Kenneth Cobleigh, Managing Director and Counsel for AIA Robin G. - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

▶
kenneth cobleigh managing director and counsel for aia
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

Kenneth Cobleigh, Managing Director and Counsel for AIA Robin G. - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Nov 15, 2022 418 likes •964 views

The Evolution of the AIA Documents From 2007 to 2017 Kenneth Cobleigh, Managing Director and Counsel for AIA Robin G. Banks, Goldberg & Banks, P.C. A17 AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando Agenda AIA Contract

slide-1
SLIDE 1

The Evolution of the AIA Documents From 2007 to 2017

Kenneth Cobleigh, Managing Director and Counsel for AIA Robin G. Banks, Goldberg & Banks, P.C.

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

slide-2
SLIDE 2

Agenda

  • AIA Contract Documents History and Overview
  • What’s new in the Owner-Contractor Agreements and A201 General Conditions in

2017?

  • What’s new in the Owner-Architect Agreements in 2017?
  • Questions?
  • Contacts and Resources
slide-3
SLIDE 3

Overview

AIA Contract Documents Program

slide-4
SLIDE 4

Quiz

  • 1. When did the AIA publish its first set of standard form

documents? A. 1888 B. 1911 C. 1987, when Howard Goldberg first became outside counsel to the Documents Committee

First AIA Contract Document 1888

slide-5
SLIDE 5
  • 2. Who compromises the Documents Committee of the AIA?

A. Architects B. Lawyers C. Insurance advisors D. Howard Goldberg’s family and friends E. All of the above

slide-6
SLIDE 6
  • 3. What are the objectives of the Documents Committee in drafting

AIA Contract Documents? A. To create fair & balanced documents B. To balance competing interests C. To put risk where it is best managed D. All of the above

slide-7
SLIDE 7
  • 4. True or False

The Documents Committee takes all of the following steps when drafting AIA Contract Documents:

  • Seeking industry comment
  • Reviewing/incorporating legal decisions
  • Investigating the impact of industry practices
  • Drafting and revising the documents
  • Soliciting and reviewing feedback on drafts
  • Finalizing and publishing the documents
slide-8
SLIDE 8

The Documents

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

2017 Release

slide-9
SLIDE 9

2017 Release

What’s been revised?

  • A101™–2017, Owner and Contractor where the basis of payment is a Stipulated Sum *
  • A102™–2017, Owner and Contractor where the basis of payment is the Cost of the Work Plus a Fee with a

Guaranteed Maximum Price *

  • A103™–2017, Owner and Contractor where the basis of payment is the Cost of the Work Plus a Fee without a

Guaranteed Maximum Price *

  • A104™-201

017 (formerly A107-2007), Standard Abbreviated breviated Form of Agreement Between Owner and Contractor

  • A105™–2017, Standard Short

rt Form of Agreement Between Owner and Contractor

  • A201™–2017, General Conditions of the Contract for Construction
  • A401™–2017, Standard Form of Agreement Between Contractor and Subcontractor

* with new Insurance Exhibit

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

slide-10
SLIDE 10

2017 Release

What’s been revised?

  • B101™–2017, Standard Form of Agreement Between Owner and Architect
  • B102™–2017, Owner and Architect without a Predefined Scope of Architect’s Services
  • B103™–2017, Standard Form of Agreement Between Owner and Architect for a Complex

lex Proje ject ct

  • B104™–2017, Standard Abbrevi

breviat ated ed Form m of Agreement Between Owner and Architect

  • B105™–2017, Standard Short
  • rt Form of Agreement Between Owner and Architect
  • C401™–2017, Standard Form of Agreement Between Architect and Consultant
  • E204™–2017, Sustainable Projects Exhibit

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

slide-11
SLIDE 11

2017 Release

What is new? Program

slide-12
SLIDE 12

Sustainable Project Exhibit

  • History

Guide for Sustainable Projects AIA Document D503™ (2011) SP versions of standard AIA Documents (2007-2009) Sustainable Projects Exhibit AIA Document E204-2017

  • E204 is attached to owner, architect and contractor agreements
  • Same process, terminology, responsibilities and material as the SP versions, but

located and coordinated within a single exhibit

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

slide-13
SLIDE 13

Sustainable Project Exhibit

  • Establish a clear and detailed process to achieve the Sustainable Objective
  • Provide a clear and detailed description of the various roles and responsibilities of the

parties

  • Address key risk factors the parties might encounter (like product substitution,

delayed or failed certification, and consequential damages) and the exhibit now allows us publish just one version of the key document.

