SLIDE 1 www.england.nhs.uk
- Stephen McGowan, EIP Clinical Lead for Y&H CN and NHSE (North)
- Dr Steve Wright, Consultant Psychiatrist, TEWV (Co-Chair)
- Rebecca Campbell, Quality Improvement Manager and Sarah Boul, Quality Improvement Lead
- Rebecca.campbell6@nhs.net and sarah.boul@nhs.net
- Twitter: @YHSCN_MHDN #yhmentalhealth
- July 2016
Yorkshire and the Humber Mental Health Network
Early Intervention in Psychosis Network 7th July 2016
SLIDE 2 www.england.nhs.uk
Yorkshire and the Humber Early Intervention in Psychosis Network
Welcome!
Introductions Aims, Objectives and Terms of Reference
Steve Wright, Consultant Psychiatrist, Tees Esk Wear Valleys NHS Trust
SLIDE 3 www.england.nhs.uk
@YHSCN_MHDN #yhmentalhealth
Housekeeping:
SLIDE 4 www.england.nhs.uk
Scope
- The key focus of this group will be the
implementation of the new mental health access and waiting time standards, and the NICE Guidelines.
- The group will also act as a community of interest in
the issue of Early Intervention in Psychosis and related mental disorders that affect young people and their families.
Aims, Objectives & Terms of Reference (1)
SLIDE 5 Aim - 1
- In line with IRIS, the Network will influence service
developments that improve the lives of people affected by psychosis and their families by embracing the aims and principles of the Early Psychosis Declaration:
- Improve access, engagement and treatment of young
people with emerging psychosis
- Recognise the importance of recovery and ordinary lives
for those with early psychosis
- Support families and close friends who are dealing with the
impact of early psychosis in a person they care about
- Raise community awareness about the importance of early
intervention for psychosis
- Help practitioners from community and specialist mental
health services deal more effectively with early psychosis
Aims, Objectives & Terms of Reference (2)
SLIDE 6 Aim - 2
- Ensure delivery of the regional EIP preparedness programme:
- Raising awareness of the requirements of the new standard
- Bringing together local experts and establishing quality
improvement networks, ensuring effective linkage with strategic clinical networks
- Understanding levels of demand in constituent CCGs and any
inequities in access relative to the levels and patterns of psychosis incidence in the population
- Understanding baseline performance and act on the gap analysis
- Optimising referral to treatment pathways, engaging all of the
likely referral sources
- Preparing for the new data collection requirements and providing
training for EIP service and information leads
- Supporting local workforce development programmes
Aims, Objectives & Terms of Reference (3)
SLIDE 7 Aim - 3
- In addition the Network will support the following:
- Information exchange
- Networking
- Sharing good practice
- Sharing resources e.g. job descriptions, operational
policies etc.
- Identifying common problems and seeking solutions
- Areas with strengths and/or expertise will offer support
to areas with developmental needs.
- Education
- Dissemination of information and communication from the
National Team
Aims, Objectives & Terms of Reference (4)
SLIDE 8 Role
- Unite individuals and partners across Yorkshire and the
Humber in a common purpose.
- Promote common understanding, joint working and
prevent duplication.
- Work collaboratively to build capacity and capability for
quality improvement in services.
Aims, Objectives & Terms of Reference (5)
SLIDE 9 Sign off?
- Any comments or suggestions prior to sign-off.
- Review in 6 months
Aims, Objectives & Terms of Reference (6)
SLIDE 10 Overview:
- Purpose is to provide a mechanism for agreeing EIP
priorities for the region
- In addition to oversee the Y&H EIP Network.
- Membership representative both of the geography of
region and also of the key roles in EIP, including service user and carers. Comments & Feedback from the first meeting
Y&H EIP Steering Group
SLIDE 11 www.england.nhs.uk
Yorkshire and the Humber Early Intervention in Psychosis Network
National and Regional Update
Moggie McGowan, EIP Clinical Lead (Yorkshire & The Humber), NHS England North
SLIDE 12 www.england.nhs.uk
Yorkshire and the Humber Early Intervention in Psychosis Network
EIP Audit – Self Assessment Tool
https://www.snapsurveys.com/wh/s.asp?k=146616273215
SLIDE 13 A DISCOURSE ON THE PSYCHOPHARMACOLOGY OF FIRST EPISODE PSYCHOSIS
And an Historically Inaccurate and Whiggish Illustration of the Quandaries of Diagnosis as pertaining to Modern Psychiatric Practice, leaning on the work of Messrs Curtis and Elton Presented By Dr Iain Macmillan
Consultant Psychiatrist EIP, Gateshead, NTW NHS Trust Honorary Clinical Senior Lecturer, Newcastle University And Regional EI Clinical Lead for Psychiatry, NHS England, North
SLIDE 14
EDMUND – ANNO 1590
SLIDE 15 HAS BEEN UNWELL
Generalised malaise Symptoms -
- Cough at night disrupting sleep
- Pain in chest causing anguish
- Swelling of the ankles – unsightly and
uncomfortable
Seeking help
SLIDE 16
DOCTOR 1
Heart ache disorder (melancholia) is the problem! Imbalance of the humours, excess black bile!
