Moo-Hyun Lee
Center for underground Physics, Institute for Basic Science (IBS), Korea
TAUP 2019 @ TIIC, Toyama, Japan
- 2019. 09. 09
Radioassay and Purification for Experiments at Y2L and Yemilab in - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Radioassay and Purification for Experiments at Y2L and Yemilab in Korea Moo-Hyun Lee Center for underground Physics, Institute for Basic Science (IBS), Korea 2019. 09. 09 TAUP 2019 @ TIIC, Toyama, Japan Yangyang underground laboratory (Y2L)
Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
Seoul Y2L
700m 1000m
CUP/IBS Daejeon A6: KIMS-CsI & HPGe A5: COSINE, AMoRE HPGe array, Alpha
Since 2003
Since 2014 3.3 hour driving 2.5 hour driving
3 AMoRE Experiment: 0!"" decay search
When b is ~ O(1),
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
zero background non-zero background
AMoRE-I 5kg AMoRE-II 200kg
E b Mt A a N T
A
D = e
n
) 2 (ln (exp)
2 / 1
Sensitivity to half-life
Isotopic Abundance Atomic mass Background rate Energy Resolution Measurement time Detector Mass Detection Efficiency
Mt A a N T
A
e
n
) 2 (ln (exp)
2 / 1
=
4
Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS) TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09
¨ Crystals: 40Ca100MoO4(CMO) or XMO
(X: Li, Na, or Pb)
¤ 100Mo enriched: > 95% ¤ 48Ca depleted: < 0.001% (N.A. of 48Ca:0.187%)
¨ Low temperature detector: 10 – 30 mK ¨ Energy resolution: ~5 keV @ 3MeV ¨ Excellent PSD
Pilot Phase I Phase II Mass (Crystal) 1.9 kg CMO 6 kg (CMO + LMO) 200 kg XMO (X: Li, Na, Pb) BKG [keV .kg. year]-1 <10-2 <10-3 <10-4 T1/2 Sensitivity [years] ~1024 ~1025 ~8 ×1026 <mbb > Sensitivity [meV] 400 - 700 100 - 300 13 - 25 Location Y2L (700 m depth) Yemi Lab (1100m depth) Schedule 2015 - 8 2019 - 2021 2021 -
CMO LiMO PbMO
5
Element Decay T1/2 Q (MeV) Mother Chain Comment
26Al
EC 7.4x105y 4.004 N/A Long lifetime
56Co
EC 0.21y 4.567 N/A Short lifetime
88Y
EC 0.29y 3.623
88Zr (0.23 y)
Short lifetime
106Rh
B- 30s 4.004
106Ru(1.02y) 126Sb
B- 12.5d 3.670
126Sn(2.3x105y)
Long lifetime
146Eu
EC 4.61d 3.878
146Gd (0.13 y)
Short lifetime
208Tl
B- 3.05m 4.999
228Th (1.91 y) 232Th
Main
209Tl
B- 2.16m 3.970
233U(159200y) 233U
2.1% branching
210Tl
B- 1.3m 5.482
226Ra(1600y) 238U
0.02% branching
214Bi
B- 19.9m 3.269
226Ra(1600y) 238U
Main
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
6
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
7
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
q 8 ultra low-background NaI(Tl) crystals with a mass of 106 kg in total q U/Th/K levels are less than DAMA, but total alphas (210Pb) are higher than DAMA. q Higher light yield (15 p.e/keV) than DAMA q Can make the threshold lower easily q Total background level is 2-3 times that of DAMA.
