www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Repeatable Mental Health Bedrooms The Radisson Blu Portman Hotel
25th March 2015
Repeatable Mental Health Bedrooms The Radisson Blu Portman Hotel 25 - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Repeatable Mental Health Bedrooms The Radisson Blu Portman Hotel 25 th March 2015 www.procure21plus.nhs.uk Delivering Cost Reduction through Standardisation Roll-Out of Repeatable Rooms and Standard Components 25 th March 2015
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Repeatable Mental Health Bedrooms The Radisson Blu Portman Hotel
25th March 2015
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Delivering Cost Reduction through Standardisation
Roll-Out of Repeatable Rooms and Standard Components
25th March 2015
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Introduction and Welcome
David Kershaw
PSCP Programme Director
Agenda
Agenda
Agenda
Housekeeping
DH – Leading the nation’s health and care
Ray Stephenson
ProCure21+ National Framework Programme Lead
Finance and NHS Directorate 25.03.15
9 DH – Leading the nation’s health and care
Government Construction Strategy
DH and the Principal Supply Chain Partners
Projects
components and discount/bulk buying
10 10 DH – Leading the nation’s health and care
11 11 DH – Leading the nation’s health and care
Your Challenge
12 12 DH – Leading the nation’s health and care
The Future
Facilities Management
further savings both Cap Ex and Op Ex
including sharing designs more widely in the healthcare sector
13 13 DH – Leading the nation’s health and care
Beyond 2016
P22
events June/July
and Standard Components within P22 framework
14 14 DH – Leading the nation’s health and care
Today
A lot of work has gone into this day
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk/club
DH – Leading the nation’s health and care
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
NHS Trust Address
Duane Passman
3T s Project Director
ProCure 21+ Cost Reduction Programme USING REPEATABLE ROOMS AND STANDARDISED COMPONENTS FOR MENTAL HEALTH Duane Passman Director of 3Ts Brighton & Sussex University Hospitals NHS Trust Visiting Professor, MARU, London South Bank University 25 March 2015
Reflecting on the past:
Harness/Nucleus/”Best Buy” – Standardisation Seen as a straightjacket and not an opportunity;
The pressure on mental health services can only intensify.
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Cost Reduction Journey
Alan Kondys
PSCP Lead - IHP
The Challenge
Construction Strategy
Our Response
programme
solutions
& Components
Cost Manager
LEADERSHIP
Programme Manager
Our Committed Response
All 6 PSCPs Working together with DH, Supply Chain and Industry
Core Teams
Today’s car is 50% cheaper
and… Better quality, more reliable and safer Standardisation - The Principles...
How this has been achieved…
Standardisation with continuous improvement
Reuse of designs and components with mechanisation Standardisation - The Principles...
Choice to suit our requirements and budget Choice to suit our requirements and budget
Kit Car
£25,000+
Seat Leon
£18,490
Skoda Fabia
£13,670
VW Golf
£20,500
Standardisation - The Principles... We are putting this Principle into Practice for NHS facilities
Unique but expensive – reliability?
These all use the same main components Only what we interface with differs – we choose
Repeatable Room Design
Room Specification Operating Policy Literature/ Research Review Evidence Matrix Patient Focus Group Previous Scheme Designs Peer Review In-Use Review Post Project Evaluation Supplier Development
Development Process
Specification Operational Policy Literature Review Evidence M atrix Patient Group Design Assessments Peer Review
Applies to all Rooms & Designs
Design
Published Work
P21+ Club website
Guidance
Development Work
Reports Literature reviews Assessment Schedules
Updated & New Framework Documents
Charter Works Information Procurement Strategy Guidance Note 19 & 20
NHS England & TDA Business Case checklists
Published Work
P21+ Club website
Standard Share
Standard Materials & Components:
Soft & Hard Flooring Suspended Ceilings Doors & Ironmongery Lighting Sanitary Ware Fire & Smoke Dampers Bedhead Services Radiant Panels Ceiling Hoists Paint
What have we achieved
14 Standard Rooms Developed & Validated: Acute
Primary/Acute
Mental Health
INNOVATION INTEGRATION AND COLLABORATIVE WORKING
iPad App
What we are doing now and in the future
Emergency Department Rooms:
Review Feasibility & Benefits for :
Standard Components
Repeatable Rooms in Use
– Doncaster – Chase Farm – Addenbrookes – Basildon – Oxleas
Repeatable Rooms in Use
– Wrightington, Wigan and Leigh
– Lymes Wards 112 & 113, Royal Stoke University
Hospital
Repeatable Rooms in Use
– Lilac Ward, Scarborough Hospital
– Lymes Wards 110 & 111, Royal Stoke University
Hospital
34
How you will benefit
COM M ERCIAL TECHNICAL
Off the shelf solutions-ready for use Off the shelf solutions-ready for use
Compliant designs and products Compliant designs and products Endorsed by Department of Health Endorsed by Department of Health Quicker design period Quicker design period
Significant savings
Designs Significant savings
Designs
Benchmarked Costs Benchmarked Costs Supporting the Government Construction Strategy Supporting the Government Construction Strategy Helps you deliver real savings Helps you deliver real savings Use on New build and refurbished projects Use on New build and refurbished projects Value for Money Value for Money
Helping you achieve your savings targets & improve your business Can you afford not to?