SLIDE 17
PX EXTRACT OF WILLOW BARK
SLIDE 18
DOCTOR 2
Nocturnal cough disorder is the prime problem, - Imbalance of the humours -excess phlegm.
SLIDE 19
PX DRAUGHT OF OPIUM
SLIDE 20 DOCTOR 3
The previous Doctors are fools and quacks, the primary problem is swollen ankle disorder - caused by a humoural imbalance – sanguinity (excess blood ).
SLIDE 21
PX LEECHES
SLIDE 22 Doctor: You know the leech comes to us on the highest authority? Edmund: Yes. I know that. Dr Hoffmann of Stuttgart, isn't it? Doctor: That's right, the great Hoffmann. Edmund: Owner of the largest leech farm in Europe…. EVIDENCE –BASED LEECH THERAPY
SLIDE 23 DIFFERING OPINIONS
Different focus on presenting symptoms Different explanations of aetiology Different treatments offered All to some extent effective
SLIDE 24
WILLIAM HARVEY – PARADIGM SHIFT
SLIDE 25
DE MOTU CORDIS, 1628
SLIDE 26 Essentially descriptive: constructed in the age of steam Observations of people with severe, established illnesses Syndromes (poorly validated) equated with Diseases Very few categories meet validity standards Aetiological assumptions underpin diagnoses OPCRIT rescued Psychiatry to some extent Reliability OK in research settings, poor in clinical ones Poor utility of diagnoses for treatment selection, research
AND THE POINT OF THIS TALE – PSYCHIATRIC DIAGNOSES….
SLIDE 27
Back to the 21st Century…. Paradigm shift in progress?
SLIDE 28
Where am I now?
SLIDE 29 Contribution of psychiatric disorders to occupation of NHS beds: analysis of Hospital Episode Statistics. Parvathy Pillay, Joanna Moncrieff DOI: 10.1192/pb.bp.109.028399 Published 31 January 2011
Bed Days – NHS resources – “current practice” doesn’t seem to be working terribly well….
SLIDE 30
Pathophysiology
SLIDE 31 The black box of pathophysiology
Genetics Stress
Syndromes Aetiology Mechanisms Depression Anxiety
Drug abuse Childhood adversity
Psychosis
Environment
SLIDE 32
Opening the black box of pathophysiology -
Howes et al Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2009;66(1):13-20
SLIDE 33 Bloomfield et al. AJP in Advance (doi: 10.1176/appi.ajp.2015.14101358)
Opening the black box of pathophysiology – neuroinflammatory processes?
SLIDE 34
Opening the black box of pathophysiology -
SLIDE 35 Opening the black box of pathophysiology -
Autoimmune encephalitis
- Anti-VGKC complex(2005, 2010)
- LGI1
- CASPR2
- Anti-NMDA receptor (2007)
- Anti AMPA receptor
- GABA-B receptor
- Anti GAD
- Gly-R
- Thyroid peroxidase TPO (Hashimoto’s)
SLIDE 36
Opening the black box of pathophysiology Maybe not just dopamine -
SLIDE 37 Effects of antipsychotics on inflammatory markers in schizophrenia: CATIE study
C-reactive protein (CRP) changes:
- lanzapine vs perphenazine (p<0.001)
and olanzapine vs ziprasidone (p=0.003) Meyer et al 2009
0.70 0.60 0.50 0.40 0.30 0.20 0.10 0.00 CRP change (mg/L) 3 6 12 18 Visit (month) Olanzapine Perphenazine Risperidone Ziprasidone Quetiapine
SLIDE 38
Diagnoses
SLIDE 39 Where are we now? From the chair of the DSM IV group?
“we are at the epicycle stage of psychiatry where astronomy was before Copernicus and biology before Darwin. Our inelegant and complex current descriptive system will undoubtedly be replaced by…simpler, more elegant models.”
