University of Alabama in Huntsville
NASA SL Preliminary Design Review
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 1
Preliminary Design Review University of Alabama in Huntsville - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
NASA SL Preliminary Design Review University of Alabama in Huntsville University of Alabama in Huntsville 11/3/2017 1 USLI PDR Mission Summary ry Design, fabricate, test and fly a rocket and payload to 1 mile in altitude Deploy a
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 1
*Throughout the presentation, all dimensions are in inches
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 2
University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 3 11/3/2017
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 4
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 5
Rover Piston Main Parachute Drogue Parachute Coupler 12 in. Tracking/Rover Deployment Avionics Fins (x4) Recovery Avionics Forward Airframe 24 in. Aft Airframe 41 in. Payload Fairing 36 in. CG 51 in. CP 63 in.
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 6
Powered Ascent: 0 – 3.2 seconds 0 – 1,050 ft. Deploy Drogue: 19 seconds 5,282 ft. Deploy Main: 50 seconds 600 ft. Landing: 100 seconds 0 ft. Deploy Rover: Team Command
– A 1-D in house Monte Carlo simulation will be used to verify results – Results will also be compared to flight tests for verification
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 7
Attribute Value Apogee (ft.) 5282 Length (in.) 96
0.56 Rail Exit Velocity (ft./s) 55.7 Static Stability (cal.) 2.0 Motor Designation AT L1520T - P Thrust-to-Weight Ratio 8.7 CG 51 in. CP 63 in.
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 8 50 sec. Main deploy (600 ft.) Apogee of 5282 ft. (19 sec.) Burnout at 3.2 sec.
– Calculated with no wind conditions
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 9 Takeoff Stability: 2.06 Maximum Stability: 2.74
University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 10 11/3/2017 Nose Cone Payload Fairing Transition Forward Body Tube
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 11
Payload Piston Avionics Bay
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 12
6.0 in. 2.0 in.
deployment system
6.0 in. 24.0 in.
command; redundant arming
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 13
Plunger Ø 6.0 in. Cylinder Ø 6.0 in.
load path supplemented with aluminum insert
forward coupler
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 14
– Mass: 4.7 lbm – Complicated FEA – Structurally weak without aluminum insert – Aluminum insert could pose manufacturing difficulties
– Aluminum brace with direct bulkhead connection, purely aerodynamic cover
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 15
University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 16 11/3/2017
– Primary coupler between airframes – Flight Avionics – Ejection System – Tracking and Ground Station – Recovery System
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 17
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 18
U Bolt (2 Places) Black Powder Housing (4 Places) Stratologger CF Altimeter (2 Places) 9V Battery (2 Places) Switch/Pressure Equalization holes (2 Places) All-Thread (2 Places) 1 in. Switchband Aluminum Bulkheads 3D Printed Avionics Sled
9 in. 12.5 in. 1 in.
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 19
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 20
Microswitch – Prevents detonation during assembly – Helps preserve battery life
– Secondary fired one second after
– Secondary fired at 550 ft.
black powder
than primary
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 21
System
PRO 900HP RF module, and an Antenova GPS Chip – PCB will includes traces for all relevant connections including battery sources.
ground station laptop.
Stru Structure Integr gratio ion
transition section of the rocket.
kept in tact
– Deployment at apogee – Fruity Chute CFC-18 (CD = 1.5) – Shock Cords: 1 inch Nylon (50 ft.) – Connected between forward motor retention bulkhead in lower airframe and avionics bay housing. – Descent speed under drogue: 62.2 ft/s
– Deployment at 700 ft. above ground level – Fruity Chute 60 in. Iris Ultra (CD = 2.2) – Shock Cords: 1 inch Nylon (50 ft.) – Connected between fairing bulkhead and avionics bay housing. – Descent speed under main: 15.23 ft/s
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 22
maximum drift at 15 mph of about 1,700 ft.
section will have a maximum kinetic energy of 75 ft-lbf
conservative estimate of 75 ft- lbf was used for the heaviest section
2 𝑛𝑤2
– m = mass of the section, lbm – v = velocity, ft/s
is 15 lbm, so the safe descent speed was determined to be 17.9 ft/s
8𝑛 𝜌𝜍𝐷𝐸𝑤2
– D = diameter of parachute, ft. – m = mass of vehicle, lbm – g = force of gravity, ft/s2 – 𝝇 = density of the air, lbm/ft3 – CD = Coefficient of Drag – v = previously calculated velocity, ft/s
93.3 inches
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 23
causing tension under Drogue and Main. Shock cord applies load to eyebolt in the coupler bulkhead.
