Export Opportunity Scan p pp y for ECOWAS countries
Michael Freudenberg Michael Freudenberg Market Analysis Section, ITC
Export Opportunity Scan p pp y for ECOWAS countries Michael - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Export Opportunity Scan p pp y for ECOWAS countries Michael Freudenberg Michael Freudenberg Market Analysis Section, ITC Introduction The problem: Exports of many ECOWAS countries are concentrated Exports of many ECOWAS countries are
Michael Freudenberg Michael Freudenberg Market Analysis Section, ITC
The problem: Exports of many ECOWAS countries are concentrated – Exports of many ECOWAS countries are concentrated
– Diversifying the economy and broadening the export base towards high-growth sectors is key for future growth. – Governments often need to complement general (“horizontal”) policies that improve the overall business environment general ( horizontal ) policies that improve the overall business environment by more targeted, sector-specific policies. ITC’s contribution: – Export Opportunity Scan to assist in the selection of priority sectors – Key questions: – Key questions:
Many ECOWAS countries are concentrated
10
Product concentration: Share of the top three exported products (%), 2005 High product diversification
10 20 30
High product and market diversification Low market diversification Côte d'Ivoire Senegal Togo
30 40 50
Low product and Ghana Niger Benin Sierra Leone Cape Verde Gambia
50 60 70
p market diversification Liberia Guinea Burkina Faso Mali Sierra Leone
70 80 90
Low product diversification Nigeria Guinea-Bissau
90 100 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
M k t t ti Sh f th t th t k t (%) 2005 Low product diversification High market diversification Market concentration: Share of the top three export markets (%), 2005
Source:Trade Map. The size of the bubbles correspond to the countries' exports in 2005, ranging from USD 5 million (Gambia) to 47 billion (Nigeria).
Industry (Rank of ) ECOWAS exports ( S ) Number
Countries where the industry represents more than 10% (50%) of exports (% f ’ ) export value) (USD million) exporters
47,206 11
3,609 9 (% of country’s exports) Nigeria (97), Cape Verde (48), Côte d'Ivoire (28), Senegal (21) Ghana (49), Togo (38), Côte d'Ivoire (29)
1,697 7
1,159 6
881 11 Liberia (85) Guinea (59), Niger (44) Mali (83), Burkina Faso (81), Benin (59)
742 10
691 11
519 9
Guinea-Bissau (92)
452 8
423 13 11 Inorg chemicals 407 3 ( ) Liberia (11) Gambia (16), Senegal (16), Cape Verde (13) Guinea (17) Senegal (13)
407 3
361 10
74 7 43 B 24 7 Guinea (17), Senegal (13) Sierra Leone (62), Niger (21) Gambia (10) G bi (42)
24 7
15 2
Source: TradeMap. Data refer to 2005.
Gambia (42) Cape Verde (15)
All sectors (HS2)
Animals (01)
Priority sectors
Export Potential Asessment Export performance ( ) Meat (02) Seafood (03)
Export Opportunity Scan p p World markets Dairy prod. (04)
Live plants (06) Vegetables (07) Fruit and nuts (08)
8 Precious stones Domestic supply conditions S Fruit and nuts (08) Coffee, tea and spices (09)
Socio-economic impact (...)
