Large Apartment Building Hotel Office Building Flexible Performance Space Museum Small Apartment Building Large Store Large Restaurant Artists or Rehearsal Space Educational Facility Small Music Venue Medium Store or Café Acres Needed
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 13
Similarly, parking will be a constraint to additional land uses; 500 spaces are already committed from the existing surface lot.
Possible Underground Parking Footprint (2,365 Spaces / 3 Levels) Might reach under Pico and 4th Streets
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 14
Some parking uses will have primarily daytime demand, allowing shared parking with nighttime uses, including the Civic.
100 200 300 400 500 Existing Committed Performing Arts Center Entertainment Complex Institutional Office Community Cultural Center Boutique Hotel Medium Apartment Bldg. Museum Destination Restaurant Small Music Venue Rehearsal Space Storefront Retail Spaces Required
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 15
Renovating the Civic or adding additional cultural uses to the site will have significant capital costs.
$0 $20 $40 $60 $80 $100 $120 Commercial Arts Complex Performing Art Center Community Cultural Campus Flexible Performance Space Small Music Venue Rehearsal Space Fine Arts Museum Experiential Museum Artists Space Educational Facility Capital Costs ($Millions)
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 16
Those uses will also have significant annual operating costs, and may not be fully covered by earned income and philanthropy.
$0 Commercial Arts Complex Performing Art Center Community Cultural Campus Flexible Performance Space Small Music Venue Rehearsal Space Fine Arts Museum Experiential Museum Artists Space Educational Facility Operating Deficit ($Millions)
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 17
$0 $10 $20 $30 $40 $50 Restaurant or Small Store Storefronts Small Office Destination Retail Small Apartment Building Office Cluster Medium Apartment Building Larger Apartment Building Larger Office Building Boutique Hotel National Flag Hotel Capital Contribution ($ Millions)
Private land uses could help subsidize capital costs for public facilities through a combination of ground lease and tax revenues.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 18
Today’s exercise will illustrate necessary tradeoffs between the public and private land use options. Physical Constraints
does each use take up?
does it require?
way to program the entire site?
Capital Constraints & Benefits
cost to build?
would it generate if it were built?
Operating Constraints
Monica provide an
for the Civic?
additional cultural uses?
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 19
This online tool will demonstrate possible components of a new mixed-use cultural district and their implications.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 20
There are 5 tabs; each represent a key decision.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 22
The Civic closed in 2012.
56-year old and unsafe building + Lack of funds for rehabilitation
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 23
Civic options were decided through an extensive public process led by the Civic Working Group that culminated in Workshop #1. Workshop #1
September 27, 2014
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 24
A sophisticated private operator could manage the Civic, drawing regional audiences, while providing community programming.
Entertainment/Arts Complex
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 25
A privately-operated Civic would cost roughly $93 million, assuming that an operator would fund some Furniture, Fixtures and Equipment (FF&E).
$0 $10 $20 $30 $40 $50 $60 $70 $80 $90 $100 $110 Capital Costs ($ Millions) Hard Costs Soft Costs FF&E Costs Contingencies Parking
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 26
The Civic could showcase Santa Monica’s creative community to a regional and local audience, with some commercial events.
Center for the Performing Arts
with some community programming
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 27
A Performing Arts Center would cost roughly $98 million, with significant costs for FF&E born by the city.
$0 $10 $20 $30 $40 $50 $60 $70 $80 $90 $100 $110 Capital Costs ($ Millions) Hard Costs Soft Costs FF&E Costs Contingencies Parking
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 28
The Civic could become a community arts and cultural campus, with programming for local adults, families and kids.
Arts and Cultural Campus
the visual and performing arts
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 29
A Community Arts and Culture campus would cost $104 million, with higher capital costs for both construction and FF&E than other options.
$0 $10 $20 $30 $40 $50 $60 $70 $80 $90 $100 $110 Capital Costs ($ Millions) Capital Costs Soft Costs FF&E Costs Contingencies Parking
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 30
Rehabilitating the Civic and building parking will be expensive in each scenario; but on an operating basis, there is variation.
$0 $1
Commercial Arts Complex Performing Art Center Community Cultural Campus
Operating Deficit ($ Millions) $0 $20 $40 $60 $80 $100 $120
Commercial Arts Complex Performing Art Center Community Cultural Campus
Capital Cost ($ Millions)
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 31
Differences in operating costs will mean that certain scenarios will ultimately have a significantly higher total cost in the long-term.
$0 $15 $30 $45 $60 $75 $90 $105 $120 $135 $150 Commercial Arts Complex Performing Art Center Community Cultural Campus 20-Year Cost (NPV, 2015 $ Millions)
Capital Cost Operating Cost
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 32
In each option, the Civic would offer different programming, catering to a range of regional to local audiences.
