random stepped surfaces Richard Kenyon (Yale) <latexit - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

random stepped surfaces
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

random stepped surfaces Richard Kenyon (Yale) <latexit - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

<latexit


slide-1
SLIDE 1

random stepped surfaces

the hidden geometry of

Richard Kenyon (Yale)

<latexit sha1_base64="nk+5qLntFDRdai6LVmbqo7DdQus=">AB/nicbVA9SwNBEN3zM8avU7GyWQxCbMJdLSgI1gE8V8SBLC3t4kWbK3e+zuCeEI+FdsLBSx9XfY+W/cS1Jo4oOBx3szMwLYs608bxvZ2l5ZXVtPbeR39za3tl19/brWiaKQo1KLlUzIBo4E1AzHBoxgpIFHBoBMOrzG8gtJMinsziqETkb5gPUaJsVLXPbxjdEBUiG9AjKTAxQfC4bTrFrySNwFeJP6MFNAM1a71Q4lTSIQhnKidcv3YtNJiTKMchjn24mGmNAh6UPLUkEi0J10cv4Yn1glxD2pbAmDJ+rviZREWo+iwHZGxAz0vJeJ/3mtxPQuOikTcWJA0OmiXsKxkTjLAodMATV8ZAmhitlbcRYGocYmlrch+PMvL5J6ueSflcq35ULlchZHDh2hY1REPjpHFXSNqiGKErRM3pFb86T8+K8Ox/T1iVnNnOA/sD5/AHpKZTI</latexit>
slide-2
SLIDE 2
slide-3
SLIDE 3

Here σ(s, t) = √ 1 + s2 + t2 is the “surface tension”.

<latexit sha1_base64="hbIWrsfLsami1o1nr8JwVmMHyEY=">ACKXicbVDLSgMxFM34tr6qLt0EW0FRykxd6EYpuHGpYFVoa82kd9pg5mHuHaEM/R03/obBUXd+iOmtQutHgczrk3yTl+ohWS6747Y+MTk1PTM7O5ufmFxaX8so5xqmRUJWxjs2lLxC0iqBKijRcJgZE6Gu48G+O+v7FHRhUcXRG3QaoWhHKlBSkJWa+coxGODFOqp2KDZxh7b4Aa/jraHM28ar8jZdlXvFnEJOHeDX15iaQEjgBFH/zvVSM19wS+4A/C/xhqTAhjhp5p/rVimIUQktUCseW5CjUwYUlJDL1dPERIhb0QbapZGIgRsZIOkPb5hlRYPYmNPRHyg/tzIRIjYDX07GQrq4KjXF/zaikF+41MRUlqk8nvh4JUc4p5vzbeUgYk6a4lQhpl/8plRxghyZabsyV4o5H/kvNydsteaflQuVwWMcMW2PrbJN5bI9V2DE7YVUm2T17ZC/s1Xlwnpw35+N7dMwZ7qyX3A+vwDVKSO</latexit>

min

h

ZZ

U

q 1 + h2

x + h2 y dx dy

<latexit sha1_base64="wxXfGoIhvdAleK9rAtgbGH8UMI=">ACFHicbVDLSsNAFJ34tr6iLt0MFkGolKSCuhLBjcsKVgtNDZPpxA5OJnHmRhpCd/6AGz/DbRe6UMStC3f+jdPHQq0H7nA4517u3BMkgmtwnC9rYnJqemZ2br6wsLi0vGKvrp3rOFWU1WgsYlUPiGaCS1YDoLVE8VIFAh2EVwf9/2LW6Y0j+UZAlrRuRK8pBTAkby7VLBi7j02x7nEvwa9vSNgtwtf3OZcW82Wl6+20OqYy3y46ZWcAPE7cESke7T317sLSY9W3P71WTNOISaCaN1wnQSaOVHAqWDdgpdqlhB6Ta5Yw1BJIqab+eCoLt4ySguHsTIlAQ/UnxM5ibTOosB0RgTa+q/XF/zGimEB82cyQFJulwUZgKDHuJ4RbXDEKIjOEUMXNXzFtE0UomBwLJgT378nj5LxSdnfL7qlJ4xANMYc20CbaRi7aR0foBFVRDVF0j3roBb1aD9az9Wa9D1snrNHMOvoF6+MbRDqhYQ=</latexit>

Minimize area:

<latexit sha1_base64="izy/JBD+GJHR3RdsQHqxbKt0pTk=">AB+HicbVDLSgMxFL3js9ZHR126CRbBVZmpC8WFNy4ESrYB7RDyaSZNjTJDElGaId+iRsXirj1U9z5N6btLT1QOBwzj3cmxMmnGnjed/O2vrG5tZ2Yae4u7d/UHIPj5o6ThWhDRLzWLVDrClnkjYM5y2E0WxCDlthaPbmd96okqzWD6acUIDgQeSRYxgY6WeWyreM8kEm1CEbe65a9ijcHWiV+TsqQo95zv7r9mKSCSkM41rje4kJMqwMI5xOi91U0wSTER7QjqUSC6qDbH74FJ1ZpY+iWNknDZqrvxMZFlqPRWgnBTZDvezNxP+8TmqiqyBjMkNlWSxKEo5MjGatYD6TFi+NgSTBSztyIyxAoTY7sq2hL85S+vkma14l9U/IdquXaT1GAEziFc/DhEmpwB3VoAIEUnuEV3pyJ8+K8Ox+L0TUnzxzDHzifP8Qhkn0=</latexit>

Re ✓Z f(z)(1 − g(z)2) dz, i Z f(z)(1 + g(z)2) dz, Z f(z)g(z)dz ◆

Weierstrass-Enneper parameterization of minimal surfaces

...

<latexit sha1_base64="eovm0ZYyi/sq4F9zpAzio2X0IQI=">AB63icbVBNS8NAEJ3Urxq/qh69LBbBU0jqQU9S8OKxgv2ANpTNdtMu3d2E3Y1Qv+CFw+KePUPefPfuGlz0NYHA4/3ZpiZF6WcaeP7305lY3Nre6e6+7tHxwe1Y5POjrJFKFtkvBE9SKsKWeStg0znPZSRbGIO1G07vC7z5RpVkiH80spaHAY8liRrApJNfzvGt7nv+AmidBCWpQ4nWsPY1GCUkE1QawrHW/cBPTZhjZRjhdO4OMk1TKZ4TPuWSiyoDvPFrXN0YZURihNlSxq0UH9P5FhoPROR7RTYTPSqV4j/ef3MxDdhzmSaGSrJclGcWQSVDyORkxRYvjMEkwUs7ciMsEKE2PjcW0IwerL6T8IrL3ho1Ju3ZRxVOINzuIQArqEJ9CNhCYwDO8wpsjnBfn3flYtlacuYU/sD5/AF/Oo0z</latexit>

Let f, g be (arbitrary) analytic functions, then

<latexit sha1_base64="+AHCS9uGeUF2GUbjUlJ7Xvh60=">ACGnicbVA9SwNBFNzM8avqKXNYhQUJNzFQisRbCwsIhgNxCDvNu+Sxb29Y/edcAR/h41/xcZCETux8d+4F1NodGBhmJn3ljdhqQl3/0JianpmdmS3Pl+YXFpeXKyuqFTIjsCkSlZhWCBaV1NgkSQpbqUGIQ4WX4c1x4V/eorEy0eUp9iJoadlJAWQk64rwSkS34x2e5s8RL4NJpRkwOQ7HDSonKTgUaZFEba7nProZqp+zR+C/yXBiFTZCI3ryvtVNxFZjJqEAmvbgZ9SZwDGLVd4V7KLKYgbqCHbUc1xGg7g+Fpd3zLKV0eJcY9TXyo/pwYQGxtHocuGQP17bhXiP957Yyig85A6jQj1OL7oyhTnBJe9MS70qAglTsCwsiCNEHA4Jcm2VXQjB+8l9yUa8Fe7X6Wb16dDiqo8TW2QbZgHbZ0fshDVYkwl2zx7ZM3vxHrwn79V7+45OeKOZNfYL3scXCf6fqg=</latexit>

parameterizes a minimal surface in R3.

<latexit sha1_base64="xI2UNgHmi4Qa9AtpXIwWkmig8=">ACHicbVDLTgIxFO3gC/GFunTCauyAwsdGVI3LhEI48EkHTKHWhoO5O2Y4ITPsSNv+LGhca4cWHi31hgFgqepMnJOfem5x4/4kwb1/12Miura+sb2c3c1vbO7l5+/6Chw1hRqNOQh6rlEw2cSagbZji0IgVE+Bya/uhy6jfvQWkWylszjqAryECygFirNTLVyKiADij2AxgQLJpkgHOtYBYQCZhIXk4gZuj7+GZyVymWevmCW3JnwMvES0kBpaj18p+dfkhjAdJQTrRue25kuglRhlEOk1wn1hAROiIDaFsqbSDdTWbHTfCJVfo4CJV90uCZ+nsjIULrsfDt5DSlXvSm4n9eOzbBeTdhMoNSDr/KIg5NiGeNoX7TAE1fGwJoYrZrJgObVvUlqVztgRv8eRl0iXvEqpfF0uVC/SOrLoCB2jU+ShM1RFV6iG6oiR/SMXtGb8+S8O/Ox3w046Q7h+gPnK8fqiWhBg=</latexit>

h : R2 → R

<latexit sha1_base64="FkXoPQ5IFkbwrfrxmUDmS+mhXlY=">ACBnicbVDLSgMxFM3UV62vUZciBIvgqsy0C8WFty4rGIf0BlLJk3b0EwyJBmhDF258VfcuFDEreAfuPNvzEy7qK0HAifn3Mu9wQRo0o7zo+VW1peWV3Lrxc2Nre2d+zdvYSscSkjgUTshUgRjlpK6pZqQVSYLCgJFmMLxK/eYDkYoKfqdHEfFD1Oe0RzHSRurYh4PzxAuRHgQBvB3flz0tZv4du+iUnAxwkbhTUrz8qmSodexvrytwHBKuMUNKtV0n0n6CpKaYkXHBixWJEB6iPmkbylFIlJ9kZ4zhsVG6sCekeVzDTJ3tSFCo1CgMTGW6oZr3UvE/rx3r3pmfUB7FmnA8GdSLGdQCpnALpUEazYyBGFJza4QD5BEWJvkCiYEd/7kRdIol9xKqXzjFKsXYI8OABH4AS4BRUwTWogTrA4BE8g1fwZj1ZL9a79TEpzVnTn3wB9bnL7dlmtY=</latexit>
slide-4
SLIDE 4

“Lozenge” tilings

<latexit sha1_base64="prc/w+MbpXs6SGiT/hNwQbGnME4=">AB+3icbVC7TsMwFHV4lvIKZWSxWiExVUkZYEKVWBgYikQfUhu1jnuTWnWcyHYQJeqvsDCAECs/wsbf4LYZoOVIVzo65173uMnCntON/W2vrG5tZ2Yae4u7d/cGgflVoqTiWFJo15LDs+UcCZgKZmkMnkUAin0PbH1/P/PYDSMVica8nCXgRCQULGCXaSH27NBjcxk8gQihjzcwroerbFafqzIFXiZuTCsrR6NtfvWFM0wiEpwo1XWdRHsZkZpRDtNiL1WQEDomIXQNFSQC5WXz3af41ChDHMTSlNB4rv6eyEik1CTyTWdE9EgtezPxP6+b6uDSy5hIUg2CLj4KUo51jGdB4CGTQDWfGEKoZGZXTEdEqpNXEUTgrt8ip1aruebV2V6vUr/I4CugEldEZctEFqMb1EBNRNEjekav6M2aWi/Wu/WxaF2z8plj9AfW5w+pIJQt</latexit>
slide-5
SLIDE 5

lozenge tilings are stepped surfaces

<latexit sha1_base64="ETFf3v2F7coyQGXgZl7fuhVdITg=">ACDXicbVC7SgNBFJ2NrxhfUubwShYhd1YaCUBG8sI5gFJCLOzd5Mhs7PLzF0hLvkBG3/FxkIRW3s7/8bJo9DEAxcO59w7c+/xEykMu63k1tZXVvfyG8WtrZ3dveK+wcNE6eaQ53HMtYtnxmQkEdBUpoJRpY5Eto+sPrid+8B21ErO5wlEA3Yn0lQsEZWqlXPJHxA6g+UBT2ib6hTAM1CEkCATWpDhkH0yuW3LI7BV0m3pyUyBy1XvGrE8Q8jUAhl8yYtucm2M2YRsEljAud1EDC+JD1oW2pYhGYbja9ZkxPrRLQMNa2FNKp+nsiY5Exo8i3nRHDgVn0JuJ/XjvF8LKbCZWkCIrPgpTSTGmk2hoIDRwlCNLGNfC7kr5gGnG0QZYsCF4iycvk0al7J2XK7eVUvVqHkeHJFjckY8ckGq5IbUSJ1w8kieySt5c56cF+fd+Zi15pz5zCH5A+fzB9qnAg=</latexit>

What happens for large system size?

<latexit sha1_base64="BewevTCbKpmUDwR2qkZiQIlA7g=">ACDHicbVC7TsNAEDzJrwClDQnIiSqyA4FVIBEQxk8pBChNaXdXzifLbu1kjBygfQ8Cs0FCBEywfQ8TdcHgWvqUYzs9rdCTMlLfn+pzczOze/sLi0XFpZXVvfKG9uNW2aG4ENkarUtEOwqKTGBklS2M4MQhIqbIU3ZyO/dYvGylRf0iDbgJ9LSMpgJx0Xa60YiAeQ5ahtjxKDVdg+sjtwBIm3Mo7PHEpv+qPwf+SYEoqbIr6dfnjqpeKPEFNQoG1ncDPqFuAISkUDktXucUMxA30seOohgRtxg/M+R7TumNL4lSTXysfp8oILF2kIQumQDF9rc3Ev/zOjlFR91C6iwn1GKyKMoVp5SPmuE9aVCQGjgCwkh3KxcxGBDk+iu5EoLfL/8lzVo1OKjWLmqV0+NpHUtsh+2yfRawQ3bKzlmdNZhg9+yRPbMX78F78l69t0l0xpvObLMf8N6/AEXAmxs=</latexit>
slide-6
SLIDE 6

Dimer cover of a graph: perfect matching of the vertices.

The Dimer Model

slide-7
SLIDE 7

Dimers on honeycomb lattice

<latexit sha1_base64="ItMjMLZMgSuLrlCO2U1brJeV3ys=">ACBHicbVC7SgNBFJ2NrxhfUcs0g0GwCrux0EoCWlhGMA9IQpid3CRD5rHMzArLksLGX7GxUMTWj7Dzb5wkW2jigQuHc+6dufeEWfG+v63l1tb39jcym8Xdnb39g+Kh0dNo2JNoUEV7odEgOcSWhYZjm0Iw1EhBxa4eR65rceQBum5L1NIugJMpJsyCixTuoXSzdMOBsricdKQkKVCDEn1jIK/WLZr/hz4FUSZKSMtT7xa/uQNFYgLSUE2M6gR/ZXkq0e43DtNCNDUSETsgIOo5KIsD0vkRU3zqlAEeKu1KWjxXf0+kRBiTiNB1CmLHZtmbif95ndgOL3spk1FsQdLFR8OY6vwLBE8YBqo5YkjhGrmdsV0TDSh1gVTcCEyevkma1EpxXqnfVcu0qiyOPSugEnaEAXaAaukV1EAUPaJn9IrevCfvxXv3PhatOS+bOUZ/4H3+AIjKmAI=</latexit>
slide-8
SLIDE 8

Thm[Kasteleyn 1965] For G a part of the honeycomb graph, let K be the bipartite adjacency matrix, Kwb = ( 1 b ∼ w else. Then | det K| is the number of dimer covers.

