Better Local Services: Improving Local Government Delivery Through - - PDF document

better local services improving local government delivery
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

Better Local Services: Improving Local Government Delivery Through - - PDF document

Better Local Services: Improving Local Government Delivery Through Innovation and Partnerships: Lessons from the New Zealand Experience A Presentation to the Commonwealth Local Government Forum Asia-Pacific Regional


slide-1
SLIDE 1
  • Better Local Services: Improving

Local Government Delivery Through Innovation and Partnerships: Lessons from the New Zealand Experience

  • A Presentation to the Commonwealth Local

Government Forum Asia-Pacific Regional Symposium

  • !"#
  • July 2005
slide-2
SLIDE 2
  • Malaysia Presentation.doc

Page i

  • $% %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% $

&%'()*%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% & )* %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% + ,,- %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% . +% -/ %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 0 1% 2',"-3 4,(2', %%%%%%%%%% 5 )4 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% 5 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% $6 ,%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% $$ %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% $+ 3-,%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% $11 7 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% $1 .% ,7)-) %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% $0

  • )/ %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% $0

,)8%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% $9 ,33 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% $9 :!/,:%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% $5 0% %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% $;

slide-3
SLIDE 3
  • Malaysia Presentation.doc

Page 1

  • 1.

INTRODUCTION

  • , - ,, !" # -

"- < 3 *) /, :/(,)) -)- ,-,:%

  • " ) , ) - ' - !" #

) ) " !" # = , ),%-,-," "- , -) ) > - , - ::,,--"-, %

  • ,"-, -

,-, -)-)- - - ) )% - - " - )-,, )-) ) ) !" # ,, - ) - %

slide-4
SLIDE 4
  • Malaysia Presentation.doc

Page 2

  • 2. CONTEXT: PUBLIC MANAGEMENT REFORMS
  • , "- "- ) -
  • 3 ? )) -

) !" # - , , )%

  • "%/$;.$-- )33

)--"- ," )%

  • ) - , ) @ ,
  • --"

, - - , % -)- - $;-

  • ")-!"# ))-"
  • ) ',)-),@
  • A - B

,, C - " ) - ) ) - , @ %

  • )= , - ,) -

&66&" B""" "D 33 -)-" ) ,C)D)D" ,D

  • , %-

"-- " ) - " ) ) "- " :,3,,

  • :%,-" "-,

) % - E - * B,)) -C , ' " ) )-%

  • ) - ) - !" #
  • ) - : -: "- -

, - - , :-,): - "-- )"-33, )"-) ,% "- , "- @ - - ) !" # - - ) - ) )-B,,'C-- ,

  • -%--)
  • "- )

),"--B-)-),") 7 C%

  • $;;6-">)- ")"-

"-- B,,

slide-5
SLIDE 5
  • Malaysia Presentation.doc

Page 3

)C-)-," "- -" "%

  • <-'!"# --

," - -)- )%-,-" --

  • ,%- 3$;56!"# "-)-)

' , ) - " -)-

  • ,) -)- ))

"- ") -)- "- , )" %

  • Public Management Reforms
  • $;51")%>

, "-"-,-,) , )%

  • ,-"::,,-- )-

)% E " , , - - "- ,- )7,, - 33 )-"-- - ), , ) - - ,, ") "- - " )-"--- -,, %

  • " - ) " " -

:,: ::% , ,- ,) - - " , )

  • ,),-,%!"#

" - , ) , % !"# )- -, > ,, - - ) , ) ,,-,,-,%

  • " >) @ ) )

, ) - - "- - , " , "- - " , )%"-", , " , ,% @ ) , " - - , " , ,, ,%

  • -, " - , " -) % -

, ,"--- "- , " % - ' " ) - , , )"-- ,"-"

  • = @% - = "

,-) - , - , - > -,@-- %

slide-6
SLIDE 6
  • Malaysia Presentation.doc

Page 4

  • -) " , ,- ,)

, , - - )" "--, )

  • -, -- -

,,%---)-, "- -- B - - )C %-)-"--" >33, )"-",)" ) )"-,- ) -%

  • ) ) -)

)-)%-,

  • )""- "-,)

) B"- - ) $;51 - " ) , , , "-- "C - ' %

  • )-) ",-)-
  • )% - ) $;5;% <

) ->%-"- 566 - ) 066 :,3,,: -% /

  • B"C 50 "-- 91 " "- "
  • 33 "- - , "-
  • 33 $& ) % - " -

)-) )%*--) ,)-") -

  • "--)%
  • / " " ) -) - ,"

> )% " ) " )) ," )-,",

  • -%-,"" "-)