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Repeatable Mental Health Bedrooms
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Functional Mental Health Bedroom
Fabia Holt/ Rosemary Jenssen
What are the repeatable mental health bedrooms?
What they are: For two care groups:
What they are not:
physical nursing needs
bariatric requirements
Literature Review
design
Architecture Research Unit)
Evidence Based Matrix
Personalisation Unit Size Day Lighting Personal Storage Artifical Lighting Artwork Reduce Violence & Aggression
Openness & Sight Lines Personal Space & Privacy Anti-ligature Measures Patient Experience Staff Experience Fixtures & Fittings Location of the bedroom Residential Character Window Specification Door & Handle Specification Temperature Ventilation Acoustics Environmental Comfort Outlook Design Principles
Mental Health Survey
Patient Workshop: Mental Fight Club
compliant design features:-
recommendations:-
M H functional single bedroom en-suite – key drivers
En-suite sh/ wc En-suite sh/ wc Sleep/ rest Sleep/ rest Work/ play storage storage support recovery entry entry
M H functional single bedroom – layout parameters
Bedroom design inc l staff / ther apeutic featur e s E n-suite design featur es
Ne t ro o m are a (sqm) Cle arwidth Cle arde pth Be d po sitio n Sig ht-line fro m do o r Wo rk spac e Sto rag e pro visio n Pe rso nalisatio n / artwo rk T e c hno lo g y Ce iling he ig ht Windo w size + o pe ratio n Do o rtype Do o r size + o pe ratio n Ne t ro o m are a (sqm) Duc t are a (sqm) L
Co nstruc tio n in-situ/ po d Do o rtype do o rsize , o pe ratio n + lo c k- bac k
M H Functional bedroom assessments
M H functional bedroom en-suite – 2 arrangements In-board with sight-line splay Parallel/ nested
M H functional bedroom in-board en-suite – room testing
featur es:-
100% sig ht-line , mo r e be d po sitio ns, e ffic ie nt fo o tprint, te ste d o bse rvatio n re c e ss de pth
M H functional bedroom en-suite – model test
T echnical Workshop
– Support for work on
storage
– En-suite arrangement:
– Standard brief
level of risk?
and testing
control
– Flexibility: baseline for
forensic bedroom?
M H functional bedroom en-suite – 2 arrangements In-board with sight-line splay Parallel/ nested
enhanc ed design featur es:-
We ig ht se nsitive do o r , sliding o r po c ke t do o rs to e n-suite , hig he r c e iling , windo w se at, fitte d furniture , artwo rk, o ppo rtunity fo r pe rso nalisatio n
featur es:-
100% sig ht-line , 2 be d po sitio ns, e ffic ie nt fo o tprint, re duc e d c o rrido r le ng th
M H functional bedroom en-suite – in-board
En- suite sh/ wc En- suite sh/ wc Sleep/ rest Sleep/ rest Work/ play
storage storagesupport recovery
entry entry
bedroom, 11.8sqm en-suite, 3.1 sqm duct, 0.4sqm
M H functional bedroom mock up@ Thorlux show room, 30:10:14
M H functional bedroom mock up@ Thorlux show room, 30:10:14
M H functional bedroom mock up@ Thorlux show room, 30:10:14
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Furniture Arrangements
MH bedroom storage test - triangular
MH bedroom storage test – rectangular high level
MH bedroom storage test – rectangular low level
Patient Workshop: Mental Fight Club
– Bed position – Furniture – Storage – Colour
featur es:-
Mo dular o ptio ns, sing le fixe d ro o m de sig n, 4 be d po sitio ns
M H functional bedroom – modularised fitted furniture
MH functional bedroom - Aerial view Rectangular furniture option with peninsula bed
MH functional bedroom - perspective view from window Rectangular furniture option peninsula bed
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Break, Exhibition and Video
Return 11:30
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Organic Mental Health Bedroom
Pat Pemberton/ Rosemary Jenssen
HBN compliance- HBN 35
Size: Bedrooms with en-suites- but no showers 17m2 5.46 Single rooms, with en-suite WC and washing facilities are
person sitting on a chair. The en-suite facilities will need to have wheelchair access. 5.47 The bedroom may be furnished with a variable height bed and general type bed head services but piped oxygen and suction are not required. An emergency call system is required. The room will also require a bedside locker, a chair of appropriate height and storage for clothes.