Entertainment/Arts Complex
entertainment
banquets
shows
programming required
Center for the Performing Arts
co-productions across a wide range of performing arts
programming required
Arts and Cultural Campus
productions in performing, visual and media arts
simultaneous events at different scales
conferences or trade shows
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 33
Which use of the Civic is the appropriate one?
Entertainment/Arts Complex
entertainment
audiences
to city
ticket tax
Center for the Performing Arts
high-quality events
audiences, showcasing the local creative community
profit entity
level of operating subsidy
Arts and Cultural Campus
profit entity or the City of Santa Monica
subsidy
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 34
You can chose one of these options in Tab 2 of the online tool.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 35
Please go to your table.
You have 20 minutes to discuss and choose your preferred Civic.
Key questions:
1. Which version of the Civic best combines and balances local and regional attractions? 2. What programming would you prefer in the Civic?
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 37
The third tab shows additional cultural and open space options for the Civic Auditorium site.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 38
Surface parking will be removed, and the entire site must be programmed with new cultural, private or open space uses.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 39
The site could accommodate additional cultural uses which would contribute to a vibrant cultural campus.
Flexible Performance / Event Space
Could accommodate almost any use.
Small Music Venue
Cabaret-style venue, could promote evening activity
Experiential Museum
Could focus on history, science, technology or another mission
Fine Arts Museum
Moderately-sized, world-class facility
Artists Space
Artistic incubator with gallery and rotating studios
Educational & Maker Facility
Creative space for adults and children
Rehearsal Space & “Hub”
Could support the needs of local artists and musicians
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 40
The Civic campus could support an additional flexible performance/event space, interacting with an adjacent plaza.
Flexible Performance/Event Space
theater, music, lectures, meetings, galas and events
Shown: ODC Theater Center / Mark Cavagnero Architects / Photo: Tim Griffith
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 41
A for-profit music venue, perhaps with an adjacent restaurant and bar would promote activity through the evening .
Small Music Venue
evening activities on the campus
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 42
A “Hub” facility could support the rehearsal needs of local artists, actors and musicians and provide space for local-non profits.
Rehearsal Space and “Hub”
Civic, studios & administrative space
Shown: Tannery Arts Studios / Mark Cavagnero Architects / Photo: Art Gray
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 43
A fine arts museum with a themed collection would contribute to the Civic’s cultural draw.
Fine Arts Museum
modern, classical or local art
person capacity for events
Shown: Oakland Museum of California / Mark Cavagnero Architects / Photo: Tim Griffith
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 44
An experiential museum would link art, science & technology.
Experiential Museum
technology or another mission
person capacity for events
Shown: Dark Side of the Moon Exhibition, SciARC Michael Maltzan Architecture, Inc.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 45
Santa Monica could support artists with an incubator space for as many 14 artists, including a moderately-sized gallery.
Artists Space
studios, gallery and common space.
events
Shown: Horn Center , Harvard Westlake School, Michael Maltzan Architecture, Inc.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 46
The Civic Auditorium site could include flexible creative and educational spaces for both digital and traditional media.
Educational and Maker Facility
space, digital media studio
Shown: Inner City Arts / Michael Maltzan Architecture, Inc. / Photo: Iwan Baan
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 47
Although none of these uses could subsidize the Civic, could they help create a vibrant arts and cultural district?
$0 $5 $10 $15 $20 $25 $30 Flexible Performance Space Small Music Venue Rehearsal Space Fine Arts Museum Experiential Museum Artists Space Educational Facility ($Millions) Capital Cost Operating Deficit
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 48
Any open space on the Civic Auditorium campus would have a significant amount of year-round programming.
to the vibrancy of a cultural district
Monica
equal to roughly 15% of
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 49
A very small open space on the Civic Auditorium site could be programmed in a number of ways.
Half-Acre Park
area
Shown: Simon and Helen Director Park / OLIN Photo by Jordan Schnitzer
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 50
A small open space could accommodate events and contribute to the vibrancy of the cultural campus.
One-Acre Park
park, plus more space for outdoor cultural programs and small events
Shown: Stanford University Li Ka Shing Center Tom Leader Studio / Photo by Bruce Damonte
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 51
A medium-sized open space could be programmed in a number of ways.
Two-Acre Park
park, plus potential for a demonstration garden and/or interactive public art installations
Shown: Stanford University Li Ka Shing Center Tom Leader Studio / Photo by Bruce Damonte
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 52
A large open space could be programmed in a number of ways but especially could host large outdoor events.
Four and ½-Acre Park
plus an entry feature and/or an outdoor performance area
Shown: Yerba Buena Gardens / MGA Partners Photo by Karl Nielsen
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 53
A sports field could provide playing space for community members and space on the sidelines for spectators.
Sports Field
Shown: Hillsboro, Oregon Park Photo by M.O. Stevens
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 54
You can chose one or more of these options in Tab 3 of the tool, but remember that land and parking are limited.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 55
Please go to your table.