)),-: :> ,- -" - -'

  • ,,)%
  • ,) > - ,, )

)"--"$6-

  • -"-" ,,),,
  • "" "--%
  • " ) ' ," ,

) - ,, - - )

  • 33 , - " )) -

"-- -)-)- "---- -,"%

slide-7
SLIDE 7
  • Malaysia Presentation.doc

Page 5

<)%!"# -- " %,"-) $5 "-- "-- )---

  • B---)

, - -C% - , "- ) - "- % - )

  • --"-%
  • A More Commercial Approach
  • )= )) )
  • ))
  • >

,

  • ) % - ) B

" - " ) "C "- ) ) 33 "-- - ", ,,)%

  • )-"),
  • "-- - - "

,,%2', ), ,, ,%

  • ,,% --

,,) ,, "-- "-" ),) -, )%?--', , " )- - ,) "-- - , "- )"33-%

slide-8
SLIDE 8
  • Malaysia Presentation.doc

Page 6

  • 3.

THE CURRENT SITUATION

  • )---$;56 $;;6"" ,,
  • -) %--$;59
  • " " - ),
  • !"# %2)"- ,

,!"# "--- ) ,) 7") % *, ,--":)"-,:

  • "- " --"--"

", %

  • $;;5-"-))-,,

"--- --$;56"--"-

  • )% < - , ' !" # -

, - ,, : : ,, - , % -)- - ) -) , - , , )-) %

  • ) )= - )

) , ) -

  • )7 ,) - ) ,
  • ,) -) )-

,"--) %

  • &66& !" # = " "% - ,,

)" % ,

  • - ,, ) "

,) "3)% " - , , - "3)--, -%- , "--,, 3)

  • %
  • " ) 33 ', - - &666

2) ? )) ) - ," , - "3)-) , ) ) ) ,)

  • 33-!"# -), ,

)@%)- - "@> "))33

  • ) , ) "-- -
  • --$;56 $;;6

" - , ) - ""--- -" ) -, ,-)-,,%

slide-9
SLIDE 9
  • Malaysia Presentation.doc

Page 7

  • - ) - - , ) , "
  • ))B) -
  • "- """% %%AC%
  • ) )F )") -

" , 3 % -,)

  • - -,",-"- ,-"

""B@>--"-- C%

  • ,- -

, " "" -

  • ,)3)33-

") "(

  • "- - , ) ,

,, > " , , - " "", - , %

  • ',B, " C
  • "--- )3-)-

)" ""@" ",%

slide-10
SLIDE 10
  • Malaysia Presentation.doc

Page 8

  • 4.

EXPERIENCE WITH MARKET-BASED OPTIONS: EXAMPLES AND LESSONS

  • !"# -- 3 ,

)) " )) , ,3,,-,%

  • ) - "--

) "- - ) @-,---,)

  • , - , , ) - , -

)))- ))- ', ,,%--,@- ) - " ', , ,,-)"- ,%

  • " - ', )

, ,3,,-,%

  • - ,, - " -)-)- "--
  • - )%
  • - (
  • )(--)3-)
  • ) ,-=" ""

%

  • ,(,)-)),

, -',--" )

  • - ', -

), -%

  • 3, ,-,( - 44 B " ,

C)- ,@ !"# =)%

  • Contracting Out
  • ,---

"--,- )%-B&66$C- ,,,,'16666%

slide-11
SLIDE 11
  • Malaysia Presentation.doc

Page 9

)--$;56"--"--"

  • ,, , -

) ,% , ,-,-: ,, -@> -,--)- ":%

  • "-"-!"# -"

) """ " %

  • - , , - )) )

,-% )-,, "-',-, )" "" %

  • )) -)- , - -

)+6"-)-"-&6 "- @3 - , "-- " - 3 - ? ,) 2'<%

  • >"- ), --)

"--- -)-)- %

  • <-,,--""-

) --)%-"- "--

  • - -- -
  • , -,"---@3 -)

" ""%

  • <- "--,>"

) , "-- - "-- , - " "" " -

  • ))%!-,' %
  • 4,)----),
  • - " -) " "" -

)%) "----"3, ) "-- , " ' , " ,, - )

  • ) 33 - " - )

, "---

  • "--"-))-%
  • - )) - ) " -

', " -- "- -) )) - ', ) , ) - ) )---,)%

  • ,"33"-- ',-

33 " "- - " - - )-,"---- %

slide-12
SLIDE 12
  • Malaysia Presentation.doc

Page 10

Lessons

  • -,"-))