What are the needs?
home
Literature Review and Workshops
Group
compliant design features:-
recommendations:-
M H organic single bedroom en-suite – key drivers
En-suite sh/ wc En-suite sh/ wc Sleep/ rest Sleep/ rest Work/ play storage storage support recovery entry entry
Bedroom design inc l therapeutic / nursing featur es E n-suite design featur es
Ne t ro o m are a (sqm) Cle arwidth Cle arde pth Be d po sitio n Sig ht-line fro m do o r Wo rk spac e Sto rag e pro visio n Pe rso nalisatio n / me mo ry bo x artwo rk Ce iling he ig ht Windo w size + o pe ratio n Do o rtype Do o r size + o pe ratio n Ne t ro o m are a (sqm) Duc t are a (sqm) L
Sig ht-line be d to wc Co nstruc tio n in-situ/ po d, g rabrails Door type do o rsize , o pe ratio n + lo c k- bac k
M H Older Adult/ Organic bedroom assessments
M H organic bedroom in-board en-suite – room testing
T echnical Workshop
– Size of the en-suite in
relation to assistance
– Single leaf entrance door
– Standard brief
we designing for?
– Flexibility: baseline for
forensic bedroom?
Organic in-board en-suite
Increased length by 275mm Increased depth by 200mm whb shower chair 1010mm s.o. doorsetassistance on and off wc, with two staff 1. 2. 3. adjustments made to organic en-suite post technical workshop layout pre and post workshop
featur es:-
100% sig ht-line , e ffic ie nt fo o tpr int, fo ur be d po sitio ns, sig ht-line to wc
M H organic bedroom in-board en-suite
En- suite sh/ wc En- suite sh/ wc Sleep/ rest Sleep/ rest Work/ play
storage storagesupport recovery
entry entry
bedroom, 14.3sqm en-suite, 3.8 sqm duct, 0.4sqm bay, 0.6 sqm
Organic nested en-suite
whb shower chair 1010mm s.o. doorsetassistance on and off wc, with two staff 1. 2. New layout nested en-suite post technical workshop
featur es:-
Shallo we r plan de pth, two be d po sitio ns, se ating are a within c o rrido r
M H organic bedroom nested en-suite
En- suite sh/ wc En- suite sh/ wc Sleep/ rest Sleep/ rest Work/ play
storage storagesupport recovery
entry entry
bedroom, 13.8sqm en-suite, 3.8 sqm duct, 1.3 sqm bay, 0.6 sqm
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Furniture Arrangements
featur es:-
100% sig ht-line , e ffic ie nt fo o tprint, fo ur be d po sitio ns, sig ht-line to wc
M H organic bedroom – modularised furniture
MH organic inboard en-suite bedroom - Aerial view T allboyfurniture option with peninsula bed
MH organic inboard en-suite bedroom – perspective view T allboy furniture option with peninsula bed
featur es:-
100% sig ht-line , shallo we r plan de pth, lo ng e r c o rrido r, two be d po sitio ns, sig ht-line to wc
M H organic bedroom – modularised furniture
MH organic nested en-suite bedroom - Aerial view T allboy furniture option with peninsula bed
MH organic nested en-suite bedroom - perspective view T allboy furniture option with peninsula bed
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Standard Components
David Kershaw
PSCP Programme Director
“StandardShare”
– Hard Flooring – Suspended Ceilings – Doors – Lighting – Sanitary Ware – Fire Dampers – Partitions – AHUs – Pipework – Chillers – Bedhead Services – Radiant Panels – Ceiling Hoists – Paint
Benefits – Potential Savings
£30.24m, or c5.04%
(against typical market rates, and based on £600m total spend pa)
9 Month Savings
Airedale Buckland and Dover Croydon Darlington Memorial Hillingdon Leighton New Cross Nottingham University Rotherham Royal Stoke University Scarborough Southampton General St Bernards Stepping Hill The Walton Centre Worcester Royal Queen Elizabeth, Gateshead
MH Components Journey
– Multiple Suppliers – Varying specifications
Mental Health Components
Components
– Fire/ Smoke Dampers; Hard and Soft Flooring;
Sanitary Ware; Radiant Panels; Lighting Doors and Ironmongery; Windows; and Paint
– Furniture
Hard Flooring
Soft Flooring
Doors – Mental Health
– Arnold Laver; David Smith; Datim; Leaderflush;
Lloyd Worrall; and Safe Hinge
Lighting – Mental Health
Sanitary Ware – Mental Health
Radiant Panels
Paint
Windows
inspection/service
Skirting Heating
Fire/ Smoke Dampers
Pipework
echnical Guide
purchase cost and installation cost
Chillers
echnical Guide