<latexit sha1_base64="KRK7tE8CPWSOZ0uBWN3O6fnEZsg=">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</latexit>

Example: K is 12 × 12; det K = 20.

<latexit sha1_base64="3P0Ke3FwLXCuJxC+RJ75PBsUKU=">ACF3icbVDJSgNBEO1xjXGLevRSmBE8DTPjQVGUgAiCFwUThSEnk5FG3sWumvEPwL/6KFw+KeNWbf2NnObg9KHi8V0VvShT0pDvfzpj4xOTU9OFmeLs3PzCYmlpuWbSXAusilSl+iLiBpVMsEqSF5kGnkcKTyPrg/6/vkNaiPT5Iy6GTZjfpnIjhScrNQqeYe3PM4U7oB7I04AZhg2SMBoLQ3QW30UaCY4A9CH3Xa5XKvucPAH9JMCJlNsJq/TRaKcijzEhobgx9cDPqNnjmqRQeFds5AYzLq75JdYtTbjd3OwN/rqDdau0oZNqWwnBQP0+0eOxMd04sp0xpyvz2+uL/3n1nDrbzZ5MspwEcNFnVwBpdAPCdpSoyDVtYQLe2tIK645oJslEUbQvD75b+kFnrBphehuXK/iOAltla2yDBWyLVdgRO2FVJtg9e2TP7MV5cJ6cV+dt2DrmjGZW2A84718RuJrK</latexit>
slide-9
SLIDE 9

Proof:

<latexit sha1_base64="4zhldmrWqy7xCzTZ2/K3bXL3BL0=">AB83icbVBNSwMxEJ34WetX1aOXYBE8ld16UDxIwYvHCvYDukvJptk2NJsSVYoS/+GFw+KePXPePfmLZ70NYHA4/3ZpiZF6WCG+t532htfWNza7u0U97d2z84rBwdt43KNGUtqoTS3YgYJrhkLcutYN1UM5JEgnWi8d3M7zwxbiSj3aSsjAhQ8ljTol1UpAHUYybWqn4ZtqvVL2aNwdeJX5BqlCg2a98BQNFs4RJSwUxpud7qQ1zoi2ngk3LQWZYSuiYDFnPUkSZsJ8fvMUnztlgGOlXUmL5+rviZwkxkySyHUmxI7MsjcT/N6mY2vw5zLNLNM0sWiOBPYKjwLA+4ZtSKiSOEau5uxXRENKHWxVR2IfjL6+Sdr3mX9bqD/Vq47aIowSncAYX4MVNOAemtACik8wyu8oQy9oHf0sWhdQ8XMCfwB+vwBqwGRbA=</latexit>

det K = X

σ∈Sn

(−1)σkw1bσ(1)kw2bσ(2) . . . kwnbσn

<latexit sha1_base64="6W7xRXHkvN94q+lQCEpBA1kHdUk=">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</latexit>
slide-10
SLIDE 10

Large random tilings seem to have a “shape”

<latexit sha1_base64="9j37agNs3omgpdVgeUxhok0jGzU=">ACFXicbVC7SgNBFJ2Nrxhfq5Y2Q4JgIWE3FlpJwMbCIoJ5QBKSu5ObZMjs7DIzGwghP2Hjr9hYKGIr2Pk3Th6FJh4YOHPuY+acIBZcG8/7dlJr6xubW+ntzM7u3v6Be3hU0VGiGJZJCJVC0Cj4BLhuBtVghIHAajC4mdarQ1SaR/LBjGJshtCTvMsZGCu13PM7UD2kCmQnCqnhdk9PU41oLxHtwxAp0HZb9yHGbMvNeXlvBrpK/AXJkQVKLfer0YlYEqI0TIDWd+LTXMynAmcJpJBpjYAPoYd1SCSHq5njmakJPrdKh3UjZIw2dqb8nxhBqPQoD2xmC6evl2lT8r1ZPTPeqOeYyTgxKNn+om4ip4WlEtMVMiNGlgBT3P6Vsj4oYMYGmbEh+MuWV0mlkPcv8oX7Qq54vYgjTU5IlpwRn1ySIrklJVImjDySZ/JK3pwn58V5dz7mrSlnMXNM/sD5/AEw1J4s</latexit>
slide-11
SLIDE 11

A typical surface lies close to a certain nonrandom surface

<latexit sha1_base64="YZE4hjTPWCBbOq/G5fDEB8UzMy0=">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</latexit>
slide-12
SLIDE 12

Thm[Cohn,K,Propp (2000)] The function h : R → R describing the limit shape is the unique minimizer of the surface tension integral

Lozenge tiling limit shape

min

h

ZZ

R

σ(hx, hy) dx dy

<latexit sha1_base64="JC5oRbucZO+EsKz9LN7x/J9leqE=">ACD3icbVA9SwNBEN2LX/H8OrW0WQxKxBDuFNRKAjaWKsYEcuHY2+zluzuHbt74nHYWdr4RyxsLBSxtbXz37hJLPx6MPB4b4aZeWHKqNKu+2GVJianpmfKs/bc/MLikrO8cqGSTGLSxAlLZDtEijAqSFNTzUg7lQTxkJFWODga+q1LIhVNxLnOU9LlqC9oRDHSRgqcTdvnVASxT6nQwRn0Fe1zVI2Dq1oc5Ft+rXdlKg+cilt3R4B/ifdFKo29p8ebaPv+JHDe/V6CM06Exgwp1fHcVHcLJDXFjFzbfqZIivA9UnHUIE4Ud1i9M813DBKD0aJNCU0HKnfJwrElcp5aDo50rH67Q3F/7xOpqODbkFmki8HhRlDGoEzgMB/aoJFiz3BCEJTW3QhwjibA2EdomBO/3y3/JxU7d2617pyaNQzBGayBdVAFHtgHDXAMTkATYHALHsATeLburEfrxXodt5asr5lV8APW2ydr59R</latexit>

0.0 0.5 1.0 0.0 0.5 1.0 0.3 0.2 0.1 0.0

The surface tension σ(s, t)

.

<latexit sha1_base64="xJ4ZqNf6sZpy7jiOp/bmCEh2IGY=">AB6HicbVA9SwNBEJ2LXzF+RS1tFoNgdzFQisJ2FgmYD4gOcLeZpKs2ds7dveEcOQX2FgoYutPsvPfuEmu0MQHA4/3ZpiZFyaCa+N5305hY3Nre6e4W9rbPzg8Kh+ftHScKoZNFotYdUKqUXCJTcONwE6ikEahwHY4uZv7SdUmsfywUwTDCI6knzIGTVWarj9csVzvQXIOvFzUoEc9X75qzeIWRqhNExQrbu+l5go8pwJnBW6qUaE8omdIRdSyWNUAfZ4tAZubDKgAxjZUsaslB/T2Q0noahbYzomasV725+J/XTc3wJsi4TFKDki0XDVNBTEzmX5MBV8iMmFpCmeL2VsLGVFmbDYlG4K/+vI6aVd/8qtNqV2m0eRxHO4BwuwYdrqME91KEJDBCe4RXenEfnxXl3PpatBSefOYU/cD5/AHWLjLA=</latexit>

= volH3(ideal tetrahedron with dihedral angles (πs, πt, π(1 − s − t)))

<latexit sha1_base64="Z9m4sd7MZeWhHNhcyzr1l5KUYvE=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="gwSUcruK3NFzKBO43FLeUOm3LIQ=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="gwSUcruK3NFzKBO43FLeUOm3LIQ=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="gwSUcruK3NFzKBO43FLeUOm3LIQ=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="ArJRVBHlUiyXCVxYqSedkuT0fto=">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</latexit>

σ(s, t)

<latexit sha1_base64="M7To+P9/GlcqV/JIEoba/CMFwf0=">AB8nicbVDLSgNBEJyNrxhfUY+CDAYhgoTdeNCTBLx4jGAesFnC7GQ2GTI7s8z0CmHJZ3gwB0W8+jXe/Bsnj4MmFjQUVd10d4WJ4AZc9vJra1vbG7ltws7u3v7B8XDo6ZRqasQZVQuh0SwSXrAEcBGsnmpE4FKwVDu+mfuJacOVfIRwoKY9CWPOCVgJb9jeD8mZXMJF91iya24M+BV4i1IqXb6MsWk3i1+dXqKpjGTQAUxvfcBIKMaOBUsHGhkxqWEDokfeZbKknMTJDNTh7jc6v0cKS0LQl4pv6eyEhszCgObWdMYGCWvan4n+enEN0EGZdJCkzS+aIoFRgUnv6Pe1wzCmJkCaGa21sxHRBNKNiUCjYEb/nlVdKsVryrSvXBpnGL5sijE3SGyshD16iG7lEdNRBFCj2jV/TmgDNx3p2PeWvOWcwcoz9wPn8Az6WUqg=</latexit>
slide-13
SLIDE 13

s =density of green t =density of blue for each slope (s, t) there is an associated growth rate (entropy) −σ(s, t):

<latexit sha1_base64="Eswh/ZqTlmUkUflJzSq1QvJWhIw=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Eswh/ZqTlmUkUflJzSq1QvJWhIw=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Eswh/ZqTlmUkUflJzSq1QvJWhIw=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Eswh/ZqTlmUkUflJzSq1QvJWhIw=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Eswh/ZqTlmUkUflJzSq1QvJWhIw=">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</latexit>

(Number of tilings) = e−Area·σ(s,t)(1+o(1))

<latexit sha1_base64="zbz1Bzm/HYw6hYuNw9afRLBVsWY=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="WXnr+2fIXZkrPtpa34isdNJBi/A=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="WXnr+2fIXZkrPtpa34isdNJBi/A=">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</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="WXnr+2fIXZkrPtpa34isdNJBi/A=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="GQweJjGSJK7y4plK17LE7OdxZc=">ACLnicbVDLahsxFNU4aeK6beKmy25ETGFMWzOTbpSmBrEoC8QM8rtHIdxhaTRId0rNMF/UTX4lWQSUrNZ0R+LBK7BwSHc+5D98SZFBaD4NarbGw+29quPq+9ePlqZ7f+eq9jdW4tLmW2vRiZkGKFNoUEIvM8BULKEbT7N/O5PMFbo9BynGQwUG6ciEZyhk4b1Yz9C+IXF91zFYKhOKAo3a2zLJv1M4UfxceF/dUPLiI80RlaMFfPtB2z64Xvth81mOaw3glYwB10n4ZI0yBKnw/p1NI8V5Ail8zafhkOCiYQcElLUot5AxPmFj6DuaMgV2UMzPLek7p4xo17KdK5+rijYMraqYpdpWJ4YVe9mfg/r59j8mlQiDTLEVK+WJTkqKms+zoSBjgKeOMG6E+yvlF8wji7hmgshXD15nXQOWmHQCs+CxtGXZRxV8pbsE5+E5JAckRNyStqEk9/kityRP96ld+P9f4tSivesucNeQLv/gHFq6ej</latexit>

1 − s − t =density of red

<latexit sha1_base64="/PnKQoz0dsZFc8elux8M85dh8tY=">ACAHicbVA9SwNBEN2LXzF+RS0sbBYTwSbhLo02SsDGMoL5gCSEvb25ZMne3rE7J4SQxr9iY6GIrT/Dzn/j5qPQxAcDj/dmJnJ1IYdN1vJ7O2vrG5ld3O7ezu7R/kD48aJk41hzqPZaxbPjMghYI6CpTQSjSwyJfQ9Ie3U7/5CNqIWD3gKIFuxPpKhIztFIvf1L0SqaE9LoYgDICRzQOqYagly+4ZXcGukq8BSmQBWq9/FcniHkagUIumTFtz02wO2YaBZcwyXVSAwnjQ9aHtqWKRWC649kDE3pulYCGsbalkM7U3xNjFhkzinzbGTEcmGVvKv7ntVMr7pjoZIUQfH5ojCVFGM6TYMGQgNHObKEcS3srZQPmGYcbWY5G4K3/PIqaVTKnlv27iuF6s0ijiw5JWfkgnjklTJHamROuFkQp7JK3lznpwX5935mLdmnMXMfkD5/MHVvyU8g=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="/PnKQoz0dsZFc8elux8M85dh8tY=">ACAHicbVA9SwNBEN2LXzF+RS0sbBYTwSbhLo02SsDGMoL5gCSEvb25ZMne3rE7J4SQxr9iY6GIrT/Dzn/j5qPQxAcDj/dmJnJ1IYdN1vJ7O2vrG5ld3O7ezu7R/kD48aJk41hzqPZaxbPjMghYI6CpTQSjSwyJfQ9Ie3U7/5CNqIWD3gKIFuxPpKhIztFIvf1L0SqaE9LoYgDICRzQOqYagly+4ZXcGukq8BSmQBWq9/FcniHkagUIumTFtz02wO2YaBZcwyXVSAwnjQ9aHtqWKRWC649kDE3pulYCGsbalkM7U3xNjFhkzinzbGTEcmGVvKv7ntVMr7pjoZIUQfH5ojCVFGM6TYMGQgNHObKEcS3srZQPmGYcbWY5G4K3/PIqaVTKnlv27iuF6s0ijiw5JWfkgnjklTJHamROuFkQp7JK3lznpwX5935mLdmnMXMfkD5/MHVvyU8g=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="/PnKQoz0dsZFc8elux8M85dh8tY=">ACAHicbVA9SwNBEN2LXzF+RS0sbBYTwSbhLo02SsDGMoL5gCSEvb25ZMne3rE7J4SQxr9iY6GIrT/Dzn/j5qPQxAcDj/dmJnJ1IYdN1vJ7O2vrG5ld3O7ezu7R/kD48aJk41hzqPZaxbPjMghYI6CpTQSjSwyJfQ9Ie3U7/5CNqIWD3gKIFuxPpKhIztFIvf1L0SqaE9LoYgDICRzQOqYagly+4ZXcGukq8BSmQBWq9/FcniHkagUIumTFtz02wO2YaBZcwyXVSAwnjQ9aHtqWKRWC649kDE3pulYCGsbalkM7U3xNjFhkzinzbGTEcmGVvKv7ntVMr7pjoZIUQfH5ojCVFGM6TYMGQgNHObKEcS3srZQPmGYcbWY5G4K3/PIqaVTKnlv27iuF6s0ijiw5JWfkgnjklTJHamROuFkQp7JK3lznpwX5935mLdmnMXMfkD5/MHVvyU8g=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="/PnKQoz0dsZFc8elux8M85dh8tY=">ACAHicbVA9SwNBEN2LXzF+RS0sbBYTwSbhLo02SsDGMoL5gCSEvb25ZMne3rE7J4SQxr9iY6GIrT/Dzn/j5qPQxAcDj/dmJnJ1IYdN1vJ7O2vrG5ld3O7ezu7R/kD48aJk41hzqPZaxbPjMghYI6CpTQSjSwyJfQ9Ie3U7/5CNqIWD3gKIFuxPpKhIztFIvf1L0SqaE9LoYgDICRzQOqYagly+4ZXcGukq8BSmQBWq9/FcniHkagUIumTFtz02wO2YaBZcwyXVSAwnjQ9aHtqWKRWC649kDE3pulYCGsbalkM7U3xNjFhkzinzbGTEcmGVvKv7ntVMr7pjoZIUQfH5ojCVFGM6TYMGQgNHObKEcS3srZQPmGYcbWY5G4K3/PIqaVTKnlv27iuF6s0ijiw5JWfkgnjklTJHamROuFkQp7JK3lznpwX5935mLdmnMXMfkD5/MHVvyU8g=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="/PnKQoz0dsZFc8elux8M85dh8tY=">ACAHicbVA9SwNBEN2LXzF+RS0sbBYTwSbhLo02SsDGMoL5gCSEvb25ZMne3rE7J4SQxr9iY6GIrT/Dzn/j5qPQxAcDj/dmJnJ1IYdN1vJ7O2vrG5ld3O7ezu7R/kD48aJk41hzqPZaxbPjMghYI6CpTQSjSwyJfQ9Ie3U7/5CNqIWD3gKIFuxPpKhIztFIvf1L0SqaE9LoYgDICRzQOqYagly+4ZXcGukq8BSmQBWq9/FcniHkagUIumTFtz02wO2YaBZcwyXVSAwnjQ9aHtqWKRWC649kDE3pulYCGsbalkM7U3xNjFhkzinzbGTEcmGVvKv7ntVMr7pjoZIUQfH5ojCVFGM6TYMGQgNHObKEcS3srZQPmGYcbWY5G4K3/PIqaVTKnlv27iuF6s0ijiw5JWfkgnjklTJHamROuFkQp7JK3lznpwX5935mLdmnMXMfkD5/MHVvyU8g=</latexit>

Alternatively, give tiles weights a, b, c depending on orientation.