Crystal Mass (kg) Powder Alpha rate (mBq/kg)
40K
(ppb)
238U
(ppt)
232Th
(ppt) Light yield (p.e./keV) Crystal 1
8.3 AS-B 3.20 ± 0.08 43.4 ± 13.7 < 0.02 1.31 ± 0.35 14.88 ± 1.49
Crystal 2
9.2 AS-C 2.06 ± 0.06 82.7 ± 12.7 < 0.12 < 0.63 14.61 ± 1.45
Crystal 3
9.2 AS-WS 0.76 ± 0.02 41.1 ± 6.8 < 0.04 0.44 ± 0.19 15.50 ± 1.64
Crystal 4
18.0 AS-WS 0.74 ± 0.02 39.5 ± 8.3 < 0.3 14.86 ± 1.50
Crystal 5
18.0 AS-C 2.06 ± 0.05 86.8 ± 10.8 2.35 ± 0.31 7.33 ± 0.70
Crystal 6
12.5 AS-WS 1.52 ± 0.04 12.2 ± 4.5 < 0.018 0.56 ± 0.19 14.56 ± 1.45
Crystal 7
12.5 AS-WS 1.54 ± 0.04 18.8 ± 5.3 < 0.6 13.97 ± 1.41
Crystal 8
18.3 AS-C 2.05 ± 0.05 56.15 ± 8.1 < 1.4 3.50 ± 0.33
DAMA
< 0.5 < 20 0.7 - 10 0.5 – 7.5 5.5 – 7.5
8
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
q Detector simulation based on GEANT4 well reproduces measured background spectra (4 channels for each crystal, single: 6 - 2000 keV, multiple: 2 - 2000 keV). q Main background in low energy region
multiple hit single hit single hit
9
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
Alpha counter HPGe Array A6 A5 ~700 m deep
10
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
Dedicated shielding: ‒ Top & bottom 10 cm Pb + 10 cm Cu (inner) ‒ Side 15 cm Pb + 10 cm Cu (inner) ‒ 5 cm thick ancient Pb closer to the detector Count rates of background (50−4000 keV) 8.1 mHz (2015), 7.9 mHz (2018), 7.8 mHz (2019)
Dedicated shielding: ‒ General Pb (10 cm) + Goslar Pb (10 cm) + Cu (10 cm) Count rates of background (50−3500 keV) 9.5 mHz (2017), 7.9 mHz (2018), 6.8 mHz (2019)
11
q Iridium Crucible
for Mo based crystal growing
q Mass : 1627.4 g q Geometry:
100 (IR) x 100 (H) x 2(T) mm
q BKG : CC1 large volume (14 days)
CMD246 IRIDIUM CRUCIBLE 190305
226Ra(238U) 40K 228Ac 228Th
17.44 ± 1.54 mBq/kg < 7.01 mBq/kg < 4.31 mBq/kg 5.04 ± 1.26 mBq/kg
192Ir
5.24 +/- 0.26 Bq/kg
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
12
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS) Year Total AMoRE COSINE HPGe LZ Y2L Yemi R&D 2017 15 9 2 3 1 2018 17 10 5 1 1 2019 6 4 1 1 Year Total AMoRE COSINE HPGe LZ Y2L Yemi R&D 2017 21 7 11 3 2018 23 15 5 2 1 2019 11 7 1 2 1
13
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
§ Developed in collaboration with CANBERRA. Operation from March 2017. § 2 ARRAYS placed one above the other with 7 HPGe (70% relative efficiency) each, total 980% with 14 HPGe detectors § Low background copper for endcap & holder. § O-rings were screened from more than 20 samples. § The sensitivity can be improved thanks to coincidence measurements. § Raw materials screening such as Mo-100 powder (AMoRE) or copper. § Rare decay search like 180mTa rare beta decay
14
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
Lot# Delivery@Y2L #1(3172) 3/9/16 #2(3328) 3434 12/28/16 3497 10/12/17 3535 3589 2/7/18 3649 5/29/18 3675 8/14/18 3741 2/13/19 3803 5/31/19 3824 8/20/19
100 kg delivered
Top Array Bottom Array Mo-100 powder bags 9771 g 2nd shipment
Last delivery ~Sep. 2019 HPGe Array meas. (9/13 – 11/28/2017) §
226Ra chain (238U) < 1.4 mBq/kg
§
228Th chain (232Th) = 0.55 ± 0.15 mBq/kg
§
88Y (cosmogenic) = 84 ± 18 !Bq/kg
1919 h data (1578 h BKG) with a total of 9618 g sample.
15
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
l An extremely sensitive alpha counter (argon gas
l Background rate : ~ 0.0001 alphas/cm2/hour. l Essential to study Pb-210 surface contamination
16
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS) CUP Preliminary CUP Preliminary
17
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
§ Volume = 70 L § High Voltage = -1,000 V § Bias = 30 V § Stainless steel with electro-polished inside surfaces § Shaping amplifier with Í12 gain § 12 bit 25 MS/s FADC § Hamamatsu silicon PIN photodiode (S3204-9) 18 Í 18 mm2 § Hamamatsu charge sensitive amplifier (H4083) § HV divider circuit
18
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
218Po 214Po
19
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
q Agilent 7900, the highest sensitivity single MS system in 2015 when purchased. q Under operation since Oct. 2015. (Moved to IBS HQ in spring 2018) q In a cleanroom nominally designed as class 1000, >150 air changes/hour. q A Millipore DI system, in-house acid distillation with a 3 linear meters of chemical hood space. q Dissolve sample in liquid form, uptake in argon (Ar) gas stream, ionize gas, extract into mass spectrometer, measure trace contaminants. q Confirmation of purification methods by measuring isotopic or chemical tracers. q Confidence in systematics at ultra-trace levels is not easily achievable through outsourced measurements.