"-', ,,)--',

  • ----,%-,,--
  • - - -= " %

,)------ ) )3 ) ) "- - , ,)33-,,-,

  • ,))-',,

,%

  • -,)"3,, %,"%
  • - - ) ,
  • ) ))

,%

  • - "--"- ),)

%,=', @ ) ,)-"

  • ,))3

"--@)),-)%

  • , - ) - " >

" , " - - ,,, " ' - , " """,,-33-,- " , "- - , ) ) ,,% " )))-)% < " ) % / - )") " " - , - - ') " , ,) "" "% , - - )) " - " "" - -) - - %-"-- ,,(

  • ) '"--"%
  • ) - ,) - ) " 33
  • " - - -

") %

  • *),7)-)

)"%

  • ?--,-,)"@D

)) )"--:, ) :,",),)-- ,%-,-,-,"--

  • " )-)--,

, - , )- "- ,

slide-13
SLIDE 13
  • Malaysia Presentation.doc

Page 11

,%-,-,"--,,- ,) , - ) > )G-,--- )-,,- "- , ,)- %

  • ?- - ,- - )3
  • ,@,-)%
  • Corporatisation
  • , -)- - , ) ,

" , "- - ,, ) @ , - % !" # ->,-, ) - "- !" # " , - 33 - > 3 ,,%

  • ,,- - - )

A - ,)%

  • )- (
  • ) ) "-- -

>%,),

  • "--)
  • , % - "- -
  • ""---

, " ) - 33 - ,,- )),,"---

  • -"-)"- )-,--
  • ,%
  • , - ) )

"--%

  • ,-,-,-

)-,,,%

  • ,,)-
  • "-, %- )):))

: - -)- , , > 3)),,,, 3) B -)- - ,C%

slide-14
SLIDE 14
  • Malaysia Presentation.doc

Page 12

H,-,,-"--- "- ,) - " - , "- > , ,%

  • ?) "-- !" # = , - - = 3

") -*%" -- $;- "--> ,%

  • , - ) ) @

) %

  • 3$;;6 - " - ) -

*," ,@) - ))) ) , "- ) % - * , ,% - "--- ---") )%

  • - ,,
  • "---" -) -

"- - - * " ,)%"-) ""> > @ %

  • --" "-)))"

%" "-,-*B

  • - ) )C ) " -

,-" -%

  • ,"--?)%-"
  • %-=-, ,,"-

)',"-- ",, -%

  • " - - - % , ),

",, %-)-,))3 ))"--%

  • - ---) -

, - *% ! ) - " ,, - " - - ', - , ) 33 ) - ) ,-*"--@ )', 33', - "--, %-- --

  • -" @ %
  • *-, " - - > % -
  • )---")-)-
  • )---- -%
slide-15
SLIDE 15
  • Malaysia Presentation.doc

Page 13

  • Lessons
  • , - ) ) B

) ) 3, , - - ,,C")) 33- )%E" %

  • ,-- - -

B-D3,,C '"--

  • " - - ) - -
  • ,%
  • ?- - )) - - , -) 3,

, --"-- " "- - @ ) ') % /,- ) -7 "---",), -,)-" "-"-- )%

  • E - -*"- -
  • " - - , - > "-

"-- ,)-% ,-, , " "-- -) -, - - * , % ) " - -

  • , )-) %
  • / "!"# )=

',"--,"-%

  • $;;6 -"
  • " ""%,

) ) - "--

  • " " , "- " " : 3

B/C:%-/"> ,=)-"- )" -- ,- "- %

  • " , " - )

2,---- ,):: 3 - - - , %

  • "> -=","-
  • ,">',

%--)-)--,"-,)

  • 3 -"-= ) "-

= ) --"-- ,)%

slide-16
SLIDE 16
  • Malaysia Presentation.doc

Page 14

Public-Private Partnerships

  • !" # = 3

)"!"# )=',"-,3 ,,-,%-)--", -

  • - "--" ) )

,3,,-,%

  • " "-- --"

"-,,I"--,-))

  • 33 - " - -) ,3,

,-,"-, )-

  • ,,%
  • - )- ,

$&666 "-- " - )= @ % - " " ) @3 " " , ) , < %

  • ,3, ,-, - 16 4"

4,)%- -163, "-,"

  • - ,

) -"- @3%

  • , - - > ) " ,

"--)-)--"-- "- - @3 " % , ) , , "

  • )) ,3, ,-, ,

, , >%

  • Lessons/Issues
  • ', ) - "

',- - ,3,,-,"-"--) %

  • <,- )%!"#
  • - ,3,

,-,--", -"-,%

  • - !" # - "
  • @ % - , %
  • ' B ,,

'C-)) %

  • - -" "@ , )
  • ' - " 3) ," - -
slide-17
SLIDE 17
  • Malaysia Presentation.doc