(…)
Promising industries
Current Export Performance World Market
Promising industries
Size Dynamism Exporter Diversification Trade Balance Size Dynamism Export value Export growth
significant Net exports World imports World import World market share Absolute change exporters Share of top exporter Relative trade balance growth Absolute change share top exporter in region g
to range between Upper threshold 100 to range between 0 (low) and 100 (high)
to obtain an overall index L th h ld Lower threshold
Industry
to world
in world exports
USD million Index % Index Index Cotton 881 100 2.7 100 100 Cocoa 3 609 100 16 9 100 100 Cocoa 3,609 100 16.9 100 100 Fuel 47,206 100 3.6 100 100 Ores 1,159 100 2.0 100 100 Ships 1,697 100 2.4 100 100 Fruit and nuts 519 59 1.6 80 70 Wood 691 78 0.7 36 57 Wood 691 78 0.7 36 57 Salt and cement 293 33 1.4 68 51 Inorganic chemicals 407 46 1.1 55 51 Seafood 423 48 0 9 42 45 Seafood 423 48 0.9 42 45 (…) Photographic goods 72 0.0 Wool, animal hair 64 0.0
Industry
ECOWAS exports
exports to world Growth
imports
Industry p USD million Index % p.a. Index % p.a. Index Ships 909 100 32 66 35 83 Fuel 26,517 100 26 55 33 78 Fruit and nuts 341 98 19 42 14 70 Rubber 270 78 28 59 16 69 Rubber 270 78 28 59 16 69 Cocoa 1,877 100 17 39 17 69 Cotton 348 100 15 35 7 68 Ores 475 100 14 33 29 67 Machinery 99 30 58 100 12 65 Vehicles 93 28 74 100 13 64 Vehicles 93 28 74 100 13 64 Inorganic chemicals 246 71 27 57 18 64 (…) Furniture
14 Aluminium
14
Industry
balance USD million Index % of trade Index Index
USD million Index % of trade Index Index Cocoa 3,596 100 99.5 100 100 Ores 1,156 100 99.6 100 100 Fruit and nuts 484 99 91.0 96 97 Fuel 40,863 100 86.6 93 97 Wood 598 100 85.6 93 96 Leather 199 88 98.2 99 94 Precious stones 324 93 82.5 91 92 Nickel 81 100.0 100 91 Furskins 81 100.0 100 91 Pulp of wood 1 81 88.7 94 88 ( ) (…) Machinery
4 2
3 1 Cereals 2 244 95 7 2 Cereals
2
Industry
ECOWAS exports
fication
y Number (0 to 15) Index % Index Index Cotton 11 100 27 99 100 Iron and steel 13 100 22 100 100 Machinery 13 100 27 99 100 Precious stones 10 91 38 82 86 Apparatus 8 73 26 100 86 Apparatus 8 73 26 100 86 Wood 11 100 49 65 83 Electronic equipment 11 100 50 64 82 equipment Oil seed 9 82 43 75 79 Seafood 13 100 54 57 79 Copper 8 73 40 79 76 Copper 8 73 40 79 76 (…) Umbrellas 91 Furskins 100
Industry label Size (Rank) Dynamism (Rank) Diversification (Rank) Trade balance Export index for ECOWAS
(Rank) (Rank) (Rank) balance (Rank) ECOWAS
1 6 1 13 88 2 Cocoa 1 4 21 1 84
1 4 21 1 84
1 2 38 3 84
1 7 42 1 79
6 3 13 3 77
7 72 6 5 64
14 4 15 23 62
8 9 51 16 60
1 1 55 88 59
16 60 4 7 57 (…)
62 37 91 55 22
62 51 89 39 20 p g
62 85 82 55 15
Product (HS 6 code) ECOWAS Export Index C h t i h ll f h d i d (080131) 100
Cashew nuts, in shell, fresh or dried (080131) 100 Cotton seeds, whether or not broken (120720) 96 Cotton, not carded or combed (520100) 95 Oil seeds and oleaginous fruits, nes, whether or not broken (120799) 94 Technically specified natural rubber (TSNR) (400122) 94 Guavas, mangoes and mangosteens, fresh or dried (080450) 94 Natural rubber in other forms nes (400129) 93 Cocoa beans, whole or broken, raw or roasted (180100) 93 Waste and scrap, of tinned iron or steel (720430) 92 p ( ) Cuttle fish and squid,shelled or not,frozen,dried,salted or in brine (030749) 92 Octopus, frozen, dried, salted or in brine (030759) 91 Aircraft engines spark-ignition reciprocating or rotary type (840710) 91 Aircraft engines, spark ignition reciprocating or rotary type (840710) 91 Cocoa butter, fat and oil (180400) 91 Veneer, tropical woods nes, <6mm thick (440839) 91 Lumber non coniferous nes (440799) 91 Lumber, non-coniferous nes (440799) 91