20
condition Cool, 100ppm(dilution) Hot, He, 100ppm Hot, He, 1% with UHMI elements Al Al K Cr Cr Mn Mn Fe Fe Ni Ni Cu Cu Ti Ti Zn Zn W Sr Sr Ba Ba Pb Pb Th Th U unit ppb ppb ppb ppb ppb ppb ppb ppb ppb ppb ppt ppt ppt ppt ppt #3172
587 291 <300 <30 481 <25 <200 2437 <10000 44 1995 13011 5435 35 76
#3328
1818 1429 <300 <30 597 37 <200 1507 <10000 1213 4144 9521 4685 39 137
#3434
1889 1238 <300 <30 332 95 <200 1756 <10000 48 3034 18007 6986 87 214
#3497
1399 938 <300 <30 504 1073 <200 1802 <10000 670 4372 11183 3962 70 257
#3535
920 578 <300 <30 1486 64 <200 1666 <10000 202 30171 11194 6119 59 198
#3589
908 847 <300 <30 683 62 <200 1399 <10000 174 71978 11690 3274 50 113
#3649
720 519 <300 <30 528 55 <200 1584 <10000 165 22203 8821 7805 81 82
#3675
1104 705 <300 <20 969 226 1735 689 29825 9557 7376 91 75
Isotope ratio 92 92 94 94 95 95 96 96 97 97 98 98 100 100 #3172 0.024 0.017 0.030 0.035 0.028 2.881 96.984 #3328 0.016 0.011 0.022 0.026 0.026 3.137 96.761 #3434 0.015 0.010 0.019 0.023 0.022 3.692 96.218 #3497 0.016 0.011 0.021 0.025 0.024 3.267 96.635 #3535 0.016 0.011 0.021 0.024 0.023 3.310 96.595 #3589 0.013 0.009 0.017 0.020 0.021 3.300 96.620 #3649 0.014 0.009 0.017 0.020 0.021 3.318 96.600 #3675 0.029 0.020 0.036 0.041 0.035 3.527 96.313 (%)
100MoO3: ICP-MS measurements @ CUP
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
21
Crystal growing optimization (Size and quality) Powder purification ICP-MS, HPGe, No Yes Crystal growing Scintillation (Phonon) No Yes Re-crystalization CUP chemical & clean room CUP & underground lab CUP lab. Y2L underground lab Baksan lab. Company (CUP lab.)
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
22
Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS) TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09
¨ Main goal
¤ CaMoO4, Li2MoO4, Na2Mo2O7 crystals growing R&D for AMoRE-II ¤ Other DBD or DM crystal R&D
¨ Deep purification of CaCO3 and MoO3 powders ( < 50 µBq/kg for U,Th chain) ¨ Crystal growing equipment:
Czochralski machine (3 sets) CMO & LMO crystals by CUP
Sublimation device
23
Unpurified Mo and Ca powders
q Successful in growing molybdate crystals. Growing time ~ 1 week. q The purity of the grown crystals are measured by ICP-MS → Promising results q Enriched LMO crystals are grown at NIIC and CUP for LT measurements.
Purified Mo and Li powders
255.6 g, 100 mm (L) cut and polished
Purified Mo and Na powder TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
24
Element Al K Ba Sr Pb Th U No. sample (ppb) (ppb) (ppb) (ppt) (ppt) (ppt) (ppt) Single crystallized natural LMO (w/o purification) CMD 113 L1701-1 48.1 347.3 5.445 <15 <300 <15 <16 CMD 113 L1701-2 21.7 449.2 5.401 75 <300 <15 <16 Single crystallized natural LMO (MoO3 sublimed) CMD163.1 CZ02-L1706-T <11 38 7.579 <50 <100 <8 <8 CMD163.2 CZ02-L1706-B <11 83 9.617 <50 <100 <8 <8 Double crystallized natural LMO (MoO3 sublimed) CMD191.1 CZ02-L1801-T <11 <30 4.744 <50 <100 <8 <8 CMD191.2 CZ02-L1801-B <11 <30 5.814 <50 <100 <8 <8 Enriched LMO (w/o purification) CMD00236.2 CZ02-L1803E-T 1437 <40 6.82 <31 <225 <6 <6 CMD00236.3 CZ02-L1803E-B 1484 <40 7.07 <31 <225 <6 <6 CMD00236.1 CZ02-L1803E-RM 3824 249 28.58 4110 12290 71 472 TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS) Single crystallized LMO (with purified MoO3) Double crystallized LMO (with 3 single crystallized LMO ) Polished LMO surface * See S.J. Ra’s poster
25
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
Li List st Al K Sr Zr Rh Ba Ir Pb Th U 99.9 .95 % CaCO3 81,5 ,500 20, 20,330 330 207,2 ,200
,270
510 33 33 880 880 99.9 .95 % MoO
1, 1,360 360 147,4 ,480 14.2 .2 306 306 <1 <10 992 992 0.0 .09 101.4 .4 1 2.7 .7 Natural CMO O (I (Ir) <6 <60 440 440 59,4 ,410 20 20
