Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Rhode Island Stormwater Design and Installations Standards Manual - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Rhode Island Stormwater Design and Installations Standards Manual - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Rhode Island Stormwater Design and Installations Standards Manual Public Workshop Acceptable Water Quality BMPs and S election Criteria January 13, 2011 Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Water Quality BMPs Larger
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Community Planning LID Site Design LID BMPs Larger Conventional BMPs Receiving Waters
Water Quality BMPs
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
3.2.3 Minimum Standard 3: Water Quality
- The WQv must be treated by at least one of the
structural BMPs listed in Chapter Five at each location where a discharge of stormwater will occur.
- Minimum average pollutant removal efficiencies: 85%
removal of total suspended solids (TS S ), 60% removal of pathogens, 30% removal of total phosphorus (TP) for discharges to freshwater systems, and 30% removal of total nitrogen (TN) for discharges to saltwater or tidal systems.
- Excludes LID credits allowed under S
ection 4.6
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Acceptable BMPs
- 5.2 Wet Vegetated Treatment S
ystems (WVTS )
- 5.3 S
tormwater Infiltration Practices
- 5.4 Permeable Paving
- 5.5 Filtering S
ystems
- 5.6 Green Roofs
- 5.7 Open Channel S
ystems
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Minimum Design Criteria
- Required Elements and Design Guidance
– If required elements can’ t be met, select a different BMP
- S
ix Categories
– Feasibility – Conveyance – Pretreatment – Treatment – Landscaping – Maintenance
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Wet Vegetated Treatment S ystems
- Designed t o st ay wet !
- Veget at ion –key component
- S
- me rest rict ions near coldwat er st reams
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Gravel WVTS
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Gravel WVTS
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Infiltration
- S
- il t est ing required
- S
eparat ion t o S HGT and bedrock
- Rest rict ions in fill
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Permeable Paving
- Two main cat egories
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Porous Pavements
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Permeable Pavers
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Filtering Practices
Sand/organic filters Bioretention areas/Tree filters
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Sand Filters
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Bioretention
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Bioretention Schematic
Planting Soil - Primarily Sand Underdrain System Vegetation on Surface Vegetation on Surface Runoff
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Bioretention Planting Soil and Mulch
- Loamy S
and to a S andy Loam – 85-88 % sand – 8-12 % silt – 0-2 % clay
- Well-aged graded compost (25%
- f soil mix)
- Layer of well-aged, shredded hardwood mulch (aged 6
months, if possible)
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Bioretention –Many Applications
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Tree pits
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Green Roofs
Extensive Intensive
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Open Channels
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Dry Swale
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Wet Swale
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Swales
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Practices Approved for Other Criteria
- S
torage Practices – Chapter 7
S
tormwater Basins
Underground
S torage Devices
- Pretreatment Practices
– Chapter 6
Grass Channel Filter S
trips
S
ediment Forebay
Deep S
ump Catch Basins
Proprietary Devices
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
- II. S
electing the Most Effective and Appropriate S tormwater Practices
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
- 1. Land Use
- 2. Physical Feasibility
- 3. Watershed
- 4. S
tormwater Management Capability
- 5. Community and Environmental
Five Selection Factors to Consider
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
#1. Land Use
The land use of the contributing drainage area influences the stormwater strategy:
- Rural areas
- Residential sites
- Roads/ highways
- Commercial sites
- LUHPPLs
- Urban sites
(e.g., redevelopment)
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Cul-de-Sac Application
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Commercial Application
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Municipal Application
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Retrofit Application
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
# 2. Physical Feasibility
S
- me Practices Cannot Be Used Because of S
ite Constraints:
- S
- ils
- Groundwater
- Drainage Area
- Minimum S
urface Area
- S
lope Restriction
- Head
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Wet Swale
- Used when water
table is close to surface
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
#3. Watershed Factors
Different Receiving Water Management Obj ectives S hape S tormwater S trategies:
- Groundwater (Aquifer protection)
- Freshwater streams and Rivers
- Other Freshwaters (Ponds/ Lakes/ Wetlands)
- Coastal Waters (shellfish/ beach areas
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
#4. Stormwater Management Capability
No single practice achieves all stormwater management obj ectives. A combination of practices is often needed to provide desired level of:
- Groundwater recharge
- Water quality treatment
- Channel protection
- Flood control
- Ability to treat LUHPPLs
To Offline Facility for Water Quality Treatment To Discharge Pipe
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
#5. Community and Environmental Impacts
Other community and environmental impacts should be considered when selecting BMPs:
- Ease of maintenance
- Affordability
- Community acceptance/
aesthetics
- S
afety
- Habitat
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
S tormwater Practice Maintenance Burden
Maintenance Burden is a function of the type
- f facility as well as the design and
implementation
- WVTS
- Medium to Easy
- Infiltration* ---------
Medium to Difficult
- Filters --------------
Medium to Difficult
- Green Roofs ---------
Medium
- Open Channels ------------
Medium to Easy *Except drywells - Easy
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.
Pollutant Removal Capability
Important when higher removals are required (see list in S ection 3.2.3). Table H-3/H-4 compares removal efficiencies for:
- Total S
uspended S
- lids
- Total Phosphorus
- Total Nitrogen
- Bacteria
Horsley W itten Group, I nc. Horsley W itten Group, I nc.