<latexit sha1_base64="i9xKiwEW391ij40slkq325ZQ3H4=">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</latexit>

Then choose a tiling with probability proportional to its weight aNabNbcNc.

<latexit sha1_base64="3g6+37+6rFr+ngBfGXoGdH1oPU=">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</latexit>
slide-14
SLIDE 14

{

<latexit sha1_base64="ikBvtVv+N2jm9OuD9UQSPxp4BHk=">AB6XicdVBNS8NAEJ3Ur1q/qh69LBbBU0nS0taLFLx4rGI/oA1ls920SzebsLsRSug/8OJBEa/+I2/+GzdtBRV9MPB4b4aZeX7MmdK2/WHl1tY3Nrfy24Wd3b39g+LhUdFiS0TSIeyZ6PFeVM0LZmtNeLCkOfU67/vQq87v3VCoWiTs9i6kX4rFgASNYG+l2kA6LJbt80ai51Rqy7Zd1wnI269WqkixygZSrBCa1h8H4wikoRUaMKxUn3HjrWXYqkZ4XReGCSKxphM8Zj2DRU4pMpLF5fO0ZlRiIpCmh0UL9PpHiUKlZ6JvOEOuJ+u1l4l9eP9FBw0uZiBNBVkuChKOdISyt9GISUo0nxmCiWTmVkQmWGKiTgFE8LXp+h/0nHLTqXs3ril5uUqjycwCmcgwN1aMI1tKANBAJ4gCd4tqbWo/VivS5bc9Zq5h+wHr7BPsNjaU=</latexit>

How is σ calculated?

<latexit sha1_base64="UxHIjKCZbgCK8Q4TW2m+DYC5yeM=">ACBHicbVA9TwJBEN3DL8SvU0uajWBiRe6w0EpJbCgxkY8ELmRub4ENe3uX3T0NuVDY+FdsLDTG1h9h579xgSsUfMkL+/NZGaeH3OmtON8W7m19Y3Nrfx2YWd3b/APjxqSiRhDZJxCPZ8UFRzgRtaqY57cSQuhz2vbHNzO/fU+lYpG405OYeiEMBRswAtpIfbtYjx4wU7jcU2wYQhkT4CThoGlw3bdLTsWZA68SNyMlKHRt796QUSkApNOCjVdZ1YeylIzQin0IvUTQGMoYh7RoqIKTKS+dPTPGpUQI8iKQpofFc/T2RQqjUJPRNZwh6pJa9mfif10304NJLmYgTQVZLBokHOsIzxLBAZOUaD4xBIhk5lZMRiCBaJNbwYTgLr+8SlrVinteqd5WS7WrLI48KqITdIZcdIFqI4aqIkIekTP6BW9WU/Wi/VufSxac1Y2c4z+wPr8ATBGlyc=</latexit>

is the Legendre dual of F

<latexit sha1_base64="c4pt83coSL/h/LU+mqGQfzvN9o4=">ACBHicbVA9SwNBEN3zM8avU8s0i4lgFe5ioZUEBLGwiGA+IDnC3t5csmRv79jdE8KRwsa/YmOhiK0/ws5/4ya5QhMfDzem2Fmnp9wprTjfFsrq2vrG5uFreL2zu7evn1w2FJxKik0acxj2fGJAs4ENDXTHDqJBL5HNr+6Grqtx9AKhaLez1OwIvIQLCQUaKN1LdLTGE9BHwLAxCBykhOM4xJXrSt8uO1VnBrxM3JyUY5G3/7qBTFNIxCacqJU13US7WVEakY5TIq9VEFC6IgMoGuoIBEoL5s9McEnRglwGEtTQuOZ+nsiI5FS48g3nRHRQ7XoTcX/vG6qwsvYyJNQg6XxSmHOsYTxPBAZNANR8bQqhk5lZMh0QSqk1uROCu/jyMmnVqu5ZtXZXK9cv8zgKqISO0Sly0TmqoxvUQE1E0SN6Rq/ozXqyXqx362PeumLlM0foD6zPH2dlqM=</latexit>

First compute the “free energy” F (the normalized log-of-determinant).

<latexit sha1_base64="GfwBorGcPy9bkLyaKQz/1FiL4A=">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</latexit>

F(a, b, c) = 1 4π2 ZZ

[0,2π]2 log(a + beiθ + ceiφ) dθ dφ

<latexit sha1_base64="1RHa8FdVTn34GDEKm+ZATZNHyI=">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</latexit>

eigenvalues of K

<latexit sha1_base64="A+N3MjhYjA+IMjdF595TMkhlWlo=">AB+3icdVBdSwJBFJ3t0+zL7LGXIQ16kt1V1F5C6CXoxSA/QEVmx7s6ODu7zMxKIv6VXnotf+SG/9m2bVoKIOXDicy/3uNFnClt2x/W2vrG5tZ2aie9u7d/cJg5yjZVGEsKDRryULY9oAzAQ3NId2JIEHoeWN75K/NYEpGKhuNPTCHoBGQrmM0q0kfqZLAhiAnhMSgc+jh/k+9ncnbholp2S2VsF2y74rhOQtxKqVjCjlES5NAK9X7mvTsIaRyA0JQTpTqOHenejEjNKId5uhsriAgdkyF0DBUkANWbLW6f4zOjDLAfSlNC4X6fWJGAqWmgWc6A6JH6reXiH95nVj71d6MiSjWIOhykR9zrEOcBIEHTALVfGoIoZKZWzEdEUmoNnGlTQhfn+L/SdMtOMWCe+vmaperOFLoBJ2ic+SgCqha1RHDUTRPXpAT+jZmluP1ov1umxds1Yzx+gHrLdPMiCT3w=</latexit>

σ(s, t) = −F(a, b, c) + (1 − s − t) log(a) + s log(b) + t log(c)

<latexit sha1_base64="PRE6q0+eGc4TckEpDgwfZbG47S0=">ACI3icbZDLSgNBEV74ju+oi4FaRhjyY0YUiKAFBXEYwKiQh1HQ6SWPg+4aIQ/RFdu/BU3LpTgxoX/YmeShRovNBxuVFd14+l0Oi6n1Zmanpmdm5+Ibu4tLymltbv9JRohivskhG6sYHzaUIeRUFSn4TKw6BL/m1f3s6rF/fcaVF5iL+aNADqhaAsGaKxm7qiuRScAWxfQoce0eGZDwS8wh+ap7RV1EZ26jDo2OHmdgu/kMQXmNHM7bslNRSfBG8NOethqMdKMzeotyKWBDxEJkHrmufG2OiDQsEkv8/WE81jYLfQ4TWDIQRcN/rpjfd01zgt2o6UeSHS1P050YdA617gm84AsKv/1obmf7Vagu3DRl+EcYI8ZKNF7URSjOgwMNoSijOUPQPAlDB/pawLChiaWLMmBO/vyZNwtVfy9kt7FyaNEzLSPNk28QmHjkgZXJOKqRKGHkiL+SNvFvP1qs1sD5GrRlrPLNBfsn6+gbEmaPO</latexit>
slide-15
SLIDE 15

a

<latexit sha1_base64="yNvyrBItUedRFZ8qXr5A/DVOFmY=">AB+XicbVBNS8NAEJ3Ur1q/oh69LaCp5LUg56k4MVjBVsLbSibzaZdutmE3U2hPwTLx4U8eo/8ea/cZvmoK0PBh7vzezsPD/hTGnH+bYqG5tb2zvV3dre/sHhkX180lNxKgntkpjHsu9jRTkTtKuZ5rSfSIojn9Mnf3q38J9mVCoWi0c9T6gX4bFgISNYG2lk29mweCSTNMgbuJGP7LrTdAqgdeKWpA4lOiP7axjEJI2o0IRjpQauk2gvw1IzwmleG6aKJphM8ZgODBU4osrLiqU5ujBKgMJYmhIaFerviQxHSs0j3RGWE/UqrcQ/MGqQ5vIyJNVUkOWiMOVIx2gRAwqYpETzuSGYSGb+isgES0y0CatmQnBXT14nvVbTvWq2Hlr19m0ZRxXO4BwuwYVraM9dKALBGbwDK/wZmXWi/VufSxbK1Y5cwp/YH3+AJRHk5g=</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="IJ7rCpA8FIJm5MBpou5NdtuzX+g=">AB6HicbVA9SwNBEJ2LXzF+RS1tFoNgFe5ioZUEbCwTMB+QHGFvM5es2ds7dveEcOQX2FgoYutPsvPfuEmu0MQHA4/3ZpiZFySCa+O6305hY3Nre6e4W9rbPzg8Kh+ftHWcKoYtFotYdQOqUXCJLcONwG6ikEaBwE4wuZv7nSdUmsfywUwT9CM6kjzkjBorNd1BueJW3QXIOvFyUoEcjUH5qz+MWRqhNExQrXuemxg/o8pwJnBW6qcaE8omdIQ9SyWNUPvZ4tAZubDKkISxsiUNWai/JzIaT2NAtsZUTPWq95c/M/rpSa8TMuk9SgZMtFYSqIicn8azLkCpkRU0soU9zeStiYKsqMzaZkQ/BWX14n7VrVu6rWmrVK/TaPowhncA6X4ME1OEeGtACBgjP8ApvzqPz4rw7H8vWgpPnMIfOJ8/eJOMsg=</latexit>

{

<latexit sha1_base64="ikBvtVv+N2jm9OuD9UQSPxp4BHk=">AB6XicdVBNS8NAEJ3Ur1q/qh69LBbBU0nS0taLFLx4rGI/oA1ls920SzebsLsRSug/8OJBEa/+I2/+GzdtBRV9MPB4b4aZeX7MmdK2/WHl1tY3Nrfy24Wd3b39g+LhUdFiS0TSIeyZ6PFeVM0LZmtNeLCkOfU67/vQq87v3VCoWiTs9i6kX4rFgASNYG+l2kA6LJbt80ai51Rqy7Zd1wnI269WqkixygZSrBCa1h8H4wikoRUaMKxUn3HjrWXYqkZ4XReGCSKxphM8Zj2DRU4pMpLF5fO0ZlRiIpCmh0UL9PpHiUKlZ6JvOEOuJ+u1l4l9eP9FBw0uZiBNBVkuChKOdISyt9GISUo0nxmCiWTmVkQmWGKiTgFE8LXp+h/0nHLTqXs3ril5uUqjycwCmcgwN1aMI1tKANBAJ4gCd4tqbWo/VivS5bc9Zq5h+wHr7BPsNjaU=</latexit>

F(a, b, c) = 1 4π2 ZZ

[0,2π]2 log(a + beiθ + ceiφ) dθ dφ

<latexit sha1_base64="1RHa8FdVTn34GDEKm+ZATZNHyI=">ACQ3icbZBNSxBEIZ7NB9mzceqx1waRVhxWY2AQVJMAQkp2DAVcnOuNT01uw29vQM3TWBzTD+Ni/5A7n5BwTJISF4DaRn14PRvNDw9lNVPcb50pa8v0Lb27+wcNHjxeNBafPnv+orm0fGizwgjsiUxl5jgGi0pq7JEkhce5QUhjhUfx6fu6fvQFjZWZPqBJjlEKIy0TKYAcGjQ/7WgHbfFBn/Dw8SACMrXYS5PulUopaZB2fbXQeimqhs1ILNGE9KGdIYCapNMb3kY1lthO3hjNbGkUFze/4U/H7Jrgxa7s7X8/efTy72h80v4fDTBQpahIKrO0Hfk5RCYakUFg1wsJiDuIURth3VkOKNiqnGVR83ZEhTzLjiY+pbcnSkitnaSx60yBxvZurYb/q/ULSrajUuq8INRitigpFKeM14HyoTQoSE2cAWGkeysXY3BJkou94UI7n75vjnsdoJXne4nl8ZbNtMCe8lWYsFbIvtsg9sn/WYOfskv1kv7xv3g/vt3c9a53zbmZW2D/y/vwFpn2zWw=</latexit>

eigenvalues of K

<latexit sha1_base64="A+N3MjhYjA+IMjdF595TMkhlWlo=">AB+3icdVBdSwJBFJ3t0+zL7LGXIQ16kt1V1F5C6CXoxSA/QEVmx7s6ODu7zMxKIv6VXnotf+SG/9m2bVoKIOXDicy/3uNFnClt2x/W2vrG5tZ2aie9u7d/cJg5yjZVGEsKDRryULY9oAzAQ3NId2JIEHoeWN75K/NYEpGKhuNPTCHoBGQrmM0q0kfqZLAhiAnhMSgc+jh/k+9ncnbholp2S2VsF2y74rhOQtxKqVjCjlES5NAK9X7mvTsIaRyA0JQTpTqOHenejEjNKId5uhsriAgdkyF0DBUkANWbLW6f4zOjDLAfSlNC4X6fWJGAqWmgWc6A6JH6reXiH95nVj71d6MiSjWIOhykR9zrEOcBIEHTALVfGoIoZKZWzEdEUmoNnGlTQhfn+L/SdMtOMWCe+vmaperOFLoBJ2ic+SgCqha1RHDUTRPXpAT+jZmluP1ov1umxds1Yzx+gHrLdPMiCT3w=</latexit>

There is a special point (θ, φ) where a + beiθ + ceiφ = 0.