You have 20 minutes to discuss and choose your preferred uses.
Key questions:
1. Which additional cultural uses could contribute most to creating a vibrant cultural district and what are the key implications of each? 2. What kind of open space best contributes to a cultural district?
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 57
The fourth tab shows private land uses that could contribute to a vibrant mixed-use site and fund the capital costs for the Civic.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 58
Private development may help cover the cost of retrofitting the Civic through a bond based on ground lease revenue & tax subvention.
Projected Tax Revenues from Private Land Uses
Ground Lease Revenue
(Property value without cost
Annual City Revenue
Revenue Bond to pay for Civic capital improvements
6% interest and 1.2 debt-coverage ratio
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 59
A number of these private land uses could fit on the site alongside the Civic and one or more additional cultural uses.
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 Large Apartment Building Hotel Office Building Flexible Performance Space Museum Small Apartment Building Large Store Large Restaurant Artists or Rehearsal Space Educational Facility Small Music Venue Medium Store or Café Acres Needed
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 60
$0 $10 $20 $30 $40 $50 Restaurant or Small Store Storefronts Small Office Destination Retail Small Apartment Building Office Cluster Medium Apartment Building Large Apartment Building Institutional Office Boutique Hotel National Flag Hotel Capital Contribution ($ Millions)
Some private land uses have a greater ability to fund a renovation of the Civic, new cultural facilities and open space.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 61
$0 $250 $500 $750 $1,000 $1,250 Destination Restaurant Café or Small Restaurant Small Office Building Storefront Restaurant Large Apartment Building Office Cluster Retail Small or Medium Apartment Institutional Office Boutique Hotel National Flag Hotel
Land uses with significant capital contributions, may have more “bang for your buck” per-square-foot of building footprint.
Capital Contribution PSF of Building Footprint
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 62
Storefront and destination retail could support a small amount of bonding capacity to rehabilitate the Civic.
Micro-Storefront
Storefront
Destination Retail
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 63
Restaurants would round out a cultural campus on the Civic site, but would not provide significant funds to the Civic.
Storefront Restaurant
Café or Small Restaurant
Destination Restaurant
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 64
Rental housing could provide affordable units and significant funding to rehabilitate the Civic.
40-Unit Building
175-Unit Building
65-Unit Building
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 65
Office buildings could provide significant funding to rehabilitate the Civic.
Small Office
Office Cluster
Larger Office
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 66
Hotels would provide the greatest amount of funding to rehabilitate the Civic.
Boutique Hotel
Midrange National Flag Hotel
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 67
You can chose a number of these options in Tab 4 of the online tool.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 68
Please go to your table.
You have 20 minutes to discuss and choose your preferred uses.
Key questions:
1. Which private land uses would contribute to a vibrant cultural district? 2. Which private land uses could best fund renovation of the Civic? 3. Which private land uses fit best within the neighborhood context?
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 70
The fifth tab presents funding options that could “Close the Gap” between costs and funding raised through private development.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 71
There are a number of financing techniques that could be used to fund both capital and operating expenses.
General Obligation Bond Ticket Tax Revenue Bond Capital Fundraising Campaign Air Rights Transfer General Fund Allocation Operating Philanthropy
Parking Revenue
Capital Funding Sources Operating Funding Sources Enhanced Infrastructure District Transient Occupancy Tax Historic Tax Credits Revenue Bond from Private Dev. Included as option Assumed More study req.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 72
The City of Santa Monica could issue two different types of bonds to cover costs not supported by private land uses.
General Obligation Bond
property owner of roughly $12 per $100,000 of value
payments from across the city
Revenue Bond (from Ticket Tax)
profit Civic use only
from ticket taxes at the Civic
fund Staples Center Construction
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 73
An intensive capital fundraising campaign could also raise funds to renovate the Civic.
Capital Fundraising Campaign
and cultural campus (Civic 3)
philanthropic organizations & private donations
and nationwide
Shown at right: Broad Stage & Edye Second Space Capital Campaign: $10 million (22% of total)
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 74
Operating costs for the Civic and associated public uses could be covered by the City’s budget or continuing philanthropy.
Annual General Fund Contribution
budget
be a citywide dedication of Transient Occupancy Tax (TOT)
Operating Philanthropy
non-profit uses
Arts/Entertainment center
comparable cultural facilities
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 75
You can chose one or more of these options in Tab 5 of the online tool.
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 76
Please go to your table.
You have 20 minutes to discuss and choose your preferred funding options.
Key questions:
1. Will your choices pay for all of the capital and operating costs? 2. Do you believe there would be enough public support for a General Obligation bond that requires a 2/3 majority vote? 3. Do you believe that this project could attract significant support from the local and regional philanthropic community?
HR&A Advisors, Inc. Santa Monica Civic Auditorium | 77
Please go to your table.