SLIDE 1
Thomas P. Lockerby, Phillips Academy Planned Giving Council of NH & VT June 1, 2017
Hacking Human Nature
How behavioral economics informs fundraising success
Hacking Human Nature How behavioral economics informs fundraising - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Hacking Human Nature How behavioral economics informs fundraising - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Hacking Human Nature How behavioral economics informs fundraising success Thomas P. Lockerby, Phillips Academy Planned Giving Council of NH & VT June 1, 2017 Inspirations Agenda Basic principles A quick romp through economic
SLIDE 2
SLIDE 3
Agenda
✤ Basic principles ✤ A quick romp through economic history ✤ Rise of behavioral economics ✤ Economics turns to fundraising ✤ Wrap
SLIDE 4
Laws of Supply and Demand
P* S D Q P Q*
Does economics govern philanthropy?
SLIDE 5
18th Century: Birth of Economics
✤ Adam Smith, 1723-1790 ✤ The Wealth of Nations, 1776; The
Theory of Moral Sentiments,1759
✤ Division of labor [WoN] ✤ “Invisible hand” [WoN] ✤ Mutual sympathy of sentiments
[TMS]
Smith
SLIDE 6
19th Century: From Malthus to Marx
✤ Thomas Malthus, 1766-1834
Karl Marx, 1818-1883
✤ The Principle of Population, 1798
(Malthus); Das Kapital, 1867 (Marx)
✤ Arithmetic increase in food/geometric
increase in population: scarcity [PoP]
✤ Capitalism leads to the alienation of
labor (proletariat) at the hands of the wealth-holders (bourgeoisie) [DK]
Marx Malthus
SLIDE 7
20th Century: Cambridge Circus to the Chicago School
✤ John Maynard Keynes, 1883-1946
Milton Friedman, 1912-2006
✤ General Theory of Employment,
Interest, and Money, 1936 (Keynes); A Theory of the Consumption Function, 1957 (Friedman)
✤ Propensity to consume [GT] ✤ Permanent income hypothesis [CF]
Friedman Keynes
SLIDE 8
Human Nature: Behavioral Economics
✤ Daniel Kahneman, 1934-
Amos Tversky, 1937-1996
✤ “Judgement under
uncertainty” (Science, 1974); “The framing of decisions and the psychology of choice” (Science, 1991)
✤ Errors arising from heuristics and
biases
✤ Prospect theory
Kahneman Tversky
SLIDE 9
Human Nature: Behavioral Economics
✤ Richard Thaler, 1945- ✤ Quasi Rational Economics, 1994;
The Winner’s Curse, 1992; The Big Short (cameo), 2015
✤ The limits of rationality in
economic decisions
✤ Nudges as economic tools
Thaler
SLIDE 10
The Hack: Philanthropic Economics
✤ James Andreoni, 1959-
Dean Karlan, 1968- John List, 1968-
✤ “Toward a Theory of Charitable
Fundraising,” Journal of Political Economy, 1998 (Andreoni); “Does Price Matter in Charitable Giving?” American Economic Review, 2007 (Karlan and List)
Karlan List Andreoni
SLIDE 11
What does economics tell us about philanthropy?
SLIDE 12
The Philanthropic Economists Ask:
Why do people make charitable gifts? Altruism theory People give because collective philanthropy maximizes the public good. Warm-glow theory People give because they get something of personal value from the act, over and above the collective social benefit.
SLIDE 13
The Philanthropic Economists Ask:
Do matching gifts work? Yes, but . . . Larger matches (3:1 or 4:1 vs 1:1) seem to have little extra effect. Limited reciprocity and commitment effects Donors respond to matches because of the desire to align their behavior with others but these behaviors are not substantially affected by the scale of the match.
SLIDE 14
The Philanthropic Economists Ask:
Should campaigns start at $0? No Multiple studies show that both the number of donors and the average size of gifts increased as a result of early leadership donor support. Threshold and credibility effects Donors respond to initiatives that have already achieved a level of success.
SLIDE 15
The Philanthropic Economists Ask:
What is the best appeal to increase bequest intentions? Include reference to others who have already done so. “Nudge unit” in Britain worked with the Remember a Charity organization to test simple message variants.
SLIDE 16
The Philanthropic Economists Ask:
What is the best appeal to increase bequest intentions? Include reference to others who have already done so. “Nudge unit” in Britain worked with the Remember a Charity organization to test simple message variants. Social norming Donors respond to initiatives that have already achieved a level of success.
SLIDE 17
Wrapping Up
✤ The philanthropic sector is worthy of economic study—so that
we can understand our work and perform at our best.
✤ Understanding donor behavior is the critical factor. ✤ Behavioral economics has much to tell us about the intersection
- f human nature and economic decisions.
✤ There are many experts whose work is accessible to the lay
person.
✤ If nothing else, this is great cocktail party fodder!
SLIDE 18