through the all thread and down to the motor casing then back up the tube. represents force due to drag represents the force due to mass
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 24
1 2 3 4
University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 25 11/3/2017
– Fin Design ▪ Optimize dimensions and materials for flight stability – Centering Ring/Thrust Plate ▪ Carry load path from the vehicle ▪ Centering and fin integration ability – Forward/Recovery Retention ▪ Provide method for recovery attachment ▪ Carry thrust through the vehicle via forward retention
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 26
– Through the wall design/slotted body tube ▪ Slots allow for fin mounting integration – G10 Fiberglass fins attached with seven 4-40 bolts per fin ▪ Fins will be mounted to centering ring – 3-D printed centering ring/fin mounting bracket ▪ Can be removed from body tube for repair/inspection – Aluminum Forward/Recovery retention bulkhead ▪ Uses U bolt for recovery system ▪ Motor case tapped to allow for forward retention
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 27
Fin Can/Centering Ring Motor/Motor Casing Thrust Ring Trapezoidal Fin(s) (4) Forward/Recovery Retention Bulkhead Secondary Centering Ring
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 28
Aerotech L1520R-P Specifications Motor Designation L1520T-P Apogee 5,282 ft. Stability 2.0 cal. Ballast 51 in. Diameter 75 mm. (3 in.) Length 25.7 in. Propellant Mass 8.0 lbm Total Impulse 835 lbf.-s Max Acceleration 289 ft./s2 Velocity off the Rail 55.7 ft./s Burn Time 2.5 sec
– L1150 ▪ Too little total impulse – L850 ▪ Too slow off the rail – L1390 ▪ Too much total impulse
– Screwed onto top of motor – Recovery retention is fixed on U-bolt – 3.9 in. diameter – 0.5 in. thick Aluminum – Fixed to body tube with four ¼-20 screws
University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 29 11/3/2017
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 30
Fin Can
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 31
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 32
– Allows more freedom in fin design – Adjust fin shape to shift CP
– 8 in base – 3.5 in height with extended base for body tube insertion – Seven holes allow integrated mounting to centering ring located inside body tube – Rounded leading edge
– G10 Fiberglass – Will be fabricated/designed in house
– Fins mounted through the body tube to centering ring – Replaceable upon breakage/damage
– Calculated to be 1444.76 mph (Mach 1.88)
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 33
– Crosswise: 38 ksi – Lengthwise: 45 ksi
– Crosswise: 65 ksi – Lengthwise: 75 ksi
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 34
– Crosswise: 2400 ksi – Lengthwise: 2700 ksi
University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 35 11/3/2017
– 4 in. body → 2.125 in. body – 6 in. fairing → 3 in. fairing – Mach 0.56 → 0.49
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 36
Subscale Rocket Full-Scale Rocket
– 3 in. motor → 1.5 in. motor – 96 in. length→ 49 in. length – 9.0 G → 15.2 G
3.0 in 6.0 in
University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 37 11/3/2017
the interior of the rocket, move a minimum of 5 ft. away from the rocket, and deploy solar panels
expandable wheels, and a stabilizing arm
transmits this data with images to a ground station
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 38
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 39
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 40
14.24 in. diameter when deployed
steering via differential
gear driven by a DC motor
effective area from 0 to 100%
battery for distance extension
– Highest strength to weight design – Resistant to drastic changes in temperature – Least deflection under load protects motors and electronics
– Will be used if aluminum unibody is too difficult to manufacture
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 41
Aluminum Unibody 3D Printed ABS Unibody Aluminum Base/3D Printed ABS Walls Ease of Manufacturing 2 5 4 Strength to Weight 5 2 3 Environmental Protection 5 2 1 Total Score 12 9 8
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 42
the wheel during adverse deployment conditions (left)
inside the rocket upon landing (right)
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 43
– Ease of manufacturing – Results in a longer tail and moment arm
– Will be used if measuring tape fails integration and deployment tests
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 44
18 inch Measuri uring ng Tape (Wrapped ed around) d) 11 inch Sideways ys Hinged Hinged Aluminum Aluminum Tail ail Ease of Manufacturing 5 2 Strength 3 5 Tail Length th 5 3 Total Score 13 10
Wheel Rotation
Counter moment from tail