<latexit sha1_base64="LCct/xBpld2JlX5XYAEyYm1vf/w=">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</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="IJ7rCpA8FIJm5MBpou5NdtuzX+g=">AB6HicbVA9SwNBEJ2LXzF+RS1tFoNgFe5ioZUEbCwTMB+QHGFvM5es2ds7dveEcOQX2FgoYutPsvPfuEmu0MQHA4/3ZpiZFySCa+O6305hY3Nre6e4W9rbPzg8Kh+ftHWcKoYtFotYdQOqUXCJLcONwG6ikEaBwE4wuZv7nSdUmsfywUwT9CM6kjzkjBorNd1BueJW3QXIOvFyUoEcjUH5qz+MWRqhNExQrXuemxg/o8pwJnBW6qcaE8omdIQ9SyWNUPvZ4tAZubDKkISxsiUNWai/JzIaT2NAtsZUTPWq95c/M/rpSa8TMuk9SgZMtFYSqIicn8azLkCpkRU0soU9zeStiYKsqMzaZkQ/BWX14n7VrVu6rWmrVK/TaPowhncA6X4ME1OEeGtACBgjP8ApvzqPz4rw7H8vWgpPnMIfOJ8/eJOMsg=</latexit>

1

<latexit sha1_base64="Aulpfhy149ryRHZUNrxGT/XeNZE=">AB6HicbZC7SgNBFIbPeo3xFrW0GQyCVdhNCq0YGOZgLlAsoTZydlkzOzsMjMrhJAnsLFQxNZX8Q3sfBsnmxSa+MPAx/+fw5xzgkRwbVz321lb39jc2s7t5Hf39g8OC0fHTR2nimGDxSJW7YBqFxiw3AjsJ0opFEgsBWMbmd56xGV5rG8N+ME/YgOJA85o8Zada9XKLolNxNZBW8BxZvPSqZar/DV7csjVAaJqjWHc9NjD+hynAmcJrvphoTykZ0gB2Lkao/Uk26JScW6dPwljZJw3J3N8dExpPY4CWxlRM9TL2cz8L+ukJrzyJ1wmqUHJ5h+FqSAmJrOtSZ8rZEaMLVCmuJ2VsCFVlBl7m7w9gre8io0yWvUirX3WL1GubKwSmcwQV4cAlVuIMaNIABwhO8wKvz4Dw7b87vHTNWfScwB85Hz9yMI7l</latexit>

z = − b aeiθ

<latexit sha1_base64="3A7AFN3tKXTBD0mWFiK+B1zqg=">ACAnicbVDLSgNBEJz1GeMr6km8LAbBi2E3CnpRBC8eFYwGsmuYnfQmQ2YfzPQKcVlE8CP8AS8eFPEmfoWe/AgP/oGTx0GjBQ1FVTfdXV4suEL+jBGRsfGJyZzU/npmdm5+cLC4qmKEsmgwiIRyapHFQgeQgU5CqjGEmjgCTjz2gd/+wCpOJReIKdGNyANkPuc0ZRS/XC8uXuhuNLylIvS2kG5yl3sAVIs3qhaJWsHsy/xB6Q4v7Wy/Xt1/vnUb3w5jQilgQIhNUqZptxeimVCJnArK8kyiIKWvTJtQ0DWkAyk17L2TmlYaph9JXSGaPfXnREoDpTqBpzsDi017HXF/7xagv6Om/IwThBC1l/kJ8LEyOzmYTa4BIaiowlkutbTdaiOhDUqeV1CPbwy3/Jablkb5bKxzqNPdJHjqyQVbJObLJN9skhOSIVwsgVuSMP5NG4Me6NJ+O53zpiDGaWyC8Yr9+hxJy+</latexit>

a

<latexit sha1_base64="PvAaFnx7iRFtuyGdDNDqPqcNaY=">AB6HicbZC7SgNBFIbPeo3xFrW0GQyCVdhNCq0YGOZgLlAsoTZydlkzOzsMjMrhJAnsLFQxNZX8Q3sfBsnmxSa+MPAx/+fw5xzgkRwbVz321lb39jc2s7t5Hf39g8OC0fHTR2nimGDxSJW7YBqFxiw3AjsJ0opFEgsBWMbmd56xGV5rG8N+ME/YgOJA85o8ZadorFN2Sm4msgreA4s1nJVOtV/jq9mOWRigNE1Trjucmxp9QZTgTOM13U40JZSM6wI5FSPU/iQbdErOrdMnYazsk4Zk7u+OCY20HkeBrYyoGerlbGb+l3VSE175Ey6T1KBk84/CVBATk9nWpM8VMiPGFihT3M5K2JAqyoy9Td4ewVteRWa5ZJXKZXrbrF6DXPl4BTO4AI8uIQq3ENGsA4Qle4NV5cJ6dN+d9XrmLHpO4I+cjx+68I8V</latexit>

beiθ

<latexit sha1_base64="MPeGe8glvDK4s/cCw8g2TnJz+yw=">AB83icdVDLSgNBEJz1GeMr6tHLYBA8hZkENF404MVjBJMISZTZScZMvtgplcIS37DiwdFvPoV/oE3/8bZREFCxqKqm6u/xYK4uMvXtz8wuLS8u5lfzq2vrGZmFru2mjxEhoyEhH5soXFrQKoYEKNVzFBkTga2j5o7PMb92CsSoKL3EcQzcQg1D1lRTopI4P16nq4BQTG4KRVZijHOaUb40SFz5Pi4WuZVyjPLoXj6WpmiflN46/QimQotTC2jZnMXZTYVBJDZN8J7EQCzkSA2g7GoAbDed3jyh+07p0X5kXIVIp+r3iVQE1o4D3UGAof2t5eJf3ntBPvVbqrCOEI5WxRP9EUI5oFQHvKgEQ9dkRIo9ytVA6FERJdTHkXwten9H/SLJd4pVS+YMXaCZkhR3bJHjkgnByRGjkndIgksTkjyQRy/x7r0n73nWOud9zuyQH/BePgCuNJRQ</latexit>

ceiφ

<latexit sha1_base64="FkuMvjnW03yXS9XYxp1w8mbZMnU=">AB8XicdVDLSgMxFM34rPVdekmWARXQ2ZaW7vRghuXFewD27Fk0kwbmskMSUYoQ/CjQtF3PoZ/oE7/8Z0qCiBy4czrmXe+/xY86URujdWlhcWl5Zza3l1zc2t7YLO7stFSWS0CaJeCQ7PlaUM0GbmlO7GkOPQ5bfvj85nfvqVSsUhc6UlMvRAPBQsYwdpI14TepKwXj9i0Xygi2yk5pfIxRHatVqtUq4Ygt1Rxy9CxUYbi2WspQ6NfeOsNIpKEVGjCsVJdB8XaS7HUjHA6zfcSRWNMxnhIu4YKHFLlpdnFU3holAEMImlKaJip3ydSHCo1CX3TGWI9Ur+9mfiX1010cOKlTMSJpoLMFwUJhzqCs/fhgElKNJ8Ygolk5lZIRlhiok1IeRPC16fwf9JyTVC2e4mK9VMwRw7sgwNwBxQBXVwARqgCQgQ4A48gEdLWfWk/U8b12wPmf2wA9YLx9CiZOD</latexit>

−beiθ

<latexit sha1_base64="Q95EANsjBkysozTpQUvI4VOCYwU=">AB9HicbVA9TwJBEN1DUcQv1NLmIjGhkdxBoZUhsbHERD4SOMneMsCGvb1zd46EXPgdNhYaY2tp71+w0n/j8lEo+JXt6bycw8PxJco+N8W6m19fTGZmYru72zu7efOzis6zBWDGosFKFq+lSD4BJqyFAM1JA19Awx9eTf3GCJTmobzFcQReQPuS9zijaCTvzIe7hLdxAEgnVzeKToz2KvEXZB8JV0uvH/Jj2on9nuhiwOQCITVOuW60ToJVQhZwIm2XasIaJsSPvQMlTSALSXzI6e2KdG6dq9UJmSaM/U3xMJDbQeB7pDCgO9LI3Ff/zWjH2LryEyhGkGy+qBcLG0N7moDd5QoYirEhlClubrXZgCrK0OSUNSG4y+vknqp6JaLpRuTxiWZI0OyQkpEJeckwq5JlVSI4zckwfyRJ6tkfVovViv89aUtZg5In9gvf0AVriVeg=</latexit>

z

<latexit sha1_base64="XveyQlHyt93sHuqAadQAhGzSM4=">AB6HicdZDLSgMxFIYz9VbrerSTbAIroZMS2lnowU3LluwF2iHkzbWwmMyQZoQ59AjcuFHrq/gG7nwbM62Civ4Q+Pn+c8g5x485Uxqhdyu3srq2vpHfLGxt7+zuFfcPOipKJKFtEvFI9nysKGeCtjXTnPZiSXHoc9r1pxdZ3r2hUrFIXOlZTL0QjwULGMHaoNbtsFhCtluvVit1iGyE3LJbM8Z1XafmQMeQTKXz18pCzWHxbTCKSBJSoQnHSvUdFGsvxVIzwum8MEgUjTGZ4jHtGytwSJWXLgadwxNDRjCIpHlCwX93pHiUKlZ6JvKEOuJ+p1l8K+sn+ig7qVMxImgiw/ChIOdQSzreGISUo0nxmDiWRmVkgmWGKizW0K5ghfm8L/TadsOxW73EKlxhlYKg+OwDE4BQ6ogQa4BE3QBgRQcAcewKN1bd1bT9bzsjRnfYcgh+yXj4AcyuPkw=</latexit>
slide-16
SLIDE 16

πs πt

a

<latexit sha1_base64="yNvyrBItUedRFZ8qXr5A/DVOFmY=">AB+XicbVBNS8NAEJ3Ur1q/oh69LaCp5LUg56k4MVjBVsLbSibzaZdutmE3U2hPwTLx4U8eo/8ea/cZvmoK0PBh7vzezsPD/hTGnH+bYqG5tb2zvV3dre/sHhkX180lNxKgntkpjHsu9jRTkTtKuZ5rSfSIojn9Mnf3q38J9mVCoWi0c9T6gX4bFgISNYG2lk29mweCSTNMgbuJGP7LrTdAqgdeKWpA4lOiP7axjEJI2o0IRjpQauk2gvw1IzwmleG6aKJphM8ZgODBU4osrLiqU5ujBKgMJYmhIaFerviQxHSs0j3RGWE/UqrcQ/MGqQ5vIyJNVUkOWiMOVIx2gRAwqYpETzuSGYSGb+isgES0y0CatmQnBXT14nvVbTvWq2Hlr19m0ZRxXO4BwuwYVraM9dKALBGbwDK/wZmXWi/VufSxbK1Y5cwp/YH3+AJRHk5g=</latexit>

b

<latexit sha1_base64="Nmy5/NFEP+Hv68Ju3Eny3EZceI=">AB+nicbVA9T8MwEHXKVylfKYwsFi0SU5WUASZUiYWxSLRFaqPKcS+tVceJbAdUhfwUFgYQYuWXsPFvcNM0PKk57eu/P5nh9zprTjfFultfWNza3ydmVnd2/wK4edlWUSAodGvFI3vtEAWcCOpDvexBL6Hr+9Hru9x5AKhaJOz2LwQvJWLCAUaKNLSr6SB/JPV5Alndr2dDu+Y0nBx4lbgFqaEC7aH9NRhFNAlBaMqJUn3XibWXEqkZ5ZBVBomCmNApGUPfUEFCUF6ab83wqVFGOIikKaFxrv6eSEmo1Cz0TWdI9EQte3PxP6+f6ODS5mIEw2CLhYFCc6wvMc8IhJoJrPDCFUMvNXTCdEqpNWhUTgrt8irpNhvueaN526y1ro4yugYnaAz5KIL1EI3qI06iKJH9Ixe0Zv1ZL1Y79bHorVkFTNH6A+szx9m7ZQ</latexit>

c

<latexit sha1_base64="p+oxpL27YmJuboZEY8HSvEC3ePI=">AB+3icbVC7TsMwFHXKq5RXKCOLRYvEVCVlgAlVYmEsEn1IbVQ57k1r1XEi20FUX6FhQGEWPkRNv4GN80ALUe60tE59/r6Hj/mTGnH+bZKG5tb2zvl3cre/sHhkX1c7aokRQ6NOKR7PtEAWcCOpDv1YAgl9Dj1/drvwe48gFYvEg57H4IVkIljAKNFGtnVdJg/k4kgMjqtJ6N7JrTcHLgdeIWpIYKtEf213Ac0SQEoSknSg1cJ9ZeSqRmlENWGSYKYkJnZAIDQwUJQXlpvjbD50YZ4yCSpoTGufp7IiWhUvPQN50h0VO16i3E/7xBoNrL2UiTjQIulwUJBzrC+CwGMmgWo+N4RQycxfMZ0Sag2cVMCO7qyeuk2y4l43mfbPWuiniKNTdIYukIuUAvdoTbqIqe0DN6RW9WZr1Y79bHsrVkFTMn6A+szx8z9ZSE</latexit>

How are weights related to densities?

<latexit sha1_base64="fFRaYxIHxvNIXmc4uJqf34qtcvU=">ACDnicbVC7SgNBFJ31GeNr1dJmMASswm4stNKATcoI5gFJCLOzN8mQ2dl5q4hHyBjb9iY6GIrbWdf+PkUWjigQuHc+7lck6QSGHQ876dtfWNza3tzE52d2/4NA9Oq6ZONUcqjyWsW4EzIAUCqoUEIj0cCiQEI9GNxO/foDaCNidY+jBNoR6ynRFZyhlTpuvhwPKdNAhyB6fTRUg2QIcWYhqCMQAHmpuPmvI3A10l/oLkyAKVjvVCmOeRqCQS2ZM0/cSbI+ZRsElTLKt1EDC+ID1oGmpYhGY9ngWZ0LzVglpN9Z2FNKZ+vtizCJjRlFgNyOGfbPsTcX/vGaK3av2WKgkRVB8/qibymnWaTc0FBo4ypEljGsbnVPeZ5pxtA1mbQn+cuRVUisW/ItC8a6YK10v6siQU3JGzolPLkmJlEmFVAknj+SZvJI358l5cd6dj/nqmrO4OSF/4Hz+AL6Bm+c=</latexit>

π(1 − s − t)

<latexit sha1_base64="d7lsqcJNXzLTb4tzCyvL3Z8o=">AB8XicbVBNS8NAEJ3Ur1q/6sfNS7AI9dCSVEGPBS8eK9gPbEPZbDft0s0m7E6EvovHhQxKv/xpv/xm3ag7Y+GHi8N8PMPD8WXKPjfFu5tfWNza38dmFnd2/oHh41NJRoihr0khEquMTzQSXrIkcBevEipHQF6ztj29nfvuJKc0j+YCTmHkhGUoecErQSI+9mJfdiq7gRb9YcqpOBnuVuAtSqp8EGRr94ldvENEkZBKpIFp3XSdGLyUKORVsWuglmsWEjsmQdQ2VJGTaS7OLp/a5UQZ2EClTEu1M/T2RklDrSeibzpDgSC97M/E/r5tgcOlXMYJMkni4JE2BjZs/ftAVeMopgYQqji5labjogiFE1IBROCu/zyKmnVqu5ltXZv0riCOfJwCmdQBheuoQ530IAmUJDwDK/wZmnrxXq3PuatOWsxcwx/YH3+AK6JkoA=</latexit>

If a ≥ b + c, system is “frozen” in all red.