Frances AJ, Egger HL: Whither psychiatric diagnosis. Aust N Z J Psychiatry 1999; 33:161–165
SLIDE 40
SLIDE 41 DSM III-R Diagnoses in FEP cohort
Macmillan et al, Early Intervention in Psychiatry 2007
SLIDE 42 Pluripotential Early Stages with Growing Syndrome Clarity?
psychosis mania depression psychosis depression mania Psychosis depression mania
Stage 1a Stage 2+ Stage 1b
schizophrenia
SLIDE 43 Neurodevelopmental-staging model of psychosis
(T.R. Insel, Nature 2010; 468;187-193)
SLIDE 44 Stage Definition Interventions
Increased risk of psychosis or mood disorder (eg family history, abuse, substance use) No specific symptoms currently Mental Health Literacy Self-Help
1a
Mild or non-specific symptoms of psychosis or mood disorder Mental Health Literacy Family Psychoeducation Substance abuse, CBT
1b
Prodromal features: Ultra High Risk 1a plus Therapy for episode: ? phase specific or MS
2
First Episode Threshold psychosis or mood Disorder 1b & case management, vocational rehabilitation
3a
Recurrence of sub-threshold psychosis or mood symptoms 2 & emphasis on maintenance meds and psychosocial strategies
3b
First threshold relapse 2a & relapse prevention strategies
3c
Multiple relapses 3b & Combination/ mood stabilisers
4
Persistent unremitting illness 3c & clozapine and other tertiary therapies.
A staging model
McGorry ANZ JP 2006; Berk et al. Bipolar Disord 2007; Berk et al. J Affective Disord 2007
SLIDE 45 Known biomarkers by clinical stage
Stage Structural MRI
- Hippocampus
- Frontal cortex
- Lateral ventricles
- Right superior temporal lobe
- Corpus callosum
- Amygdala
Neurocognition
- Intellectual impairment
- Executive function
- Verbal memory
- Working memory
- Sustained attention
- Response inhibition
- Symbol coding
Electrophysiology
- Impaired P50
- Deficits in P300
- Reduced mismatch
negativity
state EEG spectra Neuroimmunology
- Increased proinflammatory
cytokines (eg IL6, IL1, TNFa)
- Increased antiinflammatory
cytokines (eg IL10) Oxidative stress
antioxidant enzyme activity
peroxidation
dysfunction HPA axis dysregulation
- Cortisol secretion
- Glucocorticoid receptor
activity
- Mineralocorticoid receptor
activity
Sz BD MD Sz BD MD Sz BD MD Sz BD MD Sz BD M D Sz BD MD
IQ? CI? ? MMN ?
1a
IQ CI? ? MMN ? C GR
1b
FC STL ? ? IQ CI IQ? P50 P300 MMN EEG ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? C ? ? C GR
2
HV FC LV STL CC ? A? IQ CI IQ CI CI? P50 P300 MMN EEG P50 P300 ? pro anti pro anti pro C GR PV PV C PV GR MR
3
HV FC LV CC LV HV A? STL IQ C IQ CI CI? P50 P300 MMN EEG P50 P300 ? pro pro pro C GR PV PV C PV GR MR
4
HV FC LV CC LV HV A? STL IQ CI IQ CI CI? P50 P300 MMN EEG P50 P300 ? pro pro pro C GR PV PV C PV GR MR
SLIDE 46
Treatments
SLIDE 47
Stage 1b - ARMS
SLIDE 48
Antipsychotic medication
Medication requires expert and careful consideration as these typically young people, previously treatment naive, may be embarking on treatments which for some may be necessary for several years.
SLIDE 49 Stage 2 – FEP Antipsychotic medication
Most current antipsychotics show similar efficacy against positive symptoms in
- FEP. Thus choice of drug should be
based on tolerability and side effects experienced, and the individual’s ability to manage these whilst maintaining therapeutic benefit.
(Leucht et al 2009)
SLIDE 50 Stage 2 – FEP Antipsychotic medication
Leucht et al, Lancet 2013
Lieberman et al 2003
SLIDE 51 Medications – more useful when taken….
Leucht et al, Lancet 2013
SLIDE 52
Antipsychotic medication – low dose
SLIDE 53 Dose recommendations of atypical antipsychotics in first- episode non-affective psychosis – start low go slow!
