Presenters: Kathryn Wright, Associate Kathryn.wright@mc-group.com - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

▶
presenters kathryn wright associate kathryn wright mc
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

Presenters: Kathryn Wright, Associate Kathryn.wright@mc-group.com - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Dec 28, 2023 314 likes •554 views

Presenters: Kathryn Wright, Associate Kathryn.wright@mc-group.com or kathryn.wright@cadmusgroup.com Kalee Whitehouse, Senior Analyst Kalee.whitehouse@mc-group.com or Kalee.whitehouse@cadmusgroup.com Funded by the Energy

slide-1
SLIDE 1

1 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation 10/17/17 Presenters: Kathryn Wright, Associate Kathryn.wright@mc-group.com or kathryn.wright@cadmusgroup.com Kalee Whitehouse, Senior Analyst Kalee.whitehouse@mc-group.com or Kalee.whitehouse@cadmusgroup.com Funded ¡by ¡the ¡Energy ¡Foundation, ¡The ¡Kresge ¡Foundation, ¡and ¡the ¡Barr ¡Foundation

slide-2
SLIDE 2

2 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation

Agenda

» Methodology and process » Framework for understanding the market » Walk through resilience standards, frameworks, and guidelines » Discuss overall market positioning and current landscape » Key takeaways for moving the market forward

slide-3
SLIDE 3

3 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation

Process

Desk ¡ Research Stakeholder ¡ Interviews Online ¡ Focus ¡ Group ¡with ¡ Facilities ¡ Managers Final ¡ Report May ¡2017

Advisory ¡Committee ¡

slide-4
SLIDE 4

4 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation

Reviewed Standards

  • Building ¡Resilience—Los ¡Angeles ¡Project ¡

(BRLA)

  • Building ¡Resilience ¡Rating ¡Tool ¡(BRRT)
  • Envision
  • FORTIFIED
  • LEED ¡Pilot ¡Credits ¡(v. ¡1)
  • PEER
  • RELi ¡Resiliency ¡Action ¡List
  • Resilience ¡Based ¡Earthquake ¡Design ¡

Initiative ¡(REDi)

  • Sustainable ¡Sites ¡Initiative ¡(SITES)
  • Enterprise ¡Green ¡Communities ¡

Certification

  • Alliance ¡for ¡National ¡and ¡Community ¡

Resilience ¡(ANCR)

  • Interagency ¡Concept ¡for ¡Community ¡

Resilience ¡(ICCR)

  • Unified ¡Facilities ¡Criteria ¡(UFC)
  • NIST ¡Community ¡Resilience ¡

Assessment ¡Methodology ¡(CRAM) Facility-­‑Scale Community-­‑Scale

slide-5
SLIDE 5

5 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation

Evaluation Framework

Facility ¡Type

  • Infrastructure
  • Commercial
  • Campus

Scale ¡of ¡focus

  • Facility
  • Community

Building ¡life ¡ cycle

  • New ¡
  • Retrofit

Outside ¡System Target ¡ Audience Hazards ¡ included

  • Hazard ¡specific
  • Hazards ¡assessed

Performance ¡ Goals Incorporation ¡of ¡ social ¡ vulnerability Impact ¡and ¡ Scope ¡ Driver Verification ¡ process Standard ¡ Development ¡ Process

slide-6
SLIDE 6

6 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation

Comparative Framework (Subset for illustration)

Target ¡Audience Impact ¡and ¡Scope Standard ¡Development ¡Process Standard

Facility ¡Type Scale Life ¡Cycle Systems Hazards Included Performance Goals Social Vulnerability Driver Verification F C New Retrofit Industry Community Internal External

BRLA

All ¡ ü ü N Holistic (planning ¡framework)

  • ü

ü

Envision

Infrastructure ü ü ü Y Holistic ◑ ü ü ü

FORTIFIED

Commercial ü ü ü N Wind, ¡hurricanes, ¡hail Business ¡continuity ○ ü ü

LEED Pilot

Commercial ü ü Y Holistic Passive ¡survivability* ○ ü ü

PEER

Commercial, campus ü ü ü N Power ¡outage Improving ¡power ¡ performance ○ ü ü

REDi

All ü ü Y Earthquakes Building ¡re-­‑occupancy ¡and ¡ recovery ○ ü ü

RELi

All ü ü ü Y Holistic ◑ ü ü ü

SITES

Commercial ü ü N Sea-­‑level ¡rise, ¡flooding, temperature ○ ü ü

slide-7
SLIDE 7

7 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation

Building Resilience Los Angeles (BRLA)

» Created by the U.S. Green Building Council Los Angeles Chapter » BRLA seeks to strengthen community resilience by positioning facilities preparedness in the context

  • f resilience for the broader community. BRLA

staff have started to deliver trainings, but benchmarking standards are still in development.