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

slide-14
SLIDE 14

Insurance Exhibit

AIA Document A101-2017 Exhibit A, Insurance and Bonds

  • Also used as an Exhibit to A102-2017 and A103-2017
  • Key terms of Exhibit and Article 11 of A201 written into A104
  • A105 contains very basic insurance provisions

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

slide-15
SLIDE 15

Insurance Exhibit

Most, but t not

  • t all, of the A201-2007 Insurance and Bonds requirements (Article 11) are moved

to the Exhibit:

  • Owner’s Insurance
  • Contractor’s Insurance
  • Optional Coverages
  • Additional Insureds
  • Performance & Payment Bonds

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

slide-16
SLIDE 16

Insurance: Why an Exhibit

  • Changing range and types of coverage
  • Flexibility in developing Project Insurance Requirements
  • Need to allow for adaptation to changes in the insurance market w/o edits to A201
  • Facilitate transmission to insurance advisors/brokers
  • Exhibit for 2014 Design-Build documents
slide-17
SLIDE 17

Insurance: The Exhibit

  • Requires Owner or Contractor to obtain and maintain property insurance written on

builder’s risk “all-risk” completed value or equivalent policy form

  • Begins from premise that Owner will obtain and maintain property insurance, but allow

parties to shift burden to Contractor

  • Sufficient to cover the value of the entire Project on a replacement cost basis
  • And existing structure in case of renovation or remodeling
  • Maintained until Substantial Completion and thereafter continued or replaced through the

Contractor’s one-year period for correction of the Work

slide-18
SLIDE 18

Insurance: The Exhibit

In addition, the parties may agree that the Owner will purchase and maintain certain optional extended property coverages:

  • Loss of Use, Business Interruption, and Delay in Completion Insurance
  • Ordinance or Law Insurance
  • Expediting Cost Insurance
  • Extra Expense Insurance
  • Civil Authority Insurance
  • Ingress/Egress Insurance
  • Soft Costs Insurance
slide-19
SLIDE 19

Insurance: The Exhibit

The parties may also agree that the Owner will purchase and maintain certain other optional coverages:

  • cyber security insurance
  • other potential Owner coverages
slide-20
SLIDE 20

Insurance: The Exhibit

Contractor Required Coverages for all Projects:

  • Commercial General Liability
  • Automobile liability
  • Worker’s compensation
  • Employer’s liability
slide-21
SLIDE 21

Insurance: The Exhibit

Contractor Required Coverages depending on the nature of the Project:

  • Jones Act and Longshore & Harbor Worker’s Compensation
  • Professional Liability
  • Pollution liability coverage
  • Maritime Liability
  • Coverage for use or operation of manned or unmanned aircraft
slide-22
SLIDE 22

Insurance: The Exhibit

Other coverages the Contractor might obtain:

  • Railroad Protective liability
  • Asbestos Abatement liability
  • Coverage for physical damage to property while in storage or transit
  • Property coverage for property owned by he Contractor and used on the Project

Payment and Performance Bonds

slide-23
SLIDE 23

Insurance: The Exhibit

Key Take Away:

  • Exhibit allows parties to develop project specific owner and contractor insurance

requirements

  • If parties simply want the standard coverages historically required by A201, they simply

need ignore optional coverage sections and fill in required policy limits/sub-limits and penal sums for bonds.

slide-24
SLIDE 24

Insurance: A201 Article 11

  • Owner and Contractor must provide each other with notice of an impending or actual

cancellation or expiration of coverage

  • Notice provided within 3 business days of the date the party becomes aware
  • Party receiving notice has the right to stop the Work until lapse cured– unless lapse caused

by that party

  • Notice does not relieve party of the contractual obligation to provide any coverage
  • Additional provisions protect the interest of the Contractor and Subs if the Owner fails to

purchase required coverage

slide-25
SLIDE 25

Insurance: A201 Article 11

New provisions on adjustment and settlement of loss covered by property insurance:

  • Loss adjusted by and payable to the Owner as fiduciary
  • Prior to settlement Owner notifies Contractor of proposed settlement and proposed

allocation of proceeds

  • Contractor has 14days to object
  • If Contractor does not object, the Owner settles and Contractor bound by settlement and

allocation

  • If Contractor timely objects, Owner may proceed to settle the loss and dispute between

Owner and Contractor is resolved per the Claims and Disputes provisions

slide-26
SLIDE 26

2017 Release

Key Terms and Concept Changes

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

slide-27
SLIDE 27

BIM and other Digital Data

  • 2017 Agreements require the parties to agree on protocols governing the use and

transmission of digital data, and

  • Require the use of E203, G201 and G202 to establish those protocols
  • With respect to BIM, the 2017 agreements further provide that any use of, or reliance on,

information contained in a Model, without first having established the protocols, is at the using or relying party’s own risk and without liability to any other project participant

slide-28
SLIDE 28

Termination Fee Provisions

  • AIA documents allow Owner to terminate for convenience
  • In 2007 documents:
  • Contractor and Subs were entitled to “reasonable overhead and profit on work not

executed”