27% CO2 emissions; and 36% annual energy cost savings
Air Handling Units
echnical Guide
27% CO2 emissions; 36% energy costs; and 40% size savings
Accessing StandardS hare
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk/ club/
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Target Cost Savings
Richard Venables
Interserve
The Challenge
Government Construction Strategy – Efficiency Agenda
Sharing good practice/ standardisation Innovation, changing culture, BIM , Govt soft landings Incentivising supply chain collaboration to provide value/ bulk buying Controlling scope & understanding what costs money Challenging time-scales M anaging expectations Reviewing performance Publishing cost analyses
20% savings required 14.1% savings proposed
Target Cost Savings
Room sizes?
similar to HBN
saving against HBN Efficiencies?
Focus on patient care
Repeatable Room Design
Room Specification Operating Policy Literature/ Research Review Evidence Matrix Patient Focus Group Previous Scheme Designs Peer Review In-Use Review Post Project Evaluation Supplier Development
Development Process
Specification Operational Policy Literature Review Evidence M atrix Patient Group Design Assessments Peer Review
Applies to all Rooms & Designs
Right solution first time
All rooms All designs Consistent Thorough
based
Quality Time!
Design / Consultation
Construction
chain
£1,425 cost saving for PSCP / PSCM team per room If take into account Trust (clinical and management) time this saving will more than double.
Components – benefits and savings
112
Up to 37% savings
Manufacturers
F ixed price duration, extended warranties, UK manufactured
Wholesalers
Up to40% savings
National, efficient call-off, any size scheme, F ixed price 2016
Guidance
Up to30% savings
S pecification clarity, understanding cost, technical design review
Specification
Up to32% savings
R ationalise door sets (15)
Lessons learnt
Investment Aggregate spend profile Collaboration with key suppliers Focussed resources Speed to market Understand the market Design led – ensure compliant specification Benchmark and review Best price not best discount Trusted relationships Communicate and market Innovate together
Client Benefits
PSCP Investment Baseline for local branding and adaption HBM compliant designs Evidence based Quicker delivery, right first time New NHS specific products Free research and development Efficient capital spend Reduced development time Removal of waste Realistic and robust Integrated working innovate together
The end result
115
Standardised components & design
certainty of time, cost, quality Whole life cost choices
saving > 5%
Benefit Standardisation
Up to 5% target cost saving: Area/ Design Better buying
Road to Savings
GCS14.1% target 20%+ Potential with: Stakeholder engagement S taff familiarity Supplier response Lifecycle
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Lunch, Exhibition and Video
Return 13:20
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Implementation
Gary Barnes
PSCP Lead - Kier
Where to implement
When to implement
Time Benefit
100% <0%
Think BIM
requirements (from StandardShare)
Adjacencies to meet Clinical Strategy
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Panel Q & A
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Work Group Sessions – Implementation Barriers
David Kershaw
PSCP Programme Director
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Break, Exhibition and Video
Return 14:30
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Work Group Sessions – Feedback
David Kershaw
PSCP Programme Director
DH – Leading the nation’s health and care
Ray Stephenson
ProCure21+ National Framework Programme Lead
Governance and Assurance Directorate 25.03.15
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Next Steps
Alan Kondys
PSCP Lead - IHP
Cost Reduction
Cost Reduction
Further Rooms & Components
Anyone interested in participating please contact David Kershaw
Continuous Improvement
= Enhanced standards on StandardShare
Ready to Go!
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Summary
David Kershaw
PSCP Programme Director
Thank you
www.procure21plus.nhs.uk
Close and Video
Thank you!