low dimensional embeddings of logic
play

Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic aschel, 1 Matko Bosnjak, 1 Sameer - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic aschel, 1 Matko Bosnjak, 1 Sameer Singh 2 and Sebastian Riedel 1 Tim Rockt 1 University College London 2 University of Washington Machine Reading ACL 2014 Workshop on Semantic Parsing 26th June 2014


  1. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic aschel, 1 Matko Bosnjak, 1 Sameer Singh 2 and Sebastian Riedel 1 Tim Rockt¨ 1 University College London 2 University of Washington Machine Reading ACL 2014 Workshop on Semantic Parsing 26th June 2014

  2. Motivation Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 1/7

  3. Motivation Machine Reading and Reasoning Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 1/7

  4. Motivation Machine Reading and Reasoning “Colugos are arboreal gliding mammals that are found in Southeast Asia.” mammal ( Colugo ) Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 1/7

  5. Motivation Machine Reading and Reasoning “Colugos are arboreal gliding mammals that are found in Southeast Asia.” mammal ( Colugo ) “All mammals are endothermic.” ∀ x : mammal ( x ) ⇒ endothermic ( x ) Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 1/7

  6. Motivation Machine Reading and Reasoning “Colugos are arboreal gliding mammals that are found in Southeast Asia.” mammal ( Colugo ) “All mammals are endothermic.” ∀ x : mammal ( x ) ⇒ endothermic ( x ) Reasoning... endothermic ( Colugo ) Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 1/7

  7. Motivation Machine Reading and Reasoning “Colugos are arboreal gliding mammals that are found in Southeast Asia.” mammal ( Colugo ) “All mammals are endothermic.” ∀ x : mammal ( x ) ⇒ endothermic ( x ) Reasoning... endothermic ( Colugo ) I wish I had a distributed model... Mammal Endothermic Colugo Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 1/7

  8. Motivation Machine Reading and Reasoning Debugging Distributed Representations “Colugos are arboreal gliding mammals that are found in Southeast Asia.” mammal ( Colugo ) “All mammals are endothermic.” ∀ x : mammal ( x ) ⇒ endothermic ( x ) Reasoning... endothermic ( Colugo ) I wish I had a distributed model... Mammal Endothermic Colugo Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 1/7

  9. Motivation Machine Reading and Reasoning Debugging Distributed Representations “Colugos are arboreal gliding Endothermic mammals that are found in Colugo Mammal Southeast Asia.” Kagu Ectothermic mammal ( Colugo ) HasFeathers “All mammals are endothermic.” ∀ x : mammal ( x ) ⇒ endothermic ( x ) Reasoning... endothermic ( Colugo ) I wish I had a distributed model... Mammal Endothermic Colugo Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 1/7

  10. Motivation Machine Reading and Reasoning Debugging Distributed Representations “Colugos are arboreal gliding Endothermic mammals that are found in Colugo Mammal Southeast Asia.” Kagu Ectothermic mammal ( Colugo ) HasFeathers “All mammals are endothermic.” Wrong Predictions ∀ x : mammal ( x ) ⇒ endothermic ( x ) mammal ( Kagu ) Reasoning... ectothermic ( Colugo ) endothermic ( Colugo ) I wish I had a distributed model... Mammal Endothermic Colugo Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 1/7

  11. Motivation Machine Reading and Reasoning Debugging Distributed Representations “Colugos are arboreal gliding Endothermic mammals that are found in Colugo Mammal Southeast Asia.” Kagu Ectothermic mammal ( Colugo ) HasFeathers “All mammals are endothermic.” Wrong Predictions ∀ x : mammal ( x ) ⇒ endothermic ( x ) mammal ( Kagu ) Reasoning... ectothermic ( Colugo ) endothermic ( Colugo ) I wish I had a distributed model... I wish I could fix this with... ∀ x : hasFeathers ( x ) ⇒ ¬ mammal ( x ) Mammal Endothermic ∀ x : animal ( x ) ⇒ Colugo endothermic ( x ) ⊕ ectothermic ( x ) Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 1/7

  12. Information Extraction Evidence DB Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 2/7

  13. Information Extraction Logic Evidence Relation Extraction mammal(Colugo), ∀ x : mammal( x ) ⇒ mammal(Tapir), endothermic( x ) endothermic(Colugo), DB Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 2/7

  14. Information Extraction Logic Evidence Discourse Representation Theory or Semantic Parsing Relation Extraction mammal(Colugo), ∀ x : mammal( x ) ⇒ mammal(Tapir), endothermic( x ) endothermic(Colugo), DB Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 2/7

  15. Information Extraction Logic Evidence Discourse Representation Theory or Semantic Parsing Relation Extraction mammal(Colugo), ∀ x : mammal( x ) ⇒ mammal(Tapir), endothermic( x ) endothermic(Colugo), DB Background Knowledge Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 2/7

