C1 – Grades Don’t Matter! Formative Assessment Does!
C1 Grades Dont Matter! Formative Assessment Does! Will students - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
C1 Grades Dont Matter! Formative Assessment Does! Will students - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
C1 Grades Dont Matter! Formative Assessment Does! Will students learn without grades? Absolutely, if you believe it yourself and intentionally plan to make it happen . This session is designed to provide educators with strategies on
Will students learn without grades? Absolutely, if you believe it yourself and intentionally plan to make it happen . This session is designed to provide educators with strategies on how formative assessment can be used to motivate students to actively engage in learning without grades .
Roy Sovis, Genesee Intermediate School District
3
Who’s in the audience?
- K-5 Teachers
- 6-8 Teachers
- HS Teachers
- CO Administrators
- Building Administrators
- Curriculum Directors
- Higher Ed
- “Psychometricians”
- Other
Roy Sovis
Coordinator for Instruction rsovis@geneseeisd.org
- Social Studies
- Customized PD
- MDE Standards
Writing Team
- MDE Standards PD
Development Team
- Youth
Entrepreneurship
- Summative
Assessment
- Formative
Assessment
- Effective
Grading Practices
- Cognitive Coach
- Mentor
Who Cares?
@roysovis
Session Agenda
- Purpose
- Clarify Language
- The Problems with Traditional Grading
- Using Formative Assessment to Improve Learning
- Next Steps and Resources
- Provide evidence that formative
assessment process can be used to motivate students to learn without grades
- Strategies on how to start using
formative assessment to motivate students without grades
- I can explain how components of the
formative assessment process can be used to motivate students to learn without grades
What is your purpose for grading?
8
Is my purpose for grading to select talent or develop it?
- Thomas Guskey 2011
What is your purpose for grading?
9
If to develop talent, then the main reason for grading should be to provide feedback to improve student and teacher performance.
- Douglas Reeves 2016
Session Agenda
- Purpose
- Clarify Language
- The Problems with Traditional Grading
- Using Formative Assessment to Improve Learning
- Next Steps and Resources
Clarify Language - Mark or Score A number or letter given to any student test or performance that may contribute to the latter determination of a grade.*
- Ken O’Connor, A Repair Kit for Grading: 15 Fixes for Broken Grades
Based on criteria for performance
Clarify Language - Grade A number or letter reported at the end of period of time as a summary of student performance.*
- Ken O’Connor, A Repair Kit for Grading: 15 Fixes for Broken Grades
Based on criteria for performance
Clarify Language - Formative Assessment
“Formative assessment is a planned, ongoing process used by all students and teachers during learning and teaching to elicit and use evidence of student learning to improve student understanding
- f intended disciplinary learning outcomes and
support students to become more self-directed learners.”
- CCSSO FAST SCASS, 2017
Session Agenda
- Purpose
- Clarify Language
- The Problems with Traditional Grading
- Using Formative Assessment to Improve Learning
- Next Steps and Resources
The Problems With Traditional Grading
Refer to Dr. Guskey’s
- pening keynote and
breakout session!
The Problems With Traditional Grading
- A private practice
- 100% scale is subjective
- Demotivating; Lacks incentive
- Perpetuates extrinsic motivation
- Reported grades lack meaning
Source unknown
The Problems With Traditional Grading
- The final grade (letter or number) for a academic course should only
be derived from summative student evidence of performance in reference to proficiency level indicators aligned to standards
- However, proficiency level indicators for a course take time to
develop
The Problems With Traditional Grading
- Numerous challenges to change grading practices system wide
- Two entry points are promising…
1. Book study to start the conversation 2. Implement the formative assessment process
Effective Grading Practices
Using Formative Assessment to Improve Learning
Clarify Language - Formative Assessment
“Formative assessment is a planned, ongoing process used by all students and teachers during learning and teaching to elicit and use evidence of student learning to improve student understanding
- f intended disciplinary learning outcomes and
support students to become more self-directed learners.”
- CCSSO FAST SCASS, 2017
Formative Assessment for Michigan Educators
famemichigan.org/
Student evidence gathered during formative process is NEVER Graded! This starts the conversation about grading and how to change.
Strategy
Five Steps to Motivate Students to Mastery
- ASCD Express Article
25
- 1. Select high stakes summative assessment
- 2. Introduce new system: No homework, assignments not
graded
- 3. Explain final grade summative assessment only
- 4. Explain related learning opportunities (assignments)
- 5. Explain all learning opportunities receive feedback, but
no grade
Components of GISD 4 Day FA Institute
- Overview
- Planning
- Learning Target Use
- Activating PK
- Gathering Evidence
- Questioning
- Feedback
- Peer Assessment
- Self-Assessment
- Making Instructional
Decisions
27
What do students say about doing work that receives feedback, but no grade?
28
1. Book study to start conversation 2. Learn FA; begin implementation; FAME Project 3. Only give descriptive feedback on all assignments with no grades
Using Formative Assessment to Motivate Without Grades
Summary
29