120 6.1 .1 6.6 .6 1.3 .3 9.3 .3 Pt Pt-Na Natural CMO 130 130 270 270 70,8 ,890 10 10 <2 <2,0 ,000 170 170 <0 <0.0 .05 5 0.8 .8 11 11 Pu Purified CaCO3 550 550 760 760 523,8 ,800 0.5 .5 <2 <2,0 ,000 2,3 ,300 <0 <0.2 .25 23.5 .5 0.3 .3 4.3 .3 Purified MoO
230 230 5,0 ,090 1.3 .3 0.5 .5 <1 <10 120 120 0.0 .02 4.7 .7 <0 <0.0 .01 0.1 .18 Purified CMO O (I (Ir) 120 120 320 320 83,8 ,890 0.2 .27 <2 <2,0 ,000 80 80 5.1 .1 0.1 .1 <0 <0.0 .01 0.0 .08
Unit: ppb * See S.J. Ra’s poster
26 AMoRE-II: Purification of XMO crystals
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
27
u Nuclear Matrix Element: QRPA
(Faessler et al., 2012)
u AMoRE-I: 5 kg and 5 years u AMoRE-II: 200 kg and 5 years u It was assumed as “zero-background”.
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
28
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
q Extremely pure crystal development
(1 dru)
q R&D of NaI(Tl) crystal at low temperature q Current COSINE-100 shield designed to accommodate sixteen of 12.5 kg crystals (200 kg).
Material Initial [ppb] Purified [ppb]
39K
45.1 6.0
208Pb
3.3 0.8
232Th
< 0.1 < 0.1
238U
< 0.1 < 0.1
Crystal grade NaI [99.99(5) %]
Full size grower for ~ 100 kg ingot Purification factory for ~70 kg powder load
29
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS) ¨ 1 dru background (same as DAMA/LIBRA)
WIMP Mass (GeV) 1 10
2
10
3
10 )
2
SI WIMP-nucleon cross section (cm
44 −
10
43 −
10
42 −
10
41 −
10
40 −
10
39 −
10
38 −
10
37 −
10
) σ , 5 σ DAMA allowed region (90%C.L., 3 COSINE-200, 3 years of data , Median Sensitivty (90%C.L.)
ee
2-20 keV , Median Sensitivty (90%C.L.)
ee
1-20 keV
σ 1 ± σ 2 ±
7.3 sigma observation If DAMA is right..
(2-6 keV)
30
Handeok has two shafts for mining 1st shaft ~ 300 m deep 2nd shaft 600 m deep (NEW)
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
Incheon airport
Airport à Handeok (3 hrs)
Handeok iron mine, Jeongseon, Korea
2nd shaft Now in operation q 4 major constructions Ø Tunnel excavation Ø Shaft cage Ø Underground lab Ø Surface office/lab
31
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
~ 1000m
Cross section of AMoRE Hall
32
Start point entrance going down 780 m shaft
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
33
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
q CUP has two major rare process experiments, AMoRE and COSINE, running in the Y2L. q CUP has been running ultra-low background measurements facility in the Y2L and IBS HQ to screen raw materials for the detector components from 2014. q AMoRE-II with 200 kg of crystals requires even lower background level of 10-4 ckky. q Purification and growing of molybdate crystals at the CUP started from 2016 aiming for the AMoRE-II and in a good progress. q COSINE-100 has 106 kg of NaI(Tl) crystals with similar or lower background levels in 40K/U/Th than those of the DAMA except 210Pb. It has 2-3 more background than that of the DAMA in low energy. q COSINE’s next phase is going to use ultra-pure NaI(Tl) crystals with ~200 kg mass to confirm/dispute the DAMA’s annual modulation in model-independent way. q Purification and crystal growing of NaI(Tl) started at the CUP from 2017 and in a good progress. q A new underground lab to accommodate the AMoRE-II, called Yemilab, has started its tunnel excavation from March to be completed by middle of 2020.
34
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)
35 HPGe measurement example (Vikuiti film)
CMD038 VIKUITI 151002,151019
226Ra(238U) 40K 228Ac 228Th 210Pb
0.59 +/- 0.18 mBq/kg 9.35 +/- 2.35 mBq/kg < 0.93 mBq/kg < 0.64 mBq/kg < 46.04 mBq/kg
TAUP2019@Toyama, 2019-09-09 Radioassay and purification in Korea, Moo-Hyun Lee (IBS)