(for the same industries: includes only products that are exported)
Industry
world imports
USD million Index % p a Index Index USD million Index % p.a. Index Index Plastics 297,854 100 0.5 17 59 Ships 51,946 17 9.3 100 59 Fuel 1,408,597 100 0.4 16 58 Cereals 48,962 16 4.7 100 58 Vehicles 875,792 100 0.4 14 57 Machinery 1,215,348 100 0.3 11 56 Electronic equip. 1,345,274 100 0.2 9 54 Salt and cement 25,980 8 3.2 100 54 Sugar 24,151 8 2.6 99 53 Milling products 7,450 2 2.7 100 51 ( ) (…) Other base metals 853 0.0 Wool and animal hair 454 0.0
Industry
in world imports
USD million Index % p.a. Index Index Fuel 934,472 100 33 100 100 Iron and steel 112,768 84 28 100 92 Drugs 114,995 86 23 79 83 Plastics 133,432 100 16 49 74 Electronic equipment 574,537 100 15 43 72 q p , Ores 46,332 35 29 100 67 Vehicles 329,697 100 13 32 66 Apparatus 107 963 81 16 48 65 Apparatus 107,963 81 16 48 65 Machinery 432,837 100 12 28 64 Ships 35,822 27 35 100 63 ( ) (…) Umbrellas 264 4 Vegetable plaiting mat. 59 4
Industry
ECOWAS
MFN tariff minus tariff applied to ECOWAS
access pp % Index % Index Index Animals 2.1 93 19.5 83 88 Meat and fish preparations 3.1 90 11.3 69 79 Garments (knit) 2.9 90 8.1 63 77 Garments (not knit) 3.0 90 7.4 62 76 ( ) Carpets 2.7 91 6.2 60 76 Aluminium 1.5 95 2.9 55 75 Nickel 0.4 99 0.6 51 75 Musical instruments 1.4 95 2.4 54 75 Basketwork 1.2 96 2.7 54 75 (…) Dairy products 22.2 26 17.5 79 53 Sugar 19 4 35 2 3 54 45 Sugar 19.4 35 2.3 54 45 Cereals 36.8 2.4 54 27
Industry label Size (Rank) Dynamism (Rank) Market access conditions (Rank) World Market Index
3 1 22 77
14 2 62 68 2 Plastics 1 4 55 68
1 4 55 68
12 3 22 66
7 5 22 66
5 7 10 65
1 10 70 64
6 9 22 64 y
13 8 22 60
19 11 41 53 10 Articles of iron and steel 15 12 62 53
15 12 62 53 (…)
70 88 73 24
85 88 78 23
Industries ECOWAS Export World Market Overall Index Industries ECOWAS Export World Market Overall Index Export Index Market Index Index
81 75 78 2 O 79 51 65 Export Index Market Index Index
62 44 53 12 A t 44 60 52
79 51 65
59 64 61
84 36 60
44 60 52
36 68 52
64 40 52
88 31 60
48 68 58
64 40 52
60 41 51
49 50 50
77 34 56
57 53 55 9 Machinery 44 64 54
26 66 46
25 66 46 19 Art of iron & steel 35 53 44
44 64 54
42 65 54
35 53 44
53 35 44
Low ECOWAS export index High ECOWAS export index (top 20)
High world market index, but low ECOWAS export: High ECOWAS export and world market indices:
High world
but low ECOWAS export:
and world market indices:
world import index (top 20)
24 Milli d (42 16)
10 R bb (7 16)
Rank of Overall Index Rank of World import Index
(…)
Low ECOWAS export High ECOWAS export index
Rank of ECOWAS Export Index
Low
Low ECOWAS export and world market indices: (…) High ECOWAS export index, but low world market index:
Low world import index
19 S f d (12 50)
(…)
Low ECOWAS export index High ECOWAS export index (top 100)
Hi h ld k t i d Hi h ECOWAS t High world market index, but low ECOWAS export: Cargo vessels (890190) Tankers (890120) High ECOWAS export and world market indices: Beauty or make-up, sunscreen or sun tan preparations (330499) Floating or submersible drilling or production platforms (890520)
High world import
( ) Wheat nes and meslin (100190) Parts of boring or sinking machinery (843143) A t bil ith di l i g g p p ( ) Propane, liquefied (271112) Gold in other semi-manufactured form non-monetary (710813) Natural gas, liquefied (271111)
import index (top 100)