– 6 in. diameter constraint while inside rocket – > 6 in. diameter desired for handing terrain
– Desired for handling terrain – All designs similarly decent in other categories
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 45
Telescoping Wheels Foam Umbrella wheel Cost 3 4 3 Design Complexity 2 4 3 Low Risk of Damage 4 5 4 Terrain Effectiveness 4 1 5 Total 13 14 15
– Pushing wheels out of rocket without taking damage – Ease of manufacturing wheel shapes
– Highest strength while maintaining low weight – Easiest to manufacture wheels
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 46
Aluminum ABS Polycarbonate Cost 4 3 3 Design Complexity 5 4 4 Weight 3 5 4 Strength of Material 5 3 4 Total 17 15 15
Wheel – 0.703 lbm
– 5.7 in. diameter wheel expands to 14 in. diameter wheel – Linear extension spring for compression and expansion – Keeps compressed while in rocket, expands naturally once out – Spring located on the exterior, pulls in to bring spoke vertical – Rod used for assembly of main wheel to spokes
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 47
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 48
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 49
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 50
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 51
– Full weight of rover and motor torque
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 52
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 53
remote servo gear
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 54
Gear System Hinge Simplicity 3 4 Functionality 5 3 Weight 2 2 Cost 1 1 Total Score 11 10
panel deployment mechanism ̶ Gear system lid ̶ Hinged lid
– Hinge mechanism would be harder to close once opened – Gear system would be easier to bring the cover back over the solar panels
University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 55 11/3/2017
Component Mass (lbm) Chassis 2.5 Wheel Assembly 1.4 Lid/Solar Deployment 1.0 Tail 0.1 Electronics 1.4 10% Margin 0.6 Total 7.0
Li-Ion 18650 CR123A Surefire Energizer Recharge Power Plus Power 4 3 4 Capacity 5 4 4 Weight 4 3 2 Safety 3 5 5 Reusability 5 5 5 Power Density 5 3 2 Total 26 23 22
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 56
– 3x Li-Ion 18650 in series – 4x CR123a Surefire in series – 8x Energizer Recharge Power in series
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 57
Arduino Mega Arduino Uno PCB with ATMega 2560 Beaglebone Raspberry Pi 3 Clock Speed 3 3 3 5 5 I/O Pins 5 3 5 3 4 Operating Voltage 4 3 4 2 4 Power Draw 4 4 4 3 1 Complexity 4 4 2 5 2 Volume 3 4 3 4 3 Mass 4 5 4 4 3 Cost 4 4 2 2 4 Total 31 30 28 28 28
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 58
Component Sel Selection Fea eatures MCU Arduino Mega
IMU Adafruit LSM9DS0
Temperature and Pressure Sensor Adafruit BMP280
Motor Cytron DC Geared Motor SPG30-300K
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 59
Component Sel Selection Fea eatures Solar Cell OSEPP Monocrystalline Solar Cell
GPS Adafruit MTK3339
Radio X-Bee PRO
Lid Motor NMB Technologies PPN7PA12C1
DC/DC converter LM3671 Buck Converter
Camera ArduCam CMOS OV7670
Component nent Current nt (mA) Voltag tage (V) Time me (hr hr) Duty Cycle (%) Efficie iency ncy (%) Necessary ary Capacity ity (mAhr)
Arduino Mega 50.0 5.00 1.00 100 100 22.5 Pressure/ Temp 1.12 5.00 0.25 100 100 0.13 IMU 6.10 5.00 1.00 100 100 2.75 Wheel Motors 820 11.1 0.17 100 100 136 Lid Motors 96.0 5.00 0.01 100 100 0.43 Radio 210 3.30 1.00 100 80.0 78.0 Camera 20.0 3.30 0.25 100 80.0 1.86 GPS 20.0 5.00 0.25 100 100 2.25 Voltage Regulator 600 5.00 1.00 100 100 270
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 60
Required battery capacity =
𝐽 𝑛𝐵 ∗𝑊 𝑊 ∗𝐸𝐷 ∗𝑈𝑗𝑛𝑓 ℎ𝑠 𝐹𝑔𝑔𝑗𝑑𝑗𝑓𝑜𝑑𝑧 ∗11.1 𝑊
Required uired Capacity ity (mAhr) Available lable Capacity ity (mAhr) Safety ty Facto tor
514 2600 5.06
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 61
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 62
Remove RBF; Payload detects launch via acceleration Takes acceleration data throughout flight, calculates changes Once acceleration is zero for several iterations, waits for deployment signal from ground station Rover transmits acknowledgement, waits for confirmation signal Receives confirmation signal; Delays 30 seconds Supplies power to motor, begins taking temperature, pressure, and IMU data Get position data via GPS and accelerometer; Sample 2 times per second Transmit data back to ground station, save on board to eeprom If position change by a certain margin, back up, turn motor, begin moving again Once distance traveled, deploy solar panels, end data collection Measure battery voltage Transmit data back to ground station, save on board to eeprom
University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 63 11/3/2017
University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 64 11/3/2017