Page 15

," ' - ) - ,3, ,-, " " ,,- %

  • '--)@,3,,-,D
  • - " ,) - , -

, % , - ) - - , - , ) - - 33 - , -- )%- ,', ,%

  • ) % ,3,

,-, ) - - - B ),,@) )3)C-: : ,"- ", )-%

  • " ) "-- , %

E->"--,,-,@%- , , " " 33 , "

  • ,-, -

%-,,%',-,3, ,-, - , - ,

  • ,-,,---,

, ) % - , , , " > - , , , , - ,@ ) "-- %

  • < - )) " !" # - -

,, ) ) ,3,,-,%- "-,J,, B

  • (
  • ,(77"""%,-,%%)%7 7"K7J7J/%7<

7JG4,C

slide-18
SLIDE 18
  • Malaysia Presentation.doc

Page 16

  • 5.

CORPORATISATION/ARMS LENGTH ARRANGEMENTS GENERALLY

  • ", "-"--!"

# )-',"-,

  • )- ) %
  • "--" (
  • )%
  • ,) %
  • ,,33 %
  • :!,:%
  • Matching Activity to Structure
  • "-- ), 7,

)- % = ,,) , 3 "-@-)3 G , B- )C ,) - )--,', " ) ' ,% 4 - - - , - ) ) - ) )- ,) ,, ) - , "-,% - " -

  • - " ) - " @
  • , , %
  • , "-- "-- - ,

"--- "--,-, " >-,%- 3$;;6!" # -, "-" -" 33"--",) ) )-,%,

  • - ,, - , "-,
  • " -,%,
  • - - ) ,

%-"- ,> %

slide-19
SLIDE 19
  • Malaysia Presentation.doc

Page 17

Keeping Your Distance

  • - -- %!
  • - - - - "-
  • ,,)"-- %-)

)-, --)%

  • ""--3,,,"

"--"',"-) ) ,-"-%!"# -) (

  • ?-"-33 "---

= @ , - - - "

  • ) ,))"%
  • , ,33

', ) - "-- ) 33 - - ) ) " -

  • "-',----%
  • 4--)"--- - --

, - , - ) - ) )>,-"--, -%

  • ,-- "-))-
  • -,B"-- ,-
  • - C,- %-

3, , - " @ ) ) ',,,%

  • "-- - - )

)- - ) % !" # - "3 "', )), -- )

  • , , - -

, -,,%

  • Good People -- and Accountability
  • 4 "-- !" # - "- -

,, )-"--- %--',-- ,, %/----",

  • % / - -

")--)- L

  • !--,,-,) %-"
  • -)"--"-
  • - )),-
  • =>B-- ),D
slide-20
SLIDE 20
  • Malaysia Presentation.doc

Page 18

  • ) "-,-,)-""---
  • ) ) ",33"-- -
  • - ) ', - -

'"-- C%

  • ) - -)- -

, % - ) - " ,-',-,,- - ',%

  • ,"!"#
  • )- @ , ) , )

,,-B"-,,

  • ---,C%!-"
  • ,,-,, ' %
  • ,-" (
  • ,-) ,,"->

',,, %

  • , - - ,, - ) -

,,,%

  • ,%!"# ',--"->

,, "- - , - - , ,, ,,"- ,)-,

  • ,,,>,,"--,-
  • ,"--,,,,%

,,-, --,,

  • ,, -,B

)C , ) " ) - ), ))-@ ,

  • " )3,- %
  • "No Surprises"
  • ,, - -, " -
  • , "-- - , )- - -
  • - - - , , ,3,

,-,% - -, )3% - " ,, , - > - -, %,-)---, ) - ) -)- - -)- ), - % -) "-- - ) , - - , B "- - - ,

  • - -)"--,C-
  • -,,
  • , %
slide-21
SLIDE 21
  • Malaysia Presentation.doc

Page 19

  • 6.

CONCLUSION

  • ,, - , - , !"

# )= ', "- ") "- )- , ,"------ ,,,-)--) ,3,,-,%

  • "-!"# ',- --

) ) - , ")"-,,%-- ) )- -)- - ) - ,)-)-, )))%

  • ) ,, , ))
  • -,,,--,%-"

"->-""-%--

  • - ,) ) ,

,,, 33 ', ',) - , , ',%

  • , , - ) -

% - , , - - , ) "- - , , >

  • -', %
  • !"# ',- -,
  • - "-)

,%--)-)- -)-

  • )- -) - ) , "- -
  • -%