Target ¡Audience Impact ¡and ¡Scope Standard ¡Development ¡Process Facility ¡Type Scale Life ¡Cycle Outside Systems Hazards Performance ¡ Goals Social ¡ Vulnerability Driver Verification All Facility Retrofit No Holistic ¡ (planning ¡ framework)

  • ­‑
  • Industry ¡& ¡

Community

  • ­‑
slide-8
SLIDE 8

8 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation

Building Resilience Rating Tool (BRRT)

» The BRRT was created by the Insurance Council of Australia » Simplified insurance risk rating tool for residential properties » Uses geography, slope, construction materials to calculate risk related to wildfire and flooding.

Target ¡Audience Impact ¡and ¡Scope Standard ¡Development ¡Process Facility ¡Type Scale Life ¡Cycle Outside Systems Hazards Performance ¡ Goals Social ¡ Vulnerability Driver Verification Residential Facility Retrofit No Fire, ¡Wind, ¡ Hail, Flood Minimize Damage

○

Industry

  • ­‑
slide-9
SLIDE 9

9 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation

Envision

» Developed by the Institute for Sustainable Infrastructure and the Zofnass Program for Sustainable Infrastructure at Harvard » Envision is designed to measure the sustainability of public works projects, with resilience as a key consideration. Envision is available in the market. » Currently piloted in Los Angeles for public works projects.

Target ¡Audience Impact ¡and ¡Scope Standard ¡Development ¡Process Facility ¡Type Scale Life ¡Cycle Outside Systems Hazards Performance ¡ Goals Social ¡ Vulnerability Driver Verification Infrastructure Community Retrofit/New Yes Holistic

  • ­‑

◑

Industry Internal & ¡ External

slide-10
SLIDE 10

10 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation

FORTIFIED

» The FORTIFIED standards are designed to build resilience to hurricanes, high winds, and hail, and can be applied to business, commercial, and residential properties. » The standards were developed by the Insurance Institute for Business and Home

  • Safety. FORTIFIED is available in the

market.

Target ¡Audience Impact ¡and ¡Scope Standard ¡Development ¡Process Facility ¡Type Scale Life ¡Cycle Outside Systems Hazards Performance ¡ Goals Social ¡ Vulnerability Driver Verification Commercial & ¡ Residential Facility Retrofit ¡& ¡New No Wind, ¡ Hurricane, ¡ Hail Business continuity ¡ (commercial)

○

Industry ¡& ¡ Community External

slide-11
SLIDE 11

11 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation

LEED Pilot Credits on Resilient Design

» Developed by the U.S. Green Building Council » 3 specific credits that provided additional points for buildings undergoing LEED certification process. » Focuses on resilience at the facility level » USGBC is currently updating the LEED Pilot Credits.

Target ¡Audience Impact ¡and ¡Scope Standard ¡Development ¡Process Facility ¡Type Scale Life ¡Cycle Outside Systems Hazards Performance ¡ Goals Social ¡ Vulnerability Driver Verification Commercial Facility New Yes Holistic Passive ¡ Survivability

○

Industry External

slide-12
SLIDE 12

12 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation

Performance Excellence in Electricity Renewal (PEER)

» Administered by Green Business Certification (GBCI). » Third-party certification program to measure and improve power system performance for campuses, municipalities, and electricity supply projects. » Developed by EPRI and Motorola

Target ¡Audience Impact ¡and ¡Scope Standard ¡Development ¡Process Facility ¡Type Scale Life ¡Cycle Outside Systems Hazards Performance ¡ Goals Social ¡ Vulnerability Driver Verification Commercial, ¡ Campus Facility New ¡& ¡Retrofit No Power ¡ Outage Improve ¡power ¡ performance

○

Industry External

slide-13
SLIDE 13

13 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation

RELi Resiliency Action List

» Administered by Perkins + Will » A list of more than 60 actions focused on facility planning, design, operations and maintenance. » Pilot credits reference existing standards on the market.

Target ¡Audience Impact ¡and ¡Scope Standard ¡Development ¡Process Facility ¡Type Scale Life ¡Cycle Outside Systems Hazards Performance ¡ Goals Social ¡ Vulnerability Driver Verification All Facility, ¡ Community New Yes Holistic

  • ­‑

◑

Industry ¡& ¡ Community External

slide-14
SLIDE 14

14 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation

Resilience-Based Earthquake Design Initiative (REDi)

» Created by Arup » Technical design standards for buildings susceptible to seismic hazards and tsunamis » Provides ratings to buildings at the Silver, Gold, and Platinum levels with expected ratings based on downtime after an event occurs.

Target ¡Audience Impact ¡and ¡Scope Standard ¡Development ¡Process Facility ¡Type Scale Life ¡Cycle Outside Systems Hazards Performance ¡ Goals Social ¡ Vulnerability Driver Verification All Facility New Yes Seismic Building ¡re-­‑

  • ccupancy ¡and ¡

recovery

○

Industry Internal

slide-15
SLIDE 15

15 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation

Sustainable Sites Initiative (SITES)

» Administered by the GBCI » Developed by the American Society of Landscape Architects Fund, the Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center, and the U.S. Botanic Garden. » Comprehensive rating system for developing sustainable landscapes and includes considerations for resilience.

