SLIDE 1 An Environmental Health Perspective
Kathryn Savoie, Ph.D.
Detroit Community Health Director
March 20, 2020
SLIDE 2 Learning Objectives
- List 2 examples of how an
industrialized food system results in adverse health
- utcomes in the US
- Identify 2 actions that health
professionals can engage in to create a healthy food system at an institutional/ organizational level
SLIDE 3 Scope of Presentation
Part I:
- What is a Food System?
- Health Care Advocacy
- Health Concerns of an Industrialized Food
System
- Climate Change
- Pesticides
Part II: Making Change
SLIDE 4
An Ecological Health Framework
SLIDE 5
What is Healthy Food?
SLIDE 6
A Food Systems Approach
Healthy food has high nutritional value and comes from a food system that is ecologically sound economically viable, and socially responsible.
SLIDE 7 What is a Food System?
✔ Growing ✔ Harvesting ✔ Processing ✔ Packaging ✔ Transportation ✔ Marketing ✔ Consumption ✔ Waste Disposal
(food and packaging)
SLIDE 8
What is a Food System?
✔ All inputs used ✔ All outputs generated ✔ Operates within and is influenced by social, political, economic and environmental context ✔ human resources that provide labor, research and education
SLIDE 9
What is a Food System?
SLIDE 10
SLIDE 11
SLIDE 12
SLIDE 13
SLIDE 14
Conventional (Industrial) Food Systems
SLIDE 15
Conventional (Industrial) Food Systems
SLIDE 16 Conventional/Industrial Food Systems
- Large scale, monoculture
- Industrial machinery, fossil fuels
- Separates animal and plant production
- Favors distant distribution/processed foods
- Favors the use of pesticides and synthetic fertilizers
- Produces large quantities of highly processed calorie-
rich, nutrient-poor food
- Major driver of obesity, some kinds of cancer,
malnutrition, diabetes, cardiovascular disease, and
SLIDE 17
Alternative Food Systems
SLIDE 18
- Health care sector bears the burden of
treating illness associated with our broken food system.
- Health care providers interact daily with
people who experience food-related disease, and may be receptive to a food systems approach
- Healthcare professionals have
credibility, influence, and expertise.
Healthcare Advocacy
SLIDE 19 Anti-smoking campaigns is an excellent model.
Healthcare Advocacy
Multiple interventions at many levels:
- Regulation
- changing health care
environments
SLIDE 20
ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH CONCERNS IN OUR FOOD SYSTEM
SLIDE 21
THE FOOD SYSTEM: MICHIGAN APPLES
SLIDE 22 GROWING HARVESTING WASHING, GRADING, WAXING PACKING DISTRIBUTING PROCESSING PACKAGING RETAILING PREPARING CONSUMING DISPOSING COMPOSTING
THE FOOD SYSTEM: MICHIGAN APPLES
SLIDE 23 Key health concerns with our industrialized food system
◻ Exposure to toxic
chemicals
◻ Antibiotic resistance ◻ Food-borne illness ◻ Genetically modified
◻ Environmental
degradation
◻ Consumption
patterns
SLIDE 24
Where in the food system do these concerns exist?
SLIDE 25
Food Systems Approach: Climate Change
SLIDE 26 Agriculture and Climate Change
◻ Deforestation ◻ Livestock ◻ Animal manure and rice paddies ◻ Water use ◻ Fossil fuel use
SLIDE 27 How our Food System Impacts the Climate
- Contributes up to 30% of total greenhouse
gas emissions
– clearing forests for new agricultural land – methane emissions from livestock and rice
production
- Accounts for 80% of global deforestation
- Uses 70% of the world’s available fresh
water
SLIDE 28
SLIDE 29
SLIDE 30
How Climate Impacts our Food Systems
SLIDE 31
SLIDE 32 Changing Weather Patterns:
◻ Extreme heat > Poor air quality ◻ Increased precipitation > flooding ◻ Drought > desertification ◻ Superstorms
Insect borne diseases Psychological damage
Climate Change Impacts
SLIDE 33
SLIDE 34
SLIDE 35
Climate Change Impacts in Michigan
SLIDE 36
PESTICIDES IN FOOD PRODUCTION
SLIDE 37 ◻ A pesticide is any substance or mixture of
substances used to prevent, destroy, repel or reduce pests and the damage caused by pests.