<latexit sha1_base64="Z17e4ocZLfj1aI1QlaKLhG4hzMA=">ACF3icbVA9SwNBEN3zM8avqKXNkQlOMuFlpJwEa7COYDkpDs7c0lS/b2jt09IYb8Cxv/io2FIrba+W/cJFdo4oOBx3szMzYs6Udpxva2l5ZXVtPbOR3dza3tnN7e3XVJRIClUa8Ug2PKAMwFVzTSHRiyBhB6Huje4mvj1e5CKReJOD2Noh6QnWMAo0Ubq5OybABdJqwfYO6HFU6yGSkOImcLdbiCjBxB5zAQmnGMJvt3JFRzbmQIvEjclBZSi0sl9tfyIJiEITlRquk6sW6PiNSMchnW4mCmNAB6UHTUEFCUO3R9K8xPjKj4NImhIaT9XfEyMSKjUMPdMZEt1X895E/M9rJjq4aI+YiBMNgs4WBQnHOsKTkLDPJFDNh4YQKpm5FdM+kYRqE2XWhODOv7xIaiXbPbNLt6VC+TKNI4MOUR4dIxedozK6RhVURQ9omf0it6sJ+vFerc+Zq1LVjpzgP7A+vwBR3CdgQ=</latexit>

In particular,

<latexit sha1_base64="jK1Mg1LBrtX/n0QXI0PTcYHOVaA=">AB9XicbVDLSsNAFL2pr1pfVZduBovgQkpSF7qSghvdVbAPaGOZTCft0MkzEMpof/hxoUibv0Xd/6N0zQLbT1w4XDOvTP3niDhTGnX/XYK6tr6xvFzdLW9s7uXn/oKViIwltkpjHshNgRTkTtKmZ5rSTSIqjgN2ML6e+e1HKhWLxb2eJNSP8FCwkBGsrfRwK1CpWbEcCzP+uWKW3UzoGXi5aQCORr98ldvEBMTUaEJx0p1PTfRfpq9yOm01DOKJpiM8ZB2LRU4ospPs62n6MQqAxTG0pbQKFN/T6Q4UmoSBbYzwnqkFr2Z+J/XNTq89FMmEqOpIPOPQsORjtEsAjRgkhLNJ5ZgIpndFZERlphoG1TJhuAtnrxMWrWqd16t3dUq9as8jiIcwTGcgcXUIcbaEATCEh4hld4c56cF+fd+Zi3Fpx85hD+wPn8AR30kj4=</latexit>

if b ≥ a + c, system is frozen in all blue;

<latexit sha1_base64="6PAgk19lFptWajG9wFRFR5F07F4=">ACFXicbVBNS8NAEN34WetX1KOXxVYQLCWpBwVBCl48VrAf0Iay2U7apZtN2N0IsfRPePGvePGgiFfBm/GbZuDtj4YeLw3w8w8P+ZMacf5tpaWV1bX1nMb+c2t7Z1de2+/oaJEUqjTiEey5RMFnAmoa6Y5tGIJPQ5NP3h9cRv3oNULBJ3Oo3BC0lfsIBRo3UtUswEW/0wdMTmxhFWqNISYKRzI6AEZgITzrHPE7js2gWn7EyBF4mbkQLKUOvaX51eRJMQhKacKNV2nVh7IyI1oxzG+U6iICZ0SPrQNlSQEJQ3mn41xsdG6eEgkqaExlP198SIhEqloW86Q6IHat6biP957UQHF96IiTjRIOhsUZBwrCM8iQj3mASqeWoIoZKZWzEdEmoNkHmTQju/MuLpFEpu2flym2lUL3K4sihQ3SETpCLzlEV3aAaqiOKHtEzekVv1pP1Yr1bH7PWJSubOUB/YH3+AHlHnSU=</latexit>

if c ≥ a + b, system is frozen in all green.

<latexit sha1_base64="Dxl80BGw4gGjbNlMH6sewXrqcU=">ACFnicbVDLSgNBEJyNrxhfqx69DCaCoIbdeNCTBLx4jGAekCxhdtKbDJmdWZmhRjyFV78FS8eFPEq3vwbJ4+DJhY0FXdHeFCWfaeN63k1laXldy67nNja3tnfc3b2alqmiUKWS9UIiQbOBFQNMxwaiQIShxzqYf967NfvQWkmxZ0ZJBDEpCtYxCgxVmq7ZyzCBdrqAiYnYeEU64E2EGOmcaTkAwjMBCac464CEMW2m/eK3gR4kfgzkczVNruV6sjaRqDMJQTrZu+l5hgSJRhlMo10o1JIT2SRealgoSgw6Gk7dG+MgqHRxJZUsYPF/TwxJrPUgDm1nTExPz3tj8T+vmZroMhgykaQGBJ0uilKOjcTjHCHKaCGDywhVDF7K6Y9og1NsmcDcGf3mR1EpF/7xYui3ly1ezOLoAB2iY+SjC1RGN6iCqoiR/SMXtGb8+S8O/Ox7Q148xm9tEfOJ8/OR6diw=</latexit>

s =density of green t =density of blue 1 − s − t =density of red

<latexit sha1_base64="/PnKQoz0dsZFc8elux8M85dh8tY=">ACAHicbVA9SwNBEN2LXzF+RS0sbBYTwSbhLo02SsDGMoL5gCSEvb25ZMne3rE7J4SQxr9iY6GIrT/Dzn/j5qPQxAcDj/dmJnJ1IYdN1vJ7O2vrG5ld3O7ezu7R/kD48aJk41hzqPZaxbPjMghYI6CpTQSjSwyJfQ9Ie3U7/5CNqIWD3gKIFuxPpKhIztFIvf1L0SqaE9LoYgDICRzQOqYagly+4ZXcGukq8BSmQBWq9/FcniHkagUIumTFtz02wO2YaBZcwyXVSAwnjQ9aHtqWKRWC649kDE3pulYCGsbalkM7U3xNjFhkzinzbGTEcmGVvKv7ntVMr7pjoZIUQfH5ojCVFGM6TYMGQgNHObKEcS3srZQPmGYcbWY5G4K3/PIqaVTKnlv27iuF6s0ijiw5JWfkgnjklTJHamROuFkQp7JK3lznpwX5935mLdmnMXMfkD5/MHVvyU8g=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="/PnKQoz0dsZFc8elux8M85dh8tY=">ACAHicbVA9SwNBEN2LXzF+RS0sbBYTwSbhLo02SsDGMoL5gCSEvb25ZMne3rE7J4SQxr9iY6GIrT/Dzn/j5qPQxAcDj/dmJnJ1IYdN1vJ7O2vrG5ld3O7ezu7R/kD48aJk41hzqPZaxbPjMghYI6CpTQSjSwyJfQ9Ie3U7/5CNqIWD3gKIFuxPpKhIztFIvf1L0SqaE9LoYgDICRzQOqYagly+4ZXcGukq8BSmQBWq9/FcniHkagUIumTFtz02wO2YaBZcwyXVSAwnjQ9aHtqWKRWC649kDE3pulYCGsbalkM7U3xNjFhkzinzbGTEcmGVvKv7ntVMr7pjoZIUQfH5ojCVFGM6TYMGQgNHObKEcS3srZQPmGYcbWY5G4K3/PIqaVTKnlv27iuF6s0ijiw5JWfkgnjklTJHamROuFkQp7JK3lznpwX5935mLdmnMXMfkD5/MHVvyU8g=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="/PnKQoz0dsZFc8elux8M85dh8tY=">ACAHicbVA9SwNBEN2LXzF+RS0sbBYTwSbhLo02SsDGMoL5gCSEvb25ZMne3rE7J4SQxr9iY6GIrT/Dzn/j5qPQxAcDj/dmJnJ1IYdN1vJ7O2vrG5ld3O7ezu7R/kD48aJk41hzqPZaxbPjMghYI6CpTQSjSwyJfQ9Ie3U7/5CNqIWD3gKIFuxPpKhIztFIvf1L0SqaE9LoYgDICRzQOqYagly+4ZXcGukq8BSmQBWq9/FcniHkagUIumTFtz02wO2YaBZcwyXVSAwnjQ9aHtqWKRWC649kDE3pulYCGsbalkM7U3xNjFhkzinzbGTEcmGVvKv7ntVMr7pjoZIUQfH5ojCVFGM6TYMGQgNHObKEcS3srZQPmGYcbWY5G4K3/PIqaVTKnlv27iuF6s0ijiw5JWfkgnjklTJHamROuFkQp7JK3lznpwX5935mLdmnMXMfkD5/MHVvyU8g=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="/PnKQoz0dsZFc8elux8M85dh8tY=">ACAHicbVA9SwNBEN2LXzF+RS0sbBYTwSbhLo02SsDGMoL5gCSEvb25ZMne3rE7J4SQxr9iY6GIrT/Dzn/j5qPQxAcDj/dmJnJ1IYdN1vJ7O2vrG5ld3O7ezu7R/kD48aJk41hzqPZaxbPjMghYI6CpTQSjSwyJfQ9Ie3U7/5CNqIWD3gKIFuxPpKhIztFIvf1L0SqaE9LoYgDICRzQOqYagly+4ZXcGukq8BSmQBWq9/FcniHkagUIumTFtz02wO2YaBZcwyXVSAwnjQ9aHtqWKRWC649kDE3pulYCGsbalkM7U3xNjFhkzinzbGTEcmGVvKv7ntVMr7pjoZIUQfH5ojCVFGM6TYMGQgNHObKEcS3srZQPmGYcbWY5G4K3/PIqaVTKnlv27iuF6s0ijiw5JWfkgnjklTJHamROuFkQp7JK3lznpwX5935mLdmnMXMfkD5/MHVvyU8g=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="/PnKQoz0dsZFc8elux8M85dh8tY=">ACAHicbVA9SwNBEN2LXzF+RS0sbBYTwSbhLo02SsDGMoL5gCSEvb25ZMne3rE7J4SQxr9iY6GIrT/Dzn/j5qPQxAcDj/dmJnJ1IYdN1vJ7O2vrG5ld3O7ezu7R/kD48aJk41hzqPZaxbPjMghYI6CpTQSjSwyJfQ9Ie3U7/5CNqIWD3gKIFuxPpKhIztFIvf1L0SqaE9LoYgDICRzQOqYagly+4ZXcGukq8BSmQBWq9/FcniHkagUIumTFtz02wO2YaBZcwyXVSAwnjQ9aHtqWKRWC649kDE3pulYCGsbalkM7U3xNjFhkzinzbGTEcmGVvKv7ntVMr7pjoZIUQfH5ojCVFGM6TYMGQgNHObKEcS3srZQPmGYcbWY5G4K3/PIqaVTKnlv27iuF6s0ijiw5JWfkgnjklTJHamROuFkQp7JK3lznpwX5935mLdmnMXMfkD5/MHVvyU8g=</latexit>
slide-17
SLIDE 17

How to solve the variational problem? The Euler-Lagrange equation for a gradient model is

<latexit sha1_base64="H8d21X/DPExwCQnKdW0DO4uekG0=">ACHicbVC7SgNBFJ31GeMramkzGAQbw25SaCWCBYWEfIQ4hLuzt5NBmd31plZISx+iI2/YmOhiI2F4N842aTwdarDOfOnHuCVHBtXPfTmZmdm19YLC2Vl1dW19YrG5sdLTPFsM2kOoyAI2CJ9g23Ai8TBVCHAjsBtcnY797i0pzmbTMKEU/hkHCI87AWKlfabSGSE8zgWr/HAYKkgFSvMkKl0ZSUaBWDTkmhsYyREG57leqbs0tQP8Sb0qZIpmv/J+FUqWxfYRJkDrnuemxs9BGc4E3pWvMo0psGsYM/SBGLUfl4cd0d3rRIWUSJpQxTq940cYq1HcWAnYzBD/dsbi/95vcxEh37OkzQzmLDJR1EmqJF03BQNuUJmxMgSYIrbrJQNQEzts+yLcH7fJf0qnXvEatflGvHh9N6yiRbJD9ohHDsgxOSN0iaM3JNH8kxenAfnyXl13iajM850Z4v8gPxBeLZoTw=</latexit>

div (r σ(r h)) =

<latexit sha1_base64="2ZURZSxe6e2TgCKa+GbF6vqVW1U=">ACDnicbVA9SwNBEN3z2/gVtRTkMARiE+5ioY0i2FgqGA3kQpjb20sW9/aO3blgOJI/YGOr/8LGQhFbazv/jZtEQRMfDLx9b4adeX4iuEbH+bSmpmdm5+YXFnNLyura/n1jUsdp4qyKo1FrGo+aCa4ZFXkKFgtUQwiX7Ar/pk4F91mNI8lhfYTVgjgpbkIaeARmrmix6yG8wC3un1S54EX0Df07wVwc+rvbt72MwXnLIzhD1J3G9SON6+H+DhrJn/8IKYphGTSAVoXedBsZKORUsF7OSzVLgF5Di9UNlRAx3ciG5/TsolECO4yVKYn2UP09kUGkdTfyTWcE2Nbj3kD8z6unGB40Mi6TFJmko4/CVNgY24Ns7IArRlF0DQGquNnVpm1QNEkmDMhuOMnT5LStndK1fOTRpHZIQFskV2SIm4ZJ8ck1NyRqEklvySJ7Ji3VnPVmv1tuodcr6ntkf2C9fwHWO6BM</latexit>

x,y

<latexit sha1_base64="/iMZqK/fzfO+I+NVJzQ1FhJtZOE=">AB7HicdVDLSsNAFJ3UR2t9V26GRXFhYQkLW3dFdy4rGDaQhvKZDph04mYWYiltBvcONCEbf+i1t3foPgNzhpFVT0wIXDOfdy7z1+zKhUlvVq5BYWl5bzhZXi6tr6xmZpa7slo0Rg4uKIRaLjI0kY5cRVDHSiQVBoc9I2x+fZX7ighJI36pJjHxQjTkNKAYKS251ye9vUm/dGCZp/WqU6lCy7Ssmu3YGXFqlXIF2lrJcNDIv7/FR7nZr/0htEOAkJV5ghKbu2FSsvRUJRzMi02EskiREeoyHpaspRSKSXzo6dwkOtDGAQCV1cwZn6fSJFoZST0NedIVIj+dvLxL+8bqKCupdSHieKcDxfFCQMqghmn8MBFQrNtEYUH1rRCPkEBY6XyKOoSvT+H/pOWYdtl0LnQaJpijAHbBPjgGNqiBjgHTeACDCi4AXfg3uDGrfFgPM5bc8bnzA74AePpA0XakfU=</latexit>

x,y

<latexit sha1_base64="/iMZqK/fzfO+I+NVJzQ1FhJtZOE=">AB7HicdVDLSsNAFJ3UR2t9V26GRXFhYQkLW3dFdy4rGDaQhvKZDph04mYWYiltBvcONCEbf+i1t3foPgNzhpFVT0wIXDOfdy7z1+zKhUlvVq5BYWl5bzhZXi6tr6xmZpa7slo0Rg4uKIRaLjI0kY5cRVDHSiQVBoc9I2x+fZX7ighJI36pJjHxQjTkNKAYKS251ye9vUm/dGCZp/WqU6lCy7Ssmu3YGXFqlXIF2lrJcNDIv7/FR7nZr/0htEOAkJV5ghKbu2FSsvRUJRzMi02EskiREeoyHpaspRSKSXzo6dwkOtDGAQCV1cwZn6fSJFoZST0NedIVIj+dvLxL+8bqKCupdSHieKcDxfFCQMqghmn8MBFQrNtEYUH1rRCPkEBY6XyKOoSvT+H/pOWYdtl0LnQaJpijAHbBPjgGNqiBjgHTeACDCi4AXfg3uDGrfFgPM5bc8bnzA74AePpA0XakfU=</latexit>