Automobiles with diesel engine > 2500 cc (870333) (…) Diamonds non-industrial unworked or simply sawn, cleaved or bruted (710231) Aluminium oxide nes (281820) Petroleum oils o/than crude etc (271000) Petroleum oils,o/than crude etc (271000) Copper ores and concentrates (260300) Petroleum oils, crude (270900) Butanes, liquefied (271113) Ferrous waste and scrap, iron or steel, nes (720449)
Low world
Low ECOWAS export and world market indices: ( ) High ECOWAS export index, but low world market index: C h t i h ll f h d i d (080131)
world import index
(…) Cashew nuts, in shell, fresh or dried (080131) Cotton seeds (120720) Cotton, not carded or combed (520100)
All countries Best performers Size of exporter
Benin Burkina Faso Cape Verde
3 Guinea Bissau
Dynamism
Cape Verde Côte d'Ivoire Gambia
Trade balance
Ghana Guinea Guinea-Bissau
8 Mali Gu ea ssau Liberia Mali
Other criteria
Niger Nigeria Senegal
g Sierra Leone Togo g
Industry Best performers in the world Best performers in ECOWAS Industry
(Rank of Export index)
Best performers in the world Best performers in ECOWAS
(rank of export index)
India, USA, Pakistan Burkina Faso (7), Mali (17), Benin (20)
Ghana, Côte d'Ivoire, Indonesia Ghana (1), Côte d'Ivoire (2), Nigeria (6)
Saudi Arabia, Venezuela, Algeria Nigeria (6), Côte d'Ivoire (52), Ghana (55)
Peru, India, Australia Guinea (16), Sierra Leone (26), Liberia (26) 5 F it d t I T k N Z l d Côte d'Ivoire (25), Guinea-Bissau (26),
Iran, Turkey, New Zealand Côte d Ivoire (25), Guinea Bissau (26), Ghana (32)
Brazil, Russia, Malaysia Guinea (42), Côte d'Ivoire, Ghana (46) 7 Rubber Indonesia Thailand China Liberia (27) Côte d'Ivoire (33) Guinea (38)
Indonesia, Thailand, China Liberia (27), Côte d Ivoire (33), Guinea (38)
Australia, Netherlands, Jamaica, Germany Guinea (20), Senegal (24), Sierra Leone (48)
China, Korea, Japan, Italy Liberia (20), Niger (31), Benin, Mali (38) 10 Prec stones Botswana; Canada South Africa Israel Sierra Leone (28) Niger (31) Senegal (57)
Botswana; Canada, South Africa, Israel Sierra Leone (28), Niger (31), Senegal (57)
Industry Top performing ECOWAS countries
(Rank of Export index) (Rank in the world of Export Index)
Burkina Faso (7) Mali (17) Benin (20)
Ghana (1) Côte d'Ivoire (2) Nigeria (6)
Nigeria (6) Côte d'Ivoire (52) Ghana (55)
Guinea (16) Sierra Leone (26) Liberia (26)
Côte d'Ivoire (25) Guinea-Bissau (26) Ghana (32) ( ) ( ) ( )
Guinea (42) Côte d'Ivoire (46) Ghana (46)
Liberia (27) Côte d'Ivoire (33) Guinea (38)
Guinea (20) Senegal (24) Sierra Leone (48)
Guinea (20) Senegal (24) Sierra Leone (48)
Liberia (20) Niger (31) Benin, Mali (38)
Sierra Leone (28) Niger (31) Senegal (57) ( ) (…)
Industries Top 3 products Top performing ECOWAS countries
Industries (Rank of Export Index) Top 3 products (ranked by Export Index) Top performing ECOWAS countries (Rank in the world of Export Index) Cotton, not carded or combed Burkina Faso (5) Mali (6) Benin (10)
Cotton waste Mali (11) Benin (20) Senegal (26) Cotton uncombed Nigeria (3) Burkina Faso (34) .. Cocoa beans Gh (1) Ni i (1) G i (9)
Cocoa beans, whole or broken, raw or roasted Ghana (1) Nigeria (1) Guinea (9) Cocoa butter, fat and oil Côte d'Ivoire (3) Nigeria (13) Mali (13) Cocoa paste Cocoa paste wholly or partly defatted Ghana (4) Nigeria (7) .. Cocoa paste not defatted Côte d'Ivoire (1) Ghana (1) Nigeria (14)
Petroleum oils and oils obtained from bituminous minerals, crude Nigeria (7) Ghana (22) Guinea (46) Butanes, liquefied Nigeria (6) Ghana (37) Senegal (81) Natural gas, liquefied Nigeria (9) .. ..