Target ¡Audience Impact ¡and ¡Scope Standard ¡Development ¡Process Facility ¡Type Scale Life ¡Cycle Outside Systems Hazards Performance ¡ Goals Social ¡ Vulnerability Driver Verification Commercial Facility New No Sea ¡level ¡ rise, ¡flood, ¡ temperature

  • ­‑

○

Industry External

slide-16
SLIDE 16

16 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation

Enterprise Green Communities

» Created and administered by Enterprise Community Partners » Certification program designed for new construction and existing buildings with affordable housing units » Created an accompanying Ready to Respond Toolkit focusing on resilience during disasters and retrofit guidance.

Target ¡Audience Impact ¡and ¡Scope Standard ¡Development ¡Process Facility ¡Type Scale Life ¡Cycle Outside Systems Hazards Performance ¡ Goals Social ¡ Vulnerability Driver Verification Residential, multifamily Facility New ¡& ¡Retrofit Yes Holistic

  • ­‑
  • Industry

Internal ¡& ¡ External

slide-17
SLIDE 17

17 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation

Community-Scale Standards for Resilience

  • Alliance for National and Community Resilience (ANCR): A nonprofit formed by the

International Code Council with partners in the nonprofit and private sectors. Currently designing a community resilience benchmarking system. à àin development

  • Interagency Concept for Community Resilience (ICCR): Draft resilience indicators

identifying national-level measures that contribute to community resilience developed by NOAA and FEMA. à àin development

  • Unified Facilities Criteria (UFC): Developed by the U.S. Department of Defense. The criteria

incorporate sustainability principles and considerations for resilience to natural, climate- induced, and human-induced hazards. The criteria are currently used by U.S. military

  • installations. à

àin use

  • NIST Community Resilience Assessment Methodology (CRAM): Developed by the National

Institute of Standards and Technology, CRAM is designed to assess infrastructure preparedness to understand overall community resilience. à àin development

slide-18
SLIDE 18

18 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation

Market Positioning

slide-19
SLIDE 19

19 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation

Design New ¡Construction Existing ¡Buildings

Standard ¡Designed ¡to ¡Address ¡Specific ¡Hazards ¡ ¡ Hazards ¡and ¡Vulnerabilities ¡Assessed ¡as ¡Part ¡of ¡ the ¡Certification ¡or ¡Rating ¡Process RELi LEED ¡Pilot ¡Credits SITES PEER CRAM ICCR REDi FORTIFIED BRLA BRRT Enterprise

Project Life Cycle

ANCR Envision

Neighborhood/ Community

slide-20
SLIDE 20

20 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation

Takeaways

Market is still emerging

  • Many ¡standards ¡are ¡in ¡the ¡pilot ¡stages ¡or ¡working ¡with ¡first ¡set ¡of ¡customers

Value proposition not yet clear for facilities

  • Limited ¡monetary ¡incentives ¡from ¡insurance ¡breaks
  • Limited ¡regulatory ¡incentives ¡from ¡state ¡or ¡local ¡governments

Proactive facilities managers and property owners unsure where to start

  • Lack ¡of ¡familiarity ¡with ¡standards
  • Outreach ¡on ¡topic ¡not ¡occurring ¡from ¡trusted ¡voices ¡(e.g. ¡BOMA ¡or ¡NAIOP)
slide-21
SLIDE 21

21 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation

Next Steps

Strategy Lender ¡& ¡ Investor Foundation States Local ¡ Jurisdictions Facility ¡ Owner ¡/ ¡ Manager Standard ¡ Developer Insurance ¡ Sector Streamline ¡and ¡unify ¡ resilience ¡standards

  • Explore ¡code ¡and ¡insurance ¡

regulation

  • Adopt ¡local ¡policy ¡options
  • Deliver ¡technical ¡assistance ¡

to ¡facility ¡managers ¡and ¡ property ¡owners ¡

  • Demonstrate ¡the ¡ROI ¡of ¡

resilience ¡standards

  • Education ¡and ¡outreach ¡
slide-22
SLIDE 22

22 Presentation for the Alliance of Regional Collaboratives for Climate Adaptation

Contact

Ü Report Website

  • http://www.mc-group.com/voluntary-resilience-standards-an-assessment-of-the-

emerging-market-for-resilience-in-the-built-environment/

Ü Contact:

Kathryn Wright, Associate, Meister Consultants Group, A Cadmus Company Kathryn.wright@mc-group.com or kathryn.wright@cadmusgroup.com Kalee Whitehouse, Senior Analyst, Meister Consultants Group, A Cadmus Company Kalee.whitehouse@mc-group.com or kalee.whitehouse@cadmusgroup.com