IETF Standardization Process and German Activities: a Brief Overview - - PDF document

▶
ietf standardization process and german activities a
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

IETF Standardization Process and German Activities: a Brief Overview - - PDF document

Dec 22, 2022 264 likes •328 views

IETF Standardization Process and German Activities: a Brief Overview Prof. Dr. Xiaoming Fu Computer Networks Group Institute of Computer Science Georg-August-Universitt Gttingen http:/ / www.net.informatik.uni-goettingen.de/ IETF Overview

slide-1
SLIDE 1

IETF Standardization Process and German Activities: a Brief Overview

  • Prof. Dr. Xiaoming Fu

Computer Networks Group Institute of Computer Science Georg-August-Universität Göttingen http:/ / www.net.informatik.uni-goettingen.de/ IETF Overview

  • does not exist (in a legal sense), no members, no voting

– Groups make decisions by “rough consensus & running code”

  • “

“We reject kings, presidents and voting. We believe in We reject kings, presidents and voting. We believe in rough consensus rough consensus and running code and running code” ”, David Clark, 1992 , David Clark, 1992

– Consensus must be found on mailing lists rather than at physical meetings

  • 118ish working groups (where the stuff happens)
  • 8 areas (for organizational convenience) with ADs

– GEN, APS, RAI, TSV, RTG, INT, OPS, SEC

  • IESG: management (ADs + IETF Chair)
  • produces standards and other

21.-22.07.2008, Würzburg 2

Xiaoming Fu (U Göttingen)

slide-2
SLIDE 2

RFCs

21.-22.07.2008, Würzburg

  • Historical Archive
  • Many kinds of

– Informational – Historical – Experimental – Standards

  • Standards

– Proposed (PS)

– good idea, no known problems

– Draft (DS)

– PS + stable multiple interoperable implementations

– Full (STD)

– PS + wide use

– Best Current Practice (BCP)

– policies or procedures (best way we know how)

3

Xiaoming Fu (U Göttingen)

Standard track document processing cycle

  • Draft-00 RFC:
  • avg. 23 months

– If successful

  • RFC Editor Queue:
  • avg. 9 weeks

– Up to 2 years

21.-22.07.2008, Würzburg

  • Working group doc, or

Working group doc, or individual standards track doc individual standards track doc IESG IESG RFC Editor RFC Editor Submit Submit Concerns Concerns

Published RFC Published RFC

IETF Community IETF Community Review Review “ “Last Call Last Call” ” Comments, Comments, suggestions suggestions

4

Xiaoming Fu (U Göttingen)

slide-3
SLIDE 3

Non Non-

  • IETF Submissions

IETF Submissions

21.-22.07.2008, Würzburg

individual individual RFC Editor RFC Editor IESG IESG Submit Submit Comments Comments Content concerns and Content concerns and editorial details editorial details Publish Publish

5

Xiaoming Fu (U Göttingen)

German Activities: Overview

  • AD: Lars Eggert (now at Nokia/ FI, pre: NEC)
  • WG Chairs from Germany:

– Juergen Quittek: IPFIX, PSAMP (NEC) – Julien Laganier: BTNS, MEXT (NEC) – Martin Stiemerling: NSIS (NEC) – Juergen Schoenwaelder: ISMS (J U Bremen) – Joerg Ott: mmusic (HUT/ TKK, pre: U Bremen) – Hannes Tschofenig: ecrit, dime, keyprov (NSN, pre: Siemens)

  • Most active insitutions of Germany:

– NEC Europe Labs, Siemens, NSN, T-Systems, SUN (Waibstadt), FOKUS, Greenbytes (Münster), … – Bremen U. & Jacobs U., Münster FH, Göttingen U., Karlsruhe U., Braunschweig TU, Tübingen U., Essen U...

  • Primary focuses:

– RAI (AVT, MMUSC, SIP/ SIPPING, P2PSIP), TSV (TSVWG, NSIS, RSERPOOL), OPS (IPPM, IPFIX, PSAMP), SEC (ISMS), INT (NETLMM)

21.-22.07.2008, Würzburg 6

Xiaoming Fu (U Göttingen)

slide-4
SLIDE 4

RFCs co-authored by German authors

  • Among all 5043 RFCs (as of 22.06.2008):

– USA : 4329 (86%) – UK: 335 (6.6%) – Canada: 210 (4.2%) – Germ any: 196 (3. 9 %) – Finland: 183 (3.6%) – Japan: 145 (2.9%) – Sweden: 144 (2.9%) – France: 128 (2.5%) – …India: 33 (0.65%), China: 8 (0.16%)!

  • Most productive RFC authors from Germany:

– Henning Schulzrinne (63), Juergen Schoenwaelder (26), Hannes Tschofenig (18), Carsten Bormann (17), Erik Guttman (14), Juergen Quittek (12), Joerg Ott (11), Michael Tüxen (10 ), Martin Stiemerling (7), Arnt Gulbrandsen (7), …, Tanja Zseby(2), Roland Bless (2), Xiaom ing Fu (1)...

21.-22.07.2008, Würzburg 7

Xiaoming Fu (U Göttingen)

Internet draft contributors from Germany

  • Among all active 1553 I-Ds (as of 22.06.08):

– USA : 964 (62%) – UK: 192 (12%) – Finland: 164 (11%) – France: 159 (10%) – Germ any: 157 (10 %) – Japan: 129 (8.3%) – Canada: 113 (7.3%) – China: 63 (4%) – Sweden: 56 (3.6%) – …India: 35 (2.25%)

  • 164 active ID authors from Germany work in 38 WGs

– Including: Thomas Dreibholz (11), Saverio Niccolini (10), Julian F. Reschke (10), Michael Tuexen (8 ), Juergen Schoenwaelder (7), Xiaom ing Fu (7), Martin Stiemerling (5), Thomas Schierl (5), Juergen Quittek (4 ), Tanja Zseby (4 ), Michael Menth (4), … , Roland Bless (1)… – Hannes Tschofenig (45), Henning Schulzrinne (33), Joerg Ott (6 ), …

– Glad to have our speakers to share their precious experiences!

21.-22.07.2008, Würzburg 8

Xiaoming Fu (U Göttingen)