  • Architect and Consultants were entitled to “anticipated profit on the value of

services not performed”

slide-29
SLIDE 29

Termination Fee Provisions

  • 2017 documents:
  • Owner-Contractor, Owner-Architect , and Architect-Consultant agreements

eliminate automatic entitlement to OH&P and prompt parties to discuss and negotiate a termination fee

  • A401 retains entitlement to OH&P on unperformed Work
  • Nothing prevents Contractor and Sub from negotiating a termination fee in lieu of

arguing over lost OH&P calculation

slide-30
SLIDE 30

Liquidated Damages and Incentive Provisions

Earlier editions of Owner-Contractor Agreements had parenthetical note prompting parties to insert liquidated damages and incentive provisions Liquidated Damages can be used to offset waiver of consequential damages 2017 Documents have separate fill points to prompt the parties to discuss liquidated damages provisions and incentive provisions

slide-31
SLIDE 31

Notice

  • A201-2017

17 § 1.6.1 Except as otherwise provided in Section 1.6.2, where the Contract Documents require one party to notify or give notice to the other party, such notice shall be provided in writi ting ng to the designated representative of the party to whom the notice is addressed and shall be deemed to have been duly served if delivered in person, by mail, by courier, or by electronic transmission if a method for electronic transmission is set forth in the Agreement.

  • A20

201-20 2017 17 § 1.6.2 1.6.2 Notice of Claims as provided in Section 15.1.3 shall be provided in writing and shall be deemed to have been duly served only if delivered to the designated representative

  • f the party to whom the notice is addressed by certified or registered mail, or by courier

providing proof of delivery.

slide-32
SLIDE 32

Safety of Construction Means and Methods

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

3.3.1 3.3.1 The Contractor can object to means or methods specified and can propose alternative means and methods.

  • Contractor not required to perform the Work in a manner it deems unsafe
  • The Contractor then proposes alternative approach
  • The Architect reviews it to assure it is consistent with design intent
slide-33
SLIDE 33

Project Communications

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

  • A201-2017

17 Secti tion

  • n 4.2.4:

– More permissive of direct communications between the owner and contractor. – Owner must make Architect aware of direct communications

  • B101-2017 updated to be consistent with revisions in A201-2017
slide-34
SLIDE 34

Progress Payments and Retainage

  • Progress Payments (A101-2017

2017 § 5.1.6 5.1.6) – Provisions pertaining to the calculation of progress payments clarified and simplified to clearly delineate the basis for each progress payment.

  • Retainage (A101-2017

2017 § 5.1.7 5.1.7) – Now in a new independent section – Specification of retainage amount – Items that should be excluded from retainage – How retainage may be reduced at or before substantial completion.

slide-35
SLIDE 35

Contractor’s Construction Schedule

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

3.10.1 3.10.1 Expansion of basic content required in the Contractor’s Construction Schedule

  • Show dates of commencement, required milestones, and Substantial

Completion

  • Apportionment of Work by construction activity
  • Time required to complete each portion of Work
  • Demonstrate an orderly progression of the Work
  • Revised and updated at appropriate intervals
slide-36
SLIDE 36

Claims and Disputes

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

Clarified that claims first discovered after the warranty period are not required to go through the IDM: § 15.1.3.2 15.1.3.2 Claims by either the Owner or Contractor, where the condition giving rise to the Claim is first discovered after expiration of the period for correction of the Work set forth in Section 12.2.2, shall be initiated by notice to the other party. In such event, no decision by the Initial Decision Maker is required

slide-37
SLIDE 37

Removing Lien Claims

  • A201-2017

17 § 9.6.8 Provided the Owner has fulfilled its payment obligations under the Contract Documents, the Contractor shall defend and indemnify the Owner from all loss, liability, damage or expense, including reasonable attorney’s fees and litigation expenses, arising out of any lien claim or other claim for payment by any Subcontractor or supplier of any tier. Upon receipt of notice of a lien claim or other claim for payment, the Owner shall notify the Contractor. If approved by the applicable court, when required, the Contractor may substitute a surety bond for the property against which the lien or other claim for payment has been asserted.

slide-38
SLIDE 38

2017 Release

Key B101 Changes

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

slide-39
SLIDE 39

B101-2017

Initial Information

  • Done Away with Optional Exhibit A
  • Substance of 2007 Exhibit A incorporated into standard

agreement

  • Sustainable Objective to be identified, if any
  • Digital Practice and BIM addressed

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

slide-40
SLIDE 40

B101-2017

Article 3 - Scope of Services

  • Traditional 5 Phases of Services Remain with only minor edits/additions

– Clarify that Architect is not responsible for Owner’s acceptance of non- conforming work. – Updated approach to Sustainability Services – Bidding/Negotiation Phase now Procurement Phase – Substitutions During Procurement now Additional Service

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

slide-41
SLIDE 41

B101-2017

Article 3 - Scope of Services (Cont.)