Atypical Antipsychotic Starting Dose Initial Target Dose (to reach after 7 days, maintain for 3 weeks) Full (max) target dose (increase slowly over 4 weeks, total trial 8 weeks) Amisulpiride 50-100 mg daily 300 mg daily 800 mg daily Aripiprazole (1st line?) 10 mg daily 15-20 mg daily 30 mg daily Clozapine (not 1st or 2nd line) 25 mg test dose 100-150 mg daily 200-300 mg daily Olanzapine 2.5-5 mg daily 10 mg daily 20 mg daily (not recommended due to excess metabolic burden) Quetiapine
(?advantage in affective)
25 mg test dose 150 -400 mg daily 750 mg daily Risperidone (1st line?) 0.5-1 mg daily 2mg daily 4 mg daily
(Adapted from Lambert et al, Pharmacotherapy of first-episode psychosis,2003)
SLIDE 54 Dose Equivalents
Leucht et al, Schizophrenia Bulletin Advance Access Feb 2014
SLIDE 55
“An adequate trial….”
SLIDE 56
Antipsychotic medication This should be provided in conjunction with a psychosocial and vocational programme including physical, family interventions and CBT-p, delivered by a coherent specialist EIP service.
SLIDE 57
Antipsychotics – concerns arise
SLIDE 58
FGA vs SGA?
SLIDE 59
Some people may choose to avoid medication and should not be made to feel they are not cooperating. Indeed although difficult to predict who, evidence shows that some can do well without medication. Offer CBT, Family Therapy, CBT-informed case management. Antipsychotic medication
SLIDE 60
Stage 4 - Antipsychotic medication Following careful review, consideration should be given to the early use of clozapine in people whose symptoms do not respond to an adequate trial of two different antipsychotic agents.
SLIDE 61 Antipsychotic medication – discontinuation?
Wunderinck et al JAMA Psychiatry. doi:10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2013.19Published online July 3, 2013.
SLIDE 62 Antipsychotic medication in FEP – stages 2-3-4
- 1. Involve service users in treatment choices
- 2. Young, neuroplastic brains – be gentle!
- 3. Actively manage metabolic risk from the outset
- 4. Start low, go slow
- 5. Be sensitive to side effects
- 6. Don’t persist with ineffective treatments, but
give adequate trial at a decent (not high) dose
- 7. No clear guide as to 1st and 2nd choice,
?SGA>FGA, Risperidone/Aripiprazole?
- 8. Discontinuation possible once stably recovered
– gradual with clear plan to manage relapse
SLIDE 63 Thanks for listening!
Thanks to Pat McGorry and Michael Berk for some of the slides. Edmund’s case developed from conversations with Michael Berk and Assen Jablensky. Thanks to Messrs Curtis and Elton.
SLIDE 64
Post Graduate Diploma in CBT (Secondary Care)
Kerry Smith 2015
SLIDE 65 Context:
- Professional training
- Funding from LETB to support local service
development imperatives
- Training for the Diploma and Certificate is at
level 7
- (Level 6 modules were offered as CPD
elements to support staff not ready to progress at academic level 7 or as a precursor)
SLIDE 66 Knowledge and Skills Specific to Secondary Care:
- CBT competencies – Common anxiety
disorders / mild to moderate depression (primary care)
- CBT competencies- Serious mental Illness
(secondary care )
SLIDE 67 Training Pathways
PG Diploma:
- 4 taught modules and 2 supervised practice modules
i)Basic theories and skills, ii)Common disorders in SMI
iii)Psychosis and Bipolar, iv)PD and complex presentations
PG Certificate (theory):
- 3 taught modules ( one of these for SMI competencies)
PG Certificate with Clinical Practice (“Top-up”)
- 1 taught module (Psychosis and Bipolar Disorder)
- 2 supervised practice modules (Psychosis clients)
SLIDE 68 Trainees
- PG Dip: Current cohort: 23 (20)
- PG Dip: Cohort 2017: 23 offers
- Top- up : 4 (and counting)
SLIDE 69 Geography Served (in order of numbers)
- Humber
- Leeds
- Navigo
- Bradford
- Castleford
- Dewsbury
- Barnsley
- Scarborough
- Lincoln
- Other ( non NHS)
SLIDE 70 Service context
- Increasing Access to Psychological Therapies
(IAPT):
- primary care
- Children and young people
- Serious mental illness (SMI)
- EIP access standards
- NICE
SLIDE 71 Roth & Pilling competency framework
- Generic therapeutic competences
– E.g., client engagement, dealing with emotional content
– E.g., Structure, basic principles of cognitive psych and behaviourism
- Specific behavioural and cognitive therapy
– E.g., exposure, guided discovery, formulations
- Problem specific competences
– ‘Models’ of disorders such as PTSD, OCD etc.