s,t

<latexit sha1_base64="haLIHOl/n0nvdhVPZxB8QOPsQU=">AB7HicdVDLSsNAFJ3UR2t9V26GS2KCwlJWtq6K7hxWcG0hTaUyXTSDp1MwsxEKHf4MaFIm79F7fu/AbBb3DSKqjogQuHc+7l3nv8mFGpLOvVyC0tr6zmC2vF9Y3Nre3Szm5bRonAxMURi0TXR5IwyomrqGKkGwuCQp+Rj85z/zONRGSRvxKTWPihWjEaUAxUlpy5Wn/QA1KZcs8a9Scag1apmXVbcfOiFOvVqrQ1kqGcjP/hYf5bg9JLfxjhJCRcYak7NlWrLwUCUxI7NiP5EkRniCRqSnKUchkV46P3YGj7QyhEkdHEF5+r3iRSFUk5DX3eGSI3lby8T/J6iQoaXkp5nCjC8WJRkDCoIph9DodUEKzYVBOEBdW3QjxGAmGl8ynqEL4+hf+TtmPaFdO51GmYIEC2AeH4ATYoA6a4AK0gAswoOAG3IF7gxu3xoPxuGjNGZ8ze+AHjKcPNp6R6w=</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="Vvbgxmezx9qmlAfMjkn0cDUTxg=">AB6HicbZC7SgNBFIbPeo3xFrW0GQyCVdhNCq0YGOZgLlAsoTZydlkzOzsMjMrhJAnsLFQxNZX8Q3sfBsnmxSa+MPAx/+fw5xzgkRwbVz321lb39jc2s7t5Hf39g8OC0fHTR2nimGDxSJW7YBqFxiw3AjsJ0opFEgsBWMbmd56xGV5rG8N+ME/YgOJA85o8ZadbdXKLolNxNZBW8BxZvPSqZar/DV7csjVAaJqjWHc9NjD+hynAmcJrvphoTykZ0gB2Lkao/Uk26JScW6dPwljZJw3J3N8dExpPY4CWxlRM9TL2cz8L+ukJrzyJ1wmqUHJ5h+FqSAmJrOtSZ8rZEaMLVCmuJ2VsCFVlBl7m7w9gre8io0yWvUirX3WL1GubKwSmcwQV4cAlVuIMaNIABwhO8wKvz4Dw7b87vHTNWfScwB85Hz9wrI7k</latexit>

...

<latexit sha1_base64="5Bf5tBmWQe/phFfr6u/sisN4po=">AB6nicbVBNS8NAEJ34WetX1aOXxSJ4Ck96EkKXjxWtB/QhrLZbtqlm03YnQgl9Cd48aCIV3+RN/+N2zYHbX0w8Hhvhpl5YSqFQc/7dtbWNza3tks75d29/YPDytFxySZrzJEpnoTkgNl0LxJgqUvJNqTuNQ8nY4vp357SeujUjUI05SHsR0qEQkGEUrPbiu269UPdebg6wSvyBVKNDoV756g4RlMVfIJDWm63spBjnVKJjk03IvMzylbEyHvGupojE3QT4/dUrOrTIgUaJtKSRz9fdETmNjJnFoO2OKI7PszcT/vG6G0XWQC5VmyBVbLIoySTAhs7/JQGjOUE4soUwLeythI6opQ5tO2YbgL7+8Slo1790a/e1av2miKMEp3AGF+DFdThDhrQBAZDeIZXeHOk8+K8Ox+L1jWnmDmBP3A+fwBLXo0g</latexit>

Thm[K-Okounkov] z = z(x, y) is a minimizer iff y = z z − 1x + f(z) for some analytic function f.

<latexit sha1_base64="iTYBq4pmyru9tZ4RLcWpQhwth8=">ACYXicbVFNb9NAEF2bAq2hxZRjLyNipFTQyA4HuBRV4oLEgSI1baXYitab3WaV/bB21VsK3+SGxcu/BHWaQ7Q8k5P783szLwtK8GtS9OfQfho5/GTp7t70bPn+wcv4peHl1bXhtAJ0UKb6xJbKriE8edoNeVoViWgl6Vy8+9f3VLjeVaXbimoXEN4ozTrDz0ixe5UpzNafKQZeXDC4Wcvr15NtS12qpb4s1JO1pO1y9a4T4BYwSK645C01wBmDKEma05wZTLp23bUn2Xr1lg3b4ySJmDZgtaSAFRaN4wRYrUg/FRKWjGbxIB2lG8BDkm3JAG1xPot/5HNaulXJQJbO83SyhUdNv5pQdRXltaYbLEN3TqcKS2qLbJLSGN16ZQ78S0/7Ujfp3R4eltY0sfaXEbmHve734P29aO/ax6LiqakcVuRvEagFOQx83zLmhxInGE0wM72MgC+zcv5TIh9Cdv/kh+RyPMrej8bfx4OzT9s4dtEReo2GKEMf0Bn6gs7RBH0K9gJ9oOD4He4F8bh4V1pGx7XqF/EB79AVhFs5M=</latexit>

Idea (Amp` ere): rewrite in terms of the conformal coordinate z (or w).

<latexit sha1_base64="8BmusCskILNeZ8XyiXIkwqs0PjA=">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</latexit>

...a nonlinear PDE.

<latexit sha1_base64="iIbgTMjh4FTf0MDRg2B9vF7YGu4=">AB/HicbVDLSsNAFL2pr1pf0S7dDBbBVUjqQldSUMFlBfuANpTJdNoOnUzCzEQIof6KGxeKuPVD3Pk3TtostPXAhcM5987ce4KYM6Vd9sqra1vbG6Vtys7u3v7B/bhUVtFiS0RSIeyW6AFeVM0JZmtNuLCkOA047wfQ69zuPVCoWiQedxtQP8ViwESNYG2lgVx3HwUhEIn8AS9S8uXUGds13DnQKvEKUoMCzYH91R9GJAmp0IRjpXqeG2s/w1Izwums0k8UjTGZ4jHtGSpwSJWfzZefoVOjDNEokqaERnP190SGQ6XSMDCdIdYTtezl4n9eL9GjSz9jIk40FWTx0SjhSEcoTwINmaRE89QTCQzuyIywRITbfKqmBC85ZNXSbvueOdO/b5ea1wVcZThGE7gDy4gAbcQRNaQCFZ3iFN+vJerHerY9Fa8kqZqrwB9bnD4LIk18=</latexit>
slide-18
SLIDE 18

One can solve the minimization problem for “polygonal” boundary conditions...

<latexit sha1_base64="uJbSjFQR6c+AKG7g1FaEwQgdPRY=">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</latexit>

in which case the arctic boundary is an algebraic curve.

<latexit sha1_base64="erg3wrPg2oySl4iJiG6DbJ5l2A=">ACIXicbVC7SgNBFJ31GeMramkzGASrsBsLU4lgYxnBRCGcPfmJjs4O7vMzCpLyK/Y+Cs2FoqkE3/GSbKFrwMXDufcB/eEqRTG+v6Ht7C4tLyWlor29sbm1XdnbJsk0UgsTmeibEAxJoahlhZV0k2qCOJR0Hd6dT/3re9JGJOrK5il1YxgqMRAI1km9SkMo/hAJjDi6LdxGxEGjFcjDJFN90DkXhoPiIcUanAGZvqear1K1a/5M/C/JChIlRVo9iqT236CWUzKogRjOoGf2u4ItDsmaVy+zQylgHcwpI6jCmIy3dHswzE/dEqfDxLtSlk+U79PjCA2Jo9D1xmDjcxvbyr+53UyO2h0R0KlmSWF80ODTHKb8GlcvC80oZW5I4BaTIPBCDSgdaGWXQjB75f/kna9FhzX6pf16tlpEUeJ7bMDdsQCdsLO2AVrshZD9sie2St78568F+/dm8xbF7xiZo/9gPf5BaxSozI=</latexit>
slide-19
SLIDE 19

Arctic circle theorem [Jockusch-Propp-Shor, Cohn-Larsen-Propp]

<latexit sha1_base64="Y/ivDOJ5Vq3UM6H8/M1Nbtd3qA=">ACJ3icbVDLSgNBEJz1bXxFPXoZDIHE3bjQU+ieBHxENGokCxhtPJDpmdWZmhRD8Gy/+ihdBRfTonzh5HDSxoKGo6qa7K0oFN9b3v7yp6ZnZufmFxdzS8srqWn5948aoTANWQml7yJmUHCJVcutwLtUI0sigbdR57Tv396jNlzJa9tNMUxYW/IWB2ad1MgfnWiwHChwDQKpjVFpTGjtXEnMxAXK1qlafEqVnqPnqpYFi+YNiHetjIF/ySPwCdJMGIFMgIlUb+td5UkCUoLQhmTC3wUxv2mHZHCHzI1TODKYMOa2PNUckSNGFv8OcD3XFKk7aUdiUtHai/J3osMabRK4zYTY2415f/M+rZbZ1GPa4TDOLEoaLWpmgVtF+aLTJNYIVXUcYaD4ILGagXR5lwIwfjLk+SmXAr2S+XLcuH4aBTHAtki2SXBOSAHJMzUiFVAuSRPJM38u49eS/eh/c5bJ3yRjOb5A+87x+v/aXO</latexit>
slide-20
SLIDE 20

x(t − a1)(t − a2)(t − a3) (t − c1)(t − c2)(t − c3) + y (t − b1)(t − b2)(t − b3) (t − c1)(t − c2)(t − c3) = 1 a1 < b1 < c1 < a2 < · · · < c3 The arctic boundary is the envelope of a pencil of lines containing all boundary edges in order. t ∈ R ∪ {∞}

<latexit sha1_base64="lBARsdDsIn9iBiWGBv+/XeSIwY=">ACBnicbVDLSsNAFJ34rPUVdSnKYBFclaQudCUFNy6r2Ac0oUymk3boZBJmboQSunLjL+gfuHGhiFu/wZ1/46TtQlsPXDicy/3hMkgmtwnG9rYXFpeW1sFZc39jc2rZ3dhs6ThVldRqLWLUCopngktWBg2CtRDESBYI1g8Fl7jfvmNI8lrcwTJgfkZ7kIacEjNSxD8DjMvMiAv0gwDcj6aJlxkthKE36tglp+yMgeJOyWl6uFjqdax/7yujFNIyaBCqJ123US8DOigFPBRkUv1SwhdEB6rG2oJBHTfjZ+Y4SPjdLFYaxMScBj9fdERiKth1FgOvN79ayXi/957RTCcz/jMkmBSTpZFKYCQ4zTHCXK0ZBDA0hVHFzK6Z9ogFk1zRhODOvjxPGpWye1quXJs0LtAEBbSPjtAJctEZqIrVEN1RNE9ekav6M16sF6sd+tj0rpgTWf20B9Ynz9nJ1z</latexit>

For t ∈ H, get z = z(x, y) in the interior.

<latexit sha1_base64="OeK5n42pvRn3tx0TKO/bENXEMbc=">ACH3icbVDLSgMxFM34tr6qLt0EW0FBykwFdaMUBOlSwarQlpJ7ShmWRI7oh16J+48VfcuFBE3Pk3prULX2eTwzn3kntOmEh0fc/vInJqemZ2bn53MLi0vJKfnXt0urUcKhxLbW5DpkFKRTUKCE68QAi0MJV2HvZOhf3YCxQqsL7CfQjFlHiUhwhk5q5fdPtaFbAiVNWKG3TCk1UFxl3YAafHu6G7dre/U6RCUeyCexCM0KbUyhf8kj8C/UuCMSmQMc5a+fdGW/M0BoVcMmvrgZ9gM2MGBZcwyDVSCwnjPdaBuqOKxWCb2SjfgG45pU0jd2mkFdKR+n0jY7G1/Th0k8M9rc3FP/z6ilGh81MqCRFUPzroyiVFDUdlkXbwgBH2XeEcSPcrZR3mWHc1WBzroTgd+S/5LJcCvZK5fNyoXI8rmObJBNsk0CckAqpErOSI1wck8eyTN58R68J+/Ve/sanfDGO+vkB7yPT4g6oMo=</latexit>
slide-21
SLIDE 21

Lozenges and monotone nonintersecting lattice paths

<latexit sha1_base64="aW4l7hWRAO1CR8oIA0OT4MmEq0=">ACHicbVA9SwNBEN3zM8avqKXNYhCswl1SaCUBGwuLCOYDkhD2NpNkyd7usTsnxJAfYuNfsbFQxMZC8N+4l6TQxAcLj/dmZmdeGEth0fe/vZXVtfWNzcxWdntnd28/d3BYszoxHKpcS20aIbMghYIqCpTQiA2wKJRQD4dXqV+/B2OFVnc4iqEdsb4SPcEZOqmTK93oB1B9sJSpLo20qgVUKWVUOj6gKNQfSoZouBAY4YD28nl/YI/BV0mwZzkyRyVTu6z1dU8iUAhl8zaZuDH2B4z42ZKmGRbiYWY8SHrQ9NRxSKw7fH0uAk9dUqX9rRxTyGdqr87xiydhSFrjJKt1v0UvE/r5lg76I9FipOEBSfdRLJEVN06RoVxh3vRw5wrgRblfKB8wnuaSdSEiycvk1qxEJQKxdtivnw5jyNDjskJOSMBOSdlck0qpEo4eSTP5JW8eU/ei/fufcxKV7x5zxH5A+/rBwiaopA=</latexit>

traffic flow?