  • Traditional 5 Phases of Services Remain with only minor edits/additions

– Clarifies Architect’s scope of review of Contractor’s design submittals

  • Consistency with Design Concept Only
  • Architect may rely on, and is not responsible for adequacy of the submittals

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

slide-42
SLIDE 42

B101-2017

Article 4 - Supplemental and Additional Services (Cont.)

  • B101-2017 has Supplemental and Additional Services

– Supplement lemental al Services ices – services not included in Basic Services that the Architect agreed to provide at the time the contract is executed (aka “that big table in Section 4.1”) – Addi ditiona tional l Services ices – services necessitated by circumstances as the project progresses

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

slide-43
SLIDE 43

B101-2017

Article 6 – Cost of the Work

  • Modified definition to include work/materials donated to the Owner.
  • Revised architect’s duty to redesign without compensation for budget bust.

– Architect can obtain Additional compensation if re-design due to market conditions the Architect could not reasonably anticipate. – Approach is consistent with FAR Design Within Funding Obligation (Design Within Funding Limitations 48 CFR 52.236-22)

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

slide-44
SLIDE 44

B101-2017

Article 9 – Termination or Suspension

  • Deleted Termination Expenses

– Replaced with negotiable Termination Fee. – Paired with Licensing Fee for continued use of IOS

  • Added automatic termination date

– One year from the date of Substantial Completion – Explicit on provisions that survive termination

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

slide-45
SLIDE 45

B101-2017

Article 11 – Compensation

  • Added provision clarifying progress payment calculations to the Architect where overall

compensation is on a percentage basis.

  • B101-2007 silent on the issue
  • B101-2017 identifies calculation method

– previous payments will not be subsequently adjusted based on changes to the Owner’s budget.

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

slide-46
SLIDE 46
  • Digital Practice and BIM addressed – consistent with other 2017 documents
  • Standard of Care – C401 states Consultant’s standard of care, but if the Prime

Agreement includes a different standard, the Consultant agrees to perform consistent with the Prime Agreement standard of care.

  • Insurance language updated consistent with other 2017 documents

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

C401-2017, Architect/Consultant Agreement

slide-47
SLIDE 47
  • Termination and Licensing Fees

– Separate Termination and Licensing Fees for terminations not the fault of the Consultant and terminations due to the Owner terminating the Prime Agreement

  • If the Owner Terminates the Prime Agreement for the Owner’s convenience, the

Consultant’s Termination and Licensing fees are contingent on the Architect receiving a Termination Fee from the Owner.

  • For all other terminations not the fault of the Consultant, the Consultant’s Termination

and Licensing fees are not contingent.

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

C401-2017 (Cont.)

slide-48
SLIDE 48

2017 Release

Upcoming Education & Resources

slide-49
SLIDE 49

To view comparisons between the 2007/2017 documents, please click here

slide-50
SLIDE 50

Questions regarding this webinar?

Co Conta tact ct:

Hasti Hejazi Director of Global Innovation Education The American Institute of Architects hasti stihejazi hejazi@aia.org aia.org

slide-51
SLIDE 51

AIA Contract Documents 2017 Webinar: Owner- Architect Agreements and New Sustainable Projects Exhibit

  • June 1, 2-3:30pm
  • Registration Page

AIA Contract Documents 2017 Webinar: Revised General Conditions and New Sustainable Projects Exhibit

  • June 7, 3-4:00pm
  • Registration Page

AIA Contract Documents 2017 Webinar: Owner-Contractor Agreements and New Sustainable Projects Exhibit

  • June 15, 3-4:00pm
  • Registration Page

Upcoming Webinars

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando

slide-52
SLIDE 52

AIA Contract Documents Learn Page: www.aiacontracts.org/learn AIA Contract Documents education on AIAU: aiau.aia.org/aia-contract-documents Questions about AIA document content: Email: docinfo@aia.org Tel.: (202) 626-7526 Questions about ACD5: Email: docstechsupport@aia.org Tel.: (800) 942-7732

Contact and Resource Information

slide-53
SLIDE 53

Thank You!

A’17

AIA Conference on Architecture 2017 April 27-29, Orlando