exotic triangulated categories
play

Exotic triangulated categories Fernando Muro Universitat de - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Exotic triangulated categories Fernando Muro Universitat de Barcelona, Dept. lgebra i Geometria (joint work with S. Schwede and N. Strickland) Barcelona Topology Workshop 2007 Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories Goal Exhibiting


  1. Models for triangulated categories More generally we say that T has a model if there is an exact inclusion T ⊂ Ho M . Neeman defined a K -theory K ( T ) for triangulated categories. Theorem (Neeman’97) Let A be an abelian category and let T be a triangulated category with a bounded t-structure with heart A . If T admits a Waldhausen model then K ( A ) ≃ K ( T ) . Example T = D b ( A ) ⊂ D ( A ) = Ho Ch ( A ) . Neeman’s theorem can be used to obtain K ( A ) ≃ K ( B ) by embedding adequately two abelian categories A , B in T . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  2. Models for triangulated categories More generally we say that T has a model if there is an exact inclusion T ⊂ Ho M . Neeman defined a K -theory K ( T ) for triangulated categories. Theorem (Neeman’97) Let A be an abelian category and let T be a triangulated category with a bounded t-structure with heart A . If T admits a Waldhausen model then K ( A ) ≃ K ( T ) . Example T = D b ( A ) ⊂ D ( A ) = Ho Ch ( A ) . Neeman’s theorem can be used to obtain K ( A ) ≃ K ( B ) by embedding adequately two abelian categories A , B in T . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  3. Models for triangulated categories More generally we say that T has a model if there is an exact inclusion T ⊂ Ho M . Neeman defined a K -theory K ( T ) for triangulated categories. Theorem (Neeman’97) Let A be an abelian category and let T be a triangulated category with a bounded t-structure with heart A . If T admits a Waldhausen model then K ( A ) ≃ K ( T ) . Example T = D b ( A ) ⊂ D ( A ) = Ho Ch ( A ) . Neeman’s theorem can be used to obtain K ( A ) ≃ K ( B ) by embedding adequately two abelian categories A , B in T . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  4. Models for triangulated categories More generally we say that T has a model if there is an exact inclusion T ⊂ Ho M . Neeman defined a K -theory K ( T ) for triangulated categories. Theorem (Neeman’97) Let A be an abelian category and let T be a triangulated category with a bounded t-structure with heart A . If T admits a Waldhausen model then K ( A ) ≃ K ( T ) . Example T = D b ( A ) ⊂ D ( A ) = Ho Ch ( A ) . Neeman’s theorem can be used to obtain K ( A ) ≃ K ( B ) by embedding adequately two abelian categories A , B in T . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  5. A triangulated category without models Theorem A The category F ( Z / 4 ) of finitely generated free Z / 4 -modules has a unique triangulated structure with Σ = identity and exact triangle 2 2 2 Z / 4 → Z / 4 → Z / 4 → Z / 4 . − − − proof Theorem B There are not non-trivial exact functors F ( Z / 4 ) − → Ho M , Ho M − → F ( Z / 4 ) . proof Corollary F ( Z / 4 ) does not have models. remarks Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  6. A triangulated category without models Theorem A The category F ( Z / 4 ) of finitely generated free Z / 4 -modules has a unique triangulated structure with Σ = identity and exact triangle 2 2 2 Z / 4 → Z / 4 → Z / 4 → Z / 4 . − − − proof Theorem B There are not non-trivial exact functors F ( Z / 4 ) − → Ho M , Ho M − → F ( Z / 4 ) . proof Corollary F ( Z / 4 ) does not have models. remarks Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  7. A triangulated category without models Theorem A The category F ( Z / 4 ) of finitely generated free Z / 4 -modules has a unique triangulated structure with Σ = identity and exact triangle 2 2 2 Z / 4 → Z / 4 → Z / 4 → Z / 4 . − − − proof Theorem B There are not non-trivial exact functors F ( Z / 4 ) − → Ho M , Ho M − → F ( Z / 4 ) . proof Corollary F ( Z / 4 ) does not have models. remarks Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  8. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated Two candidate triangle morphisms ( α, β, γ ) and ( α ′ , β ′ , γ ′ ) are homotopic if there are morphisms (Θ , Φ , Ψ) q f i � B � C � Σ A A � B ′ � C ′ q ′ � Σ A ′ A ′ f ′ i ′ such that β ′ − β Φ i + f ′ Θ , = γ ′ − γ Ψ q + i ′ Φ , = Σ( α ′ − α ) Σ(Θ f ) + q ′ Ψ . = Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  9. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated � � � � � � � Two candidate triangle morphisms ( α, β, γ ) and ( α ′ , β ′ , γ ′ ) are homotopic if there are morphisms (Θ , Φ , Ψ) q f i A B C Σ A γ α β Σ α � B ′ � C ′ q ′ � Σ A ′ A ′ f ′ i ′ such that β ′ − β Φ i + f ′ Θ , = γ ′ − γ Ψ q + i ′ Φ , = Σ( α ′ − α ) Σ(Θ f ) + q ′ Ψ . = Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  10. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated � � � � � � � Two candidate triangle morphisms ( α, β, γ ) and ( α ′ , β ′ , γ ′ ) are homotopic if there are morphisms (Θ , Φ , Ψ) q f i A B C Σ A β ′ γ ′ α ′ Σ α ′ � B ′ � C ′ q ′ � Σ A ′ A ′ f ′ i ′ such that β ′ − β Φ i + f ′ Θ , = γ ′ − γ Ψ q + i ′ Φ , = Σ( α ′ − α ) Σ(Θ f ) + q ′ Ψ . = Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  11. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated � � � � � � � � � � � Two candidate triangle morphisms ( α, β, γ ) and ( α ′ , β ′ , γ ′ ) are homotopic if there are morphisms (Θ , Φ , Ψ) q f i A B C Σ A γ α β β ′ γ ′ α ′ Σ α Σ α ′ � B ′ � C ′ q ′ � Σ A ′ A ′ f ′ i ′ such that β ′ − β Φ i + f ′ Θ , = γ ′ − γ Ψ q + i ′ Φ , = Σ( α ′ − α ) Σ(Θ f ) + q ′ Ψ . = Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  12. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated � � � � � � � � � � � Two candidate triangle morphisms ( α, β, γ ) and ( α ′ , β ′ , γ ′ ) are homotopic if there are morphisms (Θ , Φ , Ψ) q f i A B C Σ A γ α β β ′ γ ′ α ′ Σ α Σ α ′ � B ′ � C ′ q ′ � Σ A ′ A ′ f ′ i ′ such that β ′ − β Φ i + f ′ Θ , = γ ′ − γ Ψ q + i ′ Φ , = Σ( α ′ − α ) Σ(Θ f ) + q ′ Ψ . = Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  13. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated � � � � � � � � � � � Two candidate triangle morphisms ( α, β, γ ) and ( α ′ , β ′ , γ ′ ) are homotopic if there are morphisms (Θ , Φ , Ψ) q f i A B C Σ A � � � Θ Φ Ψ � � � � � � γ α β β ′ γ ′ α ′ � � � Σ α Σ α ′ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � B ′ � C ′ q ′ � Σ A ′ A ′ f ′ i ′ such that β ′ − β Φ i + f ′ Θ , = γ ′ − γ Ψ q + i ′ Φ , = Σ( α ′ − α ) Σ(Θ f ) + q ′ Ψ . = Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  14. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated � � � � � � � � � � � Two candidate triangle morphisms ( α, β, γ ) and ( α ′ , β ′ , γ ′ ) are homotopic if there are morphisms (Θ , Φ , Ψ) q f i A B C Σ A � � � Θ Φ Ψ � � � � � � γ α β β ′ γ ′ α ′ � � � Σ α Σ α ′ � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � � B ′ � C ′ q ′ � Σ A ′ A ′ f ′ i ′ such that β ′ − β Φ i + f ′ Θ , = γ ′ − γ Ψ q + i ′ Φ , = Σ( α ′ − α ) Σ(Θ f ) + q ′ Ψ . = Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  15. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated Homotopic morphisms have isomorphic mapping cones. A candidate triangle is contractible if the identity morphism is homotopic to the zero morphism. The exact triangles in F ( Z / 4 ) are the candidate triangles isomorphic to the direct sum of a contractible triangle and a triangle X 2 of the form 2 2 2 X − → X − → X − → X for some X ∈ F ( Z / 4 ) . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  16. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated Homotopic morphisms have isomorphic mapping cones. A candidate triangle is contractible if the identity morphism is homotopic to the zero morphism. The exact triangles in F ( Z / 4 ) are the candidate triangles isomorphic to the direct sum of a contractible triangle and a triangle X 2 of the form 2 2 2 X − → X − → X − → X for some X ∈ F ( Z / 4 ) . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  17. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated Homotopic morphisms have isomorphic mapping cones. A candidate triangle is contractible if the identity morphism is homotopic to the zero morphism. The exact triangles in F ( Z / 4 ) are the candidate triangles isomorphic to the direct sum of a contractible triangle and a triangle X 2 of the form 2 2 2 X − → X − → X − → X for some X ∈ F ( Z / 4 ) . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  18. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated Let us check that F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated. A → A → 0 → A is contractible. The translate of a contractible triangle is contractible. The translate of X 2 is X 2 . Any morphism in F ( Z / 4 ) is of the form   1 0 0 0 2 0  : W ⊕ X ⊕ Y − → W ⊕ X ⊕ Z .  0 0 0 It can be extended to an exact triangle which is the direct sum of X 2 and the contractible triangle „ 1 0 „ 0 0 „ 0 0 « « « 0 0 0 1 1 0 � W ⊕ Z � Y ⊕ Z � W ⊕ Y . W ⊕ Y Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  19. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated Let us check that F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated. A → A → 0 → A is contractible. The translate of a contractible triangle is contractible. The translate of X 2 is X 2 . Any morphism in F ( Z / 4 ) is of the form   1 0 0 0 2 0  : W ⊕ X ⊕ Y − → W ⊕ X ⊕ Z .  0 0 0 It can be extended to an exact triangle which is the direct sum of X 2 and the contractible triangle „ 1 0 „ 0 0 „ 0 0 « « « 0 0 0 1 1 0 � W ⊕ Z � Y ⊕ Z � W ⊕ Y . W ⊕ Y Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  20. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated Let us check that F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated. A → A → 0 → A is contractible. The translate of a contractible triangle is contractible. The translate of X 2 is X 2 . Any morphism in F ( Z / 4 ) is of the form   1 0 0 0 2 0  : W ⊕ X ⊕ Y − → W ⊕ X ⊕ Z .  0 0 0 It can be extended to an exact triangle which is the direct sum of X 2 and the contractible triangle „ 1 0 „ 0 0 „ 0 0 « « « 0 0 0 1 1 0 � W ⊕ Z � Y ⊕ Z � W ⊕ Y . W ⊕ Y Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  21. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated Let us check that F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated. A → A → 0 → A is contractible. The translate of a contractible triangle is contractible. The translate of X 2 is X 2 . Any morphism in F ( Z / 4 ) is of the form   1 0 0 0 2 0  : W ⊕ X ⊕ Y − → W ⊕ X ⊕ Z .  0 0 0 It can be extended to an exact triangle which is the direct sum of X 2 and the contractible triangle „ 1 0 „ 0 0 „ 0 0 « « « 0 0 0 1 1 0 � W ⊕ Z � Y ⊕ Z � W ⊕ Y . W ⊕ Y Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  22. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated Let us check that F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated. A → A → 0 → A is contractible. The translate of a contractible triangle is contractible. The translate of X 2 is X 2 . Any morphism in F ( Z / 4 ) is of the form   1 0 0 0 2 0  : W ⊕ X ⊕ Y − → W ⊕ X ⊕ Z .  0 0 0 It can be extended to an exact triangle which is the direct sum of X 2 and the contractible triangle „ 1 0 „ 0 0 „ 0 0 « « « 0 0 0 1 1 0 � W ⊕ Z � Y ⊕ Z � W ⊕ Y . W ⊕ Y Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  23. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated Let us check that F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated. A → A → 0 → A is contractible. The translate of a contractible triangle is contractible. The translate of X 2 is X 2 . Any morphism in F ( Z / 4 ) is of the form   1 0 0 0 2 0  : W ⊕ X ⊕ Y − → W ⊕ X ⊕ Z .  0 0 0 It can be extended to an exact triangle which is the direct sum of X 2 and the contractible triangle „ 1 0 „ 0 0 „ 0 0 « « « 0 0 0 1 1 0 � W ⊕ Z � Y ⊕ Z � W ⊕ Y . W ⊕ Y Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  24. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated � � � � � Let us check that we can extend commutative squares 2 2 2 � X X X X α α β � Y � Y � Y Y 2 2 2 for any δ : X → Y . Suppose that   1 0 0 0 2 0  : X = L ⊕ M ⊕ N − α = → L ⊕ M ⊕ P = Y .  0 0 0 Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  25. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated � � � � � Let us check that we can extend commutative squares 2 2 2 � X X X X α α β � Y � Y � Y Y 2 2 2 for any δ : X → Y . Suppose that   1 0 0 0 2 0  : X = L ⊕ M ⊕ N − α = → L ⊕ M ⊕ P = Y .  0 0 0 Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  26. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated � � � � � � � Let us check that we can extend commutative squares 2 2 2 X X X X β + 2 · δ α α β � Y � Y � Y Y 2 2 2 for any δ : X → Y . Suppose that   1 0 0 0 2 0  : X = L ⊕ M ⊕ N − α = → L ⊕ M ⊕ P = Y .  0 0 0 Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  27. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated � � � � � � � Let us check that we can extend commutative squares 2 2 2 X X X X β + 2 · δ α α β � Y � Y � Y Y 2 2 2 for any δ : X → Y . Suppose that   1 0 0 0 2 0  : X = L ⊕ M ⊕ N − α = → L ⊕ M ⊕ P = Y .  0 0 0 Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  28. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated Let   0 0 0 0 1 0  : X = L ⊕ M ⊕ N − δ = → L ⊕ M ⊕ P = Y .  0 0 0 Since 2 · α = 2 · β then β = α + 2 · Φ for some Φ: X → Y , so ( δ, Φ , 0 ) is a homotopy from λ = ( α, β, β + 2 · δ ) to µ = ( α + 2 · δ, α + 2 · δ, α + 2 · δ ) ,   1 0 0 α + 2 · δ = 0 0 0  : X = L ⊕ M ⊕ N − → L ⊕ M ⊕ P = Y .  0 0 0 The mapping cone of µ (isomorphic to the mapping cone of λ ) is ( mapping cone of 1 L 2 ) exact . ⊕ M 2 ⊕ M 2 ⊕ N 2 ⊕ P 2 , � �� � contractible back remarks Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  29. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated Let   0 0 0 0 1 0  : X = L ⊕ M ⊕ N − δ = → L ⊕ M ⊕ P = Y .  0 0 0 Since 2 · α = 2 · β then β = α + 2 · Φ for some Φ: X → Y , so ( δ, Φ , 0 ) is a homotopy from λ = ( α, β, β + 2 · δ ) to µ = ( α + 2 · δ, α + 2 · δ, α + 2 · δ ) ,   1 0 0 α + 2 · δ = 0 0 0  : X = L ⊕ M ⊕ N − → L ⊕ M ⊕ P = Y .  0 0 0 The mapping cone of µ (isomorphic to the mapping cone of λ ) is ( mapping cone of 1 L 2 ) exact . ⊕ M 2 ⊕ M 2 ⊕ N 2 ⊕ P 2 , � �� � contractible back remarks Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  30. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated Let   0 0 0 0 1 0  : X = L ⊕ M ⊕ N − δ = → L ⊕ M ⊕ P = Y .  0 0 0 Since 2 · α = 2 · β then β = α + 2 · Φ for some Φ: X → Y , so ( δ, Φ , 0 ) is a homotopy from λ = ( α, β, β + 2 · δ ) to µ = ( α + 2 · δ, α + 2 · δ, α + 2 · δ ) ,   1 0 0 α + 2 · δ = 0 0 0  : X = L ⊕ M ⊕ N − → L ⊕ M ⊕ P = Y .  0 0 0 The mapping cone of µ (isomorphic to the mapping cone of λ ) is ( mapping cone of 1 L 2 ) exact . ⊕ M 2 ⊕ M 2 ⊕ N 2 ⊕ P 2 , � �� � contractible back remarks Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  31. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated Let   0 0 0 0 1 0  : X = L ⊕ M ⊕ N − δ = → L ⊕ M ⊕ P = Y .  0 0 0 Since 2 · α = 2 · β then β = α + 2 · Φ for some Φ: X → Y , so ( δ, Φ , 0 ) is a homotopy from λ = ( α, β, β + 2 · δ ) to µ = ( α + 2 · δ, α + 2 · δ, α + 2 · δ ) ,   1 0 0 α + 2 · δ = 0 0 0  : X = L ⊕ M ⊕ N − → L ⊕ M ⊕ P = Y .  0 0 0 The mapping cone of µ (isomorphic to the mapping cone of λ ) is ( mapping cone of 1 L 2 ) exact . ⊕ M 2 ⊕ M 2 ⊕ N 2 ⊕ P 2 , � �� � contractible back remarks Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  32. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated Let   0 0 0 0 1 0  : X = L ⊕ M ⊕ N − δ = → L ⊕ M ⊕ P = Y .  0 0 0 Since 2 · α = 2 · β then β = α + 2 · Φ for some Φ: X → Y , so ( δ, Φ , 0 ) is a homotopy from λ = ( α, β, β + 2 · δ ) to µ = ( α + 2 · δ, α + 2 · δ, α + 2 · δ ) ,   1 0 0 α + 2 · δ = 0 0 0  : X = L ⊕ M ⊕ N − → L ⊕ M ⊕ P = Y .  0 0 0 The mapping cone of µ (isomorphic to the mapping cone of λ ) is ( mapping cone of 1 L 2 ) exact . ⊕ M 2 ⊕ M 2 ⊕ N 2 ⊕ P 2 , � �� � contractible back remarks Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  33. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated A candidate triangle in F ( Z / 4 ) f i q A − → B − → C − → A is quasi-exact if q f i f A − → B − → C − → A → B is an exact sequence of Z / 4-modules. Example X 2 is quasi-exact. Contractible triangles are quasi-exact. Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  34. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated A candidate triangle in F ( Z / 4 ) f i q A − → B − → C − → A is quasi-exact if q f i f A − → B − → C − → A → B is an exact sequence of Z / 4-modules. Example X 2 is quasi-exact. Contractible triangles are quasi-exact. Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  35. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated A candidate triangle in F ( Z / 4 ) f i q A − → B − → C − → A is quasi-exact if q f i f A − → B − → C − → A → B is an exact sequence of Z / 4-modules. Example X 2 is quasi-exact. Contractible triangles are quasi-exact. Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  36. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated � � � � � q f i � A contractible A B C α β α � B ′ � C ′ � A ′ quasi-exact A ′ f ′ i ′ q ′ C is free. Let (Θ , Φ , Ψ) be a contracting homotopy for the upper row, γ = γ ′ + ( i ′ β − γ ′ i )Φ . Similarly if the first row is quasi-exact and the second row is contractible since Z / 4 is a Frobenius ring, so the duality functor Hom Z / 4 ( − , Z / 4 ) preserves contractible triangles and quasi-exact triangles. Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  37. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated � � � � � q f i � A contractible A B C α β α � B ′ � C ′ � A ′ quasi-exact A ′ f ′ i ′ q ′ C is free. Let (Θ , Φ , Ψ) be a contracting homotopy for the upper row, γ = γ ′ + ( i ′ β − γ ′ i )Φ . Similarly if the first row is quasi-exact and the second row is contractible since Z / 4 is a Frobenius ring, so the duality functor Hom Z / 4 ( − , Z / 4 ) preserves contractible triangles and quasi-exact triangles. Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  38. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated � � � � � � � q f i contractible A B C A α β / γ ′ α � � � B ′ � C ′ � A ′ quasi-exact A ′ f ′ i ′ q ′ C is free. Let (Θ , Φ , Ψ) be a contracting homotopy for the upper row, γ = γ ′ + ( i ′ β − γ ′ i )Φ . Similarly if the first row is quasi-exact and the second row is contractible since Z / 4 is a Frobenius ring, so the duality functor Hom Z / 4 ( − , Z / 4 ) preserves contractible triangles and quasi-exact triangles. Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  39. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated � � � � � � � q f i contractible A B C A α β / γ ′ α � � � B ′ � C ′ � A ′ quasi-exact A ′ f ′ i ′ q ′ C is free. Let (Θ , Φ , Ψ) be a contracting homotopy for the upper row, γ = γ ′ + ( i ′ β − γ ′ i )Φ . Similarly if the first row is quasi-exact and the second row is contractible since Z / 4 is a Frobenius ring, so the duality functor Hom Z / 4 ( − , Z / 4 ) preserves contractible triangles and quasi-exact triangles. Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  40. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated � � � � � � � q f i contractible A B C A γ α β α � � � B ′ � C ′ � A ′ quasi-exact A ′ f ′ i ′ q ′ C is free. Let (Θ , Φ , Ψ) be a contracting homotopy for the upper row, γ = γ ′ + ( i ′ β − γ ′ i )Φ . Similarly if the first row is quasi-exact and the second row is contractible since Z / 4 is a Frobenius ring, so the duality functor Hom Z / 4 ( − , Z / 4 ) preserves contractible triangles and quasi-exact triangles. Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  41. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated � � � � � � � q f i contractible A B C A γ α β α � � � B ′ � C ′ � A ′ quasi-exact A ′ f ′ i ′ q ′ C is free. Let (Θ , Φ , Ψ) be a contracting homotopy for the upper row, γ = γ ′ + ( i ′ β − γ ′ i )Φ . Similarly if the first row is quasi-exact and the second row is contractible since Z / 4 is a Frobenius ring, so the duality functor Hom Z / 4 ( − , Z / 4 ) preserves contractible triangles and quasi-exact triangles. Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  42. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated Let T and T ′ be contractible triangles in F ( Z / 4 ) . Any commutative square between the first arrows of X 2 ⊕ T and Y 2 ⊕ T ′ can be extended to a morphism � ϕ 11 � ϕ 12 → Y 2 ⊕ T ′ , : X 2 ⊕ T − ϕ 21 ϕ 22 such that the mapping cone of ϕ 11 : X 2 → Y 2 is exact. Morphisms from or to contractible triangles are null-homotopic, so � ϕ 11 � ϕ 11 � � 0 ϕ 12 ≃ , 0 0 ϕ 21 ϕ 22 whose mapping cone is ( mapping cone of ϕ 11 ) ⊕ ( translate of T ) exact . ⊕ T ′ , � �� � � �� � exact contractible back remarks Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  43. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated Let T and T ′ be contractible triangles in F ( Z / 4 ) . Any commutative square between the first arrows of X 2 ⊕ T and Y 2 ⊕ T ′ can be extended to a morphism � ϕ 11 � ϕ 12 → Y 2 ⊕ T ′ , : X 2 ⊕ T − ϕ 21 ϕ 22 such that the mapping cone of ϕ 11 : X 2 → Y 2 is exact. Morphisms from or to contractible triangles are null-homotopic, so � ϕ 11 � ϕ 11 � � 0 ϕ 12 ≃ , 0 0 ϕ 21 ϕ 22 whose mapping cone is ( mapping cone of ϕ 11 ) ⊕ ( translate of T ) exact . ⊕ T ′ , � �� � � �� � exact contractible back remarks Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  44. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated Let T and T ′ be contractible triangles in F ( Z / 4 ) . Any commutative square between the first arrows of X 2 ⊕ T and Y 2 ⊕ T ′ can be extended to a morphism � ϕ 11 � ϕ 12 → Y 2 ⊕ T ′ , : X 2 ⊕ T − ϕ 21 ϕ 22 such that the mapping cone of ϕ 11 : X 2 → Y 2 is exact. Morphisms from or to contractible triangles are null-homotopic, so � ϕ 11 � ϕ 11 � � 0 ϕ 12 ≃ , 0 0 ϕ 21 ϕ 22 whose mapping cone is ( mapping cone of ϕ 11 ) ⊕ ( translate of T ) exact . ⊕ T ′ , � �� � � �� � exact contractible back remarks Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  45. F ( Z / 4 ) is triangulated Let T and T ′ be contractible triangles in F ( Z / 4 ) . Any commutative square between the first arrows of X 2 ⊕ T and Y 2 ⊕ T ′ can be extended to a morphism � ϕ 11 � ϕ 12 → Y 2 ⊕ T ′ , : X 2 ⊕ T − ϕ 21 ϕ 22 such that the mapping cone of ϕ 11 : X 2 → Y 2 is exact. Morphisms from or to contractible triangles are null-homotopic, so � ϕ 11 � ϕ 11 � � 0 ϕ 12 ≃ , 0 0 ϕ 21 ϕ 22 whose mapping cone is ( mapping cone of ϕ 11 ) ⊕ ( translate of T ) exact . ⊕ T ′ , � �� � � �� � exact contractible back remarks Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  46. F ( Z / 4 ) is orthogonal to Ho M We are going to define two kinds of objects in a triangulated category T according to the cofiber of 2 · 1 X : X → X . Example If S is the sphere spectrum there is an exact triangle in Ho Sp 2 · 1 S q i → S / 2 S − → S − − → Σ S , where S / 2 is the mod 2 Moore spectrum. The map 2 · 1 S / 2 : S / 2 → S / 2 is the composite q η i S / 2 → S / 2 , − → Σ S − → S − where η is the stable Hopf map, which satisfies 2 · η = 0 . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  47. F ( Z / 4 ) is orthogonal to Ho M We are going to define two kinds of objects in a triangulated category T according to the cofiber of 2 · 1 X : X → X . Example If S is the sphere spectrum there is an exact triangle in Ho Sp 2 · 1 S q i → S / 2 S − → S − − → Σ S , where S / 2 is the mod 2 Moore spectrum. The map 2 · 1 S / 2 : S / 2 → S / 2 is the composite q η i S / 2 → S / 2 , − → Σ S − → S − where η is the stable Hopf map, which satisfies 2 · η = 0 . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  48. F ( Z / 4 ) is orthogonal to Ho M We are going to define two kinds of objects in a triangulated category T according to the cofiber of 2 · 1 X : X → X . Example If S is the sphere spectrum there is an exact triangle in Ho Sp 2 · 1 S q i → S / 2 S − → S − − → Σ S , where S / 2 is the mod 2 Moore spectrum. The map 2 · 1 S / 2 : S / 2 → S / 2 is the composite q η i S / 2 → S / 2 , − → Σ S − → S − where η is the stable Hopf map, which satisfies 2 · η = 0 . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  49. F ( Z / 4 ) is orthogonal to Ho M Definition Let A ∈ T and let 2 · 1 A i q A − → A − → C − → Σ A be an exact triangle. A Hopf map for A is a map η : Σ A → A such that 2 · 1 C = i η q , 2 · η 0 . = If A admits a Hopf map we say that A is hopfian. Exact functors preserve Hopf maps and hopfian objects. Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  50. F ( Z / 4 ) is orthogonal to Ho M Definition Let A ∈ T and let 2 · 1 A i q A − → A − → C − → Σ A be an exact triangle. A Hopf map for A is a map η : Σ A → A such that 2 · 1 C = i η q , 2 · η 0 . = If A admits a Hopf map we say that A is hopfian. Exact functors preserve Hopf maps and hopfian objects. Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  51. F ( Z / 4 ) is orthogonal to Ho M Definition Let A ∈ T and let 2 · 1 A i q A − → A − → C − → Σ A be an exact triangle. A Hopf map for A is a map η : Σ A → A such that 2 · 1 C = i η q , 2 · η 0 . = If A admits a Hopf map we say that A is hopfian. Exact functors preserve Hopf maps and hopfian objects. Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  52. F ( Z / 4 ) is orthogonal to Ho M Proposition If T admits a model then all objects are hopfian. Proof. Sp is “the free stable model category on one generator” S [Schwede-Shipley’02]. In particular for any object A ∈ Ho M there is an exact functor F A : Ho Sp − → Ho M with F A ( S ) = A , so A is hopfian as S . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  53. F ( Z / 4 ) is orthogonal to Ho M Proposition If T admits a model then all objects are hopfian. Proof. Sp is “the free stable model category on one generator” S [Schwede-Shipley’02]. In particular for any object A ∈ Ho M there is an exact functor F A : Ho Sp − → Ho M with F A ( S ) = A , so A is hopfian as S . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  54. F ( Z / 4 ) is orthogonal to Ho M Definition An object E ∈ T is exotic if there is an exact triangle 2 · 1 E 2 · 1 E q E − → E − → E − → Σ E . Example Z / 4 is exotic in F ( Z / 4 ) . Indeed all objects in F ( Z / 4 ) are exotic. Exact functors preserve exotic objects. Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  55. F ( Z / 4 ) is orthogonal to Ho M Definition An object E ∈ T is exotic if there is an exact triangle 2 · 1 E 2 · 1 E q E − → E − → E − → Σ E . Example Z / 4 is exotic in F ( Z / 4 ) . Indeed all objects in F ( Z / 4 ) are exotic. Exact functors preserve exotic objects. Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  56. F ( Z / 4 ) is orthogonal to Ho M Proposition If X ∈ T is both hopfian and exotic then X = 0 . Proof. If η : Σ X → X is a Hopf map and 2 · 1 X 2 · 1 X q X − → X − → X − → Σ X is exact then 2 · 1 X = ( 2 · 1 X ) η q = 0 , therefore 0 0 q X − → X − → X − → Σ X is exact, so X = 0. Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  57. F ( Z / 4 ) is orthogonal to Ho M Proposition If X ∈ T is both hopfian and exotic then X = 0 . Proof. If η : Σ X → X is a Hopf map and 2 · 1 X 2 · 1 X q X − → X − → X − → Σ X is exact then 2 · 1 X = ( 2 · 1 X ) η q = 0 , therefore 0 0 q X − → X − → X − → Σ X is exact, so X = 0. Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  58. F ( Z / 4 ) is orthogonal to Ho M Proposition If X ∈ T is both hopfian and exotic then X = 0 . Proof. If η : Σ X → X is a Hopf map and 2 · 1 X 2 · 1 X q X − → X − → X − → Σ X is exact then 2 · 1 X = ( 2 · 1 X ) η q = 0 , therefore 0 0 q X − → X − → X − → Σ X is exact, so X = 0. Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  59. F ( Z / 4 ) is orthogonal to Ho M Proposition If X ∈ T is both hopfian and exotic then X = 0 . Proof. If η : Σ X → X is a Hopf map and 2 · 1 X 2 · 1 X q X − → X − → X − → Σ X is exact then 2 · 1 X = ( 2 · 1 X ) η q = 0 , therefore 0 0 q X − → X − → X − → Σ X is exact, so X = 0. Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  60. F ( Z / 4 ) is orthogonal to Ho M Proof of Theorem B. All objects in Ho M are hopfian and all objects in F ( Z / 4 ) are exotic. Therefore F : F ( Z / 4 ) − → Ho M is an exact functor the image of F consists of objects which are both hopfian and exotic, so F = 0. Similarly for F : Ho M − → F ( Z / 4 ) . back remarks Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  61. F ( Z / 4 ) is orthogonal to Ho M Proof of Theorem B. All objects in Ho M are hopfian and all objects in F ( Z / 4 ) are exotic. Therefore F : F ( Z / 4 ) − → Ho M is an exact functor the image of F consists of objects which are both hopfian and exotic, so F = 0. Similarly for F : Ho M − → F ( Z / 4 ) . back remarks Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  62. F ( Z / 4 ) is orthogonal to Ho M Proof of Theorem B. All objects in Ho M are hopfian and all objects in F ( Z / 4 ) are exotic. Therefore F : F ( Z / 4 ) − → Ho M is an exact functor the image of F consists of objects which are both hopfian and exotic, so F = 0. Similarly for F : Ho M − → F ( Z / 4 ) . back remarks Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  63. Remarks Theorems A and B are not only true for R = Z / 4 but for any commutative local ring R with maximal ideal m = ( 2 ) � = 0 such that m 2 = 0. For instance R = W 2 ( k ) , k a perfect field of char k = 2. Let k be a field of char k = 2. The category F ( k [ ε ] /ε 2 ) of finitely generated free modules over the ring of dual numbers k [ ε ] /ε 2 has a unique triangulated structure with Σ = identity and exact triangle k [ ε ] /ε 2 → k [ ε ] /ε 2 ε ε → k [ ε ] /ε 2 ε → k [ ε ] /ε 2 . − − − However F ( k [ ε ] /ε 2 ) does have a model. skip model Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  64. Remarks Theorems A and B are not only true for R = Z / 4 but for any commutative local ring R with maximal ideal m = ( 2 ) � = 0 such that m 2 = 0. For instance R = W 2 ( k ) , k a perfect field of char k = 2. Let k be a field of char k = 2. The category F ( k [ ε ] /ε 2 ) of finitely generated free modules over the ring of dual numbers k [ ε ] /ε 2 has a unique triangulated structure with Σ = identity and exact triangle k [ ε ] /ε 2 → k [ ε ] /ε 2 ε ε → k [ ε ] /ε 2 ε → k [ ε ] /ε 2 . − − − However F ( k [ ε ] /ε 2 ) does have a model. skip model Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  65. Remarks Theorems A and B are not only true for R = Z / 4 but for any commutative local ring R with maximal ideal m = ( 2 ) � = 0 such that m 2 = 0. For instance R = W 2 ( k ) , k a perfect field of char k = 2. Let k be a field of char k = 2. The category F ( k [ ε ] /ε 2 ) of finitely generated free modules over the ring of dual numbers k [ ε ] /ε 2 has a unique triangulated structure with Σ = identity and exact triangle k [ ε ] /ε 2 → k [ ε ] /ε 2 ε ε → k [ ε ] /ε 2 ε → k [ ε ] /ε 2 . − − − However F ( k [ ε ] /ε 2 ) does have a model. skip model Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  66. Remarks Proposition The triangulated category F ( k [ ε ] /ε 2 ) is exact equivalent to D c ( A ) , so it has a model given by differential graded right modules over a differential graded algebra A. A is a DGA such that H 0 ( A ) = k [ ε ] /ε 2 , any right DG A -module M has H 0 ( M ) free as a k [ ε ] /ε 2 -module, and the equivalence is given by → F ( k [ ε ] /ε 2 ) . H 0 : D c ( A ) − skip algebra Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  67. Remarks Proposition The triangulated category F ( k [ ε ] /ε 2 ) is exact equivalent to D c ( A ) , so it has a model given by differential graded right modules over a differential graded algebra A. A is a DGA such that H 0 ( A ) = k [ ε ] /ε 2 , any right DG A -module M has H 0 ( M ) free as a k [ ε ] /ε 2 -module, and the equivalence is given by → F ( k [ ε ] /ε 2 ) . H 0 : D c ( A ) − skip algebra Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  68. Remarks A = k � a , u , v , v − 1 � / I with | a | = | u | = 0 , | v | = − 1 . The two-sided ideal I is generated by a 2 , au + ua + 1 , av + va , uv + vu . The differential is defined by d ( a ) = u 2 v , d ( u ) = 0 , d ( v ) = 0 . H ∗ ( A ) = k [ x , x − 1 ] ⊗ k k [ ε ] /ε 2 , with ε = { u } , x = { v } . We have a non-trivial Massey product � ε, ε · x , ε � = 1 mod ε. Given y ∈ H 0 ( M ) with y · ε = 0 then � y , ε, ε · x � · ε = y · � ε, ε · x , ε � = y ⇒ H 0 ( M ) is free . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  69. Remarks A = k � a , u , v , v − 1 � / I with | a | = | u | = 0 , | v | = − 1 . The two-sided ideal I is generated by a 2 , au + ua + 1 , av + va , uv + vu . The differential is defined by d ( a ) = u 2 v , d ( u ) = 0 , d ( v ) = 0 . H ∗ ( A ) = k [ x , x − 1 ] ⊗ k k [ ε ] /ε 2 , with ε = { u } , x = { v } . We have a non-trivial Massey product � ε, ε · x , ε � = 1 mod ε. Given y ∈ H 0 ( M ) with y · ε = 0 then � y , ε, ε · x � · ε = y · � ε, ε · x , ε � = y ⇒ H 0 ( M ) is free . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  70. Remarks A = k � a , u , v , v − 1 � / I with | a | = | u | = 0 , | v | = − 1 . The two-sided ideal I is generated by a 2 , au + ua + 1 , av + va , uv + vu . The differential is defined by d ( a ) = u 2 v , d ( u ) = 0 , d ( v ) = 0 . H ∗ ( A ) = k [ x , x − 1 ] ⊗ k k [ ε ] /ε 2 , with ε = { u } , x = { v } . We have a non-trivial Massey product � ε, ε · x , ε � = 1 mod ε. Given y ∈ H 0 ( M ) with y · ε = 0 then � y , ε, ε · x � · ε = y · � ε, ε · x , ε � = y ⇒ H 0 ( M ) is free . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  71. Remarks A = k � a , u , v , v − 1 � / I with | a | = | u | = 0 , | v | = − 1 . The two-sided ideal I is generated by a 2 , au + ua + 1 , av + va , uv + vu . The differential is defined by d ( a ) = u 2 v , d ( u ) = 0 , d ( v ) = 0 . H ∗ ( A ) = k [ x , x − 1 ] ⊗ k k [ ε ] /ε 2 , with ε = { u } , x = { v } . We have a non-trivial Massey product � ε, ε · x , ε � = 1 mod ε. Given y ∈ H 0 ( M ) with y · ε = 0 then � y , ε, ε · x � · ε = y · � ε, ε · x , ε � = y ⇒ H 0 ( M ) is free . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  72. Remarks A = k � a , u , v , v − 1 � / I with | a | = | u | = 0 , | v | = − 1 . The two-sided ideal I is generated by a 2 , au + ua + 1 , av + va , uv + vu . The differential is defined by d ( a ) = u 2 v , d ( u ) = 0 , d ( v ) = 0 . H ∗ ( A ) = k [ x , x − 1 ] ⊗ k k [ ε ] /ε 2 , with ε = { u } , x = { v } . We have a non-trivial Massey product � ε, ε · x , ε � = 1 mod ε. Given y ∈ H 0 ( M ) with y · ε = 0 then � y , ε, ε · x � · ε = y · � ε, ε · x , ε � = y ⇒ H 0 ( M ) is free . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  73. Remarks A = k � a , u , v , v − 1 � / I with | a | = | u | = 0 , | v | = − 1 . The two-sided ideal I is generated by a 2 , au + ua + 1 , av + va , uv + vu . The differential is defined by d ( a ) = u 2 v , d ( u ) = 0 , d ( v ) = 0 . H ∗ ( A ) = k [ x , x − 1 ] ⊗ k k [ ε ] /ε 2 , with ε = { u } , x = { v } . We have a non-trivial Massey product � ε, ε · x , ε � = 1 mod ε. Given y ∈ H 0 ( M ) with y · ε = 0 then � y , ε, ε · x � · ε = y · � ε, ε · x , ε � = y ⇒ H 0 ( M ) is free . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  74. Remarks A = k � a , u , v , v − 1 � / I with | a | = | u | = 0 , | v | = − 1 . The two-sided ideal I is generated by a 2 , au + ua + 1 , av + va , uv + vu . The differential is defined by d ( a ) = u 2 v , d ( u ) = 0 , d ( v ) = 0 . H ∗ ( A ) = k [ x , x − 1 ] ⊗ k k [ ε ] /ε 2 , with ε = { u } , x = { v } . We have a non-trivial Massey product � ε, ε · x , ε � = 1 mod ε. Given y ∈ H 0 ( M ) with y · ε = 0 then � y , ε, ε · x � · ε = y · � ε, ε · x , ε � = y ⇒ H 0 ( M ) is free . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  75. Remarks A = k � a , u , v , v − 1 � / I with | a | = | u | = 0 , | v | = − 1 . The two-sided ideal I is generated by a 2 , au + ua + 1 , av + va , uv + vu . The differential is defined by d ( a ) = u 2 v , d ( u ) = 0 , d ( v ) = 0 . H ∗ ( A ) = k [ x , x − 1 ] ⊗ k k [ ε ] /ε 2 , with ε = { u } , x = { v } . We have a non-trivial Massey product � ε, ε · x , ε � = 1 mod ε. Given y ∈ H 0 ( M ) with y · ε = 0 then � y , ε, ε · x � · ε = y · � ε, ε · x , ε � = y ⇒ H 0 ( M ) is free . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  76. Remarks A = k � a , u , v , v − 1 � / I with | a | = | u | = 0 , | v | = − 1 . The two-sided ideal I is generated by a 2 , au + ua + 1 , av + va , uv + vu . The differential is defined by d ( a ) = u 2 v , d ( u ) = 0 , d ( v ) = 0 . H ∗ ( A ) = k [ x , x − 1 ] ⊗ k k [ ε ] /ε 2 , with ε = { u } , x = { v } . We have a non-trivial Massey product � ε, ε · x , ε � = 1 mod ε. Given y ∈ H 0 ( M ) with y · ε = 0 then � y , ε, ε · x � · ε = y · � ε, ε · x , ε � = y ⇒ H 0 ( M ) is free . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  77. Remarks A = k � a , u , v , v − 1 � / I with | a | = | u | = 0 , | v | = − 1 . The two-sided ideal I is generated by a 2 , au + ua + 1 , av + va , uv + vu . The differential is defined by d ( a ) = u 2 v , d ( u ) = 0 , d ( v ) = 0 . H ∗ ( A ) = k [ x , x − 1 ] ⊗ k k [ ε ] /ε 2 , with ε = { u } , x = { v } . We have a non-trivial Massey product � ε, ε · x , ε � = 1 mod ε. Given y ∈ H 0 ( M ) with y · ε = 0 then � y , ε, ε · x � · ε = y · � ε, ε · x , ε � = y ⇒ H 0 ( M ) is free . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

  78. Remarks Theorem (Hovey-Lockridge’07) Let R be a commutative ring. The category F ( R ) is triangulated with Σ = identity if and only if R is a finite product of fields, rings of dual numbers over fields of characteristic 2 , and local rings with m = ( 2 ) � = 0 and m 2 = 0 . Corollary The triangulated category F ( R ) admits a model if and only if R is a finite product of fields and rings of dual numbers over fields of characteristic 2 . Fernando Muro Exotic triangulated categories

Download Presentation
Download Policy: The content available on the website is offered to you 'AS IS' for your personal information and use only. It cannot be commercialized, licensed, or distributed on other websites without prior consent from the author. To download a presentation, simply click this link. If you encounter any difficulties during the download process, it's possible that the publisher has removed the file from their server.

Recommend


More recommend