Industries (Rank of Top 3 products ( k d b E t I d ) Top performing ECOWAS countries (R k i th ld f E t I d )
( Export Index) (ranked by Export Index) (Rank in the world of Export Index)
Zirconium ores and concentrates Nigeria (7) Sierra Leone (8) Aluminium ores and concentrates Guinea (3) Ghana (8) Sierra Leone (11) ( ) ( ) ( ) Precious metal ores and concentrates Guinea (12) Liberia (18) Ghana (18) 5 Fruit and Cashew nuts, in shell, fresh or dried Côte d'Ivoire (1) Guinea-Bissau (1) Ghana (4) Guavas mangoes and mangosteens
nuts Guavas, mangoes and mangosteens, fresh or dried Burkina Faso (14) Mali (15) Senegal (15) Pineapples, fresh or dried Ghana (3) Côte d'Ivoire (9) Liberia (22) Veneer tropical woods nes <6mm thick Côte d'Ivoire (2) Ghana (4) Guinea (12)
Veneer, tropical woods nes, <6mm thick Côte d Ivoire (2) Ghana (4) Guinea (12) Lumber, non-coniferous nes Ghana (20) Guinea (26) Benin (31) Wood (lumber) continuously shaped non-coniferous (hardwood) Côte d'Ivoire (22) Ghana (26) Mali (30) non coniferous (hardwood)
Technically specified natural rubber (TSNR) Côte d'Ivoire (4) Liberia (8) Ghana (9) Natural rubber in other forms Côte d'Ivoire (3) Liberia (6) Nigeria (8)
Natural rubber in other forms Côte d Ivoire (3) Liberia (6) Nigeria (8) Natural rubber latex, whether or not prevulcanised Liberia (3) Côte d'Ivoire (8) Senegal, Mali (14)
Industries
Industries (Rank of Export Index) Top 3 products (ranked by Export Index) Top performing ECOWAS countries (Rank in the world of Export Index) Aluminium oxide nes Guinea (8)
chemicals Aluminium oxide nes Guinea (8) .. .. Phosphoric acid & polyphosphoric acids Senegal (1) Côte d'Ivoire (67) .. Calcium carbide Ghana (29) Nigeria (32) Côte d'Ivoire (50) R f i t d l th th t k Lib i (2)
Refrigerated vessels other than tankers Liberia (2) .. .. Fishing vessels and factory ships Senegal (10) Ghana (58) .. Floating or submersible drilling or production platforms Liberia (7) Benin (17) Côte d'Ivoire (27) production platforms ( ) ( ) ( ) 10 Precious Gold in unwrought forms non-monetary Niger (20) Nigeria (29) Senegal, Sierra Leone, Guinea, Liberia (29) Diamonds non industrial unworked or Sierra Leone
stones Diamonds non-industrial unworked or simply sawn, cleaved or bruted Sierra Leone (11) Ghana (25) Guinea (27) Prec/semi-prec stones (o/t diamonds) unworkd/simply sawn/rough shapd Nigeria (9) Senegal (13) Ghana, Sierra Leone (20) p y g p ( )
All i ti Att ti Att ti
Size of market
All importing countries Austrialia Attractive markets in the world Attractive markets in ECOWAS
1 China
Dynamism
Brazil Cape Verde Denmark
3 UAE
Market access conditions
Denmark Egypt France
Guinea (…) Zambia
Other criteria: Distance NTBs etc
Zambia
Distance, NTBs, etc.