<latexit sha1_base64="zXhIJ6orOf6bEU+hrRN7DHZKVw=">AB9HicbVA9TwJBEJ3DL8Qv1NJmIzGxIndYaKUkNpaYyEcCF7K37MGvb1zdw5DCL/DxkJjbP0xdv4bF7hCwZdM8va9mezMCxIpDLrut5NbW9/Y3MpvF3Z29/YPiodHDROnmvE6i2WsWwE1XArF6yhQ8laiOY0CyZvB8HbmN0dcGxGrBxwn3I9oX4lQMIpW8lHT0D5IKOnm26x5JbdOcgq8TJSgy1bvGr04tZGnGFTFJj2p6boD+hGgWTfFropIYnlA1pn7ctVTixp/Ml56SM6v0SBhrWwrJXP09MaGRMeMosJ0RxYFZ9mbif147xfDKnwiVpMgVW3wUpJgTGYJkJ7QnKEcW0KZFnZXwgZU4Y2p4INwVs+eZU0KmXvoly5r5Sq1kceTiBUzgHDy6hCndQgzoweIRneIU3Z+S8O/Ox6I152Qzx/AHzucPj06R8A=</latexit>

time

<latexit sha1_base64="gIBQRhTYlqBo8cunArcqoy6gQ=">AB63icbVBNS8NAEJ3Ur1q/qh69BIvgqST1oCcpePFYwX5AG8pmO2mX7m7C7kYoX/BiwdFvPqHvPlv3KY5aOuDgcd7M8zMCxPOtPG8b6e0sbm1vVPereztHxweVY9POjpOFcU2jXmseiHRyJnEtmGYy9RSETIsRtO7xZ+9wmVZrF8NLMEA0HGkWMEpNLTOCwWvPqXg53nfgFqUGB1rD6NRjFNBUoDeVE67vJSbIiDKMcpxXBqnGhNApGWPfUkE6iDLb527F1YZuVGsbEnj5urviYwIrWcitJ2CmIle9Rbif14/NdFNkDGZpAYlXS6KUu6a2F087o6YQmr4zBJCFbO3unRCFKHGxlOxIfirL6+TqPuX9UbD41a87aIowxncA6X4M1NOEeWtAGChN4hld4c4Tz4rw7H8vWklPMnMIfOJ8/LomOTw=</latexit>

space

<latexit sha1_base64="Rp67BcNzYBvxwAMpTWsAhLUVEOk=">AB7HicbVBNS8NAEJ3Ur1q/qh69LBbBU0nqQU9S8OKxgmkLbSib7aRdutmE3Y1Qn+DFw+KePUHefPfuG1z0NYHC4/3ZmZnXpgKro3rfjuljc2t7Z3ybmVv/+DwqHp80tZJphj6LBGJ6oZUo+ASfcONwG6qkMahwE4uZv7nSdUmify0UxTDGI6kjzijBor+TqlDAfVmlt3FyDrxCtIDQq0BtWv/jBhWYzSMEG17nluaoKcKsOZwFmln2m0gyd0hD1LJY1RB/li2Rm5sMqQRImyTxqyUH935DTWehqHtjKmZqxXvbn4n9fLTHQT5FymUHJlh9FmSAmIfPLyZArZEZMLaFMcbsrYWOqKDM2n4oNwVs9eZ20G3Xvqt54aNSat0UcZTiDc7gED6hCfQAh8YcHiGV3hzpPivDsfy9KSU/Scwh84nz/iDY62</latexit>
slide-22
SLIDE 22

space

<latexit sha1_base64="Rp67BcNzYBvxwAMpTWsAhLUVEOk=">AB7HicbVBNS8NAEJ3Ur1q/qh69LBbBU0nqQU9S8OKxgmkLbSib7aRdutmE3Y1Qn+DFw+KePUHefPfuG1z0NYHC4/3ZmZnXpgKro3rfjuljc2t7Z3ybmVv/+DwqHp80tZJphj6LBGJ6oZUo+ASfcONwG6qkMahwE4uZv7nSdUmify0UxTDGI6kjzijBor+TqlDAfVmlt3FyDrxCtIDQq0BtWv/jBhWYzSMEG17nluaoKcKsOZwFmln2m0gyd0hD1LJY1RB/li2Rm5sMqQRImyTxqyUH935DTWehqHtjKmZqxXvbn4n9fLTHQT5FymUHJlh9FmSAmIfPLyZArZEZMLaFMcbsrYWOqKDM2n4oNwVs9eZ20G3Xvqt54aNSat0UcZTiDc7gED6hCfQAh8YcHiGV3hzpPivDsfy9KSU/Scwh84nz/iDY62</latexit>

time

<latexit sha1_base64="gIBQRhTYlqBo8cunArcqoy6gQ=">AB63icbVBNS8NAEJ3Ur1q/qh69BIvgqST1oCcpePFYwX5AG8pmO2mX7m7C7kYoX/BiwdFvPqHvPlv3KY5aOuDgcd7M8zMCxPOtPG8b6e0sbm1vVPereztHxweVY9POjpOFcU2jXmseiHRyJnEtmGYy9RSETIsRtO7xZ+9wmVZrF8NLMEA0HGkWMEpNLTOCwWvPqXg53nfgFqUGB1rD6NRjFNBUoDeVE67vJSbIiDKMcpxXBqnGhNApGWPfUkE6iDLb527F1YZuVGsbEnj5urviYwIrWcitJ2CmIle9Rbif14/NdFNkDGZpAYlXS6KUu6a2F087o6YQmr4zBJCFbO3unRCFKHGxlOxIfirL6+TqPuX9UbD41a87aIowxncA6X4M1NOEeWtAGChN4hld4c4Tz4rw7H8vWklPMnMIfOJ8/LomOTw=</latexit>

During each time unit, speed equals 0 or 1.

<latexit sha1_base64="ZejACHFhX1qsJHpk7G1d5voi4Rw=">ACJHicbVC7SgNBFJ31GeMramkzmAgWsuzGQkEQvLCYRsiHMzt5NBmdn1nkIYfFjbPwVGwsfWNj4LU5iCl+nOpxzL+feE+ecaRME797U9Mzs3Hxpoby4tLyWlb2lpFYUmlVyqy5ho4ExA0zD4TJXQLKYQzu+Ohn57RtQmklxY5dDPSFyxlBgn9SqHkZBMJCAMPrWKiT4GQgfYsAywFczsRlFZ5wAJhmtLuMa1oIalwrWw5vcq1cAPxsB/STghVTRBo1d5iRJbebSKCdad8IgN92CKMoh9tyZDXkhF6RPnQcFSQD3S3GT97ibackOHXZqXTXjtXvGwXJtB5msZvMiBno395I/M/rWJMedAsmcmtA0K+g1HJsJB41hOmgBo+dIRQxdytmA6ItS4XsuhPD3y39Jq+6He379vF49PprUKbaAvtoBDto2N0hqoiSi6Qw/oCT1796j9+q9fY1OeZOdDfQD3scnWQOipQ=</latexit>
slide-23
SLIDE 23

r = 1

<latexit sha1_base64="k8ZAgDZLZwkALTjVArnbCGpI6cI=">AB6nicbZDPTgIxEMZn8R/iP9Sjl0Zi4onswkEvKokXjxgFSWBDumUWGrdTds1IYRH8OJBY7z6Jr6BN9/GsnBQ8Eua/PJ9M+nMBIng2rjut5NbWV1b38hvFra2d3b3ivsHTR2nimGDxSJWrYBqFxiw3AjsJUopFEg8CEYXk/zh0dUmsfy3owS9CPalzkjBpr3akLr1suWU3E1kGbw6lq89qpnq3+NXpxSyNUBomqNZtz02MP6bKcCZwUuikGhPKhrSPbYuSRqj9cTbqhJxYp0fCWNknDcnc3x1jGmk9igJbGVEz0IvZ1Pwva6cmPfHXCapQclmH4WpICYm071JjytkRowsUKa4nZWwAVWUGXudgj2Ct7jyMjQrZa9arty6pdolzJSHIziGU/DgDGpwA3VoAIM+PMELvDrCeXbenPdZac6Z9xzCHzkfP8Zmj6g=</latexit>

r = .1

<latexit sha1_base64="W9dDRx30s9IeiHRp2c+rI7SJBAg=">AB63icbZDLSgMxFIbP1Fut6pLN8EiuBpm2oVu1IblxXsBdqhZNJMG5pkhiQjlNJXcONCEbc+iW/gzrcxM+1CW38IfPz/OeScEyacaeN5305hbX1jc6u4XdrZ3ds/KB8etXScKkKbJOax6oRYU84kbRpmO0kimIRctoOx7dZ3n6kSrNYPphJQgOBh5JFjGCTWerK9fvliud6udAq+Auo3HzWcjX65a/eICapoNIQjrXu+l5igilWhFOZ6VeqmCyRgPadeixILqYJrPOkNn1hmgKFb2SYNy93fHFAutJyK0lQKbkV7OMvO/rJua6DKYMpmkhkoy/yhKOTIxyhZHA6YoMXxiARPF7KyIjLDCxNjzlOwR/OWV6FVdf2aW73KvVrmKsIJ3AK5+DBdThDhrQBAIjeIXeHWE8+y8Oe/z0oKz6DmGP3I+fgAx8o/g</latexit>

if we penalize changing speed by a factor r per corner...

<latexit sha1_base64="X9qklRkx1CilmbeyC7GeZl0U/EI=">ACJHicbVC7SgNBFJ31GeNr1dJmMBGslt1YKAgSsLGMYB6QhDA7uZsMmZ1ZmaVuORjbPwVGwsfWNj4LU4ehSae6nDOudx7T5hwpo3vfzlLyura+u5jfzm1vbOru3X9MyVRSqVHKpGiHRwJmAqmGQyNRQOKQz0cXI39+h0ozaS4NcME2jHpCRYxSoyVOu4Fi/A94AQE4ewBMO0T0WOih3UC0MXhEBMcEWqkwkVtDmFqVQClOd5Hbfge/4EeJEM1JAM1Q67nurK2kagzCUE62bgZ+YdkaUYZTDKN9KNSEDkgPmpYKEoNuZ5MnR/jYKl0c2UMiKQyeqL8nMhJrPYxDm4yJ6et5byz+5zVTE523MyaS1ICg0VRyrGReNwY7jIF1PChJYQqZm8dt6RsKbXvC0hmH95kdRKXnDqlW5KhfLlrI4cOkRH6AQF6AyV0TWqoCqi6BE9o1f05jw5L86H8zmNLjmzmQP0B873D1/Do1k=</latexit>

pressure waves

<latexit sha1_base64="+Qc5nvl/m7sI5lU0F6CralTMSs=">AB9XicbVC7TgJBFL2L8QXamkzkZhYkV0stDIkNpaYyCOBlcwOd2HC7OxmZhZCP9hY6Extv6LnX/jAFsoeJTs45N/fOCRLBtXHdbye3sbm1vZPfLeztHxweFY9PGjpOFcM6i0WsWgHVKLjEuFGYCtRSKNAYDMY3s395giV5rF8NJME/Yj2JQ85o8ZKTzardaqQjOkIdbdYcsvuAmSdeBkpQYZat/jV6cUsjVAaJqjWbc9NjD+lynAmcFbopBoTyoa0j21LJY1Q+9PF1TNyYZUeCWNlnzRkof6emNJI60kU2GREzUCvenPxP6+dmvDGn3KZpAYlWy4KU0FMTOYVkB5XyIyYWEKZ4vZWwgZUWZsUQVbgrf65XSqJS9q3LloVKq3mZ15OEMzuESPLiGKtxDerAQMEzvMKbM3ZenHfnYxnNOdnMKfyB8/kD7BGSw=</latexit>

(large penalty)

<latexit sha1_base64="OA4dtWD2o4uW1sEvrwYKdoHS7qM=">AB+HicbVA9SwNBEJ2LXzF+JGpsxiE2IS7WGglARvLCOYDkiPsbSbJkr29Y3dPiEd+iY2FIrb+FDv/jZvkCk18MPB4b4aZeUEsuDau+3kNja3tnfyu4W9/YPDYunouKWjRDFskhEqhNQjYJLbBpuBHZihTQMBLaDye3cbz+i0jySD2Yaox/SkeRDzqixUr9UrAiqRkhilFSY6UW/VHar7gJknXgZKUOGRr/01RtELAlRGiao1l3PjY2fUmU4Ezgr9BKNMWUTOsKupZKGqP10cfiMnFtlQIaRsiUNWai/J1Iaj0NA9sZUjPWq95c/M/rJmZ47adcxolByZaLhokgJiLzFMiAK2RGTC2hTHF7K2FjqigzNquCDcFbfXmdtGpV7Jau6+V6zdZHk4hTOogAdXUIc7aEATGCTwDK/w5jw5L86787FszTnZzAn8gfP5Ax4tkrg=</latexit>

(no penalty)

<latexit sha1_base64="NlgY7BClY2OcTDG3Tf8YC9F6MSA=">AB83icbVBNSwMxEJ2tX7V+VT16CRahXspuPehJCl48VrAf0C4lm2b0GwSkqywlP4NLx4U8eqf8ea/MW3oK0PBh7vzTAzL1KcGev7315hY3Nre6e4W9rbPzg8Kh+ftI1MNaEtIrnU3QgbypmgLcsp12lKU4iTjvR5G7ud56oNkyKR5spGiZ4JFjMCLZO6leFRIoKzG12OShX/Jq/AFonQU4qkKM5KH/1h5KkCRWcGxML/CVDadYW0Y4nZX6qaEKkwke0Z6jAifUhNPFzTN04ZQhiqV2JSxaqL8npjgxJksi15lgOzar3lz8z+ulNr4Jp0yo1FJBlovilCMr0TwANGSaEszRzDRzN2KyBhrTKyLqeRCFZfXiftei24qtUf6pXGbR5HEc7gHKoQwDU04B6a0AICp7hFd681Hvx3r2PZWvBy2dO4Q+8zx9e2ZE7</latexit>
slide-24
SLIDE 24

