SLIDE 1 Gauge/Gravity Duality 2013 Max Planck Institute for Physics, 29 July to 2 Aug 2013
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid Ingo Kirsch
DESY Hamburg, Germany
`
- M. Isachenkov, I.K., V. Schomerus, arXiv: 1308.XXXX
SLIDE 2
- Electron transport in conductors is usually well-described by Fermi-liquid theory (d>1)
- BUT d=1: Electrons in a one-dimensional system form a quantum liquid which can be
described as a Luttinger liquid rather than by Landau's Fermi-liquid theory
- Fermi surface but no weakly-coupled quasi-particles above FS
- Experimentally realized e.g. in quantum wires/carbon nanotubes
Luttinger Liquid
2 Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
carbon nanotube (source: wiki)
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Vertically aligned Carbon Nanotubes by using a photolithography method (source: Dept. of Electronics U. York) Luttinger relation
SLIDE 3 Gopakumar-Hashimoto-Klebanov-Sachdev-Schoutens (2012):
- UV: 2d SU(N) gauge theory coupled to Dirac fermions
Luttinger Liquid and matrix cosets
3
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 4 Gopakumar-Hashimoto-Klebanov-Sachdev-Schoutens (2012):
- UV: 2d SU(N) gauge theory coupled to Dirac fermions
- IR: effective low-energy theory flows to 2d coset CFT:
emergent SUSY in the IR - not present in the UV theory!
Luttinger Liquid and matrix cosets
3
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 5 Gopakumar-Hashimoto-Klebanov-Sachdev-Schoutens (2012):
- UV: 2d SU(N) gauge theory coupled to Dirac fermions
- IR: effective low-energy theory flows to 2d coset CFT:
emergent SUSY in the IR - not present in the UV theory!
- coset studied only for N=2, 3: equivalence to minimal models:
- What can we do
(no relation to minimal models)?
Luttinger Liquid and matrix cosets
3
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 6
Outline: I. Motivation: Luttinger Liquid II. Matrix coset theories III. Partition function ZN (for higher N) IV. Spectrum of primary fields V. Chiral ring of chiral primaries Conclusions
Overview
ETH Zurich, 30 June 2010
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
4 Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 7
Numerator partition function:
Example: The partition function Z3 (N=3)
5
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 8
Numerator partition function: Denominator partition function: D-type modular invariant of the type
Example: The partition function Z3 (N=3)
5
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 9
Numerator partition function: Denominator partition function: D-type modular invariant of the type Coset partition function:
Example: The partition function Z3 (N=3)
5
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 10
Numerator partition function: Denominator partition function: D-type modular invariant of the type Coset partition function:
Example: The partition function Z3 (N=3)
5
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 11
It is possible to write Two successive decompositions: i) decomposition of SO(16)1 characters into characters of SO(8)1 x SO(8)1: ii) decomposition of SO(8)1 characters into characters of SU(3)3 branching the characters of SO(16)1 into those of SU(3)6:
Example: The partition function Z3 (N=3)
6
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 12
Result for partition function Z3 : where and
Example: The partition function Z3 (N=3)
7
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 13
We constructed an expression for the coset partition function ZN : are branching functions:
Partition function ZN (general N)
8
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 14
The branching functions are computed using a formula for diagonal cosets. This gives the q-expansion of . Spectrum:
Bouwknegt-McCarthy-Pilch formula
9
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
Bouwknegt-McCarthy-Pilch (1991)
SLIDE 15
Goal: Compute the coset partition function ZN in terms of the branching functions and then rewrite it in terms of characters. Example: N=2
N=2,3: Partition function ZN and supersymmetry
10
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 16
Goal: Compute the coset partition function ZN in terms of the branching functions and then rewrite it in terms of characters. Example: N=2
N=2,3: Partition function ZN and supersymmetry
10
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 17 Goal: Compute the coset partition function ZN in terms of the branching functions and then rewrite it in terms of characters. Example: N=2
N=2,3: Partition function ZN and supersymmetry
10
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 18
For N>3 it is difficult to rewrite ZN in terms of characters. BUT: Still possible to write ZN = ZN (q) using BMP formula
N=4, 5: The partition function ZN(q)
11
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 19
For N>3 it is difficult to rewrite ZN in terms of characters. BUT: Still possible to write ZN = ZN (q) using BMP formula Example: N=3 similarly Likewise, we found the q-expansions of Z4 = Z4 (q), Z5 = Z5 (q) by computing 700 (N=4) and 10292 (N=5) branching functions…
N=4, 5: The partition function ZN(q)
11
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 20
Spectrum: coset elements and their conformal weights
Parallel computing on DESY’s theory and HPC clusters
N=2 N=3
12
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 21
Spectrum: coset elements and their conformal weights
Parallel computing on DESY’s theory and HPC clusters
N=4
12
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
we also have N=5 ...
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 22
A particular feature of superconformal field theories is the chiral ring of NS sector chiral primary fields. These fields form a closed algebra under fusion. Let’s identify the chiral primary fields (h=Q) by introducing charge into the branching functions (i.e. make them z-dependent) Example: N=3
Chiral Ring
13
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 23
Do the chiral primaries form a closed algebra under fusion? - Yes. For instance, for N=3: Generator of the chiral ring (h=Q=1/6): Claim: Repeatedly act with x on the identity. This generates the chiral ring of NS chiral primary fields.
Chiral Ring
14
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 24
Visualization of the chiral ring by tree diagrams: An arrow represents the action of x on a field, e.g. OPE (N=3)
Chiral Ring
15
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 25
Visualization of the chiral ring by tree diagrams: An arrow represents the action of x on a field, e.g. OPE (N=3)
Chiral Ring
15
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
SLIDE 26
Chiral Ring
16
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
N=4, 5:
SLIDE 27
Chiral Ring
16
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
N=4, 5: In the large N limit, the number of chiral primaries is governed by the partition function p(6h).
SLIDE 28 I discussed diagonal coset theories of the type Gopakumar et al. studied this space for N=2, 3 (by relating it to minimal models) Our method works in principle for general N:
- general N: we derived the partition function ZN=ZN (b(q)),
the branching functions b(q) can be computed using the BPM formula (needs a lot of computer power for higher N though)
- N=2, 3: we rewrote ZN in terms of characters
- N=4, 5: - we explicitly derived the q-expansion of ZN (up to some order)
- we identified the chiral primary fields and
- showed that they form a chiral ring under fusion
Outlook (work in progress):
- Large N limit + AdS dual description
Conclusions
Coset approach to the Luttinger Liquid
17 Gauge/Gravity Duality, MPI Munich 2013 -- Ingo Kirsch