– E.g., clinical judgement, choosing appropriate treatment interventions
http://www.ucl.ac.uk/clinical- psychology/CORE/CBT_Competences/CBT_Competences_Map.pdf
SLIDE 72 Problem specific competences
- http://www.ucl.ac.uk/clinical-
psychology/CORE/CBT_Competences/Problem _Specific_Competences/Problem_Specific_Co mpetences.pdf
SLIDE 73 Who comes on our training course?
Core Professional Groups:
- Nursing
- Social work
- Clinical Psychology
- Counselling Psychology
- Occupational Therapy
- Psychiatry
SLIDE 74 Applicants via a Knowledge Skills and Attitudes ( KSA)Route
- Applicants who can demonstrate knowledge
skills and attitudes equivalent of a core professional training.
- Need to submit a KSA portfolio at interview.
Can be completed during the course. But initial draft must indicate near readiness at interview
- General nurses, PWPs, Psychology Assistants,
Care coordinators
SLIDE 75 Selection
Application form:
- Needs to show service support and
permissions for training are in place Interview:
- Role play
- Reflection
- Questions
SLIDE 76 Teaching methods
- Teaching and guided reading: theory and practice
- Acting on knowledge in practice exercises in skills
sessions, self therapy and clinical practice.
- Applying knowledge to new areas of CBT theory
through academic writing: essays and exams.
- Reflecting on experiences by observation in
workshops, by recording own practice and using rating scales to structure this thinking, by using supervision.
SLIDE 77 Trainee feedback:
- Course is demanding
- Value high content of skills based teaching and
chance to observe practice
- (Always want more of this)
- The chance to focus on complex cases and
comorbidity is good preparation for work in any service
SLIDE 78 Predictors of successful training
- Jolley, S., Onwumere, J.,Kuipers, E., Craig, T.,
Moriaty, A. and Garety, P. (2014)
- Increasing access to Psychological therapies
for people with psychosis: Predictors of successful training.
- https://www.researchgate.net/journal/1873-
622X_Behaviour_Research_and_Therapy
SLIDE 79 Successful training:
- Previous work as a CBT therapist
- Current role as therapist
- Previous academic study at masters level
SLIDE 80 Delivery after training:
- Found many trained stopped delivering
therapy because of difficulties with workload and care- co duties
- Delivery is enhanced when therapists are
employed in dedicated posts
SLIDE 81 How services can support training
- Management support in preparation for training
- Supervisor identified early on (BABCP Accredited)
- Supervisor facilitated to attend course supervisor events
- Adequate recording facilities made available early on
- Access to appropriate clients facilitated
- Support given for seeing training cases for adequate numbers of sessions
- Support to attend all teaching sessions
- Support for study time if required
- Avoid dual roles for training cases where possible: care co-ordinator and
therapist
- Where service pressures prevent some of the practical measures above an
emotionally supportive environment can still help trainees to cope- trainees don’t expect unrealistic adjustments but need to know that mangers understand the extra challenges training involves
SLIDE 82 How services can support implementation of therapy post training
- Ensure that post training job roles allow dedicated time
for CBT practice and supervision
- Encourage CBT related CPD and consolidation
- Incorporate accreditation as a goal of staff appraisal
- Encourage investment in completing and consolidating
training rather than taking up multiple training
- pportunities without completion.
- Nurture successful trainees as assets that can benefit
colleagues through supervision and support and training
SLIDE 83 How we can support, post training?
- Supervisor workshops
- Masterclasses
- Support for accreditation
- Involvement in the training community
SLIDE 84 www.england.nhs.uk
Yorkshire and the Humber Early Intervention in Psychosis Network
Time for a break?
SLIDE 85
- 1. Medication & Treatment
- 2. Role of the Care Coordinator
- 3. Developing the therapy workforce
- 4. Service Development & Challenges
- Key Priorities and Actions for Meeting the Standards
- Key Priorities and Actions for Overall Quality
Improvement PLEASE NOTE KEY POINTS ON FLIPCHART – THESE WILL BE COLLATED & SHARED AFTER THE MEETING. Professional Groups Table Top Discussions
SLIDE 86 www.england.nhs.uk
Any Other Business
- Maastricht Approach
- Date of the Next Meeting: 17th
November
- Future Meeting Planning –
ARMS,CAMHS
- Closing Remarks
- Evaluation
Dr Steve Wright, Co-Chair
SLIDE 87 www.england.nhs.uk
Yorkshire and the Humber Early Intervention in Psychosis Network
Thank You for Attending!
Don’t forget to fill out your evaluation!