(…)
Industry Main attractive markets in the world Main attractive markets in ECOWAS
(rank of import index)
China, Netherlands, France Burkina Faso, Ghana, Guinea-Bissau, Togo (68) , , , , , g ( )
China, Japan, S. Korea Malai, Niger, Nigeria (70)
Spain, Belgium, Poland Liberia (6), Nigeria (30) 4 Cocoa Malaysia Belgium Italy Spain Burkina Faso Guinea-Bissau (37)
Malaysia, Belgium, Italy, Spain Burkina Faso, Guinea-Bissau (37)
Turkey, Bangladesh, Hong Kong Ghana (25), Burkina Faso (53), Mali (74)
Turkey, Korea, Belgium Burkina Faso, Benin, Mali (49)
Russia, Belgium, Netherlands, Italy, Spain Burkina Faso, Mali (28), Senegal (44)
Turkey, United Kingdom, UAE Burkina Faso, Guinea-Bissau, Mali, Senegal (44)
Japan, China, Netherlands, Hong Kong, It l G Niger (56), Cape Verde, Ghana (77)
Italy, Germany Niger (56), Cape Verde, Ghana (77)
Turkey, Spain, Australia, France Ghana (60),
Japan, Germany, France, Netherlands UK USA Nigeria, Togo (88), Netherlands, UK, USA g g ( )
China, Netherlands, France Guinea-Bissau (43),
Spain, Belgium, France, Germany, Italy Netherlands Turkey UK Burkina Faso (26), Niger, Mali (38) Italy, Netherlands, Turkey, UK
France, Austria, Belgium, Italy, Spain, Turkey, UK, USA Ghana (69), Burkina Faso (82), Mali (88)
Product (HS 6 code) Most attractive markets in the world Most attractive markets in ECOWAS (rank of import index)
in the world in ECOWAS (rank of import index) Cashew nuts, in shell, fresh or dried (080131) France, Saudi Arabia, India Liberia (44), Sierra Leone (53) Cotton seeds (120720) Japan, Italy, Spain Togo (11), Niger (13) Cotton not carded or combed (520100) Thailand Pakistan Turkey Guinea Malai Sierra Leone (42) Cotton, not carded or combed (520100) Thailand, Pakistan, Turkey Guinea, Malai, Sierra Leone (42) Oil seeds and oleaginous fruits, nes (120799) Canada, Mexico, USA Togo (28), Gambia (92) Technically specified natural rubber (TSNR) (400122) Japan, Singapore, S. Korea Sierra Leone (97) (400122) Guavas, mangoes and mangosteens, fresh or dried (080450) France, United Kingdom, Germany Cape Verde (28), Niger (52) Natural rubber in other forms nes (400129) France, Czech Rep., Taiwan Guinea-Bissau, Mali, Senegal (51) Natural rubber in other forms nes (400129) France, Czech Rep., Taiwan Guinea Bissau, Mali, Senegal (51) Cocoa beans, whole or broken, raw or roasted (180100) Malaysia, Germany, USA Togo (26), Sierra Leone (32) Waste & scrap, of tinned iron or steel France Malaysia Netherlands Mali Nigeria (39) p, (720430) France, Malaysia, Netherlands Mali, Nigeria (39) Cuttle fish and squid, frozen, dried, salted or in brine (030749) Italy, Spain, Greece Senegal (67), Ghana, Nigeria (70) Octopus, frozen, dried, salted or in brine (030759) Greece, Italy, Spain Ghana (54), Cape Verde (69)
Possible cooperation with ECOWAS Secretariat: C it b ildi ithi PACT II (CIDA fi d) – Capacity building within PACT II (CIDA-financed): – Mentoring for Export Potential Assessment
ECOWAS S t i t ti i t f b t i
3 workshops
– Advantages: Advantages:
Top 10 performing industries Top 10 thriving industries Top 10 promising industries Top 10 export diversification Top 10 Tariff advantages
(71)
industry
(85)
(85)