SLIDE 21 21
Equities
Should steel producers invest into the cement industry?
We see three main criteria to look at for a steel player to invest cement:
- Availability of slag and differential between clinker cost & slag prices
- Profitability and growth prospect of the local cement markets
- Other investment opportunities in the steel & mining sector
Pure steel manufacturers need first to
invest in maintenance
Debt reduction is often a priority Investment to optimise costs are likely
to be considered
Integration into mining to secure raw
materials is likely to be considered a priority over diversifying into new sectors
Steel manufacturers that are largely
vertically integrated into mining have potentially large cash reserve
Mining assets are expensive (high
coking coal and iron ore price)
Overcapacity in steel often make
further investment irrelevant
Diversification into cement can make
sense in profitable cement markets
Other investment opportunities in the steel & mining sector
Low return and/or limited growth
potential for the local cement industry
Vertical integration may offer a cost
advantage but total return may not be attractive (low margin on clinker production)
There are probably better investment
High return and/or attractive growth
prospect of the cement industry
Return on capital is attractive even
without a slag cost advantage
Diversifying in cement can appear an
interesting option if other investment
Profitability and growth prospect
- f the local cement markets
Limited slag production and/or slag
prices close to clinker costs
Using slag only offer cement producers
marginal margin benefit
Selling slag to cement producers is
nearly as profitable as vertical
- integration. It is also less risky.
Slag is available and prices are
substantially lower than clinker cost
Cement manufacturers are capturing
the incremental value
Integrating into cement enable steel
producers to capture the differential
Availability of slag and differential between clinker cost & slag prices Elements to be considered against entering the cement industry Elements to be considered for entering the cement industry