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0

1 − s − t + (1 − r−2)st = 0

plot of −σ

<latexit sha1_base64="Xa8o0BuS1iF48A5PIFUC9b4qycQ=">AB+nicbVA9SwNBEJ3zM8avi5Y2i4lgY7hLo5UEbCwjmA9IjrC32UuW7O0eu3tKOPNTbCwUsfWX2Plv3CRXaOKDgcd7M8zMCxPOtPG8b2dtfWNza7uwU9zd2z84dEtHLS1TRWiTSC5VJ8SaciZo0zDaSdRFMchp+1wfDPz2w9UaSbFvZkNIjxULCIEWys1HdLCZcGyQhVLnqaDWNc6btlr+rNgVaJn5My5Gj03a/eQJI0psIQjrXu+l5igwrwin02Iv1TBZIyHtGupwDHVQTY/fYrOrDJAkVS2hEFz9fdEhmOtJ3FoO2NsRnrZm4n/ed3URFdBxkSGirIYlGUcmQkmuWABkxRYvjEkwUs7ciMsIKE2PTKtoQ/OWXV0mrVvW9qn9XK9ev8zgKcAKncA4+XEIdbqEBTSDwCM/wCm/Ok/PivDsfi9Y1J585hj9wPn8AzaTBQ=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Xa8o0BuS1iF48A5PIFUC9b4qycQ=">AB+nicbVA9SwNBEJ3zM8avi5Y2i4lgY7hLo5UEbCwjmA9IjrC32UuW7O0eu3tKOPNTbCwUsfWX2Plv3CRXaOKDgcd7M8zMCxPOtPG8b2dtfWNza7uwU9zd2z84dEtHLS1TRWiTSC5VJ8SaciZo0zDaSdRFMchp+1wfDPz2w9UaSbFvZkNIjxULCIEWys1HdLCZcGyQhVLnqaDWNc6btlr+rNgVaJn5My5Gj03a/eQJI0psIQjrXu+l5igwrwin02Iv1TBZIyHtGupwDHVQTY/fYrOrDJAkVS2hEFz9fdEhmOtJ3FoO2NsRnrZm4n/ed3URFdBxkSGirIYlGUcmQkmuWABkxRYvjEkwUs7ciMsIKE2PTKtoQ/OWXV0mrVvW9qn9XK9ev8zgKcAKncA4+XEIdbqEBTSDwCM/wCm/Ok/PivDsfi9Y1J585hj9wPn8AzaTBQ=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Xa8o0BuS1iF48A5PIFUC9b4qycQ=">AB+nicbVA9SwNBEJ3zM8avi5Y2i4lgY7hLo5UEbCwjmA9IjrC32UuW7O0eu3tKOPNTbCwUsfWX2Plv3CRXaOKDgcd7M8zMCxPOtPG8b2dtfWNza7uwU9zd2z84dEtHLS1TRWiTSC5VJ8SaciZo0zDaSdRFMchp+1wfDPz2w9UaSbFvZkNIjxULCIEWys1HdLCZcGyQhVLnqaDWNc6btlr+rNgVaJn5My5Gj03a/eQJI0psIQjrXu+l5igwrwin02Iv1TBZIyHtGupwDHVQTY/fYrOrDJAkVS2hEFz9fdEhmOtJ3FoO2NsRnrZm4n/ed3URFdBxkSGirIYlGUcmQkmuWABkxRYvjEkwUs7ciMsIKE2PTKtoQ/OWXV0mrVvW9qn9XK9ev8zgKcAKncA4+XEIdbqEBTSDwCM/wCm/Ok/PivDsfi9Y1J585hj9wPn8AzaTBQ=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Xa8o0BuS1iF48A5PIFUC9b4qycQ=">AB+nicbVA9SwNBEJ3zM8avi5Y2i4lgY7hLo5UEbCwjmA9IjrC32UuW7O0eu3tKOPNTbCwUsfWX2Plv3CRXaOKDgcd7M8zMCxPOtPG8b2dtfWNza7uwU9zd2z84dEtHLS1TRWiTSC5VJ8SaciZo0zDaSdRFMchp+1wfDPz2w9UaSbFvZkNIjxULCIEWys1HdLCZcGyQhVLnqaDWNc6btlr+rNgVaJn5My5Gj03a/eQJI0psIQjrXu+l5igwrwin02Iv1TBZIyHtGupwDHVQTY/fYrOrDJAkVS2hEFz9fdEhmOtJ3FoO2NsRnrZm4n/ed3URFdBxkSGirIYlGUcmQkmuWABkxRYvjEkwUs7ciMsIKE2PTKtoQ/OWXV0mrVvW9qn9XK9ev8zgKcAKncA4+XEIdbqEBTSDwCM/wCm/Ok/PivDsfi9Y1J585hj9wPn8AzaTBQ=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Xa8o0BuS1iF48A5PIFUC9b4qycQ=">AB+nicbVA9SwNBEJ3zM8avi5Y2i4lgY7hLo5UEbCwjmA9IjrC32UuW7O0eu3tKOPNTbCwUsfWX2Plv3CRXaOKDgcd7M8zMCxPOtPG8b2dtfWNza7uwU9zd2z84dEtHLS1TRWiTSC5VJ8SaciZo0zDaSdRFMchp+1wfDPz2w9UaSbFvZkNIjxULCIEWys1HdLCZcGyQhVLnqaDWNc6btlr+rNgVaJn5My5Gj03a/eQJI0psIQjrXu+l5igwrwin02Iv1TBZIyHtGupwDHVQTY/fYrOrDJAkVS2hEFz9fdEhmOtJ3FoO2NsRnrZm4n/ed3URFdBxkSGirIYlGUcmQkmuWABkxRYvjEkwUs7ciMsIKE2PTKtoQ/OWXV0mrVvW9qn9XK9ev8zgKcAKncA4+XEIdbqEBTSDwCM/wCm/Ok/PivDsfi9Y1J585hj9wPn8AzaTBQ=</latexit>

s

<latexit sha1_base64="juLKOHJRHJMTZmvlvGjltWqrm8=">AB6HicbZC7SgNBFIbPeo3xFrW0GQyCVdhNCq0YGOZgLlAsoTZydlkzOzsMjMrhJAnsLFQxNZX8Q3sfBsnmxSa+MPAx/+fw5xzgkRwbVz321lb39jc2s7t5Hf39g8OC0fHTR2nimGDxSJW7YBqFxiw3AjsJ0opFEgsBWMbmd56xGV5rG8N+ME/YgOJA85o8Zad0rFN2Sm4msgreA4s1nJVOtV/jq9mOWRigNE1Trjucmxp9QZTgTOM13U40JZSM6wI5FSPU/iQbdErOrdMnYazsk4Zk7u+OCY20HkeBrYyoGerlbGb+l3VSE175Ey6T1KBk84/CVBATk9nWpM8VMiPGFihT3M5K2JAqyoy9Td4ewVteRWa5ZJXKZXrbrF6DXPl4BTO4AI8uIQq3ENGsA4Qle4NV5cJ6dN+d9XrmLHpO4I+cjx/WOI8n</latexit>

t

<latexit sha1_base64="XzXtso5Wup+2TIr3MvB6Y4YOeSs=">AB6HicbZC7SgNBFIbPeo3xFrW0GQyCVdhNCq0YGOZgLlAsoTZyWwyZnZ2mTkrhJAnsLFQxNZX8Q3sfBsnmxSa+MPAx/+fw5xzgkQKg67aytb2xubed28rt7+weHhaPjpolTzXiDxTLW7YAaLoXiDRQoeTvRnEaB5K1gdDvLW49cGxGrexwn3I/oQIlQMIrWqmOvUHRLbiayCt4CijeflUy1XuGr249ZGnGFTFJjOp6boD+hGgWTfJrvpoYnlI3ogHcsKhpx40+yQafk3Dp9EsbaPoUkc393TGhkzDgKbGVEcWiWs5n5X9ZJMbzyJ0IlKXLF5h+FqSQYk9nWpC80ZyjHFijTws5K2JBqytDeJm+P4C2vArNcsmrlMp1t1i9hrlycApncAEeXEIV7qAGDWDA4Qle4NV5cJ6dN+d9XrmLHpO4I+cjx/XvI8o</latexit>

p r e s s u r e w a v e s

< l a t e x i t s h a 1 _ b a s e 6 4 = " n M C g P 4 E z Q E K S k b P l / 7 R q 9 e E e v B I = " > A A A C A n i c b V D L S s N A F J 3 4 r P U V d S V u g k V w V Z K 6 J U U 3 L i s Y B / Q h D K Z 3 L R D J z N h Z l I p
  • b
j x V 9 y 4 U M S t X + H O v 3 H a Z q G t B w Y O 5 9 5 z 5 9 4 T p
  • w
q 7 b r f 1 s r q 2 v r G Z m m r v L 2 z u 7 d v H x y 2 l M g k g S Y R T M h O i B U w y q G p q W b Q S S X g J G T Q D
  • c
3 3 p 7 B F J R w e / 1 O I U g w X 1 O Y q w N l L P P v a 5
  • D
w C r h 3 j U y q T 4 P s P e A S q Z 1 f c q j u D s y 8 g l R Q g U b P / v I j Q b L E z C I M K 9 X 1 3 F Q H O Z a a E g a T s p 8 p S D E Z 4 j 5 D e U 4 A R X k s x M m z p l R I i c W j y z y z 9 7 c h x
  • t
Q 4 C U 1 n g v V A L d a m 4 n + 1 b q b j q y C n P M c D L / K M 6 Y
  • 4
U z z c O J q A S i 2 d g Q T C Q 1 u z p k g C U m 2 q R W N i F 4 i y c v k 1 a t 6 l 1 U a 3 e 1 S v 2 6 i K O E T t A p O k c e u k R 1 d I s a q I k I e k T P 6 B W 9 W U / W i / V u f c x b V 6 z C c 4 T + w P r 8 A Q 4 4 l 9 U = < / l a t e x i t >

For r < 1, the surface tension has a different form:

<latexit sha1_base64="4R8SJZh/yUy5p5kvl1a8zOtbeLM=">ACHXicbVDLSgNBEJz1GeNr1aOXwUTwIGE3CoqIBATxGME8IAmhd9KbDJl9MDMrhJAf8eKvePGgiAcv4t84m+SgiQUDRX3dFd5seBKO863tbC4tLymlnLrm9sbm3bO7tVFSWSYVFIpJ1DxQKHmJFcy2wHkuEwBNY8/rXab32gFLxKLzXgxhbAXRD7nMG2kht+/QmkjQvL938MdU9pCqRPjCkGsN0hvZAUaAd7vsoMdTUj2Rw0bZzTsEZg84Td0pyZIpy2/5sdiKWBOYHJkCphuvEujUEqTkTOMo2E4UxsD50sWFoCAGq1nDsbkQPjdJF5tnLhirvyeGECg1CDzTGYDuqdlaKv5XayTaP28NeRgnxi2bLPITQXVE06iMa4lMi4EhwCQ3t1LWAwlMm0CzJgR31vI8qRYL7kmheFfMla6mcWTIPjkgR8QlZ6REbkmZVAgj+SZvJI368l6sd6tj0nrgjWd2SN/YH39AORcoJc=</latexit>
slide-25
SLIDE 25

r = 1 r = .1 r = 10 Simulations

slide-26
SLIDE 26

r = .25

<latexit sha1_base64="maYJfByfp6tmaRzPl8KEQAF1Mfc=">AB7HicbZDLSgMxFIZP6q3W9Wlm2ARXA0zLaIbteDGZQWnFtqhZNJMG5rJDElGKEOfwY0LRdz6Ir6BO9/G9LQ1h8CH/9/DjnhKng2rjuNyqsrK6tbxQ3S1vbO7t75f2Dpk4yRZlPE5GoVkg0E1wy3AjWCtVjMShYA/h8GaSPzwypXki780oZUFM+pJHnBJjLV9dOtWzbrniOu5UeBm8OVSuP2u1OgA0uWvTi+hWcykoYJo3fbc1AQ5UYZTwcalTqZSuiQ9FnboiQx0E+HXaMT6zTw1Gi7JMGT93fHTmJtR7Foa2MiRnoxWxi/pe1MxNdBDmXaWaYpLOPokxgk+DJ5rjHFaNGjCwQqridFdMBUYQae5+SPYK3uPIyNKuO5zrenVupX8FMRTiCYzgFD86hDrfQAB8ocHiCF3hFEj2jN/Q+Ky2gec8h/BH6+AHteI+Q</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="FNVo8WktGCxoNI2UHeyu5C1eHjE=">AB7HicbZDNSsNAFIVv6l+tf1WXbgaL4CokFdGNWnDjsoJpC20ok+mkHTqZhJmJUEKfwY0LRdz6Ir6BO9/GSdqFth4Y+DjnXubeGyScKe0431ZpZXVtfaO8Wdna3tndq+4ftFScSkI9EvNYdgKsKGeCepTjuJpDgKOG0H49s8bz9SqVgsHvQkoX6Eh4KFjGBtLE9e2fXzfrXm2E4htAzuHGo3n2eFmv3qV28QkzSiQhOleq6TqL9DEvNCKfTSi9VNMFkjIe0a1DgiCo/K4adohPjDFAYS/OERoX7uyPDkVKTKDCVEdYjtZjl5n9ZN9XhpZ8xkaSaCjL7KEw50jHKN0cDJinRfGIAE8nMrIiMsMREm/tUzBHcxZWXoVW3Xcd2751a4xpmKsMRHMpuHABDbiDJnhAgMETvMCrJaxn6816n5WrHnPIfyR9fEDqHWQHA=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="FNVo8WktGCxoNI2UHeyu5C1eHjE=">AB7HicbZDNSsNAFIVv6l+tf1WXbgaL4CokFdGNWnDjsoJpC20ok+mkHTqZhJmJUEKfwY0LRdz6Ir6BO9/GSdqFth4Y+DjnXubeGyScKe0431ZpZXVtfaO8Wdna3tndq+4ftFScSkI9EvNYdgKsKGeCepTjuJpDgKOG0H49s8bz9SqVgsHvQkoX6Eh4KFjGBtLE9e2fXzfrXm2E4htAzuHGo3n2eFmv3qV28QkzSiQhOleq6TqL9DEvNCKfTSi9VNMFkjIe0a1DgiCo/K4adohPjDFAYS/OERoX7uyPDkVKTKDCVEdYjtZjl5n9ZN9XhpZ8xkaSaCjL7KEw50jHKN0cDJinRfGIAE8nMrIiMsMREm/tUzBHcxZWXoVW3Xcd2751a4xpmKsMRHMpuHABDbiDJnhAgMETvMCrJaxn6816n5WrHnPIfyR9fEDqHWQHA=</latexit> <latexit sha1_base64="FNVo8WktGCxoNI2UHeyu5C1eHjE=">AB7HicbZDNSsNAFIVv6l+tf1WXbgaL4CokFdGNWnDjsoJpC20ok+mkHTqZhJmJUEKfwY0LRdz6Ir6BO9/GSdqFth4Y+DjnXubeGyScKe0431ZpZXVtfaO8Wdna3tndq+4ftFScSkI9EvNYdgKsKGeCepTjuJpDgKOG0H49s8bz9SqVgsHvQkoX6Eh4KFjGBtLE9e2fXzfrXm2E4htAzuHGo3n2eFmv3qV28QkzSiQhOleq6TqL9DEvNCKfTSi9VNMFkjIe0a1DgiCo/K4adohPjDFAYS/OERoX7uyPDkVKTKDCVEdYjtZjl5n9ZN9XhpZ8xkaSaCjL7KEw50jHKN0cDJinRfGIAE8nMrIiMsMREm/tUzBHcxZWXoVW3Xcd2751a4xpmKsMRHMpuHABDbiDJnhAgMETvMCrJaxn6816n5WrHnPIfyR9fEDqHWQHA=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="uTS6VQRnCcNEXQ5jtR7Fskar98=">AB7HicbVBNS8NAEJ34WetX1aOXxSJ4CklB9KIUvHisYNpCG8pmu2mXbjZhdyKU0t/gxYMiXv1B3vw3btsctPXBwO9GWbmRZkUBj3v21lb39jc2i7tlHf39g8OK0fHTZPmvGApTLV7YgaLoXiAQqUvJ1pTpNI8lY0upv5rSeujUjVI4zHiZ0oEQsGEUrBfrGrV32KlXP9eYgq8QvSBUKNHqVr24/ZXnCFTJjen4XobhGoUTPJpuZsbnlE2ogPesVTRhJtwMj92Ss6t0idxqm0pJHP198SEJsaMk8h2JhSHZtmbif95nRzj63AiVJYjV2yxKM4lwZTMPid9oTlDObaEMi3srYQNqaYMbT5lG4K/PIqadZc3P9B69avy3iKMEpnMEF+HAFdbiHBgTAQMAzvMKbo5wX5935WLSuOcXMCfyB8/kDr7yN6A=</latexit>

No limit shape: limit is random.

<latexit sha1_base64="NlPQlSanTJ/e8p8GXUZ+AG7+hvU=">ACXicbVC7SgNBFJ2Nrxhfq5Y2g0GwWnZjoVhIwMZKIpgHJEuYnZ1NhsxjmZkVwpLWxl+xsVDE1j+w82+cJFto4oELZ865l7n3RCmj2vj+t1NaWV1b3yhvVra2d3b3P2DlpaZwqSJZOqEyFNGBWkahpJMqgnjESDsaXU/9gNRmkpxb8YpCTkaCJpQjIyV+i68lZBRTg3UQ5Sy+JBNVRIxJ7fbfqe/4McJkEBamCAo2+9WLJc4EQYzpHU38FMT5kgZihmZVHqZJinCIzQgXUsF4kSH+eySCTyxSgwTqWwJA2fq74kca3HPLKdHJmhXvSm4n9eNzPJRZhTkWaGCDz/KMkYNBJOY4ExVQbNrYEYUXtrhAPkULY2PAqNoRg8eRl0qp5wZlXu6tV61dFHGVwBI7BKQjAOaiDG9ATYDBI3gGr+DNeXJenHfnY95acoqZQ/AHzucPLmqZWg=</latexit>
slide-27
SLIDE 27

thank you for your attention!

slide-28
SLIDE 28

thank you for your attention!