– System verification through repeatable exhibition of the design feature – Pre-determined pass/fail criteria – Parachute deployment, repeat flight tests, capability to launch within an hour
– Demonstration of system with known input and output values – Numerical data feedback as well as demonstrative verification – Static motor fire, flight test with altimeters, recovery location tracking
– Nondestructive/passive examination of the system – No numerical data collected – Design components present, use of checklists, follow safety guidelines
– Calculation of performance prior to any physical testing – Completely theoretical based on expected performance – Simulation software, FEA, hand calculations, CAD
with, and verified using the following methods
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 65
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 66
Recovery Ejec Ejection Cou Couple ler Str Strength Motor
Load Path th Si Simulation/ Aer erodynamics Ov Overall System Perf erformance Will the parachutes eject properly with the planned explosives? Will the rocket buckle at the coupler under max. thrust? Is the load path sufficiently strong/how does the motor behave when fired? Is the simulation accurate/is the rocket stable? Does the rocket reach the expected altitude/does every component work properly? Multiple ground ejections of each component Apply calculated moment to coupler Static fire of the motor, measuring thrust through the high-risk loadpath components Launch a subscale version
multiple times Launch the full-scale (final) rocket multiple times
University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 67 11/3/2017
University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 68 11/3/2017
– Weekly Safety Briefings on relevant current activities – Create Hazard analysis and Standard operating procedures
can be minimized
– No team member shall work alone when manufacturing and testing the rocket and its components. – CRW members double and triple check each other’s work to ensure that all steps of manuals and standard procedures are followed – Supervision from experienced mentors and staff ensures all procedures are done correctly.
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 69
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 70
– Aid in Hazard and failure mode analysis for their respective sub-section of the rocket
rocket – Analyze failure modes – Track evolution of the component to aid in verification process
each (as outlined in the PDR report)
criteria (as outlined in the PDR report)
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 71
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 72
SLI Handbook
reliability and risk assessment of their systems.
Train ainin ing Activ tivity ty Date Red Cross Fir irst Aid CPR/ R/AED/FA 10/13/2017 Bas asic ic Eme Emergency y Proc
10/17/2017 Proc
Hazard d Analy alysis is 10/18/2017 Saf afe Testi ting Proc
10/24/2017 Roo
alysis is 10/24/2017 Outr utreach Saf afety y Proc
11/7/2017 Sub ub-scale le Lau Launch Saf afety y Proc
11/14/2017 Haz Hazardous Materia ial Han Handlin ling/Dis isposal 11/21/2017 Fir ire Ext Extin inguis isher trai ainin ing 11/21/2017 TBD TBD
University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 73 11/3/2017
University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 74 11/3/2017
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 75
University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 76 11/3/2017
CRW
Man anagement
Sa Safety
Lau Launch Veh ehicle
Payload
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 77
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 78
Rover Frame 4% Rover Electronics 11% Airframe 13% Motors 50% Recovery 22% Rover Frame Rover Electronics Airframe Motors Recovery
79 11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR
– Before project started, but good practice – 80 middle school girls participated
– Invited to teach space, robotics, and maker culture
2018
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 80
University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 81 11/3/2017
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 82
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 83
Portrait_by_Curiosity_Rover_Arm_Camera.jpg
Compo ponent Mass s (g) g) Numbe mber r per r rove ver Total al Mass s (g) g) Total al Mass s (lb lbm) Arduino Mega 37.0 1 37.0 0.08 BMP280 1.30 1 1.30 0.00 SPG30 geared motor 160 2 320 0.71 Motor Shield 30.0 1 30.0 0.07 LSM9DS0 2.30 1 2.30 0.01 Solar cell 8.50 3 25.5 0.06 Camera 10.0 1 22.5 0.05 900 MHz Xbee 8.50 1 6.50 0.01 Brushed DC motor 9.98 2 20.0 0.04 Battery 150 1 150 0.33 GPS 8.50 1 8.50 0.02 Voltage regulator 0.90 1 0.90 0.00 Total mass
1.38
11/3/2017 University of Alabama in Huntsville USLI PDR 84