HB 278 Update A Report on the Advantages and Disadvantages of - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

HB 278 Update A Report on the Advantages and Disadvantages of Prototypical School Design and Construction in Alaska

2015 ASA Legislative Fly-In Annual Conference 3/8/15

Introduction

Purpose of the Study:

HB 278 Sec. 53

School Design and Construction Report

• The Department of Education And Early Development shall

prepare and submit a report to the legislature not later than June 15, 2015, on the benefits and disadvantages of using prototypical designs for school construction in both the railbelt and rural areas of the state

Project Team

Report Objectives

The Study Includes:

• Objective #1: Conduct research at a national level to examine the

successes and failures of prototypical school design and construction as a basis from which to start research at a local/state level.

• Objective #2: Gain a comprehensive understanding of Alaska’s diversity

with respect to culture, geography & climate and how these diversities influence school design and construction overall and in particular prototypical school design and construction.

• Objective #3: Reach out to various people groups of Alaska to gather

first hand information related to their experiences in the utilization of prototypical design and construction in local schools.

• Objective #4: Create a well researched & documented report suitable

to present to the Alaska State Legislature that informs the body of the Benefits and Disadvantages of Prototypical School Design and Construction in Alaska.

Methodology/Process

Project Work Plan: Step 5: Final Report Step 4: Compare/Contrast the Findings of the Expansive Research with the Local Step 3: Survey & Analyze the Local Context (Statewide Research) Step 1: Define the Objective Step 2: Research & Analyze the Expansive Context (National Research)

Define the Advantages and Disadvantages of Statewide Prototypical School Design in Alaska

Methodology/Process

Step 1: Define the Objective

How will we define an advantage? How will we define a disadvantage?

Economics Education Community

affordability consistency equity scalability familiarity familiarity ?? ?? ?? Strategic alignment

• Ed. adequacy

local “fit-ness” Design relative to local climate homogeneity no local input ?? ?? ??

Methodology/Process

Step 1: Define the Objective – DEFINE YOUR TERMS!

Step 2: Research & Analyze the Expansive Context (National Research)

• DeJONG-RICHTER will begin with a survey of

research on the target objective

• This survey will culminate in a research synopsis

which will be presented to DEED and the community at large

• The findings of this survey will inform questionnaire

development for all stakeholders

Methodology/Process

Step 3: Survey & Analyze the Local Context (Statewide Research) Our team will be spending 1-2 days in each of the 6 major geographical regions of Alaska

Methodology/Process

• Cover all of Alaska’s diverse regions
• Invite school executives and architects from each

region to the meetings

• Tour schools in each region

(Look at schools that are considered most educationally adequate, and schools that have notable challenges)

• Host a large community meeting with

questionnaires and small group discussions

Methodology/Process

Step 3: Survey & Analyze the Local Context (Statewide Research)

Step 4: Compare/Contrast the Findings of the Expansive Research with the Local

• DeJONG-RICHTER will collate and analyze the

results from the questionnaires & tours

• DeJONG-RICHTER will provide data summaries of

these analyses with summary narratives.

• DeJONG-RICHTER will compare/contrast the findings
• f the tours and questionnaires with the broader

research study.

Methodology/Process

Step 5: Final Report

• DeJONG-RICHTER & Nvision will provide a report
• n the Benefits and Disadvantages for the use of

Prototypical School Design and Construction Statewide in Alaska

• Report will be based upon:
• National Research
• Local Research
• Local Stakeholder Feedback

Methodology/Process

Work Summary to Date

Completed:

• A detailed “Work Plan” was developed
• The Research & Analysis of the Expansive Context

(National Research) has been completed

• In Summary – Facility Prototype Design appears most

advantageous in large individual districts w/ rapid growth

• The Survey & Analysis of the Local Context

(Statewide Research) has been started

• A “Request for Information” was sent to all School Districts

throughout Alaska in January 2015

• Conference Agendas & Questionnaires have been developed
• Regional Conferences & the Statewide Conference have been

scheduled w/ invitations sent out

.

Regional Conferences

Arctic Region Barrow – Mon. March 9th, 2015 Interior Region Fairbanks – Tues. March 10th, 2015 West Region Bethel – Thur. March 12th, 2015 Southwest Region Kodiak – Fri. March 13th, 2015 Southeast Region Juneau – Mon. March 30th, 2015 Southcentral Region Mat-Su – Tues. March 31st, 2015 Anchorage – Wed. April 1st, 2015

Regional Conferences

Purpose/Intent: The Regional Conferences are designed to communicate with and gather local perspectives from community members, educators, facility managers and the professional design and construction industry as the basis for research within the State of Alaska. Each Regional Conference will feature the following:

• Presentation of National Research
• Questionnaires will be completed by everyone in attendance
• Interactive discussion and comments
• Public Opportunity to have a voice in the research process

Statewide Conference

Statewide Anchorage – Fri. April 3rd, 2015

Statewide Conference

Purpose/Intent: The Statewide Conference is designed to communicate with and gather local perspectives from the educational community exclusively. With the Regional Conferences complete, the Statewide Conference will be an in-depth examination of the findings on a more intensive level with education professionals and facility operators. The research team will engage the audience through a work session that will involve discussion and analysis of both the national and statewide research results.