  16. Logical Inference Logic Evidence Discourse Representation Theory or Semantic Parsing Relation Extraction mammal(Colugo), ∀ x : mammal( x ) ⇒ mammal(Tapir), endothermic( x ) endothermic(Colugo), DB Logical Inference Background · · · Knowledge Baader et al. (2007) Bos (2008) · · · endothermic(Tapir) Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 2/7

  17. Logical Inference Logic Evidence Discourse Representation Theory or Semantic Parsing Relation Extraction mammal(Colugo), ∀ x : mammal( x ) ⇒ mammal(Tapir), endothermic( x ) endothermic(Colugo), weight 0.53 DB Logical Inference Background · · · Knowledge Baader et al. (2007) Bos (2008) · · · Garrette et al. (2011) Beltagy et al. (2013) endothermic(Tapir) Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 2/7

  18. Inference via Distributed Representations Logic Distributed Representations Evidence Bordes et al. (2011), Nickel et al. (2012), Socher et al. (2013) Relation Tapir Extraction mammal(Colugo), ∀ x : mammal( x ) ⇒ mammal mammal(Tapir), endothermic( x ) endothermic(Colugo), Colguo endothermic DB Logical Inference Background · · · Knowledge Baader et al. (2007) Bos (2008) · · · Garrette et al. (2011) Beltagy et al. (2013) endothermic(Tapir) Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 2/7

  19. Inference via Distributed Representations Logic Distributed Representations Evidence Bordes et al. (2011), Nickel et al. (2012), Socher et al. (2013), Riedel et al. (2013) OpenIE Tapir mammal(Colugo), ∀ x : mammal( x ) ⇒ mammal mammal(Tapir), endothermic( x ) endothermic(Colugo), Colguo “Colugos, gliding endothermic mammals. . . “ DB Logical Inference Background · · · Knowledge Baader et al. (2007) Bos (2008) · · · Garrette et al. (2011) Beltagy et al. (2013) endothermic(Tapir) Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 2/7

  20. Inference via Distributed Representations Logic Distributed Representations Evidence Bordes et al. (2011), Nickel et al. (2012), Socher et al. (2013), Riedel et al. (2013) OpenIE Tapir mammal(Colugo), ∀ x : mammal( x ) ⇒ mammal mammal(Tapir), endothermic( x ) endothermic(Colugo), Colguo “Colugos, gliding endothermic mammals. . . “ DB Logical Inference Background Algebra · · · Knowledge Baader et al. (2007) Bos (2008) · · · Garrette et al. (2011) Beltagy et al. (2013) True endothermic(Tapir) endothermic(Tapir) False Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 2/7

  21. Distributed Representations that Simulate First-order Logical Reasoning Logic Distributed Representations Evidence Bordes et al. (2011), Nickel et al. (2012), Socher et al. (2013), Riedel et al. (2013) This Work OpenIE Tapir mammal(Colugo), ∀ x : mammal( x ) ⇒ mammal mammal(Tapir), endothermic( x ) endothermic(Colugo), Colguo “Colugos, gliding endothermic mammals. . . “ DB Logical Inference Background Algebra · · · Knowledge Baader et al. (2007) Bos (2008) · · · Garrette et al. (2011) Beltagy et al. (2013) True endothermic(Tapir) endothermic(Tapir) False Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 2/7

  22. Distributed Representations that Simulate First-order Logical Reasoning Logic Distributed Representations Evidence Bordes et al. (2011), Nickel et al. (2012), Socher et al. (2013), Riedel et al. (2013) This Work OpenIE mammal mammal(Colugo), ∀ x : mammal( x ) ⇒ mammal(Tapir), endothermic( x ) Colugo endothermic(Colugo), Tapir “Colugos, gliding endothermic mammals. . . “ DB Logical Inference Background Algebra · · · Knowledge Baader et al. (2007) Bos (2008) · · · Garrette et al. (2011) Beltagy et al. (2013) True endothermic(Tapir) endothermic(Tapir) False Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 2/7

  23. Distributed Representations that Simulate First-order Logical Reasoning Logic Distributed Representations Evidence Bordes et al. (2011), Nickel et al. (2012), Socher et al. (2013), Riedel et al. (2013) This Work OpenIE mammal mammal(Colugo), ∀ x : mammal( x ) ⇒ mammal(Tapir), endothermic( x ) Colugo endothermic(Colugo), Tapir “Colugos, gliding endothermic mammals. . . “ DB Logical Inference Background Algebra · · · Knowledge Baader et al. (2007) Bos (2008) · · · Garrette et al. (2011) Beltagy et al. (2013) True endothermic(Tapir) endothermic(Tapir) False Rockt¨ aschel et al. Low-dimensional Embeddings of Logic 2/7

  24. Propositional Logic Logic Logical Tensor Calculus (Grefenstette, 2013) � 1 � 0 � � [true]; [false] ; 0 1

Download Presentation
Download Policy: The content available on the website is offered to you 'AS IS' for your personal information and use only. It cannot be commercialized, licensed, or distributed on other websites without prior consent from the author. To download a presentation, simply click this link. If you encounter any difficulties during the download process, it's possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.

Recommend


More recommend