◻ Pests are living organisms that occur where they
are not wanted or that cause damage to crops, humans, or other animals.
◻ Pests can include insects, weeds, fungi, and
rodents.
What is a pesticide?
SLIDE 38 ◻ Over 16,000 pesticide products in use in the United
States (agricultural and non-agricultural).
◻ Major categories:
Organophosphates Carbamates Pyrethrins Pyrethroids Biologicals Organochlorines
Pesticide Use
SLIDE 39 ◻ Health effects
depend on the type
◻ Acute and chronic
effects
Nervous System Skin or eye irritants Hormone or
endocrine system
Carcinogens Obesogens – linked
to increase BMI, insulin resistance
Health Concerns of Pesticide Use
SLIDE 40
Farm Workers and Pesticides
SLIDE 41
Pesticides and Bees
SLIDE 42 Food Matters: to Pregnant Women, Children, and Future Generations
Nutrition Matters Good nutrition is an essential requirement of healthy human development Timing Matters Health consequences
life exposures Vulnerability Matters Developing fetus and young human are uniquely vulnerable to environmental exposures
SLIDE 43
A Food System Approach: Public Policy
SLIDE 44
A Food System Approach:
Economic Drivers of Food Choice
SLIDE 45 Food deserts
▪ Urban and rural communities with
economic and transportation barriers to accessing healthy food
Hunger in America
▪ Over 49 million Americans live in
households that are “food insecure”
▪ US minimum wage = $7.25/hour
A Food System Approach: Access & Availability
SLIDE 46 Largest Impact
Examples
Eat healthy, be physically active Rx for high cholesterol,
- diabetes. Vitamin/Mineral
supplements Poverty, education level, inequality Immunizations, exercise, colonoscopy Strategic Food/Bev Pricing, HFHC Pledge, Farmers Markets, CSA
Socioeconomic Factors Changing the Context
to make individuals’ default decisions healthy
Long-lasting Protective Interventions Clinical Interventions
Counseling & Education Smallest Impact Largest
Impact
www.cdc.gov/about/grand-rounds/archives/2010/download/GR-021810.pdf
Factors that affect health
SLIDE 47 A Food System Approach: Externalities Health and environmental costs are not reflected in the price of food
in the food system
SLIDE 48 Changing your thinking: A systems perspective
Story M, Hamm MW, Wallinga D, eds. Food Systems and Public Health: Linkages to Achieve Healthier Diets and Healthier Communities (suppl) Journal of Hunger & Environmental Nutrition, Volume 4, Issues 3 & 4. December 2009 (in press)
Farm & Food Policy Healthier Eating Environments Behavior Change
SLIDE 49 “Our national obesity epidemic is but a single symptom of a more serious illness:
- ur unhealthy food system.
In order to prescribe healthier food, we must rethink the entire system, from the farm to
David Wallinga, MD – Healthy Food Action, 2010
SLIDE 50
Healthy Food in Health Care: A Menu of Change
SLIDE 51
Making Change
✔In Your Practice ✔In Your Institution ✔In Your Professional Affiliations ✔In Communities ✔Regionally ✔Nationally ✔Globally
SLIDE 52
Be aware of and help educate patients about how to reduce pesticide exposure
In Your Practice
SLIDE 53
In Your Practice
SLIDE 54
SLIDE 55
SLIDE 56
20% by 2020 Procuring, Serving Healthier Food
SLIDE 57
Educating Peers
SLIDE 58 Health care farming…
Henry Ford West Bloomfield Greenhouse Organic Hydroponic
SLIDE 59 . . . and farmers markets/farm stands
Eastern Market Farm Stand at DMC
SLIDE 60
Fruit and Vegetable Prescription Programs
❖ Link health care and food systems ❖ Support a healthier local food system
SLIDE 61
SLIDE 62 Making Change In Communities
- Local Food Policy Councils
- Farm to School efforts
- Corner Store Conversions
- Community Gardens
- Educating community leaders and elected
- fficials
SLIDE 63 Making Change Nationally
Ecology Center
Health professional engagement in healthy food advocacy www.ecocenter.org
Safer Chemicals, Healthy Families
Reform Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA) to keep toxins out of food www.saferchemicals.org
Health Care Without Harm Health professional engagement
https://noharm-uscanada.org/content/us-canada/health-professional- engagement
Food Research Action Council National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition
SLIDE 64
Thank you!
kathryn@ecocenter.org